Quantcast
Channel: Bharatkalyan97
Viewing all 11214 articles
Browse latest View live

Netaji files coming out in a dribble. NaMo, release GOI files on Netaji.

$
0
0


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r5Tx5--MBrk

Netaji files show family was under observation, intercepted communication hinted at sightings

In a letter written by Dr Lilly Abegg to Netaji's brother, Sarat Chandra Bose on December 9, 1949, intercepted at the Elgin Road Post Office, she writes, "I heard in 1946 from Japanese sources that your brother is still living."



Written by Aniruddha Ghosal | Kolkata | Updated: September 19, 2015 5:59 am - 

The files declassified on Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose in Kolkata (Photo by Shubham Dutta)
The 64 files on Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose, officially released Friday and dubbed as ‘historic’ by the West Bengal CM Mamata Banerjee, reveal not only the minute scrutiny that Netaji and his family were subjected to by Indian intelligence agencies, but also the doubts that continued regarding Netaji’s death in various quarters.
Consider this, a letter written by Dr Lilly Abegg to Netaji’s brother, Sarat Chandra Bose on December 9, 1949. In the letter, intercepted at the Elgin Road Post Office, she writes, “I heard in 1946 from Japanese sources that your brother is still living.”
Abegg, a Swiss journalist, was a correspondent in Japan and China and at the time of writing the letter worked for the Swiss weekly Die Weltwoche. In the letter, she wrote, “On account of the good relation between Indian and my country, it is not possible to tell everything in  a too open and undiplomatic manner. Further, as I have not been in India, it is impossible for me to take sides with one side only and against the government.” In a previous correspondence, dated November 1, 1949, Abegg had once against written to Sarat Chandra Bose and asked, “Any news from Mr Subhash Chandra Bose? United Press reported that he was in Peking.”

On August 20, 1965, a weekly secret survey of the Netaji Research Bureau by state intelligence officers intercepted communication between Sisir Kumar Bose (Netaji’s nephew) and Tatsuo Hayashida, the Japanese author of the book, ‘Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose: His great struggle and martyrdom’. In it, Sisir Kumar Bose writes that Dr Satya Narayan Sinha, a member of the parliament and former Indian Foreign Service officer had said that the erstwhile Formosa government, had documents that created doubts regarding Netaji’s death.
“Dr Sinha visted Formosa in November-December last year and made enquiries regarding the air crash. A number of Chinese nationals were produced before him by the present government there and who made statements to him which are at complete variance with statements made by Japanese friends before the Netaji Enquiry Committee. Dr Sinha has written further that the present government in Formosa have documents in their possession showing that an air crash of the same description occurred in October 1944 but no such air crash took place in August 1945. It is reported that the Formosa Government will publish these documents if requested to do so by the Government of India,” reads the letter.
The files reveal sustained surveillance of Netaji’s family and the activities of the Netaji Research Bureau in Kolkata. In particular, letters written to and from two addresses – 1, Woodburn Park, Calcutta – the residence of Netaji and his family and 38/2 Elgin Road – Netaji Bhawan – were intercepted at the Elgin Road Post Office and forwarded to the Deputy Commissioner of Police, Special Branch, CID Calcutta.
On Friday, the files were handed over to the descendants of Netaji by Kolkata Police Commissioner SK Purkayastha at the Kolkata Police Museum. Banerjee tweeted, “Today is a historic day. Our government has made all Netaji files public. People have the right to know about the brave son of India.” But state government officials maintained that the files released on Friday constituted only a small fraction of the existing surveillance records on Netaji and his family and the key to his disappearance lay in the files with the union government.
Afterwards, Netaji’s family members urged the union government to follow the West Bengal governments example and declassify these files. “Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee has done a great thing and now the Centre has no other option but to declassify the files it has…The more important files that can unravel the mystery behind his disappearance are with the central government departments and the mystery can be solved only if those files are declassified,” Netaji’s grandnephew and family spokesperson Chandra Kumar Bose told the media here after the release.
netaji files, netaji subhash chandra bose, netaji documents, netaji death, subhash chandra bose death, mamata banerjee
FILE1
FILE2
FILE3

See more at: http://indianexpress.com/article/india/india-others/netaji-files-show-family-was-under-observation-intercepted-communication-hinted-at-sightings/#sthash.TMMq5mie.dpuf

PC Vasan Eye care ghotala. Is FM listening? NaMo, restitute kaalaadhan.

$
0
0


ED's 11 Posers to Vasan Health Care, Karti Conduit in Multi-crore Deal

Published: 19th September 2015 03:53 AM
Last Updated: 19th September 2015 11:16 AM
CHENNAI:  The Enforcement Directorate (ED) appears to have finally woken up to the need for a probe into the surreptitious manner in which huge amounts, running into crores of rupees, flowed into Vasan Health Care Pvt Ltd (VHCPL), to which former finance minister P Chidambaram and his son, Karti Chidambaram, are linked.
On August 28, two separate summons were issued by Dr Rajeshwar Singh, deputy director, ED — one to the managing director of M/s VHCPL and the other to V Dwarakanathan — the latter used as a conduit by Karti Chidambaram to increase his stake in Vasan via some front companies.
In his summons, Rajeshwar Singh explained that he was investigating under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002, and that the attendance of the managing director of VHCPL was necessary in connection with it.
In an annexure to the summons, the ED has sought information on eleven different aspects pertaining to the company. They include: (a) names and addresses of companies, firms and trusts in and outside India in which promoters, directors and shareholders of the VHCPL held positions since 2007 to 2012; (b) details of those who exited or entered the company between 2007 and 2012, along with number of shares issued, amount paid, premium, if any; (c) copy of the balance sheet for the same period; (d) net worth, profit and loss and dividend paid during these years; (f) details of shares and debentures issued by VHCPL; and (g) details of deposits received from individuals and companies and loans given during financial years 2007-08 to 2011-12.
In the other summons sent to Dwarakanathan, the ED sought copies of his passports, names of his family members, copy of I-T returns filed from 2004-05 to 2010-11, details of bank accounts and immovable assets held by him in India and outside since 2005, transactions done with companies of Karti Chidambaram and his family, names and addresses of companies in and outside India whose debentures and shares he acquired and transferred since 2005 under secondary sale of shares or in the market. The ED has also sought information about names and addresses of individuals from whom such shares and debentures were acquired and to whom they were transferred, amount paid for acquisition and amount received by transfer.
As reported in these columns, Vasan was first incorporated in 2007 with Dr M Arun and his wife, Meera Arun, as first shareholders, both of whom were issued 27 lakh shares of Rs 100 per share on a premium of Rs 100 plus. Three lakh shares were separately given to Dwarakanathan at the same price and premium.
Then begins the game. Within 48 hours of acquiring the shares, Dwarakanathan transferred half of his holdings (1.5 lakh shares equivalent to five per cent of Vasan’s capital) to a company which goes by the name, Advantage Strategic Consulting Private Ltd. This company is two-thirds owned by Ausbridge Holdings and Investments Pvt Ltd, which Karti Chidambaram (KC) holds almost fully. But the transfer of shares happened without any premium having been paid. In other words, KC’s company secures Vasan’s shares for a lesser price.
Why has Dwarakanathan chosen to buy shares at a premium and then sell them by incurring loss, is the obvious question that the ED has to look into. That could well and truly blow the lid off the entire operation of Vasan, whose turnover grew by 38 times in just three years.
If only the ED pursues the matter to its logical end, the link between Vasan and KC via Dwarakanathan will become known. For the last few years, no one doubted that the de facto owner of Vasan was KC. Otherwise, Vasan could not have raised equity of Rs 230 cr but a debt of over Rs 600 cr.

Vasan Eye Care's One-line Denial Shamelessly Evasive

Published: 19th September 2015 03:59 AM
Last Updated: 19th September 2015 10:24 AM
The New Indian Express came across through Twitter, Vasan’s one line denial of its exposé (“PC, Vasan Eye Care and Rs 223-cr Black Money” Sept 17, 2015) in a posting by Vasan in its business page on Facebook. Headlined “A note for all”, Vasan said in the post, “We vehemently deny the malicious and baseless allegations against our Company in the article.” For the rest, the FB post talked about how credible the Vasan board of directors is and how huge are the eye care services provided by it — neither of which was the subject of the NIE exposé. The same note minus the headline was addressed to the Editor of The New Indian Express on Thursday afternoon by fax. Since the note-turned “reply” talks about malicious and baseless allegations in the article, this paper wants to know what those allegations in the article are. The so-called reply is deafeningly silent on every critical question thrown up by the exposé. Here are some of the questions raised by the exposé which Vasan has to answer.
Who is J Dinakaran and what is JD Group?
What is Vasan’s relation with JD Group?
Did Vasan not receive Rs 8.56 cr as interest-free loan from JD Group?
Why did JD Group have to give interest-free loan to Vasan?
Did Dr Arun receive hundreds of crores of black money from JD Group?
Did JD Group not tell Vasan about the I-T search on them in Dec 2014?
If not, was Vasan unaware of the raid till September 17, 2015?
Who is Dwarakanathan?
Did Vasan not allot 3 lakh shares to Dwarakanathan on October 28, 2008, at a premium?
Did he not transfer 1.5 lakh out of it within 48 hours, reportedly at a loss of Rs 1.5 cr to a company controlled by Karti Chidambaram?
●  Were the turnover figures of Vasan mentioned in the article correct?
●  Can you explain how the top-line pole-vaulted from Rs 16 crore in the earlier year to Rs 311 cr in 2010-11, to Rs 462 cr in 2011-12 and to Rs 604 cr in 2012-13?
●  Did Vasan file balance sheet for 2013-14 due in Sept 2014 and when did it file it with company law authority?
●  Has it not filed the Income tax return for 2013-14 in 2014?
●  How did it file tax return without the balance sheet?
●  Did Vasan default in paying tax deducted at source of Rs 19.22 cr?
●  Did Vasan not know it is a serious offence which can send Dr Arun to jail?
●  Who gave Vasan the assurance no prosecution will be filed?
●  Who advised Vasan to write to the CBDT for time to pay the amount?
●  Did Vasan’s representative meet the CBDT chairman?
●  Was Vasan not valued at $1 billion in 2014 by Fitch?
●  Did Vasan not value itself at Rs 7,000 cr in 2014?
●  How is it that the high value company could not pay a relatively small tax deducted from others?
And a few more
●  Is not Dr A M Arun listed as the 244th richest in with Rs 2,314 cr in Hurun India report of 2015?
●  Why then did he not help Vasan pay tax deducted from others to the treasury?
●  Is Vasan paying its suppliers on time now?
●  Is it financially healthy now?
●  Has ED not issued notice to Vasan and Dr Arun on the transfer of 1.5 lakh shares from Dwarakanathan to Karti Chidambaram’s company?
But Vasan’s reply does not answer them because either it dare not or it is advised not to. Vasan does not dispute any facts in the article.
While replying to a charge, what is not denied is generally regarded admission.
It does not need any super lawyer to advise on such fundamentals. It is better not to reply than make one-line denials with adjectives like malicious and baseless without showing how it is malicious or baseless.
Vasan is deafeningly silent on the hard facts in the NIE exposé that raises questions which Vasan finds unanswerable. Result, Vasan attempts to escape them in a one-line denial. Vasan’s ritualistic denial shamelessly ducks the facts in the article and evades the obvious questions the exposé raises.
Post Script
Surprisingly there is no response or rebuttal from P Chidambaram or Karti Chidambaram. If the denial of Vasan is on their behalf also, the comments and questions equally hold good for them. But there are far more questions they have to answer than Vasan or Dr Arun.
(The author is a leading political and business commentator)
  • Avatar
    Thanks a lot for Indian Express for exposing such rouges .
    Vasan has not even paid its employees their salaries for the past three months , they didn't pay the incentives for the past one year, they didn't pay the TDS[tax deducted at source ] since 2013 -2014. and Dr Arun has stolen everyone's money and become the richest man. He should be jailed and all his assets should be seized.
    • Avatar
      surprising the the so called independent media both print & electronic have not picked up the story. Does the old corrupt regime still holds so much of clout with media houses? The Govt. should not spare any official who is trying to protect the corrupt. Whatever the english media shouts there is a great need in the Govt, to weed out officials who are inclined towards the previous regime. We have tolerated this filth enough.
      • Avatar
        Men may come and men may go, but Vasan will grow well as before like the Sun Group.
          • Avatar
            Brilliant !! TNIE - Three Cheers to you, Sir. True Ramanath Goenka spirit. Keep it up,
            regards
          http://linkis.com/newindianexpress.com/8odu3

          Authentic account of how Netaji reached Soviet Union and Nehru's perfidy

          $
          0
          0


          Embedded image permalink
          1. Mrs Pandit was told by Stalin in 1949 that Bose was his captive.
          2. Purabi Roy brought this out in 1st tranche of her research in Soviet Archives; PVNR cut scholarship; she pursued on own....
          3. final research out soon; Roy is heroine in her own right; saved, struggled, spent own money

          PC Vasan Eye care ghotala. NaMo, restitute kaalaadhan.

          $
          0
          0

          After Express Expose, Vasan Healthcare Director Quits

          Published: 20th September 2015 03:29 A
          CHENNAI: After the expose in The New Indian Express titled ‘PC, Vasan Eye Care and Rs 223 cr Black Money’, M/s Vasan Healthcare Pvt Ltd had issued a statement in which one of its claims was that the company’s board of directors is made up of senior and respected persons with vast corporate governance track record.
          One of its most respected and senior directors was M A Alagappan, who belongs to the reputed Murugappa Group. On March 16, 2011, Alagappan was appointed director of Vasan after he and his associates invested Rs 2 crore by subscribing to fresh equity shares in Vasan at a premium. When Express broke the story, Alagappan was in London. He is learnt to have forthwith tendered his resignation as Vasan’s director and insisted on it being accepted. Vasan’s board of directors accepted it on Saturday, it is learnt.
          Alagappan is a promoter of the Murugappa group with business turnover of over Rs 27,000 crore and profits of over Rs 1,800 crore. He had earlier acted as Executive Chairman of Murugappa Corporate Group and has now been succeeded by his family members.
          http://www.newindianexpress.com/states/tamil_nadu/After-Express-Expose-Vasan-Healthcare-Director-Quits/2015/09/20/article3037018.ece

          Finally Modi goes after Gandhi family -- Navin Upadhyay. NaMo, restitute kaalaadhan -- for poor people of Bharatam.

          $
          0
          0

          19 Sept. 2015


          • Finally, Modi goes after Gandhi family!

            Finally, Modi goes after Gandhi family!

            Navin Upadhyay

            New Delhi

            Sixteen months into office without reaching any closer to fulfilling his pre-election pledge to revive the sagging economy and conjuring up millions of jobs, Prime Minister Narendra Modi has finally decided to take on the Congress `first family’ in a clear signal that his regime would not let them rest in peace if they continued to stall the parliament and his economic reform agenda.
            On Friday, the Enforcement Directorate started two simultaneous proceedings against members of the Congress first family—Sonia Gandhi, Rahul Gandhi and Robert Vadra–that indicated that the Modi government was ready to escalate the war between the BJP and Congress to a new level. Both cases were gathering dust for a long time. The way the Enforcment Directorate (ED) decided to reopen them has left no one in doubt that the coming weeks and months could see bitter hostility between the Government and the main opposition.
            Aware that a “cornered” Congress will hit back by creating further hurdles in passage of legislation related to economic reforms in parliament, Modi has started reaching out to the opposition and signalling out the `grand old party’ for `ruining’ the country in his public speeches.
            To start with, the BJP has been able to win over Mulayam Singh Yadav whose Samajwadi Party recently pulled out of the anti-NDA alliance of the Janata Dal (U), Rashtriya Janata Dal and the Congress in Bihar. For obvious political reasons, and not to antagonize its Muslim vote bank in Uttar Pradesh, Mulayam Singh Yadav has rejected any deal between him and the Prime minister. But the fact remains that the SP took the decision to withdraw from the Nitish-led alliance two days after Mulayam’s brother and party General Secretary Ram Gopal Yadav met with BJP chief Amit Shah.
            Mulayam’s has backstabbed the Opposition much to the delight of the BJP amid allegations that the wily SP chief fell in line because of the ongoing CBI probe in massive corruption charges against Noida’s chief engineer Yadav Singh, who is also reported to have greased the palms of several Samajwadi party leaders and their sons. The factor that forced Mulayam’s hand in Bihar is expected to linger on for a long time in a country where a CBI probe is often used as a tool to blackmail political opponents. So, it is unlikely that the SP will play ball with the Congress in the winter session of parliament.
            Modi’s recent meeting with Nationalist Congress Party (NCP) chief, Sharad Pawar, another leader who is known for flip-flops and opportunistic politics, and NCP’s decision to walk out of the Nitish-led alliance seems part of the same script to isolate the Congress, so that the Government could go all out against the Gandhi family without fear of backlash from the combined opposition. Sharad Pawar has far too many vested interests in cricket and politics and sugar cooperatives to take on the BJP.
            Similarly, AIADMK chief J Jayalalitha shares a personal equation with Modi and will be expected to endorse any step the NDA government initiated against the Congress first family. On the issue of corruption, the left parties and the Aam Admi Party cannot come to the rescue of the Congress. Trinamool Congress chief Mamata Banerjee has no reason either to warm up to the Congress when her state is headed for polls next year.
            The BJP will hope that the Congress will crumble under pressure and start cooperating with the Centre, but in India politics such ‘vendetta’ politics has often invited backlash. Already, the Congress is accusing the Modi government of misusing the probe agencies to settle personal scores. Congress leaders claim that the National Herald case was closed by the previous Chief of the ED, Rajan Katoch, who was removed from his post on a complaint from BJP leader Subramanian Swamy that he was helping the Congress leaders in the case.
            Whatever Congress leaders may say but they face charges of committing serious financial impropriety in the NH case. Sonia, Rahul and top Congress leaders face allegations of conspiring to grab nearly Rs 5000 Cr of The National Herald ‘s landed property across the country.
            The Congress leadership will find it difficult to explain how it loaned Rs 90 cr to The National Herald when a political party in India cannot enter into any commercial transaction by using its fund. The CBI and the ED are expected to lodge cases against the Congress leaders for grabbing prime land allotted to the newspaper by the Urban Development Ministry. While the ED may register a complaint under the Provision of Money Laundering Act, the CBI may proceed against these leaders under the Prevention of Corruption Act…
            At the same time, to tighten the screws against the Congress first family, the Enforcement Directorate has started a probe into some land deals in Bikaner against unknown private entities that allegedly grabbed Government land and sold it later after making exorbitant profits. Many of the companies involved in the land grab are suspected to be linked to Vadra.
            The Haryana Government has already set up a judicial probe into the land grabbing charges against Vadra, and the report is expected soon.
            So far, as part of a tacit understanding, the BJP and the Congress never went against top leaders of each other’s party. Now, much of the political discourse in the coming weeks will depend on whether Modi breaks this `unwritten code’, or the recent actions by ED are mere red herrings!

            12 files on Netaji held back by Bamboo Mamata. NaMo, release ALL files on Netaji

            $
            0
            0

            ‘12 files on Netaji’s activities between 1941-42 held back’

            ‘12 files on Netaji’s activities between 1941-42 held back’
            KOLKATA: The declassification of Netaji files by the Bengal government is revealing more puzzling gaps than it's solving old ones. It turns out that 12 files placed before the justice Mukherjee Commission between 2001 and 2005 were not declassified on Friday. 

            What's more, 13 files in the Kolkata Police archives, released on Friday, had not been sent to the commission, says a researcher who had deposed before the panel. "I am tallying the files that were sent to the Mukherjee Commission with those that have been declassified. Altogether, 61 files were sent to the panel. The government has now come out with 64 files. But several of them do not match. Among those that have not been declassified are reviews of revolutionary activities of 1941 and 1942 by the Intelligence Branch," said Jayanta Chowdhury. 

            File no. 1621-42 that was not sent to the commission but has now surfaced is marked 'confidential' and is on Netaji's nephew Sisir Kumar Bose. It contains a foreign mail interception memo from the security control office at 3/1 Pretoria Street and is dated July 2, 1953. The intercepted letter was written by Sisir K Bose and addressed to Frau Emilie Schenkl in Vienna. It was posted on June 16, 1953. 

            READ ALSO: Snooping on Netaji's family 'proves he was alive after 1945', researchers say

            Netaji and India's dictatorship urge



            Assistant sub-inspector Becharam Mandal carried out the interception and photographed it before it was delivered. The memo confirms that a copy was kept and its contents forwarded to various intelligence officers, including K S Nair, assistant director of Intelligence Bureau under the home ministry. But the letter is not in the file. 

            Chowdhury says the missing letter is extremely significant and should have figured in the file. "There is no plausible reason why the letter went missing unless its contents were considered damaging at a later date and removed from the contents. Had SB officials felt the contents were inappropriate, the note would not have been there at all," he said. 

            An entry in file no. 357-42 has led to a rather curious inconsistency on Netaji's 'marriage' to Emilie Schenkl. Dated May 4, 1946, it contains a weekly survey of intelligence gathering on Netaji. It says: 'During secret interception, a very interesting letter from one Emilie Schenkl of Vienna addressed to Sarat Chandra Bose was noticed. Emilie Schenkl claims to be the widow of Subhas Chandra Bose... Subhas Bose proposed to her and they were married in January 1942. On November 29, 1942, a daughter was born... The marriage was not registered and was performed according to Hindu rites, on account of the German objection to marriage of Germans with foreigners.' 

            READ ALSO: 10 things to know about Netaji's declassified files 

            Chowdhury points out that in the book 'Letters to Emilie Schenkl: Netaji Collected Works (vol 7)', published by Netaji Research Bureau, the editorial footnote by Sisir Bose states that Netaji had secretly married Schenkl on December 26, 1937. "This discrepancy of more than four years is interesting. I wonder which version is correct and how the mistake happened," he said.  

            Chowdhury is also surprised by the relative lack of intelligence reports on the supposed plane crash in which Netaji allegedly died in Taiwan in August 1945. "For someone who was being tracked so assiduously for 'subversive' activities and whose family was under surveillance, one expects a lot of reports on the plane crash and how family members, friends and followers reacted to it. But strangely, there is very little on it. Also there is no reference to the ashes. What is seen instead is that after the British government, the state government on the behest of the Centre continues to be extremely active in snooping on Netaji's family," he added. http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/12-files-on-Netajis-activities-between-1941-42-held-back/articleshow/49029562.cms

            Sunday , September 20 , 2015 |

            The con-fidential game

            - THE FINE ART OF ‘RELIABLE INFORMATION’
            One of the files declassified by the Bengal government on Friday
            Calcutta, Sept. 19: If a Robert Langdon, the symbologist in The Da Vinci Code, is yet to leap from the 64 files to crack the Netaji Code, the vacuum is filled by the presence of many a Bernard Woolley, the bureaucrat caught between the politician and the civil service in the Yes Minister series.
            The so-called Netaji files, bereft of any explosive information and laden with old newspaper clippings, offer a peek into the woolly world of the intelligence-gathering bureaucracy that has perfected self-preservation into a fine art.
            The view can be fascinating for some (those sampling the curated excerpts served up on a platter) and frustrating for others (those who curated the gems after wrestling with 12,744 pages of impermeable prose and those who were supposed to take decisions long ago on the basis of such intelligence inputs.)
            A beginners' primer will not be out of place before stepping into the universe of establishments as evocatively christened as "Calcutta Police Security Control Office" or Intelligence Branch, from where "surveys" were conducted on Netaji's descendants.
            Confidential", "top secret" and " secret": If a document bears any of these stamps, chances are that a wet blanket is about to be spread out.
            A sample: File 10 has an arresting gem of intelligence, listed under the head "Unveiling the statue of Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose".
            The date is November 16, 1947, a few months after India won independence. If the pulse is racing and adrenaline rushing in anticipation of some explosive revelation, here it pops: "At the unveiling ceremony (300 including 50 girls) held at the crossing of Nimtalaghat Street and Ram Seth Road, on 16.11.47."
            The files also give an insight into what "secret information" means.
            Dated March 12, 1959, one input from the Calcutta Police Security Control Office on Pretoria Street says: "A secret information d/- 4.3.59 reveals that Shri Amiya Nath Bose(Netaji's nephew), 1, Woodburn Park Calcutta, has requested Mr. Wilhelm Keppler, Hamburg, Othmarochen, West Germany, to sent him an article on the works and activities of Shri Subhas Chandra Bose during his stay in Germany during 1941-1943."
            In the realm of intelligence, evidently there is a difference between "secret information" and "reliable information".
            In order to discern the difference, an example follows:
            An extract from a "weekly survey" by the police in July 1959 says: "According to a reliable information, dt. 26.6.59, Mrs. N.C. Vetter, Wein IX/69, Austria, Washington, 41 has congratulated Shri Amiya Nath Bose... for sending Academy Brochure to his friend Professor Mckgowan. Mrs. Vetter has also informed Shri Bose that she can send newspaper cuttings in German about Netaji if this be useful to him."
            The nature of the contents of the documents with "secret information" and "reliable information" does not appear to be dramatically dissimilar.
            However, they have been differently worded probably because of the source. The one with "secret information" does not mention any source, which suggests a police officer "intercepted" (the indecorous act of opening and reading a letter addressed to someone else) the mail and "accessed" the information.
            But the "reliable information" is credited to a "casual agent's report". Intelligence veterans said today that casual agents meant an informal source who supplied information in exchange for money or protection. A less fashionable term used by the initiated is "informers".
            Some of the files offer a lesson in drafting replies with enough room for manoeuvre.
            One file contains notes exchanged between intelligence officials on a passport application by Amiya Bose for travel to Europe along with his wife Jyotsna Bose.
            A memo related to a no-objection certificate for granting the passport says: "Copy forwarded to... asst. director, Intelligence Bureau, New Delhi for information. Amiya Nath Bose is the Secretary, Foreign Affairs Sub-Committee of the Socialist Republican Party and is proceeding to the U.K., France, Switzerland and Turkey as a representative of the 'Hindustan Standard' and 'Ananda Bazar Patrika'."
            If the memo was meant to serve as the basis for a no-objection certificate, the officer appears to have issued it without using any word or phrase that can pin him down later.
            The files have several newspaper clippings. A newspaper by definition means it will be circulated among many readers. Why newspaper clippings, which would already have been read by the public, were labelled "classified" in the first place and why they had to be "declassified" for people to read them will remain one of the greatest mysteries of our time.
            For instance, a "sensational" claim that suggested Netaji was alive after 1945 has made it to the files in the form of a Howrah CID report. The input is actually based on a report in theBlitz, a Bombay-based tabloid, on March 26, 1949.
            By any yardstick, a newspaper report that has already been printed cannot be termed "classified". The proof lies in several newspaper reports in 2013 quoting a book that mentions the Blitz report. In effect, the Bengal government has "declassified" a claim that was already in the public domain.
            Footnote: One news clipping in the files declassified on Friday suggests how little things have changed since 1940.
            A clipping dated June 13, 1940, from the Amrita Bazar Patrika says: "The first big drive of Alderman Subhas Chandra Bose to run the administration of the Calcutta Corporation... (was to) strike off its (the newspaper's) name from the list of the daily newspapers for the publication of corporation advertisements." Among the six selected for the advertisements was the Anandabazar Patrika from ABP, which also publishes The Telegraph.
            The clipping says the "move, it is understood, evoked a spirited protest from the European members".
            Matters have come full circle since then. On March 14, 2012, the Bengal government removed from the state-run library list some newspapers, including the Anandabazar Patrika and The Telegraph.

            http://www.telegraphindia.com/1150920/jsp/frontpage/story_43576.jsp#.Vf3ymNyqqko

            Blood lust -- Ravinar

            $
            0
            0

            SUNDAY, SEPTEMBER 13, 2015

            Blood Lust


            I sometimes do easy things. Because they are easy to do! Most people want a dream job. Most people don’t get such jobs. Most people get strutty jobs that pays for their livelihood. That’s the Mac dream. It is because the 95% are ordinary that the other 5% stand out and not the other way around. When Lee Iacocca started fixing Chrysler he found most managers in the company were prancing around with coffee cups in their hands through the corridors or loitering around gossiping at the water fountain. We just have to find these morons who loiter around the corridor who blabber, mean nothing, do nothing and create nothing to keep our emotional bankruptcy going. Make him the Boss... The Commies learned that trick long ago. Find a guy who does nothing and we can be in business and run a country (Oh the Congress found Gandhis long ago).

            When an anarchist like Arvind Kejriwal won his first CMship supported by the Commie Congress the beasts in the media came up with a chant… Will Kejri stop Modi? Will Kejri become PM? There were absolute idiotic bimbos like Saba Naqvi who even said there is a last minute surge in Varanasi for AK. These are the bimbos who blabber for 5000 bucks on your TV channels. You know – Unlike YOU… They have a dream job – Mental Masturbation everly for a price. Here is what Arnab Goswami said when Kejri won some election:

            You would think their mental-masturbation has been paid for. NO! They keep demanding more orgasms. So this pimp at India Today had the same question - 

            Karan The Tool Thapar 31.8.2015 – Is Hardik Patel a threat to BJP and Modi… Will Patel agitation go nationwide? BURN SOMETHING – That’s the only way to show you have fire. That is what our media does and so do some of our stupid G-37 panellists.

            There are two things here. Firstly, AK doesn’t want to be CM. He wants to be a vagabond , media item girl who will dance for anything. In a democracy, numbers matter. For a third rate joker party like AAP getting so much media space should tell you that the item girls pays for her own show. Secondly, those idiot Patels who participated in Hardik Patel’s rally to engineer chaos and anarchy are doing exactly what AK wants to do. You see, AK’s Muslim crap has failed, his funds have dried up and his only ploy left to create chaos and anarchy is to use morons like Hardik Patel to BURN any state that does not have Commie rule.

            We are hearing about a Gas dealers’ agitation. Why do these people want to agitate? Stupid subsidies are directly passed on to customers. So they are making losses? So the only way these scumbags made profits was through corruption? The answer is absolutely YES! Then there is thing about some meat ban somewhere. So Sagarika, AK’s sub-prime promoter, says she would like her meat dripping with blood.

            The answer to these bimbos is undebatable – You have eaten the flesh of Indians dripping with blood all through the last 60 years. It is not our fight anymore – The fight is between bimbos like Hardik V Sagarika (Both through AK) – You want blood…. Go get it! 

            51 comments:

            1. Hard hitting as always. Thanks.
              Reply
            2. I wonder when a section of Media will call shots on Sagarika's tweet on her "like her meat dripping with blood". Instead we have sold out journalists like Om Thanvi, Shravan Patel who used to be rational long ago but bought over for trinkets of flat, foreign trips, advertisement... I feel whole media (English, Hindi, Gujarati, Marathi... every one) was bought and it was never a fourth pillar - it in fact became a Congress-Commies strutted pillar to help them run their acidic design against this country. Wish social media continue to rise and thwart the evil design and machinations of such sold out people, ideology and bankrupt media.
              Reply
              Replies
              1. True, those charged with reporting the reality are just maligning the majority and non-Abrahamic minority. Relentless anti-national propaganda.
            3. You want blood ,go get it....
              The hard Truth of present day
              Reply
            4. Sagarika, AK's sub-prime promoter.... Liked that. :)
              Reply
            5. Dear mediacrooks - I think you should seriously consider publishing your blog in regional languages and Hindi. Objective of your writeup will be best served then.
              Reply
              Replies
              1. Agree.Time for Ravi to expand.
              2. Welcome back �� Sir. Wishing you a speedy recovery.
            6. Dear mediacrooks - I think you should seriously consider publishing your blog in regional languages and Hindi. Objective of your writeup will be best served then.
              Reply
            7. Well written. These media morons always want India dripping with blood. C5M has tweeted she had eaten deer which is banned. Such is her brazenness that she is able to tweet the unlawful activity which she did and hide behind press freedom.
              Reply
            8. Mind blowing article as usual Sir
              Reply
            9. "As to blood—ah, blood, the whole subject fascinates me. I do like that as well, warm and dripping, when I am thirsty. And I am often thirsty."
              — Christopher Pike (The Last Vampire (The Last Vampire, #1))
              Reply
            10. Hope all these people agitating realise that all their outrage is last surge of their effort, which is bound to fail. You've rightly pointed out that they're lazy, incompetent , so they may wish the worst on India but are too corrupt to act intelligently enough to destroy it . Jai hind
              Reply
            11. Dear Sir

              2 much gap burnol and eno sales up as g37 burning
              Reply
            12. Let me think, which animal wants it meat with dripping blood? Even Hyena is not close enough.
              Reply
            13. For these media crooks every tom,dick and harry are a threat to Modi and every drop in sensex or drop in rainfall etc is reflected on Modi's performance. The Gutter Mouth of Bihar L;allu even went to the extent of saying the Modi visit to Bihar for Rally were bad omen. This gutter mouth Lallu has really fallen into abysmal gutter. The same with these media crooks bankruptcy of rationality and ideas. They, as you rightly say derive an orgasmic urge to relate all sundry and nonsense to Modi. Last Desperate attempt. The Blood thirsty lady crook can become a Vampire smelling blood at dark nights - a lady Draculla!
              Reply
              Replies
              1. Spot on!
                Anything goes wrong n its bcos of Modi. What the hell.
                C Company n it's franchise. Ceo Sona, directing the business.
            14. Great writing though relatively a short blog.
              Reply
            15. welcome back sir.....please see if the time b/w two posts is less...we cant wait for so long
              Reply
            16. Our MSM is no fourth pillar, or fifth pillar of democracy. It is a FILTH PILLAR, soiled by foreign shady money embroiled in heaps of money laundering cases.
              Reply
            17. As I keep saying, perhaps the only way these hatemongering scumbags will be stopped will inevitably involve blood. But not the kind they will like.
              Reply
            18. hmm..Meat ban.. I remember speaking to one of my muslim friends who said generally it is the butchers who decide the day of Ramadan. The whole thing about sighting of moon is gimmicky and they have a big say on when Ramadan falls.
              Reply
            19. Their desperation is showing! Crooks are clutching at anything just anything that will some how stop Modi or BJP or RSS or Hindus.Witness the way Hardik Patel was made in to a hero like AK - overnight.Or witness the way they are screaming at MIM for having chosen to fight Bihar polls.They keep warning about division of Muslim votes.It was Rahul G who failed them.Then it was AK.Now Nitish or even Lalu - a man who has actually been jailed for his loot.He has emerged as saviour.Next they are likely to prop up Mamata or Maya.Just any one - no other crooks have been so desperate for so long.
              Reply
            20. It is not our fight anymore – The fight is between bimbos like Hardik V Sagarika (Both through AK) - I felt for some time, may be Modi had the clarity to think this on a broader scale, and ignored the MSM completely. But as most of us common men, we always lust for a word by word rebuttal from him for every stupid utterances from these bimbos, but of late, I think everyone is coming to their senses, it does not matter in the long run. Thats why I think he is a great leader, and a visionary...
              Reply
            21. Sagarika ghost is vampire in female form and Rajdeep should be careful.
              Reply
            22. Once Hardik Patel's this agitation fails, I have a suggestion, his next agitation should be, also give us Patels subsidy to perform "Yatra" or stop subsidy for all.
              These pseudo Secular media morons did not say a word when some schools banned mid-day meals during Ramadan month for all students but years old meat ban during Jain festival is hurting them. They did not utter a word when the principal of a Convent school tried to rub Mehndi off Hindu girls' hands and cut off Rakhis off wrists of boys claiming no religion related 'ornaments' in school, while the Principal herself wearing Cross pendant necklaces.
              Reply
              Replies
              1. //These pseudo Secular media morons did not say a word when some schools banned mid-day meals during Ramadan month for all students but years old meat ban during Jain festival is hurting them. They did not utter a word when the principal of a Convent school tried to rub Mehndi off Hindu girls' hands and cut off Rakhis off wrists of boys claiming no religion related 'ornaments' in school, while the Principal herself wearing Cross pendant necklaces.//
                Excellent, mention the states also where this happened for sickulars to read and understand......
            23. Again another revelation.
              C Company - G37. So whats the businesses?
              A) meat, alcohol, drugs, prostitution, trading lies.
              N saga whats wrong with u"meat dripping in blood". R u human. I doubt.
              Reply
            24. Paying encomiums to the author serves no useful purpose. We all know that the situation is worsened. How to resurrect the Fourth Estate lost to the Italian design.Think big and act tough.
              Reply
            25. ha ha. how I wish Ravinar has a wider TV audience for his say!!!!!!
              Reply
            26. DEAR MEDIACROOKS, u should try to remain more neutral as currently u r coming across as a MODI MOUTHPIECE
              Reply
            27. Ravinar Sir! Is there no way we can have your blogs translated into Hindi and other widely read Indian languages and popularized? else, such wonderful posts are read only by a miniscule minority ( vis a vis the vast population)
              Reply
            28. How can C5M Eat Pork Meat otherwise she will not be Considered PSecular because in Psecular Pork is Banned.
              Reply
            29. Dear Mr Ravinar
              I love ur posts and this word..... Mental Masturbation,,,,hillarious n aptly said.
              You know Sir some Unknown person has said ur coming out as Modi Mouthpiece
              Well i love my fellow country men....We like to comment but from behind....We want a change but wait for someone else to start
              Wonder when we will wake up n Be the change ourselves.
              Anycase all i would say to Modi critics is that If not him then Whom. I do not advocate my self as Modi fan but do we have a choice. He is the only light through the dark tunnel. Whether he passes the acid test or not one does not know but for sure he will not fail the way others have.
              Keep up your writing n Thank you for enlightening us
              Regards
              bhavik
              Reply
            30. Really a nice stuff,the images shown are rare one and not found in other webpages. keep sharing such a relevant content. Greatful to find useful content like Infoshutter knowledge portal.
              Reply
            31. This comment has been removed by the author.
              Reply
            32. काफी समय से मैंने इन चैनलों को देखना बंद कर दिया है ऐसा लगता है की हम एक अन्धकार युग में जा रहे हैं.. आखिर भारतीय मीडिया इतना तर्कहीन, विद्वेषी, संस्कार घातक और कलुष क्यों है.. क्यों इसकी भारतीय सभ्यता से दुश्मनी सी है.. हम भारतीय लोगों में से ही कुछ इनमे काम करते हैं.. तो फिर ये किस धन का असर है है की ये सब कुछ नकारने पर तुले हैं.. अगर इनका यही तरीका रहा तो इनका न रहना ही श्रेयस्कर है.. नहीं चाहिए फूहड़, गन्दी और विगलित मानसिकता के संस्कार जो हमारे समाज को खोखला कर देना चाहते हैं.. बंद कर दो इनको की देशद्रोह को ये देशप्रेम से ऊंचा मानते हैं.. न जाने कौन इनका आका है और किस प्रकार का धन इस कुकर्म में झोंका जा रहा है..
              Reply
            33. BJP govt HRD minister Smriti Irani can do a good job of harmonizing the Indian degrees with those of other countries in Europe & America, Canada, New Zealand, Middle East..etc., which may take 2-3 years and tweaking some finer points in present education system itself can generate immense employment. currently many countries do not recognize Indian degrees for some reason or other. If the acceptances come, by tweaking syllabus, or conducting some additional exams, to bring it at par with those of other advanced countries, then it open flood gates to indian techies (mainly doctors & engineers)
              Reply
            34. Media Item Girl - hahahaha.... You nailed it Ravinar. A fittingly apt description for the scumbag kujliwal.
              Reply
            35. When I read English media it appears they want to keep the communal issues alive. It appears to be some great conspiracy against BJP and Modi and in general against Hindus. The way all opposition conspired against the 13 day Vajpayee Govt now even after winning a clear majority BJP has to face such big hurdles of maligning opposition from all quarters is pathetic. This explains why it took 800 + 200 years for us to get freedom from Muslim and British rulers. understanding this disunity sickness very well RSS founder Dr.Hedegwar started RSS with the sole aim of uniting all Hindus and root out the regional and caste fissures among us. But even after 90 years of starting this great organization wehave not made any reat strides for unity. Even MK Gandhi said to the RSS that they could bring in a caste less society that He himself could not. Instead of brining SC & STs into mainstream Gandhi labeled them as Harijans and they got drifted away more. I am surprised that even being different countries europe can become one European union but different states in India couldnot be united on one thread despite having same culture.
              Reply
            36. Dear Sir this SUAR KAA GOSHT aka Sagarika Ghost forgot one thing, she likes meat dripping in Blood because of the company of that Italian Witch Lady Dracula. But she has forgotten that she can ONLY eat the meat deliciously laced with Italian Dog shit and Pig piss. Also she loves her all holes filled with Dog semen, 4 in 1 but dogs should be white preferably Italian, and c..t filled with the semen o her son and all white tourists, 4 in 1, 21600 times a day After all she is a protege of Phillip Tattaglia of Media, MR PORNO ROY WHO brought Professional STICKIN artists from Bangaldeshi Brothels to Mediawhores. A trillionare so called Commie Rat and a shiteater of Italian Madam.
              Reply
            37. Sir, you can also check and its the Duty of all nationalists like Ravinarji and Subramanium Swamy Sir. I will repeat what I had said many times. Somewhere in Jan (25th Jan around) 2005, Channel 7JTV,the Channel of Jagran TV (now part of ITALIAN BASTARDS NETWORK=CNN-IBN7 made by the duo of Sonagacchi-Bangaldeshi Monkey-Rat crossed Overused Rancid Oversized "ASSET" of a christian Pros Sagarika and the product of unknown Portuguese Father and "Filthy" mother the Xian Rat Rajdeep ashamed of his REAL PORTUGUESE ITALIAN GENETICS) reported in 9 PM news that Rajiv Gandhi assasination report was out, but was so explosive that the Central Law Minister at that time H.R.Bhardwaj, the later nefarious Karnataka Governor, himself went to suppress that report. The reporter of that channel repeatedly asked this H.R Bhardwaj abt it but the rat refused to even open his mouth. The news was not repeated in other broadcasts. Next day the channel suddenly went OFFAIR due to 'Technical reasons". Third day, a 2 bit gutter news reader known as Rajdeep Sardesai (SUAR-DESAI) from NDTV, earning maybe Rs 10000/- PM, had created a MEDIA MEGA CORPORATION with USA CNN called CNN-IBN, BOUGHT CHANNEL7 JTV lock stock and barrel, had a full team of Professional Prost and Pimps ready, did a Rs 1 lakh FAKE STING on hapless B. Laxman and suppressed the REAL NEWS. WITHIN TWO DAYS this gutter degenerate Pimp of Indian AQSA MOHAMMAD, had ALL THE MONEY, A PROFESSIONAL TEAM AND STING UNDER HIS BELT? IMPOSSIBLE EVEN FOR BILL GATES AND WARREN BUFFET
              Reply
              Replies
              1. Mr.Unknown, I think your replies are very crude and downright objectionable. This blog is all about objective analysis and not about name calling and abusing. Please refrain from such abuse as very serious issues are discussed here.
              2. cool man, he is writing what we all want to, but have no guts
            38. BJP ruled states to move quickly and implement land reforms to make business easy. First to start making water available for agriculture. If this single industry can increase its productivity, India can become self sufficient in food stuff, atleast can reduce "hunger poverty" and can result in less burden for govt, and can also think of reducing the incoming tax.
              Reply
            39. Dear Ravi, hope u r reading this.... Discipline is the key for everything we do. As a follower of ur post I do expect some consistency from you or indication on when is ur next post.
              Reply
            40. Since the news of sheena bora murder came into lime light, almost all channels (english & hindi) became investigative agencies running 24 x 7 for full 10 days, to misery of indian public, media behaving hysterically, as if India came to standstill & stopped working.....
              Reply
            41. Do you know to which partythey belong to ?
              Former law minister Kapil Sibal charges at least Rs.8 lakh and up to Rs.15 lakh for one appearance at the Supreme Court. Congress politician Abhishek Manu Singhvi and Harish Salve (the son of late Congress politician NKP Salve), who is now also a London barrister, generally charge upwards of Rs.6 lakh for one day’s appearance in a case in the Supreme Court, with Salve charging up to Rs.15 lakh.
              But when Subramanium goes to the Delhi high court he charges Rs.11-16.5 lakh. And when he heads to tribunals, his rates are at least Rs.25 lakh per appearance.

              Rajya Sabha member and Congress politician K.T.S. Tulsi, who is also a former additional solicitor general (ASG) of India, charges between Rs.5 lakh and Rs.6 lakh in the Supreme Court. But the sought-after criminal attorney is busier in the lower courts and the high court where he charges around Rs.9 lakh.

              Others charging in the range of Rs.5-6 lakh in the Supreme Court are Supreme Court Bar Association president Dushyant Dave, C.A. Sundaram, and former ASGs L. Nageswara Rao and Parag Tripathi.

              Dave and Sundaram are rarely seen in the Delhi high court by most accounts, but Rao charges in the range of Rs.3-4 lakh and Tripathi charges in the range of Rs.7-10 lakh for one Delhi high court hearing. There are also seniors in Delhi who appear almost exclusively in the high courts.
              Ram Jethmalani 25 lacs
              Harish Salve 6-15 lacs
              Abhishek Manu Singhvi 15 lacs
              CA Sundaram 6 - 17 lacs
              Dushyant Dave 10 lacs
              K T S Tulsi = 7lacs
              Kapil sibal = 9-16 lacs
              Chidambaram - 7-15 lacs
              Gopal Subramanimum - 11-17 lacs
              Sounds these all belong to one national party only.... and these were also indirectly appointing judges.... any under table link to mold or doctor the judgments.
              Reply

            http://www.mediacrooks.com/2015/09/blood-lust.html#.Vf32HNyqqko

            Tuisto, Founder of the Germanic People (according to Tacitus) was Tvaṣṭṛ of Rigveda. Links Mleccha (Meluhha) of Indus Script with Germanic people of Germania.

            $
            0
            0
            Mirror: http://tinyurl.com/oydr6x2

            Tuisto, Founder of the Germanic People (according to Tacitus)

            Tuiscon (Tuisto) as depicted in a German broadside by Nikolaus Stör c. 1543, with a caption by Burkard Waldis. 

            Meyer considers Tuisto and  Tvaṣṭṛ  of Rigveda to be identical. [Meyer (1907) sees the connection as so strong, that he considers the two to be identical.( Meyer (1907): referenced in : North, Richard (1997). Heathen Gods in Old English Literature. Cambridge University Press.(p.269)] Tuisto is described as being "celebrated" (celebrant) by the early Germanic peoples in song, with Tacitus reporting nothing negative about Tuisto. (Lindow, John. (2001) Norse Mythology: A Guide to the Gods, Heroes, Rituals, and Beliefs, p. 296).

            Tacitus' reference to Mannus as the son of Tuisto is instructive and jibes with the Indian tradition of Manu as a form of Tvasta together with Maya, Silpi and Visvajna. Vishvakarma [ God ] created five prajapathies — from his five faces such as Sadyojāta,Vāmadeva, Aghora,Tatpuruṣha,Īsāna.[11] They are Manu, Maya, Tvasta, Silpi, Visvajna. These memories among the people is so strong that the narrative of Tacitus about Tuisto may indeed be a recollected memory of  Tvaṣṭṛ and also Visvakarma of Rigveda  It is no mere accident that both  Tvaṣṭṛ and Visvakarma of Rigveda are related as the divinities venerated by artisans, artificers, smiths who make vajra, the thunderbolt and other weapons and metal implements.

            These narratives are  evidence validating Indus Script Corpora as catalogus catalogorum of metalwork, together with archaeometallurgical evidences, say, recovered from Chanhu-daro.

            These narratives together with the evidence of Gundestrup Cauldron with Indus Script hieroglyphs may be evidence of migrations of Bharatam Janam into Europe establishing contacts with Germanic peoples described in Tacitus'Germania.

            The links of Mleccha (Meluhha) with Germanic people of Germania date to ca. 3rd millennium BCE.
            A ‘Sheffield of Ancient India’: Chanhu-Daro’s Metal working Industry. Illustrated London News 1936 – November 21st, p.909. 10 x photos of copper knives, spears , razors, axes and dishes..http://bharatkalyan97.blogspot.in/2015/06/tvastr-as-visvakarma-karu-smith-cire_17.html

            Tuisto was Tvaṣṭṛ of Rigveda who produced the metal weapon: vajra, the thunderbolt. The divinity Tvaṣṭṛ is mentioned in the Mitanni treaty, which establishes him as a Proto-Indo-Iranian divinity. Tvaṣṭr is Śukrācārya's son, Śukrācārya (the weapons' mentor of the asura) is Bhṛgu's grandson and Vāruṇibhṛgu's son. Tvaṣṭr is the father of ViŚvarupa.

            See: http://bharatkalyan97.blogspot.in/2015/06/tvasta-metal-artificer-was-meluhha.html This includes RV 10.90  which identifies Tvaṣṭṛ (Sanskritत्वष्टृ) is the first born creator of the universe. Also included is RV 10.82 which venerates Visvakarman n associations with Vtra and Dadhici, episodes later elaborated in Bhagavata Purana. See: http://bharatkalyan97.blogspot.com/2015/06/tvastr-is-metaphor-for-veneration-of.html Tvaṣṭr̥ is a metaphor for veneration of metalwork artificers, Bhāratam Janam, in Rigveda. RV 1.80.16 refers to Dadhyanc, son of Atharvan; RV 1.80.1 refers to Indra wielding the metal vajra thunderbolt weapon against VRtra. RV 1.85.9 refers to Indra slaying VRtra using the vajra made by TvaSTA and releasing the water of oceans. RV 1.32.1, RV 1.32.5 to 14, RV 1.52.2 to 15, RV 1.61.6 to 12, RV 1.80.3 to 5, RV 1.80, 3 to 13, RV 1.85.9, RV 1.86.6, RV 2.1.11, RV 3.54.15, RV 4.42.7, RV 6.47.2, RV 10.48.8, RV 10.65.2, RV 10.65.10, RV 10.66.8 also refers to Indra's battle against VRtra and as the slayer of VRtra. The gloss vRTrhA of RV 2.1.11 is also explained by Sayana as 'destroyer of sin'.

            These references reinforce the role of Tvaṣṭā as a metal artificer who made metallic weapons. This gets elaborated in a narrative in the Bhagavata Purana related to a son of Tvaṣṭā called Vis'varupa who was killed in battle. 

            There is a remarkable episode of mispronunciation by Tvaṣṭā, making him a mleccha. This mispronunciation with a wrong accent on the phrase: Indra-śatro resulted in the birth of Vtra who, instead of becoming a slayer of Indra, gets killed in battle by Indra.

            "The sagas, which are the sole record of their past history, say that the God Tuisto (Or Tuisco, the deity that gives its name to Tuesday)sprang from the earth, and that he and his son Mannus were the authors and founders of the race. To Mannus they ascribe three sons, whose names are borne respectively by the Ingaevones["Grimm's identification of the Ingaevones with the Saxons, of the Iscaevones with the Franks, and of the Herminones with the Thuringians is convenient " (Stubbs, Const. Hist., i. 38]mext to the ocean, the Herminones in the middle of the countiy, and the Iscaevones in the rest of it. Others, with true mythological license, give the deity several more sons, from whom are derived more tribal names, such as Marsians, Gambrivians, Suabians, and Vandals ; and these names are both genuine and ancient. The name Germany, however, is new and of recent application, owing to the fact that the first of these peoples to cross the Rhine and dispossess the Gauls, a tribe now known as the Tungrians, then got the name of "Germans". Thus what was originally a name given to a tribe and not that of a race gradually came to be accepted, so that all men of the race were called Germans, by the victorious tribe first as a name of fear, and by themselves afterwards when the name  had once been coined. "(The Agricola and Germania of Tacitus, 1894, Tr. KB Townshend, Methuen & CO.Aberdeen Univ. Press,pp.54-55) https://archive.org/stream/tacitusagricolag00taciiala/tacitusagricolag00taciiala_djvu.txt


            "While the gods Indra and Agni stood for Power and Wisdom, the gods PUSan and Bhaga, Rbhus, TvaSTA and Vis'vakarman presided over the economic activities of the people. The technical and the ritual aspects of productive activity were closely united just as the forms of wealth were conceived in close connection with the favour of the gods...All rUpas are of TvaSTA (the divine fashioner). TvaSTA inherited them from Agni or, as Aitareya has it, TvaSTA is nothing but speech. In other words, all forms are originally contained in divine wisdom, the ultimate illuminer. It is from there that the artificing and fashioning mind derives them. Reality is conceived as a luminous powere which creates things or forms out of itself. The human mind is capable of responding to the Light and apperceiving the forms in which it expresses itself. The forms which man perceives, thus, are not phantasms produced by the senses or the mind but created things rooted in reality."(Pande, GC, 1990, Foundations of Indian culture: spiritual vision and symbolic forms, Delhi, Motilal Banarsidass, p.61, p.344)
            "According to the Bhagavat Purana, he chanted: “Indra-satro vivardhasva ma ciram jahi vidvisam” (“O enemy of Indra, flourish to kill your enemy without delay”). (Bhagavat Purana 6.9.11). Tvasta intended to chant the word indra-satro, meaning, “O enemy of Indra.” Instead of chanting those words short, Tvasta chanted it long, and its meaning changed from “the enemy of Indra” to “Indra, who is an enemy.” Consequently, instead of a son who would kill the king of the gods, he had a son who would die at Indra’s hands. The smallest mistake in pronunciation led to his plans being foiled." -- Nimai Agarwalhttp://kidspiritonline.com/2014/12/the-power-of-words-in-my-tradition/
            [quote]hata-putras tatas tvasta
            juhdvendraya satrave 
            indra-satro vivardhasva
            ma ciramjahi vidvisam

            TRANSLATION

            After Visvarupa was killed, his father, Tvasta, performed ritualistic ceremonies to kill Indra. He offered oblations in the sacrificial fire, saying, "O enemy of Indra, flourish to kill your enemy without delay."

            PURPORT

            There was some defect in Tvasta's chanting of the mantra because he chanted it long instead of short, and therefore the meaning changed. Tvasta intended to chant the word indra-satro, meaning, "O enemy of Indra." In this mantra, the word indra is in the possessive case (sasthi), and the word indra-satro is called a tat-purusa compound (tatpurusa-samasa) . Unfortunately, instead of chanting the mantra short, Tvasta chanted it long, and its meaning changed from "the enemy of Indra" to "Indra, who is an enemy." Consequently instead of an enemy of Indra's, there emerged the body of Vrtrasura, of whom Indra was the enemy.

            Bhag. 6.9.11

            In the compound word indra-satro, the ending of the word satro is uttered short when it is in the possessive case (sasthi) and long when it is in the vocative case (sambodhana) . Tvasta mistakenly uttered it long. He expected "Indra's killer" to be born from the sacrifice, but the mantra he uttered meant "Indra is the killer of the person to be born."

            In the above scenario, "long" and "short" do not denote dirgha and hrasva (see section 2.4.2 on vowels), but long (udatta) and short (anudatta) pitch accents on vowels (also in 2.4.2). Tvasta spoke Vedic Sanskrit (vaidika bhasa or vaidika samskrta), in which the word meaning can change depending on the pitch in which a vowel is accented. Vedic Sanskrit occurs only in the sruti-sastra, the four Vedas, and it is also called srauta bhasa. The rest of Sanskrit literature is written in classical Sanskrit (laukika bhasa or laukika samskrta), which is not altered by vowel pitch accents.

            The commentaries by Sridhara Svami and Varhsidhara on Bhagavatam 6.9.11 explain this incident in more detail. They say that the version of the mantra given in 6.9.11 is different from the mantra used by Tvasta. The mantra given in the Vedas and described by Sridhara Svami and Vamsidhar was indra-satrur vardhasva, and their explanations of the mistake are based on this. It was customary to change a Vedic mantra a bit when mentioning sruti texts in writing because the audience did not necessarily have qualifications (adhikara) in sruti. Hence the mantra from the Veda was changed in 6.9.11. Or it was changed owing to considerations of the verse meter. Hence we see that there is no actual vocative in the Vedic mantra. Sridhara Svami mentions that the mistake was in the svaras, vowel pitch accents. As far as the letters were concerned, they were accurately chanted. The mistake in the svaras (vowel pitch accents) was that he chanted "indra" with the udatta accent, which changed it from what was intended (a tatpurusa meaning "Indra's enemy") to something else (a bahuvrihi) meaning  Tndra is the killer of the person to be born." [unquote] 
            Vritra is also mentioned in the Rig Veda, where he is the demon of drought, who imprisons all the strom clouds and causes drought. Indra slays him with his thunder-bolt (Vajra) and frees the strom-clouds, bring bountiful rain to end the famine.

            Slaying of Vritra


            This story is taken from B.P. and Bhagavata Purana (Canto 6, Chapter 7-13).
            Brihaspati was the Guru of the Devas. He was very learned and was first among the Brahmanas. Everyone used to respect him. It so happened, that when he visited the court of Indra, the King of the Gods was busy watching his beautiful Apsaras sing and dance, saw his Guru arrive. However, in his arrogance, he did not rise from his throne, nor did he utter the customary words of welcome and worship.

            The sage felt insulted. He resolved that he will no longer grace the councils of the Devas, and went away to perform penance. Too late, Indra realized his mistake. H searched high and low for his perceptor, but could not find him. Without their Guru to guide them, the Devas could not survive for long. Besides, their traditional foes, the Asuras, will seek to exploit this opportunity to and cash in on their weakened state.

            Acting on the advice of Lord Brahma, the Devas installed Vishwarupa, the son of the God Tvashta as their new Guru. He was also a Brahmana renowned for his learning and yogic power. As time progressed, Vishwarupa started to notice that Indra and the Devas spent an inordinate amount of time in pursuit of pleasure. Besides, his mother was aAsura woman, and his loyalty was divided. Secretly, he started giving a portion of the sacrificial oblations (Havis) to the Asuras. As a result, their strength increased.

            When Indra came to know of this treachery, he became very angry. Without pausing to think the consequences of his actions, he struck off the three heads of Vishwarupa. The first head, that was used for drinking Soma, became a francolin partridge, the second head, used for drinking wine turned into a sparrow and the third, used for eating, turned into a partridge. the head of his teacher with his sword. Since he had killed a Brahmana, that too his Guru, he became guilty of the sin of Brahma-Hatya. However, he escaped his punishment by distributing the sin among the land, water, and women. (Other accounts say that his lusture diminished and he had to regain it by doing penance, during which time he was exiled from heaven.) In return for ridding Indra of the sin, earth got water to fill its empty holes, trees got re-growth of cut branches, waters became purifying, and women obtained undiminished sexual desire. As a result of their share of the sin, earth has wastelands, trees have sap, waters have froth, and women have menstruation.

            Now, Tvashta wanted revenge for the murder of his son. He began arrangements for a sacrifice that would give him a son who could slay Indra. The sacrifice was duly performed, but there was a small problem. When it was time for the final incantations, Tvashta ought to have said, "May this son of mine be the slayer of Indra", but he stressed the wrong syllables in the Mantra, and the meaning changed to "May Indra be the slayer of this son of mine."
            From the sacrificial fire, there rose a terrible Asura. He was named Vritra, 'the encloser'. He immediately grew immensely big and was as large as the largest mountain. His hair was like molten copper, he had a mustache and beard of the same color and had eyes blazing like the midday sun. He was armed with a magical trident. He derived his immense strength from the incantations chanted at the sacrifice. His father then ordered him to go and slayIndra. Obedient to the command, the demon began to seek the slayer of his elder brother.

            Some time before this, the Asuras had been thoroughly defeated by the Devas in battle. Peace reigned for a while. The Devas needed a place to store their weapons safely, for they feared treachery. They then remembered that the Asuras dared not approach the hermitage of the sage Dadhichi, such was the yogic power of the hermit. They entrusted all their weapons to his safekeeping.

            When Dadhichi's wife Lopamudra came to know about this, she was not pleased. She said to her husband, "An ascetic should not take sides in a war. Now the Asuras will think that you are their enemy and seek to harm you. Besides, the Gods have not mentioned how long you are to take care of their weapons. If something were to happen to them in your custody, will they not blame you. We have renounced all worldly possessions and attachments, you were wrong to have taken this responsibility."

            Dadhichi saw the force of her arguments. He said, "What you say certainly makes sense. However, I have given my word. It is important to stand by ones promise. Besides, the Asuras were always the enemies of us sages, so the question of neutrality does not arise. What is fated will happen, and no one prevent it."

            Years passed, and Dadhichi was alarmed to note that the lusture of the divine weapons was beginning to diminish. Their power was slowly dissolving in air. The sage then used his yogic power to dissolve all the weapons in water and then he drank it all up. Their power was then lodged in his bones.

            Now, with Vritra threatening at their doorsteps, the Devas wanted their weapons back. Dadhichi said, "I have bad news for you. Your weapons are no longer there. Their power now resides in my bones. I shall give up my life. You can then have new weapons made from my bones."

            The Gods naturally balked at the thought of the Rishi's death. However, no other choice was available, for they needed the weapons to battle VritraDadhichi gave up his life. Vishwakarma made Indra the weapon Vajra from the back bone of the hermit. This weapon was the most powerful weapon of all.

            The armies of the Devas and Asuras met in the battlefield. From the furious onslaught of the Asura army, theDevas were initially driven back, but they redoubled their efforts and slowly gained the upper hand.

            Seeing his forces retreating, Vritra was extremely angry. He charged ahead and stopped the advance of the Devas single-handedly. He let out a mighty roar, which caused many of the Devas to faint. Under his purposeful tread, the heavens began to shake. He picked up his immense mace and struck Iyravata with it. Indra revived his mount with a touch of Amrit.

            At this point, angry words were exchanged between Vritra and Indra

            The Asura taunted Indra for having slain his brother, a defenseless Brahmana

            Angered, Indra struck off one hand of Vritra with his sword. In retaliation, theAsura made his mouth immensely huge and swallowed Indra whole.

            Though he was swallowed by the AsuraIndra did not die, for he was protected by the grace of Vishnu. He judged it to be time to use his Vajra. He used the great weapon and sliced open the abdomen of the demon, and emerged victorious.

            However, having slain the creature emerged from a holy sacrifice, he was once again weighed down with sin. Unlike before, he could not get rid of it easily. He retired to the banks of Manasarovar and performed a penance for thousand years to expiate his sins and to regain his lusture.

            http://web.archive.org/web/20070105054802/http://members.cox.net/apamnapat/articles/SlayingOfVritra.html

            Sky as witness to history (Website) - Kalyanaraman (April 2013) -- Chelvapila

            $
            0
            0
            Dear Friends,
                                 As you know how the flat earth believers and their cohorts, the seculars have been deriding every thing our culture and civilization put forward, from our epics to eating habits. And they call themselves scientific, rational yet advocate beef eating contrary to science which tells us increased risks in humans consuming such flesh which is only befitting for a jackal . 

            Same contempt is shown also to our epics dismissing them as mythology while their superstitions remain proven since they are scientific, at least that is what they say.

            Regardless their attempts to deny, denigrate every thing India in general and Hindus in particular hold , plenty of evidence is still available despite all wiping out universities, libraries containing much more .
            For instance there is Dwaraka ruins seen submerged in sea just as predicted in Mahabharat.
            Here are some links for further details in this regard.




            And then there is astronomy. The authors of Ramayana, Mahabharata meticulously recorded configuration of stars, constellations and planets at important events that took place. Please see article below, 'Sky as witness'.

            Since these two, one under water, the other in the skies both are unreachable for those who brought composite culture, they escaped iconoclastic Islamic ax, hence still exist intact. And one can learn , reconstruct our past from these as well , actually should do so despite howls of saffronization from usual suspects. Because it will tell the world as well as convince our own people as well the continuity of our civilization from ages just as recorded in our epics. Time is also a continuity. A great past will and should lead to a great future.

            Best wishes,
                                                                                                                                   G V Chelvapilla
            Sri Kalyanaraman is a scholar, researcher of our Saraswathi civilization and is an author of several books . 

            Sky as witness to history
            -- Use of skymaps, as clock and calenar, to record historical events in ancient Hindu texts

            3067 
            September 26 
            Kṛṣṇa’s Diplomatic Mission for Peace. Moon is near revati, 
            and śani is at rohiṇi. 


            3067
            September 29
            Full Moon of Kṛttika. Lunar eclipse Day 


            3067
            October 8
            Karṇa rides with Kṛṣṇa. uttara phalguni nakṣatra. Kṛṣṇa sends message to Bhīṣma and Droṇa to start the war seven days from that day, i.e. on amāvāsya at jyeṣṭha.


            3067
            October 14
            Jyeṣṭha amāvāsya solar eclipse. The retrograde motion of Mars before reaching jyeṣṭha had occurred several months earlier.


            3067
            November
            22
            Mahābhārata War begins. Bharaṇi day. ग्रहौ ताम्रारुण शिखौ प्रज्वलितावुभौ ”two comets blazing with coppery red hair”.


            3067
            December
            12
            Last day of the war. Balarāma returns on theśravaṇa Day after his Sarasvati river pariyatra.


            3066
            January
            17
            Bhīṣma’s demise Māgha śukla aṣṭami rohiṇi nakṣatra.
            Winter solstice had occurred on January 13, 3066 BCE, śukla pañcami. MB 6.2.32: रोहीणीम पीडयन्नेष स्तिथो राजन शनैश्चरः





            Fourteenth Day of War. Moon rising at 2:30 am seen just above the horizon.


            2926
            August
            16
            Krittikas never
            swerve from the East. Horizon map facing east at Delhi. एता ह वै प्राच्य्येइ 
            दिशो न च्यवन्ते 
            अमी हि उत्तरा हि सप्तर्षयः

            उद्यन्ति पुऱा एताः

            1807
            March
            27
            Full moon at Viśākha, Buddha's nirvāṇa. अथ खो भगव चंदिमं देवापुत्तम् अराभ रहुम असुरिन्दम्गथव ऐइअभसि 
            तथागतं अरहंतम चंदिम सरणं गतो 
            रहु चंदम पमुन्चस्सु 
            बुद्ध लोकनुकम्पकती 
            अथ खो भगव सुरियं देवपुत्तम अरभ रहुं असुरिन्दम गथय ऐइअभसि 
            तथागतं अरहंतम सुरियं सरणं गतो 
            रहु पमुंच सुरियं बुद्ध लोकनुकम्पकती 


            1807
            January
            26
            Lunar eclipse. Winter solstice occurred earlier when the Sun was ear dhaniṣṭa (the position which corresponds to 270° along the ecliptic).


            1807
            February
            10
            Solar eclipse.


            Vyāsa narrates, as Gaṇeśa, scribe, records the text.

            Vedic planetarium is treasure of astronomical knowledge bequeathed to us by our ancestors. 

            Skymaps were the calendar and clock to date terrestrial events with stunning precision.

            Help it grow with additional skymaps and planetarium interactive games.

            https://sites.google.com/site/vedicplanetarium/home

            --
            S. Kalyanaraman

            __._,_.___

            "Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can
            change the world. Indeed, its the only thing that ever has."

            US state universities have an open-admission policy. NaMo, why can't Bharatam do the same?

            $
            0
            0
            India needs to allow reservation, not red tape

            Our college intakes in different programmes are set in stone, based on some ideal student-faculty ratio.

            There is no problem with reservation in the United States because state universities have an open-admission policy. Why can't India do the same? -- asks Prof. Subhash Kak.
            SUBHASH KAK
            Hardik Patel has touched upon a raw nerve in Gujarat. He had nearly half a million attend his rally in Surat. He wants to go national with the grievance related to admission in schools and colleges. He wants the OBC status for the Patidar community.
            There are stories going around that a student with 90 per cent in the examinations has not got into a college whereas some other student in the reserved category has been admitted with only 50 per cent marks. If true, this is unacceptable and no wonder people are outraged.
            What is the government to do? The maximum that the OBCs are allowed under the present reservation regime is 50 per cent. If powerful communities like the Patidars are given the OBC status, the currently listed communities will have their share reduced in the current zero-sum game. This could lead to the next round of protests. On the other hand, if the OBC quota is increased, then the general quota will shrink to an unacceptable level.
            If one thinks outside of the box, one can see a simple solution to this seemingly insoluble problem. One doesn’t even have to do original, creative thought to arrive at this solution for this is how the United States, another diverse country, has dealt with similar demands.
            The public universities in the US have an open admission policy for most programs including computer science and engineering. The exceptions are the law and the medical programmes that require students to take a national entrance examination with universities picking different cut-off points for admission. Once admitted, the students are expected to pass the specified sequence of courses. In other words, admission doesn’t imply graduation.
            The Indian education bureaucrat will shudder at the thought of open admission in engineering. Unlike India, American universities do not have fixed number of slots for specific programmes. I remember in the late 1990s, during the IT bubble days, at one time 95 per cent of the freshman class at MIT picked electrical engineering and computer science.
            The Indian system has problems because it is driven by outdated bureaucratic ideas. Its devotion to some imagined perfection is what takes it away from reasonable, commonsense solutions. College intakes in different programmes are set in stone, based on some ideal student-faculty ratio, without any elasticity built in to deal with the demand. This is done for the convenience of the bureaucrats and not as effective policy. We need less government control but better governance that requires oversight.
            An open admission policy does not mean that any college should be able to admit all the students that apply. However, the intake should be correlated with the demand as it changes from year to year and the government college system should ensure that no one with a good record is denied admission. An open admission policy means that students will be admitted to some college, not necessarily the college of the student’s choice, in the state.
            The Indian bureaucrat will say but won’t we then have too many engineers or computer scientists? They will be fearful that the standards will go down.
            The market place will deal with the first problem and very soon some kind of equilibrium will be reached regarding demand. It is true that oversight will be needed to ensure that the college teaching and students’ performance are held to some minimum standards. Minimum standards can also be ensured by a national certification examination at the end of the studies.
            http://www.dailyo.in/politics/reservation-hardik-patel-indian-education-american-universities-colleges-students-mit-iit-bureaucracy-red-tape-engineering-it/story/1/6328.html

            Triskelion, mollusc, safflower, endless knot motifs on Galician artifacts compare with Indus Script hieroglyphs

            $
            0
            0
            Mirror: http://tinyurl.com/ohhz8lw

            The orthography of triskelion hieroglyph on a Kirkburn linch-pin yields a clue to decipher the cognate trefoil hieroglyph of Indus Script Corpora. The trefoil is a composite of three crucibles joined together. Crucibles are used to produce hard alloys. Trefoil hieroglyph-multiplexes adorn a Mohenjo-daro statuette of a person with a well-trimmed beard and wearing fillet on his forehead and on his shoulder. The hieroglyph-multiplexes are deciphered The trefoil adornment on a statuette of Mohenjo-daro of पोतृ pōtṛ " Purifier "(Rigveda) is identified as a composite of three crucibles (koṭhārī) joined together and deciphered as koṭhārī खोद khōda kolimi  paṭṭaḍa 'treasurer, engraver (scribe) of the smithy (workshop)'. 

            The trefoil adornment on a statuette of Mohenjo-daro of पोतृ pōt " Purifier "(Rigveda) is identified as a composite of three crucibles (koṭhārī) joined together and deciphered as koṭhārī खोद khōda kolimi  paṭṭaḍa 'treasurer, engraver (scribe) of the smithy (workshop)'. 

            He wears a fillet of authority on his forehead and also on his shoulder. Hieroglyph: Or. pāta ʻ metal -- foil ʼ, patā ʻ eyelid ʼ, pātiā ʻ thin slip of metal ʼ(CDIAL 3733) Ta. paṭṭaṭai, paṭṭaṟai anvil, smithy, forge. Ka. paṭṭaḍe, paṭṭaḍi anvil, workshop. Te. paṭṭika, paṭṭeḍa anvil; paṭṭaḍa workshop.(DEDR 3865).

            The triskelion hieroglyph of a Galician torc terminal and Kirkburn linch-pin is a variant of the trefoil which adorns as a hieroglyph, the shawl worn by the person with well-trimmed beard on Mohenjo-daro statuette.

            When the trefoil adorns a young bull: खोंड [ khōṇḍa ] m A young bull, a bullcalf. (Marathi) Rebus: kō̃da -कोँद 'kiln, furnace' (Kashmiri) खोद khōda 'engraving'

            I do not know why the trefoils adorn bulls forming a funeral couch of an Egyptian ruler Tutankhamen. Do the koṭhārī 'crucibles' signify a veneration of the temples as treasury, he left behind?

            Triskelion and spirals on a Galician torc terminal (Museu do Castro de Santa Tegra).

            Castro torc terminal from the oppidum of Santa Tegra, A GuardaFile:Torque de Santa Tegra 1.JPG Celtic
            http://www.eccentricbliss.com/tag/museu-do-castro-de-santa-tegra/
            Stone work: Castro culture

            Triskelion of the oppidum of Coeliobriga

            A selection of motifs and carvings from the oppida region "From the 2nd century BC, specially in the south, some of the hill-forts turned into semi-urban fortified towns, oppida.The terms oppida and urbs are used by classical authors such as Pliny the Elder and Pomponius Mela for describing the major fortified town of NW Iberia.https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Castro_culture#cite_note-14


            Back of a sitting statue

             
            Torque de Foxados, Museo de Pontevedra, Galicia

            Torcs from northern Galicia

            కొఠారు [ koṭhāru ] Same as కొటారు.కొటారు [ koṭāru ] , కొటారము or కొఠారు koṭāru.[Tel.] n. A store, a granary. A place to keep grain, salt, &c.
            కొఠీ [ koṭhī ] koṭhī. [H.] n. A bank. A mercantile house or firm. కొషీవేయు to set up or open a bank. 
            கொட்டகாரம் koṭṭakāram
            , n. prob. kōṣṭha + agāra. [T. koṭāramu, M. koṭṭakāram, Tu. koṭṭāra.] Store-room, granary; நெல்முதலிய பண்டம்வைக்கும் அறை. நெற்கூட்டி னிரைசெறிந்த புரிபலவா நிலைக்கொட்டகாரத்தில் (பெரியபு. இடங் கழி. 7).கொட்டடி koṭṭaṭi
            , n. < U. kōṭhari. cf. Mhr. kōṭhaḍi. 1. Room, as kitchen, store- room; சமையல் முதலியவற்றிற்கு உதவும் அறை. 2. Cattle-shed; மாட்டுக்கொட்டில். 3. Prisoner's cell; சிறைச்சாலை அறை. 4. Check, silk cloth of a woman; சேலைவகை.கொட்டாரம் koṭṭāram
            , n. cf. Mhr. kōṭhāra. [T. koṭāramu, K. Tu. koṭṭāra, M. koṭṭāram.] 1. cf. kōṣṭhāgāra. Granary; தானியக் களஞ்சியம். படைக்கலக் கொட்டிலும் புடைக்கொட் டாரமும் (பெருங். மகத. 14, 19). 2. [K. koṭārū.] Place where paddy or other grains are husked; நெல் முதலிய தானியம் குத்துமிடம். 3. Elephant-stall; யானைக்கூடம். Loc. 4. Palace; அரண்மனை. Loc. 5. cf. kōṭṭāra. Principal entrance of a palace, etc.; porch; அரண்மனை முதலியவற்றின் தலைவாசல். (W.)கொட்டி³ koṭṭi n. cf. kōṭṭāra. 1. Tower- gate in a temple; கோபுரவாசல். 2. Gate; வாயில். (அக. நி.)

            खोंडरूं [ khōṇḍarūṃ ] n A contemptuous form of खोंडा in the sense of कांबळा-cowl.खोंडा [ khōṇḍā ] m A कांबळा of which one end is formed into a cowl or hood.खोंडी [ khōṇḍī ] f An outspread shovelform sack (as formed temporarily out of a कांबळा, to hold or fend off grain, chaff &c.) See under खुंडी. 2 A species or variety of जोंधळा.

            खोंड [ khōṇḍa ] m A young bull, a bullcalf. (Marathi)

            खोदणी [ khōdaṇī ] f (Verbal of खोदणें) Digging, engraving &c. खोदणें [ khōdaṇēṃ ] v c & i ( H) To dig. 2 To engrave.खोदाई [ khōdāī ] f ( H) Price or cost of digging or of sculpture or carving.
            खोदींव [ khōdīṃva ] p of खोदणें Dug. 2 Engraved, carved, sculptured.खोदकाम [ khōdakāma ] n Sculpture; carved work or work for the carver.खोदगिरी [ khōdagirī ] f Sculpture, carving, engraving: also sculptured or carved work.खोदणावळ [ khōdaṇāvaḷa ] f (खोदणें) The price or cost of sculpture or carving.

            kōnda कोंद, see kō̃dakrāl क्राल् । कुलालः m. (the f. is kröjü  q.v., and signifies either his wife, or a female potter), a potter (always a Musalmān) (El.; K.Pr. 114; L. 462; W. 17; H. xi, 1, 11).-kō̃da -कोँद । कुलालकन्दुः f. a potter's kiln. -khŏḍ -ख्व़ड् । स्थानविशेषः m. N. of a quarter in Śrīnagar, near the Haba Kadal bridge, and inhabited by potters.sērĕ-kajāba सेर्य-कजाब । इष्टिकाकूटम् m. a pyramid-shaped pile of bricks. -kölib -का&above;लिब् । इष्टिकायन्त्रम् m. a brick-mould (cf. ). -kō̃da -कोँद । इष्टिकाभ्राष्ट्रः f. a brick-kiln. kō̃da-bal, a brick-kiln or a potter's kiln bāna 1 बान । पात्रम् m. a vessel  -kō̃da -कोँद । कुलालचुल्लिः f. a potter's furnace, the pile of combustible materials in which he bakes his earthen vessels. -kã̄dur -काँदुर् । काष्ठमयो&1;लिंजरविशेषः m. (sg. dat. -kã̄daras -काँदरस्), a large kind of jar, wrapped round with twigs cased in mud, kept in kitchens as a receptacle for articles frequently required; a china merchant (El.) kō̃da कोँद । कुलालादिकन्दुः f. a kiln; a potter's kiln (Rām. 1446; H. xi, 11); a brick-kiln (Śiv. 133); a lime-kiln. -bal -बल् । कुलालादिकन्दुस्थानम् m. the place where a kiln is erected, a brick or potter's kiln (Gr.Gr. 165). -- khasüñü -- । कुलालादिकन्दुयथावद्भावः f.inf. a kiln to arise; met. to become like such a kiln (which contains no imperfectly baked articles, but only well-made perfectly baked ones), hence, a collection of good ('pucka') articles or qualities to exist. Cf. Śiv. 133, where the causal form of the verb is used. kō̃da khārüñü, to raise a kiln; met. to raise or make a really good kiln in which only perfect bricks are baked (Śiv. 133; cf. kō̃da khasüñü, p. 384b, l. 28).payĕn-kō̃da पयन्-कोँद । परिपाककन्दुः f. a kiln (a potter's, a lime-kiln, and brick-kiln, or the like); a furnace (for smelting). -thöji -था&above;जि&below; or -thöjü ; । परिपाक-(द्रावण-)मूषा f. a crucible, a melting-pot. -ʦañĕ -च्&dotbelow;ञ । परिपाकोपयोगिशान्ताङ्गारसमूहः f.pl. a special kind of charcoal (made from deodar and similar wood) used in smelting furnaces. -wôlu -वोलु&below; । धात्वादिद्रावण-इष्टिकादिपरिपाकशिल्पी m. a metal-smelter; a brick-baker. -wān -वान् । द्रावणचुल्ली m. a smelting furnace.(Kashmiri) پجه pajaʿh, s.f. (3rd) A brick-kiln, a furnace. Pl. يْ ey.پجه pajaʿh, s.f. (3rd) A furnace, a place for the manufacture of glass, a glass-house, a place where glass is made. Pl. يْ ey.(Pashto)

            OP. koṭhārī f. ʻ crucible ʼ, P. kuṭhālī f., H. kuṭhārīf. (CDIAL 3546)
             Sv. dāntar -- kuṭha ʻ fire -- place ʼ (CDIAL 3546)
             

            WPah.kṭg. kóṭṭhi f. ʻtemple treasury, name of a partic. temple' 
            (CDIAL 3546)

            Rebus: kṓṣṭha 3546 kṓṣṭha2 n. ʻ pot ʼ Kauś., ʻ granary, storeroom ʼ MBh., ʻ inner apartment ʼ lex., °aka -- n. ʻ treasury ʼ, °ikā f. ʻ pan ʼ Bhpr. [Cf. *kōttha -- , *kōtthala -- : same as prec.?]Pa. koṭṭha -- n. ʻ monk's cell, storeroom ʼ, °aka<-> n. ʻ storeroom ʼ; Pk. koṭṭha -- , kuṭ°koṭṭhaya -- m. ʻ granary, storeroom ʼ; Sv. dāntar -- kuṭha ʻ fire -- place ʼ; Sh. (Lor.) kōti (ṭh?) ʻ wooden vessel for mixing yeast ʼ; K. kōṭha m. ʻ granary ʼ, kuṭhu m. ʻ room ʼ, kuṭhü f. ʻ granary, storehouse ʼ; S. koṭho m. ʻ large room ʼ, °ṭhī f. ʻ storeroom ʼ; L. koṭhā m. ʻ hut, room, house ʼ, °ṭhī f. ʻ shop, brothel ʼ, awāṇ. koṭhā ʻ house ʼ; P. koṭṭhākoṭhā m. ʻ house with mud roof and walls, granary ʼ, koṭṭhīkoṭhī f. ʻ big well -- built house, house for married women to prostitute themselves in ʼ; WPah. pāḍ. kuṭhī ʻ house ʼ; Ku. koṭho ʻ large square house ʼ, gng. kōṭhi ʻ room, building ʼ; N. koṭho ʻ chamber ʼ, °ṭhi ʻ shop ʼ; A. koṭhākõṭhā ʻ room ʼ, kuṭhī ʻ factory ʼ; B. koṭhā ʻ brick -- built house ʼ, kuṭhī ʻ bank, granary ʼ; Or. koṭhā ʻ brick -- built house ʼ, °ṭhī ʻ factory, granary ʼ; Bi. koṭhī ʻ granary of straw or brushwood in the open ʼ; Mth. koṭhī ʻ grain -- chest ʼ; OAw. koṭha ʻ storeroom ʼ; H. koṭhā m. ʻ granary ʼ, °ṭhī f. ʻ granary, large house ʼ, Marw. koṭho m. ʻ room ʼ; G. koṭhɔ m. ʻ jar in which indigo is stored, warehouse ʼ, °ṭhī f. ʻ large earthen jar, factory ʼ; M. koṭhā m. ʻ large granary ʼ, °ṭhī f. ʻ granary, factory ʼ; Si. koṭa ʻ storehouse ʼ. -- Ext. with -- ḍa -- : K.kūṭhürü f. ʻ small room ʼ; L. koṭhṛī f. ʻ small side room ʼ; P. koṭhṛī f. ʻ room, house ʼ; Ku. koṭheṛī ʻ small room ʼ; H. koṭhrī f. ʻ room, granary ʼ; M. koṭhḍī f. ʻ room ʼ; -- with -- ra -- : A. kuṭharī ʻ chamber ʼ, B. kuṭhrī, Or. koṭhari; -- with -- lla -- : Sh. (Lor.) kotul (ṭh?) ʻ wattle and mud erection for storing grain ʼ; H.koṭhlā m., °lī f. ʻ room, granary ʼ; G. koṭhlɔ m. ʻ wooden box ʼ.
            kōṣṭhapāla -- , *kōṣṭharūpa -- , *kōṣṭhāṁśa -- , kōṣṭhāgāra -- ; *kajjalakōṣṭha -- , *duvārakōṣṭha -- , *dēvakōṣṭha -- , dvārakōṣṭhaka -- .Addenda: kṓṣṭha -- 2: WPah.kṭg. kóṭṭhi f. ʻ house, quarters, temple treasury, name of a partic. temple ʼ, J. koṭhā m. ʻ granary ʼ, koṭhī f. ʻ granary, bungalow ʼ; Garh. koṭhu ʻ house surrounded by a wall ʼ; Md. koḍi ʻ frame ʼ, <-> koři ʻ cage ʼ (X kōṭṭa -- ). -- with ext.: OP. koṭhārī f. ʻ crucible ʼ, P. kuṭhālī f., H. kuṭhārīf.; -- Md. koṭari ʻ room ʼ. kōṣṭhapāla 3547 kōṣṭhapāla m. ʻ storekeeper ʼ W. [kṓṣṭha -- 2, pāla -- ]M. koṭhvaḷā 
            m. (CDIAL 3546, 3547) kōṣṭhāgāra 3550 kōṣṭhāgāra n. ʻ storeroom, store ʼ Mn. [kṓṣṭha -- 2, agāra -- ]Pa. koṭṭhāgāra -- n. ʻ storehouse, granary ʼ; Pk. koṭṭhāgāra -- , koṭṭhāra -- n. ʻ storehouse ʼ; K. kuṭhār m. ʻ wooden granary ʼ, WPah. bhal. kóṭhār m.; A. B.kuṭharī ʻ apartment ʼ, Or. koṭhari; Aw. lakh. koṭhār ʻ zemindar's residence ʼ; H. kuṭhiyār ʻ granary ʼ; G. koṭhār m. ʻ granary, storehouse ʼ, koṭhāriyũ n. ʻ small do. ʼ; M. koṭhār n., koṭhārẽ n. ʻ large granary ʼ, -- °rī f. ʻ small one ʼ; Si. koṭāra ʻ granary, store ʼ.kōṣṭhāgārika -- .Addenda: kōṣṭhāgāra -- : WPah.kṭg. kəṭhāˊr, kc. kuṭhār m. ʻ granary, storeroom ʼ, J. kuṭhārkṭhār m.; -- Md. kořāru ʻ storehouse ʼ ← Ind.

            kōṣṭhāgārika 3551 kōṣṭhāgārika m. ʻ storekeeper ʼ BHSk. [Cf. kōṣṭhā- gārin -- m. ʻ wasp ʼ Suśr.: kōṣṭhāgāra -- ] Pa. koṭṭhāgārika -- m. ʻ storekeeper ʼ; S. koṭhārī m. ʻ one who in a body of faqirs looks after the provision store ʼ; Or. koṭhārī ʻ treasurer ʼ; Bhoj. koṭhārī ʻ storekeeper ʼ, H. kuṭhiyārī m.Addenda: kōṣṭhāgārika -- : G. koṭhārī m. ʻ storekeeper ʼ.(CDIAL 3550, 3551) Koṭṭhaka1 (nt.) "a kind of koṭṭha," the stronghold over a gateway, used as a store -- room for various things, a chamber, treasury, granary Vin ii.153, 210; for the purpose of keeping water in it Vin ii.121=142; 220; treasury J i.230; ii.168; -- store -- room J ii.246; koṭthake pāturahosi appeared at the gateway, i. e. arrived at the mansion Vin i.291. -- bala -- k. a line of infantry J i.179. -- koṭṭhaka -- kamma or the occupation connected with a storehouse (or bathroom?) is mentioned as an example of a low occupation at Vin iv.6; Kern, Toev. s. v. "someone who sweeps away dirt."(Pali)

            kolom 'three' (Mu.)Rebus: kolami 'smithy, forge' Ta. kol working in iron, blacksmith; kollaṉ blacksmith. Ma. kollan blacksmith, artificer. Ko. kole·l smithy, temple in Kota village. To. kwala·l Kota smithy. Ka. kolime, kolume, kulame, kulime, kulume, kulme fire-pit, furnace; (Bell.; U.P.U.) konimi blacksmith (Gowda) kolla id. Koḍ. kollë 
            blacksmith.Te. kolimi furnace. Go. (SR.) kollusānā to mend implements; (Ph.) kolstānā, kulsānā to forge; (Tr.) kōlstānā to repair (of ploughshares); (SR.) kolmismithy (Voc. 948). Kuwi (F.) kolhali to forge.(DEDR 2133) <kol>\\<koRa>(D)  {N} ``^oven, ^fireplace, ^hearth''.  #40042 So<koRa>//<kol>(L)  {N} ``^oven, ^fireplace, ^hearth''..(Munda)

            मेढा [ mēḍhā ] A twist or tangle arising in thread or cord, a curl or snarl.(Marathi)  *mēṇḍhī ʻ lock of hair, curl ʼ. [Cf. *mēṇḍha -- 1 s.v. *miḍḍa -- ]
            S. mī˜ḍhī f., °ḍho m. ʻ braid in a woman's hair ʼ, L. mē̃ḍhī f.; G. mĩḍlɔmiḍ° m. ʻ braid of hair on a girl's forehead ʼ; M. meḍhā m. ʻ curl, snarl, twist or tangle in cord or thread ʼ.(CDIAL 10312)
            मेढी [ mēḍhī ] f (Dim. of मेढ) A small bifurcated stake: also a small stake, with or without furcation, used as a post to support a cross piece. (Marathi) मेढ्या [ mēḍhyā ] a (मेढ Stake or post.) A term for a person considered as the pillar, prop, or support (of a household, army, or other body), the staff or stay. 2 Applied to a person acquainted with clandestine or knavish transactions.

            meď 'copper' (Slovak)

            Santali glosses:
            Wilhelm von Hevesy wrote about the Finno-Ugric-Munda kinship, like "Munda-Magyar-Maori, an Indian link between the antipodes new tracks of Hungarian origins" and "Finnisch-Ugrisches aus Indien". (DRIEM, George van: Languages of the Himalayas: an ethnolinguistic handbook. 1997. p.161-162.) Sumerian-Ural-Altaic language affinities have been noted. Given the presence of Meluhha settlements in Sumer, some Meluhha glosses might have been adapted in these languages. One etyma cluster refers to 'iron' exemplified by meD (Ho.). The alternative suggestion for the origin of the gloss med 'copper' in Uralic languages may be explained by the word meD (Ho.) of Munda family of Meluhha language stream:

            Sa. <i>mE~R~hE~'d</i> `iron'.  ! <i>mE~RhE~d</i>(M).
            Ma. <i>mErhE'd</i> `iron'.
            Mu. <i>mERE'd</i> `iron'.
              ~ <i>mE~R~E~'d</i> `iron'.  ! <i>mENhEd</i>(M).
            Ho <i>meD</i> `iron'.
            Bj. <i>merhd</i>(Hunter) `iron'.
            KW <i>mENhEd</i>
            @(V168,M080)

            — Slavic glosses for 'copper'
            Мед [Med]Bulgarian
            Bakar Bosnian
            Медзь [medz']Belarusian
            Měď Czech
            Bakar Croatian
            KòperKashubian
            Бакар [Bakar]Macedonian
            Miedź Polish
            Медь [Med']Russian
            Meď Slovak
            BakerSlovenian
            Бакар [Bakar]Serbian
            Мідь [mid'] Ukrainian[unquote]
            Miedź, med' (Northern Slavic, Altaic) 'copper'.  

            One suggestion is that corruptions from the German "Schmied", "Geschmeide" = jewelry. Schmied, a smith (of tin, gold, silver, or other metal)(German) result in med ‘copper’.
            Architectural fragment with relief showing winged dwarfs (or gaNa) worshipping with flower garlands, Siva Linga. Bhuteshwar, ca. 2nd cent BCE.
            Relief with Ekamukha linga. Mathura. 1st cent. CE (Fig. 6.2).
            Sivalinga. Terracotta. 4.5x4.5 cm. Kalibangan.
            Sivalinga. Harappa.

            Mohejodaro, tablet in bas relief (M-478)
            Harappa seal.
            m1356, m443 table मेढा [ mēḍhā ] A twist or tangle arising in thread or cord, a curl or snarl.(Marathi) mer.ha = twisted, crumpled, as a horn (Santali.lex.) meli, melika = a turn, a twist, a loop, entanglement; meliyu, melivad.u, meligonu = to get twisted or entwined (Te.lex.) [Note the endless knot motif]. Rebus: med. ‘iron’ (Mu.) sattva 'svastika glyph' Rebus: sattva, jasta 'zinc'.

            Altar, platform:  Ta. mēṭai platform, raised floor, artificial mound, terraced house. Ma. mēṭa raised place, tower, upper story, palace. Te. mēḍa house with two or more stories, upper chamber. Pa. mēṛ ole bungalow. Go. (Ko.) mēṛā large house, bungalow (Voc. 2965). Konḍa mēṛa mide terraced building (see 5069). Pe. mēṛstoried house, mansion. Kuwi (S.) mēḍa illu storied house; (Isr.) mēṛa upstair building. / Cf. Skt. (lex.meṭa- whitewashed storied house; Pkt. meḍaya- id. (DEDR 4796) మేడ (p. 1034) [ mēḍa ] mēḍa. [Tel.] n. A mansion or large house: an upper chamber, a storey,(Telugu) pīṭha n. ʻ stool, bench ʼ Gr̥S., °aka -- m.n. BhP., pīṭhī -- , °ṭhikā -- f. R. 2. *pēḍha -- 1. 3. *pēḍḍha -- . [Variety of form suggests non -- Aryan origin]
            1. Pa. pīṭha -- , °aka -- n., pīṭhikā -- f.; Pk. pīḍha -- , °aga<-> n. ʻ stool ʼ, pīḍhī -- f. ʻ supporting beam of a house ʼ, °ḍhiā<-> f. ʻ a kind of seat ʼ; Pr. pīrə ʻ outside wall ʼ NTS xv 269; K. pīrpīrü f. ʻ stool ʼ; S. pīṛhī f. ʻ throne ʼ; L. pihṛā m., °ṛī f. ʻ stool ʼ, awāṇ. pīˋṛā, P. pīṛhā m., °ṛhī f., Ku. pīṛo m.; N. pirā ʻ stool, bench ʼ; A. pirā ʻ stool ʼ, pīri ʻ beam of a boat, flat pieces of wood fixed crosswise over shafts of a cart ʼ; Or. piṛha ʻ altar, platform ʼ, piṛhā ʻ stool ʼ, piṛhi ʻ footstool ʼ; Bi. pīṛhā°ṛhīpiṛhiyā ʻ wooden seat on which a woman sits at the handmill ʼ, piṛhiyā ʻ apex triangle in front of driver's seat in a cart ʼ, (Gaya) pīṛhā ʻ pastry -- board ʼ; Mth. pīṛhā°ṛhi ʻ stool ʼ, Bhoj. pīṛhā, OAw. pīḍha; H. pīṛhā m. ʻ large square stool ʼ, pīṛhī f. ʻ small do. ʼ; G. pīḍhiyũ n. ʻ beam to which floor planks are fastened ʼ, pīḍhi f., ʻ molar tooth ʼ, pīḍhiyũ n. ʻ molar tooth, gums ʼ (cf. dantapīṭhāḥ m. pl. ʻ tooth sockets ʼ VS. com. and semant. bársva -- ʻ tooth -- socket ~ bunch, bolster ʼ P. Thieme ZDMG 62, 47); M. piḍhẽ n. ʻ stool ʼ; Si. piḷapila ʻ ledge along a house to sit on, veranda, portico ʼ.2. Pk. pēḍha -- m., °ḍhī -- , °ḍhiā -- f. ʻ stool ʼ.3. Paš.weg. nir. peṛāˊ ʻ stairs ʼ (IIFL iii 3, 147 < pīṭha -- ?); S. peḍhī f. ʻ shelf fixed in a wall ʼ; G. peḍhī f. ʻ step of a ladder ʼ; M. peḍhī f. ʻ raised place on the floor ʼ.(CDIAL 8222)

             करडी [ karaḍī ] f (See करडई) Safflower: also its seed. Rebus: karaḍa 'hard alloy' of arka 'copper'. Rebus: fire-god: @B27990.  #16671. Remo <karandi>E155  {N} ``^fire-^god''.(Munda).

            sangi 'mollusc', Rebus: sangi 'pilgrim'

            Rings on neck: koDiyum (G.) koṭiyum = a wooden circle put round the neck of an animal; koṭ = neck (G.lex.)
            Rebus: koD  'artisan's 
            workshop'
            (Kuwi) koD  = place where artisans work (Gujarati). 
            koṭe 'forge' (Mu.)
            koṭe meṛed = forged iron, in contrast to dul meṛed, cast iron (Mundari)



            Hieroglyph: Bi. goṭā ʻ seed Rebus: L.  khoṭā ʻ forged ʼ; P.  khoṭ 'alloy'

            *gōṭṭa ʻ something round ʼ. [Cf. guḍá -- 1. -- In sense ʻ fruit, kernel ʼ cert. ← Drav., cf. Tam. koṭṭai ʻ nut, kernel ʼ, Kan. goṟaṭe &c. listed DED 1722]K. goṭh f., dat. °ṭi f. ʻ chequer or chess or dice board ʼ; S. g̠oṭu m. ʻ large ball of tobacco ready for hookah ʼ, °ṭī f. ʻ small do. ʼ; P. goṭ f. ʻ spool on which gold or silver wire is wound, piece on a chequer board ʼ; N. goṭo ʻ piece ʼ, goṭi ʻ chess piece ʼ; A. goṭ ʻ a fruit, whole piece ʼ, °ṭā ʻ globular, solid ʼ, guṭi ʻ small ball, seed, kernel ʼ; B. goṭā ʻ seed, bean, whole ʼ; Or. goṭā ʻ whole, undivided ʼ, goṭi ʻ small ball, cocoon ʼ, goṭāli ʻ small round piece of chalk ʼ; Bi. goṭā ʻ seed ʼ; Mth.goṭa ʻ numerative particle ʼ; H. goṭ f. ʻ piece (at chess &c.) ʼ; G. goṭ m. ʻ cloud of smoke ʼ, °ṭɔ m. ʻ kernel of coconut, nosegay ʼ, °ṭī f. ʻ lump of silver, clot of blood ʼ, °ṭilɔ m. ʻ hard ball of cloth ʼ; M. goṭā m. ʻ roundish stone ʼ, °ṭī f. ʻ a marble ʼ, goṭuḷā ʻ spherical ʼ; Si. guṭiya ʻ lump, ball ʼ; -- prob. also P. goṭṭā ʻ gold or silver lace ʼ, H. goṭā m. ʻ edging of such ʼ (→ K. goṭa m. ʻ edging of gold braid ʼ, S. goṭo m. ʻ gold or silver lace ʼ); M. goṭ ʻ hem of a garment, metal wristlet ʼ.
            *gōḍḍ -- ʻ dig ʼ see *khōdd -- .Addenda: *gōṭṭa -- : also Ko. gōṭu ʻ silver or gold braid ʼ.(CDIAL 4271)

             L. khoṭ f. ʻ alloy, impurity ʼ, °ṭā ʻ alloyed ʼ, awāṇ. khoṭā ʻ forged ʼ; P. khoṭ m. ʻ base, alloy ʼ (PhonPj 117 Bshk. khoṭ ʻ embers ʼ, Phal. khūṭo ʻ ashes, burning coal ʼ(CDIAL 3931)
            Crucibles. Ban Chiang. "These thick-walled spouted vessels were made of clay. Analysis of the interiors shows that they were used to melt bronze, copper, and tin for casting in molds. A notable feature of crucibles in the Ban Chiang area is lagging, the thin quartz-rich clay layer deliberately added to the interior of the crucible. The lagging layer would tend to reflect heat into the metal and also retard crucible disintegration. The use of a lagging layer indicates that the Ban Chiang metalworkers possessed a sophisticated understanding of refractory principles. Some crucible fragments have several layers of lagging, indicating that they were used repeatedly.http://penn.museum/banchiang/findings/pottery/



            Two views of a fine crucible that was found in one of the pits. It would have been used in the manufacture of copper or silver objects.
             Find out more at http://www.wessexarch.co.uk/projects/county/hampshire/28-jewry-street-winchester

            Trefoil inlay decorated on a bull calf. Uruk (W.16017) ca. 3000 BCE. kõdā 'young bull calf' Rebus: kõdā 'turner-joiner' (forge),

            damkom = a bull calf (Santali) Rebus: damha = a fireplace; dumhe = to heap, to collect together (Santali)

            Trefoil design on the uttarIyam of the priest, AcArya, PotR. This denotes: three strands of rope: dāmā 'rope' rebus: dhāma ʻreligious conduct'.Trefoil designs on the shawl garment of the 'priest' Mohenjo-daro statue. The left shoulder is covered with a cloak decorated with trefoil, double circle and single circle designs that were originally filled with red pigment. Drill holes in the center of each circle indicate they were made with a specialized drill and then touched up with a chisel.  Material: white, low fired steatiteDimensions: 17.5 cm height, 11 cm width Mohenjo-daro, DK 1909 National Museum, Karachi, 50.852 Marshall 1931: 356-7, pl. XCVIII

            The trefoil hieroglyph on the priest's shawl, on the body of a bull calf and on the base pedestal of a s'ivalinga is comparable to the hieroglyph which appears on painted lid or dish -- in the context of venerating the dead. This points to reverence for ancestors.Sumerian marble calf with inlaid trefoils of blue stone. From the late Uruk era, cira 3000 B.C.Sumerian marble calf with inlaid trefoils of blue stone. From the late Uruk era, Jemdet Nasr cira 3300 - 2900 B.C.E 5.3 cm. long; Vorderasiatisches Museum, Berlin; Parpola, 1994, p. 213.

            Steatite statue fragment; Mohenjodaro (Sd 767); trefoil-decorated bull; traces of red pigment remain inside the trefoils. After Ardeleanu-Jansen 1989: 196, fig. 1; Parpola, 1994, p. 213.
            Trefoils painted on steatite beads, Harappa (After Vats, Pl. CXXXIII, Fig.2)
            Harry Burton photograph taken during the excavation of the tomb in 1922 in pharaoh's Antechamber, Treasury and Burial chamber.
            King Tut's burial bed in the form of the Celestial Cow. The Cow represents the Goddess Hathor Mehet-Urt, whose horns are decorated with the solar disk.

            Funeral couch of Tutankhamen (1336 BC - 1327 BCE) features cow with solar disc and inlay blue glass trefoils decorating the body. Said to represent Goddess Hathor.
            "An inscription from The Book of the divine cow found in the Burial chamber alludes to its sacred function as a solar barque for bearing the pharaoh to the heavens...Hieroglyphs carved on the footboard promise the protection of Isis and the endurance of Osiris."http://www.kingtutexhibit.com/catalogs/tutankhamun_catalog.pdf

            Lingamgrey sandstone in situ, Harappa. 

            Terracotta sivalinga, Kalibangan.Shape of polished lingam found at Harappa is like the summit of Mt. Kailas, Himalayas. Plate X(c), Lingam in situ in trench Ai (MS Vats, 1940, Exxcavations at Harappa, Vol. II, Calcutta). In trenches III and IV two more stone lingams were found. (MS Vats, opcit., Vol. I, pp. 51-52). The Hindu traditional metaphor of s'iva is the glacial river Ganga emerging from locks of his hair as he sits in penance on summit of Mt. Kailas, Himalayas. The metaphor results in Kailas in Ellora, showing Ravana lifting up the mountain.

            Stone base for Sivalinga.Tre-foil inlay decorated base (for linga icon?); smoothed, polished pedestal of dark red stone; National Museum of Pakistan, Karachi; After Mackay 1938: I, 411; II, pl. 107:35; Parpola, 1994, p. 218.
            Two decorated bases and a lingam, Mohenjodaro. Trefoil inlay decorated base (for linga icon?); smoothed, polished pedestal of dark red stone; National Museum of Pakistan, Karachi; After Mackay 1938: I, 411; II, pl. 107:35; Parpola, 1994, p. 218. "In an earthenware jar, No. 12414, recovered from Mound F, Trench IV, Square I"

            If one end of a tape or belt is turned over three times and then pasted to the other, a trefoil knot results. (Shaw, George Russell (MCMXXXIII). Knots: Useful & Ornamental, p.11.)
            It is possible to decipher the hieroglyphs using the rebus-metonymy layered cipher of Indus writing system. 

            The Meluhha semantics of objects signified by these three hieroglyphs are related to metalwork guild.

            Trefoil hieroglyph or three 'beads, orifice' 

            kolom 'three' (Munda) Rebus: kolami 'smithy, forge'. The triplicate  composing the trefoil is a semantic determinant of the signified object: smithy, forge.

            *pōttī ʻ glass bead ʼ.Pk. pottī -- f. ʻ glass ʼ; S. pūti f. ʻ glass bead ʼ, P. pot f.; N. pote ʻ long straight bar of jewelry ʼ; B. pot ʻ glass bead ʼ, putipũti ʻ small bead ʼ; Or. puti ʻ necklace of small glass beads ʼ; H. pot m. ʻ glass bead ʼ, G. M. pot f.; -- Bi. pot ʻ jeweller's polishing stone ʼ rather than < pōtrá -- 1.(CDIAL 8403) பொத்தல் pottal n. < id. [K. poṭṭare, M. pottu, Tu. potre.] 1. Hole, orifice. 

            Rebus: Soma priest, jeweller's polishing stone

            पोतृ pōt " Purifier " , Name of one of the 16 officiating priests at a sacrifice (the assistant of the Brahman (Rigveda) pōtrá1 ʻ *cleaning instrument ʼ (ʻ the Potr̥'s soma vessel ʼ RV.). [√Bi. pot ʻ jeweller's polishing stone ʼ? -- Rather < *pōttī -- .(CDIAL 8404) pōtṛ पोतृ m. 1 One of the sixteen officiating priests at a sacrifice (assistant of the priest called ब्रह्मन्). -2 An epithet of Viṣṇu.
            Mesopotamian lama deity, a bull with a human head, kind, protective spirits associated with the great sun god Shamash. In one inscription, an Assyrian king called upon lama deities to "turn back an evil person, guard the steps, and secure the path of the king who fashioned them." 2100-2000 BCE Serpentine, a smooth green stone the color of life-giving water in a desert area. The hollowed-out shapes on the body originally were inlaid with pearly shell or lapis lazuli.

            "Images of human-headed bulls are found throughout Mesopotamian history. Several statuettes dating from the late third millennium BC show a bearded creature wearing the divine horned headdress, lying down with its head turned to the side. They have been found at various Sumerian sites, the majority from Telloh.


            Bovine head rhytonCrete. Cow-head rhython with trefoil decor.

            1 G. Contenau, Manual d'archeologie orientale, II, Paris, 1931, p. 698-9.
            2 ibid. and A. Evans, the Palace of Mines, II, 1928, p. 261
            3 The Babylonian Legends of the Creation (Brit. Mus. 1931), p. 59; Antiquaries Journal, III, 1923, p.331
            4 Evans, op cit. I, 1921, pp. 513-14
            5 ibid. IV, 1935, p. 315

            miṇḍāl markhor (Tor.wali) meḍho a ram, a sheep (G.)(CDIAL 10120)

            Rebus: meḍ (Ho.); mẽṛhet ‘iron’ (Mu.Ho.)mẽṛh t iron; ispat m. = steel; dul m. = cast iron (Munda) 


            "Late Harappan Period dish or lid with perforation at edge for hanging or attaching to large jar. It shows a Blackbuck antelope with trefoil design made of combined circle-and-dot motifs, possibly representing stars. It is associated with burial pottery of the Cemetery H period,dating after 1900 BC.The Late Harappan Period at Harappa is represented by the Cemetery H culture (190-1300 BC) which is named after the discovery of a large cemetery filled with painted burial urns and some extended inhumations. The earlier burials in this cemetery were laid out much like Harappan coffin burials, but in the later burials, adults were cremated and the bones placed in large urns (164). The change in burial customs represents a major shift in religion and can also be correlated to important changes in economic and political organization. Cemetery H pottery and related ceramics have been found throughout northern Pakistan, even as far north as Swat, where they mix with distinctive local traditions. In the east, numerous sites in the Ganga-Yamuna Doab provide evidence for the gradual expansion of settlements into this heavily forested region. One impetus for this expansion may have been the increasing use of rice and other summer (kharif) crops that could be grown using monsoon stimulated rains. Until late in the Harappan Period (after 2200 BC) the agricultural foundation of the Harappan cities was largely winter (rabi) crops that included wheat and barley. Although the Cemetery H culture encompassed a relatively large area, the trade connections with thewestern highlands began to break down as did the trade with the coast. Lapis lazuli and turquoise beads are rarely found in the settlements, and marine shell for ornaments and ritual objects gradually disappeared. On the other hand the technology of faience manufacture becomes more refined, possibly in order to compensate for the lack of raw materials such as shell, faience and possibly even carnelian." (Kenoyer in harappa.com slide description) http://www.harappa.com/indus2/162.html

            The chariot linch-pin found at Kirkburn has a triskele hieroglyph-multiplex with an orthography of hierolyph components signifying associated semantics of metalwork. The circular edge of the ends of the linch-pin is embossed with raised circles signifying ingots out of the three sets of crucibles. 
            Copper alloy and iron linch pin; exposed iron shank, rectangular in section and markedly off-centre to the upper terminal.  Upper terminal slightly lop-sided, its perforation is clear of corrosion, and there are wear facets at two points on the edge of th

            In this hieroglyph-multiplex, the central hieroglyph component is  three curved (crucibles) emanating from the centre. At the tip of each of the three cuve-endings, an explanatory hieroglyph component signifies: 1. crucible; and 2. a round ingot emanating from the crucible. Orthography clearly signifies metalwork by a Celtic artisan. The bend in the curved legs emanating from the centre in the triskele is relatable to: कोट or bend, कोटः kōṭḥ Crookedness. A beard (Samskritam. Apte)

            Hieroglyph: koṭhārī f. ʻ crucible  (Old Punjabi)(CDIAL 3546) Rebus: Pk. koṭṭhāgāra -- , koṭṭhāra -- n. ʻ storehouse ʼ; K. kuṭhār m. ʻ wooden granary ʼ, WPah. bhal. kóṭhār m.; A. B. kuṭharī ʻ apartment ʼ, Or. koṭhari; Aw. lakh. koṭhār ʻ zemindar's residence ʼ; H. kuṭhiyār ʻ granary ʼ; G. koṭhār m. ʻ granary, storehouse ʼ, koṭhāriyũ n. ʻ small do. ʼ; M. koṭhār n., koṭhārẽ n. ʻ large granary ʼ, -- °rī f. ʻ small one ʼ; Si.koṭāra ʻ granary, store ʼ.(CDIAL 3550).

            *gōṭṭa ʻ something round ʼ. [Cf. guḍá -- 1. -- In sense ʻ fruit, kernel ʼ cert. ← Drav., cf. Tam. koṭṭai ʻ nut, kernel ʼ, Kan. goṟaṭe &c. listed DED 1722] K. goṭh f., dat. °ṭi f. ʻ chequer or chess or dice board ʼ; S. g̠oṭu m. ʻ large ball of tobacco ready for hookah ʼ, °ṭī f. ʻ small do. ʼ; P. goṭ f. ʻ spool on which gold or silver wire is wound, piece on a chequer board ʼ; N. goṭo ʻ piece ʼ, goṭi ʻ chess piece ʼ; A. goṭ ʻ a fruit, whole piece ʼ, °ṭā ʻ globular, solid ʼ, guṭi ʻ small ball, seed, kernel ʼ; B. goṭā ʻ seed, bean, whole ʼ; Or. goṭā ʻ whole, undivided ʼ, goṭi ʻ small ball, cocoon ʼ, goṭāli ʻ small round piece of chalk ʼ; Bi. goṭā ʻ seed ʼ; Mth. goṭa ʻ numerative particle ʼ; H. goṭ f. ʻ piece (at chess &c.) ʼ; G. goṭ m. ʻ cloud of smoke ʼ, °ṭɔm. ʻ kernel of coconut, nosegay ʼ, °ṭī f. ʻ lump of silver, clot of blood ʼ, °ṭilɔ m. ʻ hard ball of cloth ʼ; M. goṭā m. ʻ roundish stone ʼ, °ṭī f. ʻ a marble ʼ, goṭuḷā ʻ spherical ʼ; Si. guṭiya ʻ lump, ball ʼ; -- prob. also P. goṭṭā ʻ gold or silver lace ʼ, H. goṭā m. ʻ edging of such ʼ (→ K. goṭa m. ʻ edging of gold braid ʼ, S. goṭo m. ʻ gold or silver lace ʼ); M. goṭ ʻ hem of a garment, metal wristlet ʼ.*gōḍḍ -- ʻ dig ʼ see *khōdd -- .Addenda: *gōṭṭa -- : also Ko. gōṭu ʻ silver or gold braid ʼ.(CDIAL 4271) Rebus: खोट (p. 212) [ khōṭa ] f A mass of metal (unwrought or of old metal melted down); an ingot or wedge.(Marathi)

            kōṣṭhāgārika m. ʻ storekeeper ʼ BHSk. [Cf. kōṣṭhā- gārin -- m. ʻ wasp ʼ Suśr.: kōṣṭhāgāra -- ] Pa. koṭṭhāgārika -- m. ʻ storekeeper ʼ; S. koṭhārī m. ʻ one who in a body of faqirs looks after the provision store ʼ; Or. koṭhārī ʻ treasurer ʼ; Bhoj. koṭhārī ʻ storekeeper ʼ, H. kuṭhiyārī m.Addenda: 
            kōṣṭhāgārika -- : G. koṭhārī m. ʻ storekeeper ʼ.(CDIAL 3551)

            The Kirkburn triskele yields the following hieroglyphs and rebus readings:

            Hieroglyphs: 1. कोटः kōṭḥ Crookedness. 2. Bi. goṭā ʻ seed Rebus: L.  khoṭā ʻ forged ʼ; P.  khoṭ 'alloy'

            Hieroglyph: koṭhārī f. ʻ crucible' Rebus: koṭhārī ʻ treasurer ʼ

            Hieroglyph: kolom 'three' Rebus: kolimi 'smithy, forge'.Hieroglyph: koṭhārī f. ʻ crucible' Thus, the triskele/trefoil reads: kolom khoṭ Rebus: kolimi 'smithy' koṭhārī ʻ treasurer ʼ

            The trefoil wearing statuette signifies the message of a treasurer of the smithy:  kolimi koṭhārī 

            S. Kalyanaraman
            Sarasvati Research Center
            September 20, 2015

            त्वष्टा tvaṣṭā (Rigveda) is θwōrəštar- “craftsman” (Avestan), Tuisto (German) links with Indus Script Corpora as catalogus catalogorum of metalwork

            $
            0
            0
            Tuisto, the founder of Germanic people according to Tacitus is also called Tuisco. This variant naming is cognate with two etyma streams of Indian sprachbundत्वष्टा tvaṣṭā (Rigveda) and takkha -- , °aya -- m. ʻ carpenter, artisan ʼ(Prakritam). The designer of the vajra, thunderbolt and the fashioner of the cow are both mentioned in Avestan as  θwōrəštar- “craftsman” and as Gə̄uš Tašan, also a 'divine craftsman'. 
            [quote]GƎˊUŠ TAŠAN (the fashioner of the Cow), a divine craftsman who figures prominently in the Gathas (q.v.) of Zoroaster but falls into obscurity in the Younger Avesta, being there associated with the fourteenth day of the month, known in Middle Persian simply as Gōš. Through his poetry Zoroaster articulated a new religious vision (daēnā; see DĒN) based on the reinterpretation of many traditional concepts. In his system the Gə̄uš Tašan is explicitly identified both with Ahura Mazdā himself and his creative aspect, the (Spə̄ništa) Mainyu “The Most Beneficent Spirit.” To the question posed in Yasna 29.1 by the the soul of the Cow (Gə̄uš Uruuan): “Who fashioned me?” (kə̄ mā tašaṱ), Zoroaster responds in Yasna 44.6 and in Yasna 51.7, there through the agency of the Spə̄ništa Mainyu, “thou (Ahura Mazdā) hast fashioned the Cow” (gąm tašō), and in Yasna 47.3 it is the (Spə̄ništa) Mainyu alone “who hath fashioned the Cow” (yə̄..gąm..hə̄m.tašaṱ). The explicit link to older concepts is made in Yasna 29.1 when the Cow also asks “For whom have you crafted me?” (kahmāi mā θβarōždūm) and in Yasna 29.6 when Ahura Mazdā says “Craftsman fashioned you for the husbandman and the herdsman” (aṱ zī θβā fšuiiantaēcā vāstrāicā θβōrəštā tataša). Thus, by associating the Gə̄uš Tašan with the Indo-Iranian demiurge Θβōrəštar (Vedic Tvaṣṭar), Zoroaster signals his origin. But, why is he the fashioner of the Cow specifically? As shown by Stanley Insler and Hanns-Peter Schmidt, the Cow is a metaphor for Zoroaster’s religious vision, and, moreover, as shown by Wolfgang P. Schmid, the Cow is also a metaphor in Vedic diction for poetry itself. Now, in Vedic and Avestan the root takṣ-/taš- can be used for horses and various material things such as chariots, but it is also widely employed with words for speech when poets refer to their own creation of poetry. Since James Darmesteter’s discovery of the connection of Av. vacastašti- (a strophe of the Gathas) and Gr. epeōntektōn, scholars have recognized an Indo-Eropean idiom wekwos- tekó- (to fashion speech). Thus, it is clear that Zoroaster has substituted the metaphorical gav- for the traditional vacah- to create his “Fashioner of the Cow,” who is actually none other than an ancient *vacahah tašan- (the Fashioner of Speech). That is, for Zoroaster it is Ahura Mazdā himself who is the master poet who inspires the religious vision in the human poet.
            Bibliography:
            J. Darmesteter Études iraniennes II, Paris, 1883, pp. 116-18.
            S. Insler The Gāthās of Zarathustra, Tehran and Liège, 1975, pp. 135, 141-47.
            W. P. Schmid, “Die Kuh auf die Weide,” Indogermanische Forschungen 645/1, 1958, pp. 1-12.
            H.-P. Schmidt, Zarathustra’s Religion and His Pastoral Imagery, Leiden, 1975.
            (William W. Malandra)
            Originally Published: December 15, 2001 [unquote]
            Note the pronunciation (Meluhha, mleccha) variants: Tuisto, Tuisco (German) cognate with tvaṣṭā, takṣa (Samskritam)
            Cognate etyma from Indian sprachbundதச்சன் taccaṉn. < takṣa. 1. Carpenter; மரத்தில் வேலை செய்பவன். மரங்கொஃ றச்சரும் (மணி. 28, 37). 2. Person of carpenter caste; தச்சுவேலைசெய்யும் சாதியான். 3. The 14th nakṣatra, as pertaining to Višvakarma; [விசுவ கர்மாவுக் குரியது] சித்திரை நாள். (பிங்.)தச்சாசாரியம் taccācāriyam, n. < id. +. Status or position of a master-carpenter; தச் சத் தலைமை. (S. I. I. ii, 278, 17.)(Tamil)తక్షకుడు (p. 0500) [ takṣakuḍu ] takshakuḍu. [Skt.] n. The name of mythological serpent ఒక సర్పరాజు. The name of a race of men called Takshakas. A carpenter వడ్లవాడు.(Telugu) ترکانړ tarkāṟṟṉ, s.m. (5th) A carpenter. Pl. ترکانړان tarkāṟṟṉān. (Panjābī).دروزګر darūz-gar, s.m. (5th) A carpenter, a joiner. Pl. دروزګران darūzgarān (corrup. of P درود گر).(Pashto)
            takṣa 5618 takṣa in cmpd. ʻ cutting ʼ, m. ʻ carpenter ʼ VarBr̥S., vṛkṣa -- takṣaka -- m. ʻ tree -- feller ʼ R. [√takṣ]Pa. tacchaka -- m. ʻ carpenter ʼ, taccha -- sūkara -- m. ʻ boar ʼ; Pk. takkha -- , °aya -- m. ʻ carpenter, artisan ʼ; Bshk. sum -- tac̣h ʻ hoe ʼ (< ʻ *earth -- scratcher ʼ),tec̣h ʻ adze ʼ (< *takṣī -- ?); Sh. tac̣i f. ʻ adze ʼ; -- Phal. tērc̣hi ʻ adze ʼ (with "intrusive" r).  takṣaṇa 5619 takṣaṇa n. ʻ cutting, paring ʼ KātyŚr. [√takṣ]Pa. tacchanī -- f. ʻ hatchet ʼ; Pk. tacchaṇa -- n., °ṇā -- f. ʻ act of cutting or scraping ʼ; Kal. tēčin ʻ chip ʼ (< *takṣaṇī -- ?); K. tȧchyunu (dat. tȧchinis) m. ʻ wood -- shavings ʼ; Ku. gng. taċhaṇ ʻ cutting (of wood) ʼ; M. tāsṇī f. ʻ act of chipping &c., adze ʼ.Addenda: takṣaṇa -- : Pk. tacchaṇa -- n. ʻ cutting ʼ; Kmd.barg. taċə̃ři ʻ chips (on roof) ʼ GM 22.6.71. 5620 tákṣati (3 pl. tákṣati RV.) ʻ forms by cutting, chisels ʼ MBh. [√takṣ]Pa. tacchati ʻ builds ʼ, tacchēti ʻ does woodwork, chips ʼ; Pk. takkhaï, tacchaï, cacchaï, caṁchaï ʻ cuts, scrapes, peels ʼ; Gy. pers. tetchkani ʻ knife ʼ, wel. tax -- ʻ to paint ʼ (?); Dm. taċ -- ʻ to cut ʼ (ċ < IE. k̂s NTS xii 128), Kal. tã̄č -- ; Kho. točhik ʻ to cut with an axe ʼ; Phal. tac̣<-> ʻ to cut, chop, whittle ʼ; Sh. (Lor.) thačoikiʻ to fashion (wood) ʼ; K. tachun ʻ to shave, pare, scratch ʼ, S. tachaṇu; L. tachaṇ ʻ to scrape ʼ, (Ju.) ʻ to rough hew ʼ, P. tacchṇā, ludh. taccha ʻ to hew ʼ; Ku.tāchṇo ʻ to square out ʼ; N. tāchnu ʻ to scrape, peel, chip off ʼ (whence tachuwā ʻ chopped square ʼ, tachārnu ʻ to lop, chop ʼ); B. cã̄chā ʻ to scrape ʼ; Or. tã̄chibā,cã̄chibā, chã̄cibā ʻ to scrape off, clip, peel ʼ; Bhoj. cã̄chal ʻ to smoothe with an adze ʼ; H. cã̄chnā ʻ to scrape up ʼ; G. tāchvũ ʻ to scrape, carve, peel ʼ, M. tāsṇẽ; Si. sahinavā, ha° ʻ to cut with an adze ʼ. <-> Kho. troc̣ik ʻ to hew ʼ with "intrusive" r. Addenda: tákṣati: Kmd. taċ -- ʻ to cut, pare, clip ʼ GM 22.6.71; A. cã̄ciba (phonet. sãsibɔ) ʻ to scrape ʼ AFD 216, 217, ʻ to smoothe with an adze ʼ 331. TAÑC: takmán --tákṣan 5621 tákṣan (acc. tákṣaṇam RV., takṣāṇam Pāṇ.) m. ʻ carpenter ʼ. [√takṣ]Pk. takkhāṇa -- m., Paš. ar. tac̣an -- kṓr, weg. taṣāˊn, Kal. kaṭ -- tačon, Kho. (Lor.) tačon, Sh. thac̣&oarcacute;ṇ m., kaṭ -- th°, K. chān m., chöñü f., P. takhāṇm., °ṇī f., H. takhān m.; Si. sasa ʻ carpenter, wheelwright ʼ < nom. tákṣā. -- With "intrusive" r: Kho. (Lor.) tračon ʻ carpenter ʼ, P. tarkhāṇ m. (→ H. tarkhānm.), WPah. jaun. tarkhāṇ. -- With unexpl. d -- or dh -- (X dāˊru -- ?): S. ḍrakhaṇu m. ʻ carpenter ʼ; L. drakhāṇ, (Ju.) darkhāṇ m. ʻ carpenter ʼ (darkhāṇ pakkhī m. ʻ woodpecker ʼ), mult. dhrikkhāṇ m., dhrikkhaṇī f., awāṇ. dhirkhāṇ m. (CDIAL 5618 to 5621).
            "Central to both Iranians and Indo-Aryans was the sacrificial worship (Av. yasna-, OInd. yajñá-) of the gods (Av. daēva-, OPers. daiva, OInd. devá; see DAIVA, DĒV), in which an essential element was the preparation of the sacred drink (Av. haoma-, OPers. hauma-, OInd. sóma-; see HAOMA). They worshiped deities, some of whom bore the same or nearly identical names, for example, Miθra/Mitra, Vayu/Vāyu, Θwōrəštar/Tvaṣṭar, and some represented common concepts of divine functions, for example, Vərəθraγna/Indra (warrior), Spəntā Ārmaiti/Pṛthivī (Earth), Ātar/Agni (Fire). At the head of the Iranian pantheon stood Ahura Mazdā. He was a creator (dātar) in the sense that he exercised dominion over creation in establishing order and putting (vb. -) everything in its proper place. The actual crafting of the creation was the work of the demiurge, θwōrəštar- “craftsman.” 
            Reference to thunderbolt weapon made of metal:

            त्वष्टा वज्रम् अतक्षद आयसम् मयि देवासो वृजन्नपि क्रतुम् 

            मामानीकम् सूर्यस्ये वादुष्टरम् माम् आर्यन्ति कृत्येन कर्त्वेनच 

            Translation. Griffith: 3 For me hath Tvastar forged the iron thunderbolt: in me the Gods have centred intellectual power.

            Translation: Sayana, Wilson: 10.048.03 For me Tvas.t.a_ fabricated the metal thunderbolt; in me the gods have concentrated pious acts; my lustre is insurmountable, like that of the Sun; men acknowledge me as lord in consequence of what I have done, and of what I shall do. [My lustre is the Sun: my army is hard to overcome, like the sun's lustre; ani_ka = lit., face].

            2 He slew the Dragon lying on the mountain: his heavenly bolt of thunder Tvastarfashioned. (RV 1.32.2).
            6 Even for him hath Tvastar forged the thunder, most deftly wrought, celestial, for the battle,(RV 1.61.6)
            9 When Tvastar deft of hand had turned the thunderbolt, golden, with thousand edges, fashioned(RV 1.85.9)
            10 Yea, Strong One! Tvastar turned for thee, the Mighty, the bolt with thousand spikes and hundred(RV 6.17.10)


            Tvastr the maker of divine instruments makes Vajra for Indra, notes Rigveda."Tvastr made it for him from the bones of the seer Dadhica: it is hundred-jointed, thousand-pointed. ...'' Samudramanthanam narrative in Bhagavata Purana.
            Indra Holding Thunderbolt VajraIndra Holding Thunderbolt Vajra – Keshava Temple, Somnathpur

            Indra with Vajra
            Khmer style, NE-Thailand, That Phanom Rung Temple,
            12th century, Buriram Province, Worship of Siva.
            Bas-relief of Phnom Kulen in Cambodia, IX century.Indra holds double-vajra, seated on a column.
            Panchalas of Ahichhatra, 75-50 BC, Indramitra, 5.92g, 17mm, Indra holding 'Vajra' (Thunderbolt) http://www.coinnetwork.com/profiles/blogs/hindu-deities-of-indian-coins
            Indra on Airavata elephant, holding vajra.Sculpture from Orissa.Indra on Airavata, Consort Shachi. Keshava Temple, Somnathpur.

            Vajradhara (Adi-Buddha) is he thunderbolt-bearer. rdo-rje-hc'an 'he who holds a thunderbolt'; ocirdara (corruption of vajradhara), or Vacir bariqci (he who holds a thunderbolt); Symbols: vajra 'thunderbolt'; ghaNTa 'bell'; MudrA: vajra-hUmkAra. Colour: dark blue; S'akti: PrajnApaaramita; Other names: Karmavajra, dharmavajra. Vajradhara, the 'indestructible', lord of all mysteries, master of all secrets, is an exoteric representation of Adi-Buddha and in this form is believed to reign over the Eastern Quarter...Certain Lamaist sects identified Vajradhara with Vajrasattva, while others looked upon Vajrasattva as an active form of Vajradhara, who was too lost in divine quietude to occupy himself directly with the affairs of sentient beings. Others again worshipped Vajradhara as a supreme deity distinct and apart from Vajrasattva...Vajradhara was thus looked upon as Adi-Buddha by the two greatest sects of the MahAyAna schoo; the dKar-hGya-pa (Red-caps) and the dGe-lugs-pa (Yellow-caps)...He has the UrNA and ushNIsha. His arms are crossed on his breast in the vajrahUmkAra mudrA holding the vajra and ghaNTA. These two symbols may, however, be supported by flowering branches on either side, the stems being held in the crossed hands, which is his special mystical gesture." (Getty, Alice, 1988, The gods of Northern Buddhism: their history and iconography, Courier Corporation;1914, Oxford, Clarendon Press, p.ix).
            Vajrasatva with vajra
            Khmer style, NE-Thailand
            13th century,
            Vajrayana, Tantric Buddhism,
            Phimai Museum, Thailand.The vajra is the most important ritual implement, symbol of Vajrayana Buddhism

            Vajra pestles, vajra bell and vajra's tray: 五鈷杵 gokosho, 独鈷杵 tokkosho, 金剛盤 kongōban, 三鈷杵 sankosho and 五鈷鈴 gokorei.
            Open vajra.
            Yamantaka, Fear-Striking Vajra, Lord of Death (Tibetan: Gshin-rje-gshed), multiheaded, holding vajra, rope, dagger, riding a water buffalo, statue of a guardian, enormous strength, Tibetan Esoteric Buddhism, Art Institute, Chicago, Illinois, USA
            Vajrasattva holds the vajra in his right hand and a bell in his left hand.


            "The Assyro-Chaldean gods were represented holding a trident (v. trizUla) with the points zig-zag shaped, representin lightning. In Mesopotamia the golds hold a double trident, which is also found in the caves of Ellora, as well as other parts of India, in the hand of Siva. The Northern Buddhists believe that Buddha wrested the vajra (double trident) from the Hindu god Indra, and adopted it as a Buddhist symbol with the slight change of closing the points of the darts. The Indian vajra with three darts is flat and the points do not touch. The Tibetan 'thunderbolt' with four darts is round, and as the points are closed the two ends resemble lotus-buds in form. A fifth dart runs through the centre of the vajra, from end to end, making five darts, which represent the five bodies of the DhyAni-Buddhas. In Japan the vaja (kongO0, called doko (or tokko) has only one dart, which is four-sided. There is also a three-darted vajra, the san-kO, which resembles the Indian form in that it is flat and that the points are not closed. The five-darted kongO, the go-kO, differs from the Tibetan vajra in that all the five darts are outside. It is looked upon as representing the five elements as well as the five bodies of the celestial Buddhas. If the vajra has seven darts around an eighth, it is called kyukokyo...Padmasambhava introduced the vajra into Tibet, and through his influence it became most popular. The priests adopted its use to exorcise devils, and it was also introduced into the ceremonies for worshipping AmitAyus. In the esoteric doctrine the vajra is the mystic symbol of the linga, and the expression, 'in vajra attitude', is the attitude of yab-yum. The vajra is the special symbol of Akshobhya and of VajrapANi. Vajradhara holds it in his right hand and the vajra-handled bell in his left hand, as does also Trailokyavijaya, KongOsatta, and Aizen-myO-O; Vajrasattva holds it balanced on his right hand, while the left hand holds the vajra-handled bell on his hip. The vajra is carried as an accessory symbol by all the Yidam, but not by the DharmapAla...The Vajra-dhAtu, is the 'diamond' element. Vajra is here translated 'diamond' rather than 'thunderbolt', and represents the Spiritual world, or complete Enlightenment -- the esoteric teachings of the Dharma-kAya as against the exoteric teachings of the NirmANa-kAya. It is the sixth element, the manas (mind), and is symbolized by the triangle with the point below (v. tri-koNa), as well as by the full moon. It is located in the West, and is symbolized by the setting of the sun." (Getty, Alice, 1988, The gods of Northern Buddhism: their history and iconography, Courier Corporation, p.200)

            Thunderbolts (vajras) in Mesopotamia
                 The oldest thunderbolt reference is found in The Seven Tablets of Creation made of are baked clay and found among some 22.000 other tablets in the ruins of the palace and library of Ashur-bani-pal (B.C. E 668-626) at Ḳuyûnjiḳ (Nineveh)'' in modern day Iraq (location: N36.366 E43.166).
            ''Marduk destroying Tiâmat, who is here represented in the form of a huge serpent.'' 
            From a seal-cylinder in the British Museum,
            no. 89,589.
            ''Battle between Marduk (Bel) and the Dragon[Tiamat]. Drawn from a bas-relief from the Palace of Ashur-nasir-pal, King of Assyria, 885-860 B.C.E, at Nimrûd.''
            British Museum. Nimrud Gallery, Nos. 28 and 29. 
             "The form of the vajra as a sceptre or a weapon appears to have its origin in the single or double trident, which arose as a symbol of the thunderbolt or lightning in many ancient civilizations of the Near and Middle East. Parallels are postulated with the meteoric hammer of the Teutonic sky-god Thor, the thunderbolt and sceptre of the Greek sky-god Zeus, and the three thunderbolts of the Roman god Jupiter. As a hurled weapon the indestructible thunderbolt blazed like a meteoric fireball across the heavens, in a maelstrom of thunder, fire and lightning." Source: http://www.sundial.thai-isan-lao.com/sundial_vajra_literature.html
            "The vajra is the Indian representative of the thunderbolt, and a comparison of corresponding ideas with other Indo-European peoples leads to the conclusion that even in the Indo-European period there was some idea of a vaguely personified independent wielder of the thunderbolt. With the Germanic tribes he became the "Thunderer," the porr of Old Norse mythology, in Hellas and Rome he was associated with Zeus-Jupiter, and in India he became Indra. But a vague recollection of his original independence had left its impression on the religious mind of the Aryans, and he was never quite absorbed by Indra. Even in the Rigveda, our chief document for the period when Indra, rose to the rank of supreme god, we also find Rudra designated as vajrabahu (II, 33. 3); in the Atharvaveda Bhava and Sarva are asked to use their Vajra against evil-doers (IV.28.6), and Soma smites with the vajra (VI. 6. 2), &c.; in the Bhagavatapurana (X. 159. 20) Visnu wields the thunderbolt, and so forth." pp. 316-317 in Note on Vajrapani-IndraSten Konow, Acta Orientalia, 1930.
            Eagle on thunderbolt with oak-leaf. 
            Ptolomy III, 246 - 221 BC
            Egypt, Eurgetes, Alexandria.
            Opposite site: Zeus-Ammon.
            Source: Wildwinds.com
            Syracyse, 288 B.C.E
            Zeus and thunderbolt
            Sicily, Syracuse, 357-354 B.C.E
            ''Vajra
                 The Vajra, thunderbolt, which Usana Kavya is said to have fashioned, as also Tvastri in RV 1 .32.2, was Indra's exclusive weapon and on account of his skill in wielding it, he is called in RV Vajrabhrit, bearing the bolt, Vajrivat, armed with the bolt. Vajradaksina, holding the bolt in his right hand, Vajrabahu orVajrahasta, holding the Vajra in his hand, or Vajrin, armed with the bolt, which is the commoner epithet of them all. Not much information about the shape of Vajra is available in the RV. However, it is said that it was made of iron, and that it belonged to the category of the weapons called the astras i.e. those weapons which are operated by throwing.
                 In RV V.34.2 cited earlier where Uiani is said to have presented a weapon with thousand bhristis to Indra. Geldner has translated bhristis as spike. The meaning of the word, however, is doubtful. It also occurs in RV 1.133.5 in the context of the picaci who is described as pisangabhristi. Geldner thinks that the weapon is Soma.
                  JB 1.97 narrates the story of the birth of Vajra: The devas and the asuras were contesting. Those devas created a sharp-edged thunderbolt (which was) as if a man. (They through) him (? tam) warded off the asuras. Having pushed them away, he returned to the devas. The devas were frightened. They attacked him, and broke him into three. Broken into three, he remained the same ...
                 It seems likely that the vajra was similar to trisula. A double trisula is found on some of the Assyrian bas-reliefs [see picture below: 4.0 Thunderbolts (vajras) in Mesopotamia], where it is depicted as having the three edges on each side with the handle in between.
            Before acquiring the thunderbolt, the devas and the asuras were fighting with the staves and bows (dandairdhanubhisca) and did not succeed in defeating each other. Thereupon they started pairing the masculine and feminine words with a view to ending the battle conclusively.
                 AiBr. II.31 states in the ritual language the reason of the balance in the strength of the devas and the asuras: "The Asuras performed at the sacrifice all that the Devas performed. The Asuras became thus of equal power (with the Devas) and did not yield to them (in any respect). Thereupon the Devas saw (by their mental eyes) the tusnim samsa i.e. silent praise. The Asuras (not knowing it) did not perform this (ceremony) of the Devas. This "silent praise" is the silent (latent) essence (of the mantras). Whatever weapon (Vajra) the Devas raised against the Asuras, the latter got aware of them . The Devas then saw the silent praise as their weapon; they raised it, but the Asuras did not become aware of it. The Devas aimed it at the Asuras and defeated the latter who did not perceive (the weapon aimed at them). Thereupon the Devas became the masters of the Asuras...""
                 This may simply be interpreted as suggesting that the asuras were alert every time they were attacked, but when taken unawares, they succumbed to the attack.
                 The discussion of archaeological material shows that this original double trisula was transformed by the asuras into a weapon which could perform two kinds of functions. It could be thrown and could be held as well.''
            Source: Shendge, Malati J.: The civilized Demons: The Harappans in the Rigveda. Pgs. 79-80.

            वज्र[p= 913,1] a kind of hard mortar or cement (कल्क) VarBr2S. (cf. -लेप) mn. " the hard or mighty one " , a thunderbolt (esp. that of इन्द्र , said to have been formed out of the bones of the ऋषि दधीच or दधीचि [q.v.] , and shaped like a circular discus , or in later times regarded as having the form of two transverse bolts crossing each other thus x ; sometimes also applied to similar weapons used by various gods or superhuman beings , or to any mythical weapon destructive of spells or charms , also to मन्यु , " wrath " RV. or [with अपाम्] to a jet of water AV. &c ; also applied to a thunderbolt in general or to the lightning evolved from the centrifugal energy of the circular thunderbolt of इन्द्र when launched at a foe ; in Northern Buddhist countries it is shaped like a dumb-bell and called Dorje ; » MWB. 201 ; 322 &c RV. &c a diamond (thought to be as hard as the thunderbolt or of the same substance with it) , Shad2vBr. Mn. MBh. &c n. a kind of hard iron or steel L. mfn. adamantine , hard , impenetrable W. mfn. shaped like a kind of cross (cf. above ) , forked , zigzag ib. [cf. Zd. vazra , " a club. "](Monier-Williams)

            Note: In Rigveda, vajra refers to something hard or mighty compared to a thunderbolt or a jet of water. At what stage of semantic evolution, the gloss was expanded to mean 'adamaentine, glue' is unclear. This is the stage when the artisans might have recognized the feature of cementite, as a nanotube which forms when carbon combines with iron. It is clear that in VarAhamira's time, the gloss vajra meant an adamantine glue: sanghAta. It is possible that this gloss was signified by the sangaDa 'lathe' which is a device most commonly deployed on Indus Script Corpora. Kalyan

            S. Kalyanaraman
            Sarasvati Research Center
            June 15, 2015

            Vientine, Laos
            Indra in Vientaine, Laos 
            http://swamiindology.blogspot.in/2014/09/why-did-sumer-and-egypt-worship-indra.html
            S. Kalyanaraman
            Sarasvati Research Center
            September 20, 2015

            Islam is a political movement masquerading as religion: US Admiral (R) James 'Ace' Lyons, Feb. 11, 2015

            Teutsch, Deutsch, Tyr (Norse), Teshub (Hurrian),Tuisco, Tuisto, Tvastr, Taksa armourer -- out of Tower of Babel

            $
            0
            0
            Mirror: http://tinyurl.com/q2h4k7t

            Narrating the history of events in an extensive area of Eurasia ca. 3rd millennium BCE is a challenge. Many words undergo phonetic changes, e.g. Tvastr, Taksa as Tyr, Teshub, Tuisco, Tuisto. The narratives related to such persons however is related to their contributions in metallurgy and making of armour of the Bronze Age. It is possible to reasonably reconstruct the narrative out of the Tower of Babel thanks to decipherment of Indus Script Corpora as catalogus catalogorum of metalwork.

            See: http://bharatkalyan97.blogspot.in/2015/09/tvasta-rigveda-is-worstar-craftsman.html
            Tuisco Tuesday After Figure 1 shows a seventeenth-century imagining of the Germanic god Tuisco. Many in the seventeenth century believed that the Germans and their language (Deutsch, then often spelled Teutsch) were named after this supposed Germanic god. Tower of Babel in the background.  https://blogs.nottingham.ac.uk/clas/2013/08/16/germania-remembered/   Germania Remembered 1500–2009. Commemorating and Inventing a Germanic Past, co-edited byDr Nicola McLelland (German) and Dr Christina Lee (English)

            Tuisco e Moni (divinità germaniche) From Manusk, 1774 book.

            Tuisco from Promptuarii Iconum Insigniorum cf. Proto-Indo-European Society of ca. 2000 BCE (Simek, Rudolf (2007) translated by Angela Hall. Dictionary of Northern MythologyD.S. Brewer)

            See: http://bharatkalyan97.blogspot.in/2015/06/tvastr-meluhha-of-bharatam-janam.html?view=timeslide
            Two views of Mitanni Storm Divinity, Teshub. Axe (paras'u) in his upraised right hand and a vajra (thunderbolt) in his left hand. The trident is also pictured in Mitanni seals. He wears a short fringed tunic with a wide belt. His horned helmet is reminiscent of the bull figures often associated with him. The photo on the left is from the Hittite capital in Turkey. 

            Teshub was the divinity of the sky, weather and storms (Hurrian).

            How Tvaṣṭr̥ armourer, forged discus of Viṣṇu, Triśūla of Śiva and other weapons of divinities from solar disc, Sun divinity 
            Links with metalwork are clear from the meanings provided in Samskritam which extend from workman to copper to creative power:  tvāṣṭra त्वाष्ट्र a. Belonging or coming from त्वष्टृ; त्वाष्ट्रं यद् दस्रावपिकक्ष्यं वाम् Rv.1.117.22. -ष्ट्रः Vṛitra; येनावृता इमे लोकास्तमसा त्वाष्ट्रमूर्तिना । स वै वृत्र इति प्रोक्तः पापः परमदारुणः ॥ Bhāg.6.9.18;11.12.5. -ष्ट्री 1 The asterism Chitra. -2 A small car. -ष्ट्रम् 1 Creative power; तपःसारमयं त्वाष्ट्रं वृत्रो येन विपाटितः Bhāg.8.11.35. -2 Copper. tvaṣṭṛ त्वष्टृ m. [त्वक्ष्-तृच्] 1 A carpenter, builder, workman, त्वष्ट्रेव विहितं यन्त्रम् Mb.12.33.22. -2 Viśvakarman, the architect of the gods. [Tvaṣtṛi is the Vulcan of the Hindu mythology. He had a son named Triśiras and a daughter called संज्ञा, who was given in marriage to the sun. But she was unable to bear the severe light of her husband, and therefore Tvaṣtṛi mounted the sun upon his lathe, and carefully trimmed off a part of his bright disc; cf. आरोप्य चक्रभ्रमिमुष्णतेजास्त्वष्ट्रेव यत्नो- ल्लिखितो विभाति R.6.32. The part trimmed off is said to have been used by him in forming the discus of Viṣṇu, the Triśūla of Śiva, and some other weapons of the gods.] पर्वतं चापि जग्राह क्रुद्धस्त्वष्टा महाबलः Mb.1.227. 34. -3 Prajāpati (the creator); यां चकार स्वयं त्वष्टा रामस्य महिषीं प्रियाम् Mb.3.274.9. -4 Āditya, a form of the sun; निर्भिन्ने अक्षिणी त्वष्टा लोकपालो$विशद्विभोः Bhāg.3.6.15. आदित्य a. [अदितेरपत्यं ण्य P.IV.1.85.] A son of Aditi; a god, divinity in general. (The number of Ādityas appears to have been originally seven, of whom Varuṇa is the head, and the name Āditya was restricted to them (देवा आदित्या ये सप्त Rv.9.114.3.). In the time of the Brāhmaṇas, however, the number of Ādityas rose to 12, representing the sun in the 12 months of the year; धाता मित्रो$र्यमा रुद्रो वरुणः सूर्य एव च । भगो विवस्वान् पूषा च सविता दशमः स्मृतः ॥ एकादशस्तथा त्वष्टा विष्णुर्द्वादश उच्यते ।); आदित्यानामहं विष्णुः Bg.1.21; Ku. 2.24. (These 12 suns are supposed to shine only at the destruction of the universe; cf. Ve.3.8; दग्धुं विश्वं दहनकिरणैर्नोदिता द्वादशार्काः).(Samskritam. Apte)

            "King Shaushtatar (ruled c. 1430) extended the boundaries of Mitanni through the conquest of Alalakh, Nuzi, Assur, and Kizzuwatna. Egypt, under Tuthmosis III (1479-1425 BCE), defeated the Mitanni at Aleppo after a long period of contention over control of the region of Syria. Later Egyptian dynasties entered into pacts and treaties with Mitanni and the daughter of the Mitanni King Tushratta, the princess Taduhepa, was given in marriage to Amenhotep III (1391-1353 BCE) as part of a treaty which balanced power between the two nations.This treaty was put to the test during a power struggle in Washukanni between Tushratta and a relative of the previous king, Shuttarna, known as Artatama II. Egypt backed Tushratta in this conflict while the Hittite king Suppiluliuma I backed Artatama II. Tushratta seemed poised to succeed when Egypt, fearing the growing power of the Hittites, withdrew its support. Suppiluliuma I, tired of diplomacy and now free to do as he pleased without fear of Egyptian reprisal, led his forces on Washukanni and sacked it. Tushratta was assassinated by his son, perhaps in an effort to save the city. Following this conquest, Mitanni was ruled by Hittite kings."http://www.ancient.eu/Mitanni/ The name Tushratta may also be a phonetic variant of Tvaṣṭr̥, Tuisto.                                                  Indo-Aryan superstrate in Mitanni is postulated. 
            "In a treaty between the Hittites and the Mitanni (between Suppiluliuma and Shattiwaza, ca. 1380 BC), the deities Mitra, Varuna, Indra, and Nasatya (Ashvins) are invoked.Kikkuli's horse training text (circa 1400 BC) includes technical terms such as aika (Vedic Sanskrit eka, one), tera (tri, three), panza (pañca, five), satta (sapta, seven), na (nava, nine), vartana (vartana, round). The numeral aika "one" is of particular importance because it places the superstrate in the vicinity of Indo-Aryan proper (Vedic Sanskrit eka, with regular contraction of /ai/ to [eː]) as opposed to Indo-Iranian or early Iranian (which has *aiva; compare Vedic eva "only") in general. Another text has babru(-nnu) (babhru, brown), parita(-nnu) (palita, grey), and pinkara(-nnu) (pingala, red). Another text has babru(-nnu) (babhru, brown), parita(-nnu) (palita, grey), and pinkara(-nnu) (pingala, red). Their chief festival was the celebration of the solstice (vishuva) which was common in most cultures in the ancient world. The Mitanni warriors were called marya (Hurrian: maria-nnu), the term for (young) warrior in Sanskrit as well;[1] note mišta-nnu (= miẓḍha,~ Sanskrit mīḍha) "payment (for catching a fugitive)" (Mayrhofer II 358). Sanskritic interpretations of Mitanni names render Artashumara (artaššumara) as Arta-smara "who thinks of Arta/Ṛta" (Mayrhofer II 780), Biridashva (biridašṷa, biriiašṷa) as Prītāśva "whose horse is dear" (Mayrhofer II 182), Priyamazda (priiamazda) as Priyamedha "whose wisdom is dear" (Mayrhofer II 189, II378), Citrarata as citraratha "whose chariot is shining" (Mayrhofer I 553), Indaruda/Endaruta as Indrota "helped by Indra" (Mayrhofer I 134), Shativaza (šattiṷaza) as Sātivāja "winning the race price" (Mayrhofer II 540, 696), Šubandhu as Subandhu 'having good relatives" (a name in Palestine, Mayrhofer II 209, 735), Tushratta (tṷišeratta, tušratta, etc.) as *tṷaišaratha, Vedic Tveṣaratha "whose chariot is vehement" (Mayrhofer I 686, I 736). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indo-Aryan_superstrate_in_Mitanni



            Tvaṣṭṛ is sometimes associated or identified with deities,such as Savitṛ, Prajāpatī, Viśvakarman and Puṣan. He is the father of Saraṇyū, who twice bears twins to Vivasvat (RV 10.17.1), Yama and Yami, also identified as the first humans to be born on Earth. He is also the father of Viśvarūpa or Triśiras who was killed by Indra, in revenge Tvaṣṭṛ created Vrtra a fearsome dragon. Tvaṣṭṛ is a solar deity in the epic of Mahābhārata and the Harivaṃśa. He is mentioned as the son of Kāśyapa and Aditi, and is said to have made the three worlds with pieces of the Sun god Surya.  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tvastar  

            Invocation to Tvaṣṭr̥.



            RV 1.113.10 I invoke the chief and multiform Tvas.t.r. (= Vis'vakarma_); may he be solely ours. Sayana explains: Tvas.t.a_ = Vis'vakarma_, artificer of the gods, the fabricator of the original sacrificial vase or ladle. tvas.t.a_ vai pas'u_na_m mithuna_na_m ru_kakr.t---iti s'ruteh (Taittiri_ya.Sam.hita_ 6.1.8.5): Tvas.t.a_ forms in animals in pairs. This remarkable elucidation seems to anticipate the characteristic hieroglyphic multiplex forms -- particularly antithetical, pairs -- of composite animals used repeatedly in Indus Script Corpora. This characteristic pairing seems to be reflected in the explanation for the cognate word Tuisto in Germania -- as derived from tvai 'two':
            Tvastar, Tuisto, Ymir. According to Tacitus's Germania (98 CE), Tuisto is the divine ancestor of the Germanic peoples...Tuisto, is commonly connected to the Proto-Germanic root tvai ("two") and its derivative tvis ("twice"; "doubled")...Jacob argues that the Germanic Tuisto (assuming a connection with Tvastr) must originally have been the grandfather of Ymir (cognate to Yama). Incidentally, Indian mythology also places Manu (cognate to Germanic Mannus), the Vedic progenitor of mankind, as a son of Vivaswān, thus making him the brother of Yama/Ymir.(Jacob, Alexander (2005). Ātman: A Reconstruction of the Solar Cosmology of the Indo-Europeans. Georg Olms Verlag., p.232)...According to Rives (1999), the fact that the ancient Germanic peoples claimed descent from an earth-born god was used by Tacitus to support his contention that they were an indigenous population: the Latin word indigena was often used in the same sense as the Greek autochthonos, meaning literally '[born from] the earth itself' (from χθών – chthōn "earth").(Rives, J. B. (1999) (Trans.) Tacitus' Germania. Oxford University Press, pp. 111-112.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tuisto Suryadeva.jpgSurya with consorts Saranyu (Sanjna) and Chhaya. Saranyu is the daughter of Tvastar

            Saranya (Saraṇyū) or Saraniya (also known as Saranya, Sanjna, or Sangya) is the consort of Surya, and the divinity of clouds in Hindu tradition. She marries Vivasvat and is mother of Revantathe twin Asvins, Manu, the twins Yama and Yami. Saraṇyū is the female form of the adjective saraṇyú, meaning "quick, fleet, nimble", used for rivers and wind in the Rigveda. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saranyu

            RV 10.17.1-2: 
            Tvastar prepares the bridal of his Daughter: all the world hears the tidings and assembles.
            But Yama's Mother, Spouse of great Vivasvat, vanished as she was carried to her dwelling.
            From mortal men they hid the Immortal Lady, made one like her and gave her to Vivasvat.
            Saranyu brought to him the Asvin brothers, and then deserted both twinned pairs of children.
            10.017.01 Tvas.t.a_ celebrates the marriage of his daughter; therefore, the whole world is assembled; but the mother of Yama, the newly-married wife of the mighty Vivasvat, disappeared. [Deity Saran.yu_: The legend: Saran.yu_, the daughter of Tvas.t.a_, was given in marriage to Vivasvat, and had by him Yama and Yami_. Intimidated by his ardour, she substituted another female, her shadow, Cha_ya_, for herself, and going to Uttarakuru, changed herself to a mare. Vivasvat begot Manu by Cha_ya_, when, finding his error, he set off to look for his wife. Discovering her disguise, he transformed himself to a horse, and had by his wife the two As'vins].
            10.017.02 The gods concealing the immortal (Sarn.yu_) for th esake of mortals and having formed her, gave her to Vivasvat. She bore the two As'vins when this had happened and then Saran.yu_ gave birth to two twins. [For the sake of mortals: maryebhyah = manus.yebhyas tadutpattyartham, for men, i.e. that men might be born. Manu was the offspring of Vivasvat and the woman resembling Saran.yu_ and all men are descended from Manu; the two twins: Yama and Yami_, but dva_ mithuna_, may mean two pairs of twins, Yama and Yami_,  the first pair and the As'vins the second].
            10.017.03 May the discriminating Pu_s.an, whose cattle are never lost, the protector of all beings, transfer you hence (to a better world); may he give you to these Pitr.s; may Agni (give) you to the beneficent gods. [This and the following three r.cas are to be recited at the funeral rites of a man who has been duly initiated, di_ks.ita].
            10.017.04 May the all-pervading Va_yu protect you, may Pu_s.an (preserve) you, (going) first on the excellent path (to heaven); may the divine Savita_ place you, where the virtuous abide, whither they have gone. [a_yu = Va_yu].
            10.017.05 Pu_s.an knows all these regions severally; met him conduct us by (the path) that is most free from peril; let him precede us, who is the giver of prosperity, endowed with radiance, accompanied by all pious men, ever vigilant, and knowing our (deserts).
            10.017.06 Pu_s.an has been born on the best path of paths, on the best path of heaven on the best path of earth, he goes forward and backward over both (worlds), the assemblies longed for by all, discriminating (the merits of the dead). [Pu_s.an has been born: i.e., manifested in order to conduct men after death to their destination, according to their merits; he goes forward: i.e., favourably to the virtuous to show the fruit of good owrks, backward, i.e., he walks adversely to the wicked; discriminating the merits: i.e., he walks adversely to the wicked].
            10.017.07 The devout invoke Sarasvati_; they worship Sarasvati_ at the strewn sacrifice; the virtuous call upon Sarasvati_; may Sarasvati_ bestow blessings upon the donor (of the oblation).
            10.017.08 Divine Sarasvati_, who rides in the same chariot with the Pitr.s, and delighted (along with them) by the (sacrificial) viands, seated on the sacred grass gratified (by our offering, and grant us wholesome food.
            10.017.09 Sarasvati_, whom the Pitr.s invoke when circumambulating sacrifice on the right, bestow upon the worshippers at this sacrifice a portion of food fit for thousands, and increase of riches.
            10.017.10 May the maternal waters, purify us; may the shedders of water purify us with the effusion; for the divine (waters) bear away all sin; I come away from them purified (to heaven).  [Shedders of water...with effusion: ghr.tena no ghr.tapvah punantu: waters which purify others by water; ghr.ta = effused water; ghr.tapvah = divinities presiding over effused water; or, ghr.ta = oiled butter (Yajus. 4.2); udemi = I go to heaven (S'atapatha Bra_hman.a 3.1.2.11)].
            10.017.11 The Soma has risen to the earthly and heavenly (worlds), both this visible world, and that which (existed) before (it); I offer that Soma flowing through the common region (of heaven and earth) after the sacrifice (offered by the) seven (officiating priests). [drapsam = a name of the Sun (S'atapatha Bra_hman.a: 8.4.1.20); hotra_h = ditah, which are seven: zenith, nadir, centre and four cardinal points].
            10.017.12 Soma, which escapes (from the hide), your filaments which let fall from the hands (of the priest escape) from the vicinity of the planks (of the press), or (from the hand) of the Adhvaryu, or from the filter; I offer it all with my mind (to Agni) with the word vas.at.
            10.017.13 Your juice and your filaments, (Soma), which escape, and which fall from the ladle on this side or on that; may this divine Br.haspati sprinkle it for our enrichment.
            10.017.14 (Waters)! the plants flourish by means of water my prayer is effectual through water; the essence of water is vigorous through water; purify me with it. [payasvat = having water; or, sa_ravat, having pith or vigour; being vigorous b\y means of water in the shape of rain].

             List_of_languages_by_first_written_accounts 
            c. 2900 BC Sumerian "proto-literate" period from about 3500 BC 
            c. 2700 BC Egyptian "proto-hieroglyphic" from about 3300 BC (2nd Dynasty, Narmer Palette)
            c. 2400 BC Akkadian from about 2800 BC.[probably the 1st extensive use of writing]
            c. 2400 BC Eblaite - They love not commenting this 1. [Proto-Ugaric, Hittite, Canaanite-ish]
            c. 2250 BC Elamite - [Most closely related to Indo-Iranian group, developed east of mesopotamia in Susa] 
            c. 2000 BC Hurrian - fragmentary, known only from a few glosses in Hittite texts
            c. 1800 BC Luwian - hieroglyphs [closely tied to Hittite]
            c. 1700's BC Minoan archival documents written in Cretan hieroglyphs c. 1625 BC: 
            c. 1650 BC Hittite Various cuneiform texts and Palace Chronicles written during the reign of Hattusili I
            c. 1500 BC Canaanite-Proto-Sinaitic alphabet

            Map of the Near East ca. 1400 BCE showing the Mitanni kingdom at its greatest extent https://en.wiki2.org/wiki/Mitanni
            Portrait of Tuisco (or Tuisto), identified by Tacitus as the ancestor of the Germans, after an illustration in Wolfgang Lazius' De aliquot gentium migrationibus.https://www.flickr.com/photos/58558794@N07/7725732342
            Tacitus wrote:"In ancient lays, their only type of historical tradition, they celebrate Tuisto, a god brought forth from the earth. They attribute to him a son, Mannus, the source and founder of their people, and to Mannus three sons, from whose names those nearest the Ocean are called Ingvaeones, those in the middle Herminones, and the rest Istvaeones. Some people, inasmuch as antiquity gives free reign to speculation, maintain that there were more sons born from the god and hence more tribal designations- Marsi, Gambrivii, Suebi, and Vandilii- and that those names are genuine and ancient." (2.2) loc. cit. http://celto-germanic.blogspot.in/2014/04/tuisto-god-tiwaz.html
            Richard North notes that tuisto may be 'two-standing' or 'standing twice'. Mannu is the son of Tuisto who is 'born from the earth'. (North, Richard, 1997, Heathen gods in old English literature, Cambridge University Press, pp.27, 270). 
            Týr (/ˈtɪr/; Old Norse: Týr [tyːr]) is a god associated with law and heroic glory in Norse mythology... If a warrior carved the rune Tîwaz on his weapon he would be dedicating it to Týr and strengthen the outcome of a battle to be in his favor. After a warrior has dedicated his weapon to Týr he should not lose it or break it.  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/T%C3%BDr 
            The identification with metalsmiths provides a possible link of Tyr to Tvaṣṭr̥, Tuisto. 
            S. Kalyanaraman, Sarasvati Research Center, Sept. 21, 2015 




                 


               

            Editor New IE responds to PC threats: "Express stands by every word of its report and is prepared to face legal action if it comes." Kudos to Gurumurthy for exposing the kaalaadhan scam.

            $
            0
            0

            Sep 21 2015 : The Times of India (Chennai) September 21, 2015 Page 7 Chennai Edition
            PC refutes reports inking him, Karti to Vasan investment
            Chennai:
            TIMES NEWS NETWORK
            
            
            Refuting reports that he and his son Karti were investors in a private healthcare company Vasan Health Vasan Healthcare Pvt Ltd, ormer Union inance minister P Chidambaram on Sunday said it was part of a political campaign against members of the erstwhile UPA government and Congress party individuals.“Let me say clearly that the entire reportage is false, malicious and part of a political campaign against members of the UPA government or individuals belonging to the Congress party,“ he said.
            “Neither I, my son nor any member of my family have any equity or investment or economic interest in the company concerned,“ he said.
            “I have no knowledge of events concerning the income tax department or its officers said to have taken place in June 2015 and subsequently. The UPA government demitted office in May 2014,“ Chidambaram added.
            In support of the company, he said it has globally `re nowned investors' and an eminent board of directors. “I am sure they will defend the company against the malicious allegations,“ Chidambaram said. “The media must be responsible and truthful.Carrying false and malicious reports without independent verification will certainly attract the provisions of law and I shall not hesitate to place the matter in the hands of my lawyers to take appropriate action,“ he warned in the statement issued on his letterhead as a Supreme Court advocate.
            In a separate statement, Vasan healthcare chairman and managing director Dr A M Arun said the company has marquee investors among its shareholders.
            “Our board is made up of senior and respected people with vast corporate governance track record. We take pride in playing a larger lead role in eradication of blindness in India in a big way, We have so far treated over 3 crore customers across our clinics in 19 states and 120 cities. This contribution in turn has resulted in preventing productivity loss and adding value to millions of patients,“ he said.
            http://epaperbeta.timesofindia.com/Article.aspx?eid=31807&articlexml=PC-refutes-reports-inking-him-Karti-to-Vasan-21092015007023

            Chidambaram Denies Family Ties with Vasan Healthcare

            Published: 21st September 2015 03:35 AM
            Last Updated: 21st September 2015 04:49 AM
            CHENNAI: Former Union finance minister P Chidambaram on Sunday denied having any financial link with Vasan Eye Care group that is being probed by the Enforcement Directorate for alleged money laundering. On September 17, Express had in a report ‘PC, Vasan Eye Care and `223-cr Black Money’ highlighted how crores of rupees were surreptitiously funneled into Vasan Eye Care through little-known chit fund company, JD Group, and other individuals and firms used as conduit to increase the stake of the former minister’s son Karti in Vasan.
            Denying the nexus, Chidambaram in a statement said: “Neither I nor my son nor any member of my family have any equity or investment or economic interest in the company (he did not name it) concerned.” Terming the allegations ridiculous and laughable, he said: “Let me say clearly that the entire report is false, malicious and part of a political campaign against members of the (erstwhile) UPA government or individuals belonging to the Congress party.”
            He claimed he was unaware of events concerning the IT department after the UPA demitted office in May 2014. (Then IT Commissioner  – Central, Chennai, M Srinivasa Rao, in a sworn affidavit before the CAT had alleged that he was being victimised for pursuing the Vasan scam and named Chidambaram among others).
            “I understand that the company has globally renowned investors who have invested in the company and an eminent Board of Directors. I am sure they will defend the company against the malicious allegations,” he said. He further advised the media to be responsible and truthful. “Carrying false and malicious reports without independent verification will certainly attract the provisions of law and I shall not hesitate to place the matter in the hands of my lawyers to take appropriate action under law,” he said.
            EDITOR RESPONDS: Express stands by every word of its report and is prepared to face legal action if it comes.

            Army destroyed papers on V.K. Singh’s military intel unit days before he retired - Josy Joseph.

            $
            0
            0
            Army destroyed papers on V.K. Singh’s military intel unit days before he retired
            Union Minister and former Army Chief Gen. V.K. Singh.
            TSD’s activities, funding under the scanner.
            When Union Minister General V. K. Singh was just days away from retiring as its chief in 2012, the Army destroyed dozens of documents on a military intelligence unit that he had created and whose activities and funding had attracted widespread scrutiny.
            According to documents perused by The Hindu, between May 22 and May 25, 2012, the Southern Army Command based in Pune moved very quickly to assemble two different boards of officers to carry out the complete destruction of all documents in its custody on Technical Services Division (TSD) — the controversial military intelligence unit Gen. Singh had set up in 2010. He retired on May 31, 2012 and later plunged into a political career with the BJP, and is now Minister of State for External Affairs in the Narendra Modi government.
            The destroyed files included payments of military intelligence funds by TSD for several months of 2010 and 2011. One file contains a detailed month-wise bank statement of the unit. Another is on the claims by Colonel Hunny Bakshi, who was heading TSD. It also contains a file on temporary duty and claims of Col. Bakshi, and a separate file on the claims of Lt. Col. Servesh Dhadwal, who, too, was part of TSD. One of the files deals with foreign visits, presumably of TSD officers.
            Also destroyed were a “statement of case for raising of Technical Services Division (TSD)”; details of the operational role, tasks, and charter of TSD; the channel of reporting of TSD; a request on policy for spending the secret fund; policy on usage of post-paid mobile connection; and some intelligence inputs.
            According to a report by The Indian Express on August 4, 2014, an internal inquiry by Lieutenant General Vinod Bhatia, the then Director General of Military Operations, found that TSD had misused secret service funds to buy mobile phone interceptors without authorisation, to fund activities to destabilise the Omar Abdullah government in Jammu and Kashmir, to fund an NGO that tried to scuttle the chances of General Bikram Singh succeeding Gen. V. K. Singh as Army chief, and for foreign travel of its officers on their personal passports
            The then Defence Secretary, S.K. Sharma, had refused to give his mandatory approval to the military intelligence budget, because of an abnormal increase in its spending, primarily caused by TSD activities.
            Against this background, the conduct of the Army in the days running up to Gen.V.K. Singh’s retirement raises serious questions of impropriety.
            More importantly, the actions could be in violation of Army regulations as well as the rules governing the classification and handling of classified documents.
            The entire data on TSD, including money spent on its supposed purported sources and reimbursement to its officers for travel and other activities, came into the custody of the Southern Army Command after TSD’s havildar-clerk, Sham Das D, mysteriously appeared in Kerala to hand over a CD containing all the details to an official of the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI). The DRI official claimed that he was contacted by sources based abroad, offering to sell highly sensitive military secrets.
            The DRI passed on the documents to a Major heading the detachment of the Southern Army Command liaison unit in Thiruvananthapuram. These files were written into a CD and sent to Pune, and further to the Army headquarters.
            On May 22, Brigadier V.K.K. Chavan, BGS (Intelligence) of the Southern Command “for GOC-in-C” (general officer commanding-in-chief), told Col. Anoop Kumar, the commanding officer of the liaison unit: “Request destroy all the letters mentioned in Para 1 above and all connected corres/docu related to this sensitive case at your HQ and also at 2/4 Det loc Trivendrum to eradicate any chances of leakage of info.”
            However, there seemed to have no such effort to reach out to the DRI to eradicate details that may have been in its custody.
            The very next day, Col. Kumar convened two different boards of officers: one for destroying all documents that were held in Thiruvananthapuram, and the other for documents in Pune. They were told to “assemble at place, date and time to be fixed by the presiding Offr to recommend and destroy” office copy of the southern command liaison unit letter dated May 17, and two letters dated May 18. The boards will also destroy “all connected corres/docu related to the sensitive case,” the order said.
            On May 25, the two boards met and decided on destroying all documents, including official communication between the liaison unit and the Southern Army Command. The documents destroyed by the two boards were identical and numbered up to 62 items by the boards. Most of them were documents from a TSD computer.
            On May 25, Col. Anoop Kumar commanding officer of the southern command liaison unit, approved the “destruction of documents as instructed” by the southern command. He quoted relevant paragraphs from the Regulations for the Army 1987 and CHCD-2001 (Classification and Handling of Classified Documents) to approve the decisions of the boards held on the same day.
            “However, it will be ensured that no documents are destroyed which may be of interest from historical, financial, statistical, instructional, legal or general points of view,” he said.
            Col. Kumar’s claim runs contrary to the fact that the entire set of documents were recovered from a soldier who was under a court of inquiry for leaking them and they were the most important exhibit against him. And that the documents related to the financial dealings of a unit that was already under scrutiny at the highest levels.
            http://m.thehindu.com/news/national/army-destroyed-papers-on-vk-singhs-military-intel-unit-days-before-he-retired/article7671302.ece

            Mao out, Confucius in -- Xi Jinping's vision for China

            $
            0
            0

            Xi Jinping's Trillion-Dollar Entourage

            9/18/2015 7:54AM     

            When Chinese President Xi Jinping heads to the U.S. for a state visit next week, he will travel with the CEOs of 15 of his country’s biggest companies, representing a combined market cap of nearly $1 trillion. http://www.wsj.com/video/xi-jinping-trillion-dollar-entourage/2279E01D-1D11-46FC-81E9-7D15E0B4C428.html

            Why China Is Turning Back to Confucius


            Jermey Page

            20 September 2015

            Beijing

            One Thursday morning in June, 200 senior officials crammed into an auditorium in the Communist Party’s top training academy to study a revolutionary idea at the heart of President Xi Jinping’s vision for China.

            They didn’t come to brush up on Marx, Lenin or Mao, staple fodder at the Central Party School since the 1950s. 

            Nor were they honing their grasp of the state-guided capitalism that defined the nation for the last 35 years.

            They came to hear Wang Jie, a professor of ancient Chinese philosophy and a figure in thecountry’s next ideological wave: a renaissance of the traditional culture the Communist Party once sought to destroy.

            For two hours, Prof. Wang says, he reeled off quotes from Confucius and other Chinese sages—whom the party long denounced as feudal relics—and urged his audience to incorporate traditional concepts of filial piety and moral rectitude into their personal and professional lives.

            “I’m getting hoarse,” Prof. Wang says over a cup of green tea after class. The previous day, he had lectured at the culture ministry and, the day before, at the commerce ministry. Mondaywould be the insurance regulator. “Xi Jinping’s words,” he says, “have lit a fuse.”

            Two years after outlining a “China Dream” to re-establish his nation as a great world power, Mr. Xi is backfilling his vision and seeking a fresh source of legitimacy by reinventing the party as inheritor and savior of a 5,000-year-old civilization. 

            The shift forms the backdrop forMr. Xi’s visit to the U.S. this weekand could shape China for years.

            Mr. Xi appears to be seeking to inoculate Chinese people against the spread of Western political ideals of individual freedom and democracy, part of what some political insiders say he views as a long-term contest of values and ideology with the U.S.

            The effort is gaining urgency now, as an economic slowdown and stock-market rout fray the social compact of the last three decadesin which citizens traded political freedom for rapid wealth creation.With Communist dogma and Chinese-style capitalism losing appeal, the party needs fresh ideas.

            “It’s like the prodigal son returning,” says Guo Yingjie, a University of Sydney Chinese-studies professor who wrote a book on Chinese cultural nationalism. “China has had more than a century of anti-traditionalism. Now they’re heading in the opposite direction.”

            In the last year, the party has publicly ordered its officials nationwide to attend lectures on Confucius and other classical Chinese thinkers, while tightening restrictions on Western influence in art, academia and religion. 

            Prof. Wang’s lectures joined the Party School’s core curriculum this year. Party officials didn’t respond to inquiries.

            The education ministry has decreed that traditional culture, including classical literature wiped from the curriculum a century ago, be taught in schools and feature prominently in university entrance exams.

            Schoolbooks, tightly controlled by the party, are being revised to include ancient texts promoting respect for elders and traditional moral values, say people involved in the process. Teachers are being retrained, as most never studied the texts.
            ‘National moral thinking’
            The goal isn’t just to encourage “national self-confidence” but to aid “personality development,” encourage altruism and instill“Chinese national moral thinking,” the ministry says in an emailed response to questions.

            The government is also plowing money into projects including a free online classical library, television series on China’s ancient history and a $250 million national center for traditional culture next to Beijing’s Olympic Stadium.

            Chinese officials have portrayed all this as part of a quest to identifyChina’s distinct “cultural genes”and to re-establish China not just as a strong nation, but also as a civilization with its own core values on a par with the West. 

            They also have suggested they see it as a new way to justify China’s authoritarian government—as an extension of an ancient political tradition—and to tackle corruption.

            “To solve China’s problems, we can only search in the land of China for the ways and means that suit it,” Mr. Xi in October told the party’s Politburo, its top 25 leaders, official media reported.“We need to fully make use of the great wisdom accumulated by the Chinese nation over the last 5,000 years.”

            The changes mark a U-turn for the party and come with significant dangers. By embracing classical thinkers it once demonized, the party risks undermining its authority among citizens who recall earlier ideological campaigns.

            It could also encourage Chinese citizens to explore other ideas the party has tried to wipe from history, such as those in organized religion, which the leadership still considers subversive. 

            Some scholars argue Confucianism is compatible with democracy; others want it to become a national religion or ideology.

            Mr. Xi continues to stress the importance of Marx and Mao, and of Deng Xiaoping, who launched China’s market reforms in 1979. 

            He has placed greater emphasis on Mao than his two predecessors and stepped up political education on Marxism in universities.

            But party insiders and political analysts say his longer-term agenda is to merge those ideas with elements of China’s ancient political culture to forge a new nationalist ideology.

            Central to the ideological pivot is Confucius.

            Thought to have lived in the sixth and fifth centuries B.C.,Confucius emphasized respect for elders, social ritual and personal moral virtue, including among leaders. 

            His ideas formed the basis of Chinese schooling and entry exams for the imperial bureaucracy for two millennia.

            But by the late 19th century, reformist intellectuals concluded that China’s weakness compared with Western powers was largely due to its conservative Confucian culture. 

            They felt it made society too hierarchical, stifling technological innovation and fostering bureaucratic corruption. 

            China needed to adopt Western science and political ideas, they argued.

            When the Communist Party took power in 1949, it banned ancestor worship and other Confucian rituals as “feudal practices” and taught party loyalty. 

            It renewed that onslaught in the 1966-1976 Cultural Revolution.

            Since market reforms began in 1979, the party has allowed a limited, uncoordinated cultural renaissance. 

            It has also carried out periodic“patriotic education” campaigns since crushing 1989 pro-democracy protests.

            Until recently, it has been wary of overtly embracing China’s ancient past amid opposition from older party members who still see Confucianism as a source of weakness. 

            In 2011, a Confucius statue was erected along Tiananmen Square but removed 100 days later following heated debate online and within the party.
            Confucius’ comeback
            Mr. Xi is taking a different tack, explicitly endorsing the cultural revival and formalizing it in schools and Party training—cherry-picking elements that suit his needs. 

            In September 2014, he became the first Communist leader to attend celebrations marking Confucius’ birthday. 

            He has complained that textbooks lack enough Chinese classical literature.

            People can follow Mr. Xi’s lead at places like the Confucius Academy in the southwestern city of Guiyang, a 75-acre complex local property developers built for 1.15 billion yuan ($185 million) and opened in 2013.

            Carved into a lush mountainside,it is dominated by a 30-foot-high Confucius statue. 

            Now managed and funded by the local government, it provides free lectures on Confucian philosophy to the public and facilities for Confucian scholars to live and work.

            Last year, the party opened a traditional-culture training center here for local officials, the first of its kind. It invited the Party School’s Prof. Wang to give the first lecture: “Traditional Culture and Official Ethics.”

            City and provincial bureaucrats have attended regular courses there ever since, local officials say.

            “We need to help them understand how to be an upright person—a moral person,” says Xu Qi, the complex’s party secretary. 

            “This is Uncle Xi’s demand,” he adds, using a popular nickname for the president, who praised the Confucius Academy last year.

            The complex has support from the central government, which funds a permanent exhibit on Confucius. Top leaders have visited, including party ideology chief Liu Yunshan.

            One recent Saturday, some 300 people, many in their 20s, attended a free three-hour lecture on the“Book of Changes,” one of the foundations of the feng shuisystem for aligning physical places and structures with the spiritual world. 

            Also viewed as a moral and political guide, it is among the Confucian canon’s five classics.

            Popular interest in traditional culture has grown in the past decade, influenced by Taiwanese and Hong Kong activists, experts say. 

            Many private kindergartens have children recite classical texts.Mainland scholars offer businessmen private classes in “national studies.”

            The Guiyang complex is among clear signs the party is trying to exploit and regulate that interest, says Sebastien Billioud, author of the book “The Sage and the People: The Confucian Revival in China.”

            “I think they’re using this as a test,” he says. “When everyone is cynical about everything, you need to find—or reinvent—some ideological ground somewhere. They need to invent something because growth is not going to be there forever.”

            One of the party’s concerns, analysts say, is that the Mao era’s iconoclasm followed by decades of unbridled materialism has led to a moral breakdown contributing to corruption and neglect of the elderly.

            Internationally, Mr. Xi is eager to project a more appealing image of China based on values, as well as strength, as it seeks a leadership role through initiatives including a plan for new East-West trade routes.
            ‘Mao doesn’t sell’
            “What we have just doesn’t sell”abroad, says Bai Tongdong, a philosophy professor at Shanghai’s Fudan University who has taught traditional culture to businessmen and officials. “Mao doesn’t sell. Communism doesn’t sell. But Confucianism and other traditional thinking can make sense.”

            Before Mr. Xi took power, some party members pushed a more-assertive revival of Maoist symbols and rhetoric, championed by former Politburo rising star Bo Xilai

            That movement weakened after Mr. Bo’s wife was convicted in 2012 of murdering a British businessman and Mr. Bo was jailed the following year for corruption and abuse of power.

            While Mr. Xi has borrowed from Mr. Bo’s leadership style, the ideological balance has tipped toward cultural revivalists,political insiders say. 

            Among them is Wang Qishan, China’s powerful anti-corruption chief, said by people who know him to be an avid reader in history and philosophy. 

            In April, he held an unusual meeting with three foreigners,including the American political thinker Francis Fukuyama,according to a transcript one participant posted online. Mr. Fukuyama says the transcript was accurate, declining to comment.

            During the meeting, Mr. Wang said he had read books on U.S. constitutional law, the Ming empire and England’s Tudors.“First, we need to make clear our own history and civilization,” he said. “China has outstanding DNA in its own culture.”

            He said China needed to study Confucius and Mencius, a sage of the same tradition. 

            Mr. Wang, who couldn’t be reached for comment, also expressed admiration for 15th-century Confucian scholar Wang Yangming.

            The education ministry has mandated that primary-school children be taught to understand Chinese festivals, honor their parents and “know they are part of the Chinese nation,” according to a notice issued last year.

            High schoolers should take up a traditional Chinese sport, do calligraphy and recite ancient poetry, the ministry said. 

            University students should study “important books of ancient Chinese thought and culture.”

            The China National Culture Art Center, a civic organization, has produced new traditional-culture textbooks used in pilot schemes in places such as the Beijing suburb of Tongzhou, where 51 schools hold daily traditional-culture classes, according to staff there.

            In a Tongzhou primary-school class recently, children recited from a textbook based on a sixth-century text. “Be devoted to your parents with all your strength, loyal to the throne with your life,”the book intones, and, “The husband leads; the wife follows.”

            “Most parents support it, but not 100%,” says Su Jinliang, director of the Tongzhou District Teacher Training Center. “Some of them feel: How can you bring back these things that were overthrown and criticized in the Cultural Revolution? They feel it’s more important to study things like English.”

            Aware of such sentiments, the party is treading cautiously. 

            Education authorities publicly criticized one Shanghai school for making 700 children kneel before their parents in what was deemed an excessive display of filial piety. 

            A Beijing school was scolded for going too far in teaching girls “traditional female virtue.”

            The Party School’s Prof. Wang says such problems will be ironed out as authorities clarify what is still considered “feudal.” 

            He has launched an app for party officials to share traditional-culture information and to question scholars about things they don’t understand. 

            He proposed a Confucius statue for the school’s grounds but hasn’t gotten approval. 

            “The time’s not quite right,” he says. 

            “Perhaps in a few years.”

            Write to Jeremy Page at 


            In Netaji files, story of INA colonel the British were wary of

            $
            0
            0

            In Netaji files, story of INA colonel the British were wary of

            • Snigdhendu Bhattacharya, Hindustan Times, Kolkata
            • Updated: Sep 21, 2015 08:23 IST

            Files relating to Indian freedom fighter Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose are displayed at the Police Museum in Kolkata. The West Bengal government has declassified 64 files related to Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose, which have been placed in the archives of the Kolkata police museum. (AFP PHOTO)



            In 1946, British intelligence officials were keeping a close watch on members of freedom fighter Subhas Chandra Bose’s Indian National Army (INA) who were being freed from jail as the empire’s decades-old grip over the subcontinent slackened. 
            But the British were concerned about one man whose release they felt could prompt a revival of the INA and spark unrest in Bengal, declassified files on Bose revealed. 
            Among the documents made public by the West Bengal government is a 1946 letter from the head of the army’s Eastern Command to a top spy chief in Delhi, requesting him to ensure that lieutenant colonel AC Chatterji was held under military captivity. 
            “This HQ is concerned at the probable return to Bengal in the near future of Lt Col AC Chatterji. This officer had very considerable influence in this province, and apart from his official status as Director of Public Health in Bengal before the war and his personal contacts with leaders of political strife, as appointed by Subhas Bose as the Governor Designate of the Liberated Countries,” a military officer wrote on February 5, 1946.
            With support from Imperialist Japan, the INA was aiming to overthrow the colonial rule in India and it fought against British and Commonwealth forces during campaigns in Burma, Imphal and Kohima during World War 2.

            ReadNetaji's brother sought Japan's help for rebellion against British
            “His (Chatterji’s) return at this juncture would revive excitement and enthusiasm in the INA, which at present is showing a tendency to switch to other forms of political propaganda such as cloth shortage, famine, release of political prisoners, and detenus and even defence of the Maharaja of Rewa,” the communication said.
            The letter came months after Netaji, as Bose is popularly known, reportedly died in an air crash in Taiwan on August 18, 1945 at the age of 48, though this has been disputed by members of his family and others.
            The officer wrote that Bengal intelligence officers were likely to ask the government of Bengal to pass orders for Chatterji’s detention, but the Eastern Command was unsure of the local administration’s response to such a proposal.

            ReadConfusion on Netaji's death, snooping on kin: What Bengal files say
            “As it is not known what the reaction of Govt of Bengal will be to such a request, the holding of this officer for two or three months in military custody would tide over a difficult period, at the end of which it is hoped the popularity of INA will have been further reduced,” the letter said.
            He suggested that Chatterji be kept in military custody outside India. In case this was not possible, he should be kept in military custody outside the jurisdiction of the Eastern Command for “as long as possible”, or at least till one month after the Bengal provincial election that was scheduled in late March 1946, the officer said.
            Bose appointed Chatterji as the minister of finance in the Provisional Government of Free India in February 1945. Chatterji evaded the British army in Saigon when his troops got stranded there following Japan’s sudden surrender to the Allied Powers, but was arrested after a few months.
            http://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/netaji-files-british-were-wary-of-bose-s-ina-confidante/article1-1391990.aspx

            Integral humanism to strengthen the weakest link -- Mohan Bhagwat. NaMo announce National Water Grid 24x7 water for every farm, every home in 6.2 l villages.

            $
            0
            0

            NaMo should do three things to be recognized in Bharatiya Itihaas: 1. National Water Grid reaching Himalayan waters to every farm, every home 2. Form Indian Ocean Community 3. Set a mission for IOC to reach the fair share of world GDP which the community had in 1 CE (pase Angus Maddison).


            Kalyanaraman

            ‘STRENGTHENING THE WEAKEST LINK WILL LEAD THE NATION TO DEVELOPMENT’

            Sunday, September 13, 2015
            Deendayalji was a reluctant politician. By nature, he was a thinker and organiser. Still, when he was told to take the responsibility of Bharatiya Jana Sangh, he tried his best to transform the nature of Bharatiya politics with his golden touch. This 25th September marks the beginning of his birth centenary year. On this occasion, RSS Sarsanghachalak Mohan Bhagwat had a frank conversation with Prafulla Ketkar, Editor, Organiser and Hitesh Shankar, Editor, Panchjanya about this committed swayamsevak and Pracharak, and relevance of his thinking propounded in the form of Integral Humanism. Excerpts:

            • Do you see reflection of Deendayalji’s political philosophy in the present day party politics? Is reality in tune with his vision?
            It is clearly evident that the nature and conduct of the present day politics is not in tune with the principles of Integral Humanism. Presently, politics is not for nation, not for the last man standing, but revolving around the interests of political parties. In rajniti (politics), raj that means power comes first, followed by niti (policy). When everyone thinks in the same way, everything revolves around ‘power’. Attaining power is an easy task, but policy making on certain principles is difficult. Society also thinks on the same lines, as people also evaluate political parties and politicians on electoral victory and defeat, and not what they do after victory or defeat. Victory and defeat depend on momentary waves, issues converted into calculations for votes. I am not saying it is because of the Constitutional provisions or political parties and the politicians are responsible for this, but this is a general melody. Even if a political party decides to work on ideological and policy lines, it gets defeated by people with selfish interests. In the absence of political maturity, parties tend to play with emotions for gaining power. Politics thus has become a race for attaining power.

            This political system, revolving around shortcuts for political power, has to be transformed and merely people sitting there cannot do that. Society has to do that. If voters come out of petty interests, forgoing individual, caste or community interest in larger national interest, only then will the situation change. Then, political parties will also have to follow the rule. If real political reforms take place, then things can change.

            Sometimes at critical junctures, when the situation becomes unbearable, people have voted for change, going beyond narrow interests. But this has to be more permanent than momentary.  Consistent and stable political maturity of the society can transform the system in line with Integral Humanism.
            • We are celebrating birth centenary year of Deendayalji. This year is also the golden jubilee year of his enunciation of Integral Humanism. The contexts have changed. How far do you see the relevance of his thinking in the present context?
            Context has definitely changed, but relevance of Integral Humanism will remain as the philosophical framework since it is based on eternal principles. Of course, principles have to be redefined in the present context. The strength of a society depends on the condition of the last man standing. Weakest link should be strengthened. This should be everybody’s concern. This will never change. But what kind of schemes should be devised to strengthen the weakest link so that it can change according to the context. This has to be done in the light of Integral Humanism.
            • When Integral Humanism was articulated, Socialism was the buzz word in Bharat. Now there is talk of liberalisation and globalisation. How far has the context changed and Integral Humanism re-contextualised?
            The real issue is not about which word or ideological framework is in fashion, but honesty and intention in implementing the principles that ideology espouses. Both, Socialism and Liberalism were propounded for the overall development of the humanity. After establishing Communist rule in Russia in 1917, the credibility of Socialism and Communism deteriorated. The same is true for Liberal Capitalism. The US is trying to dominate the world in the name of Liberal Principles, but in reality there are only selfish interests and no liberalism. There was never a struggle for ideological supremacy, but of selfish interests.

            The action verifies the principles and not the other way round. Tomorrow if Communists come to power and sincerely follow the principles of Communism after attaining power, then perhaps they will realise the limitations of Communist ideology and can make necessary amends. Both Socialism and Capitalism come and go in reaction to each other. Socialists become Capitalists and vice a versa. But no one says that it is the failure of Socialism or Capitalism as for them it is not an ideological question, but just of power and selfish interests. In Bharat, can we really address this issue of sincerity about ideological positions, nurture the political culture of being honest about our ideological principles and act accordingly, is the real question. Here Integral Humanism shows the way.

            • ‘Politics for Nation’ was at the basis of Deendayalji’s philosophy. Now there is a political change in the country and people have lot of expectations. Do you see this as an end of divisive and appeasement politics and beginning of a new era?
            I think I have addressed this in my answer to the first question. They will have to do it, but merely change of guard is not going to change the overall situation. If only one party tries to do that then there will always be doubt about how far they can go. If appeasement policies are followed, then how far they can go, I am not sure. Social awakening is also necessary for this. Ultimately, people get the government they deserve. Whether the society is ready to live and die for the nation is the real issue we need to address. Politicians will have to play their role, but society has to create the environment for as per that role. Both should go hand in hand. Slogans such as Garibi Hatao (eradicate poverty) will work until there is poverty. Once poverty is eradicated, once people are educated, then people in power will have to face more questions and challenges. So they may not like to face such a situation. Politicians should stay away from such temptation. They should facilitate all efforts to change the atmosphere towards national reconstruction.
            • What can be the practical approach to bring Integral Humanism in practice?
            Whenever we think of a Darshan or philosophy, we do not limit it only for Bharat, but extend it for the whole universe. Saintly figures like Dyaneshwar also said that the whole world should see the rise of own Dharma. Dr Hedgewar also proposed a resolution in the Congress session on ‘Complete Independence for Bharat to free the world from the capitalist imperialism’, unfortunately which was not accepted. This goal of Bharat as Nation should be clear to the common people of Bharat. Integral Humanism is the thought process to realise the true potential of Bharat. This can resolve many problems of the world and not only of Bharat. World over all ideologies are exploitative and suppressive. Deendayalji provided alternative to all of them through Integral Humanism, based on the concept of Dharma. Till date, we have experimented with the system on the basis of foreign ideologies. This has been the fashion of the day. Without completely discarding them, we need to accept their positive aspects and adding inputs from the soil of Bharat we need to think of constructing a new model. Some efforts are going on in this direction through the present dispensation. This darshan of a powerful and prosperous Bharat is for the welfare and peace all over the world, which is all the more relevant today. To realise this, we need to explore relevant policy experiments.
            • Though Bharat is primarily considered an agrarian nation, the plight of farmers is really sad. How can we find solutions to the problems of farmers in the light of philosophical direction shown by Deendayalji?
            Our inherent connectivity to Nature including agriculture and forests is the secret of our enriched life values and culture. We consider Nature an integral part of human life. We always lived as a unit in the world. 

            Presently also, Bharat is primarily agrarian. Farmers and Vanvasis are true carriers of Bharatiya interests and way of life. Even policy reforms should follow them. While doing this, one thing should be clear that industries should also be in tune with our conventional wisdom. Before British started ruling us, 200 years ago, we were leaders both in agricultural and industrial production. Many researchers have proved with data that we integrated these two ways of production for thousands of years. After British ruining this tradition, we are also thinking in a fragmented way where we think agrarian and industry in isolation and antithetical to each other. This is typical a western approach. We need not carry either agrarian or industrial tag, we need both. All the policies should be such that even poorest of the poor farmer should come out of poverty. Landless labourer should not be forced to commit suicide. At the same time, to be relevant in the world, we need to move ahead in the field of industry and technology. Deendayalji said, necessary industrialisation should take place without deforestation and maximum utilisation of barren land. Once we should assess our need of agricultural land so that we can fulfil our needs and also ensure some food supplies to the world. We need to evaluate the forest covers to ensure environmental balance. Then how much land to allocate for the industry, can also be calculated.

            In this regard, Man. Sudarshanji, former RSS Sarsanghachalak, did an exemplary experiment in Jharkhand. Calling a group of Scheduled Tribes, he presented a technology of iron making with a small tandoor like mould. Taking such examples into account, we need to find new ways and do new experiments. American and European conditions are different. Therefore their systems of planning are different. They cannot be uniformly applied everywhere. Whatever is good with them we will definitely learn, but primarily we need to devise technology and policies as per our needs. I firmly believe that the integration of our technology, knowledge and tradition of Bharat can give a system, which can ensure happiness and welfare of all.
            • In political science it is taught that pressure groups make democracy vibrant. Panditji believed that we need to take care of each other’s interests and move forward. How you see agitations such as demand for ‘One Rank, One Pension’ or reservations from the Integral humanist perspective?
            I do not think that Integral Humanism has negated the role of interest groups. Interest groups are formed because we have certain aspirations in democracy. At the same time, we should remember that through interest groups we should not strive to address those aspirations at the cost of others. We should have integral approach of welfare for all. It is sensible to realise that my interest lies in larger national interest. Government also has to be sensitive to these issues that there should not be any agitations for them. From the Integral Humanist perspective, the thinking that Government is different from us, should be altered. For instance, you need a fan on fast speed while I don’t want it at all, still we can both agree to have a fan on lesser speed. Harmonisation of interests is possible with this perspective. We can move forward with synchronisation and not struggle. My interest is in collective interest, should be realised by both, government and society. This balance is required from both sides. In fact, they are not two sides but just parts of the integral whole. Everyone should realise that suppression and oppression of one section by the other is against the interests of all. That should be the approach we need to inculcate.
            • There seems to be a contradiction here. On the one hand you are saying that society is not that matured but at the same time you expect this weakest link to perform a transformative role. Don’t you think this is more ideal than practical?
            This may look impractical and difficult, but this is the only way forward. There is no alternative. Government has to formulate effective policies and society should be organised with integral perspective. These complementary processes have to go hand in hand. Political parties will have to resolve that ‘yes we can do this’. We have not tried this so could not achieve it. If both, social and political elites, accept this and strive in the same direction we can achieve this. Sometimes we will have to pass through difficult situations but we have to continue in the desired direction. For instance, while taking a route march with drums, we face a situation where instruments cannot be played, but marching has to be on by finding the alternate route. Finally, we have to synchronise again. This may look a small example but this is the right example as it reflects the mindset. People in power and those working in society together can make the nation stronger, not with struggle. Integral Humanism is the most practical approach, we have to walk a bit with this approach to realise it on the ground. Unless we demonstrate it through adequate experimentation we cannot prove the practicability of the same.
            • There have been strains in the Centre-State relations. Sometimes in the name of special packages, while sometimes on identity issues. How can we find a way out to this problem through Integral Humanism?
            Emotional cordiality is the only solution to this. Both Centre and States are running governments for the Nation. Unitary states are constituents of the nation, they are not separate. As hands, legs or brain cannot claim that they are independent; similarly states are also integral parts of body politic. Until, this bonding is there, everything will be in line. Once special packages become a political tool and all other constituents feel that political blackmailing can take them forward then it leads to unhealthy competition. We need to logically justify and act for harmonious relations.
            • You said integrity and honesty are the main parameters. Do you see any such policy initiative, undertaken or suggestive, which is in tune with Integral Humanism?
            Reservation for socially backward classes is the right example in this regard. If we would have implemented this policy as envisaged by the Constitution makers instead of doing politics over it, then present situation would not have arrived. Since inception it has been politicised. We believe, form a committee of people genuinely concerned for the interest of the whole nation and committed for social equality, including some representatives from the society, they should decide which categories require reservation and for how long. The non-political committee like autonomous commissions should be the implementation authority; political authorities should supervise them for honesty and integrity.
            • Integral Humanism links education and education policy with both employability and sanskars (values for balanced life). Can you suggest some measures to reform the present education policy?
            First, if all we need to reform the prevalent thinking about education. All important education centres accept that education should be employable and at the same time it should produce good human beings. Post-Independence, we never thought of our own model of education based on our values. Whatever little suggestions were made, those were never implemented. Based on the integral approach, we need to completely transform the condition and direction of our education system. Education policy should focus on the making of good and motivated teachers, for which, interference of people in power in the field of education should reduce. Education should be based on truth; it should give confidence to the citizens. It should make us good human beings. I am not limiting education to what is provided in schools. Education should get conducive atmosphere in family and society as well. Deendayalji used to talk about society-centric education. We need to sincerely think and move forward in that direction.   http://organiser.org//Encyc/2015/9/21/%E2%80%98Strengthening-the-weakest-link-will-lead-the-nation-to-Development-.aspx

            Bronze Age revolution from 5th to 2nd millennium BCE and Indus Script Corpora as catalogus catalogorum of metalwork

            $
            0
            0


            Mirror: http://tinyurl.com/pokc7kt

            Archaeometallurgical investigations have presented an overview in space and time of the revolution brought about in Eurasia during the Bronze Age from 5th to 2nd millennium BCE. This revolution was dramatically catalysed by the invention of Indus Script writing which has now an evidence of about 7000 inscriptions constituting the Indus Script Corpora as veritable catalogus catalogorum of metalwork by Meluhha artisans and seafaring merchants. The decipherment of the script highlights the mediating role played by Meluhha artisans, merchants and scribes.

            Nissim Amzallag presents an overview of the evolution of the Bronze Age in Eurasia from 5th millennium to 2nd millennium BCE. CP Thornton spans the horizon of brass and bronze in prehistoric Southwest Asia. Omid Oudbashi et al review the evolution of Bronze Age in Ancient Iran and India. These scintillating archaeometallurgical excursuses have to be presented in the context of an intervening invention: invention of writing exemplified by Indus Script Corpora which now has about 7000 inscriptions. How did the artisans catalogue their metalwork competence? Two exquisite figures are presented in Omid Oudbashi et al. (2012): See Fig. 4 and Fig. 6 in their monograph (embedded). 

            These are Indus Script hieroglyphs. The themes are: tiger, goat, antelope, 'Master of Animals'. The theme of an antelope and aquatic birds are evidenced in the 5th millennium artefacts of Nahal Mishmar. This theme is also signified by Indus Script hieroglyphs.

            Nissim Amzallag's synthetic theory suggests two variables in archaeometallurgy: crucible metallurgy and furnace smelting. There are two other variables which are of equal importance. These are: 1) transition from arsenical bronze to tin-bronzes as naturally occurring arsenical copper was a scarce resource. The tin-bronze was a revolution which was mediated by Meluhha seafaring merchants using the world's large tin belt in Mekong river delta in the Far East. 2) cire perdue (lost-wax) technique of metalcasting which revolutionised the creation of bronze artefacts. Cire perdue metalcasting is exemplified by Dong Son bronze drums, dancing girl of Mohenjo-daro and Nahal Mishmar arsenical copper artefacts.

            Two pure tin ingots were (and later a third one) discovered from a shipwreck in Haifa, Israel, now held in the Museum of Ancient Art of the Municipality of Haifa (#8252); the three ingots displayed hieroglyphs of Indus Script.
            Tin ingots in the Museum of Ancient Art of the Municipality of Haifa, Israel (left #8251, right #8252). The ingots each bear two inscribed Cypro-Minoan markings. (Note: I have argued that the inscriptions were Meluhha hieroglyphs (Indus writing) denoting ranku 'tin' dhatu 'ore'. See: The Bronze Age Writing System of Sarasvati Hieroglyphics as Evidenced by Two “Rosetta Stones” By S. Kalyanaraman in: Journal of Indo-Judaic Studies Volume 1: Number 11 (2010), pp. 47-74.)


            ranku 'liquid measure'; ranku 'antelope' Rebus: ranku 'tin' (Santali) dhatu 'cross' Rebus: dhatu 'mineral ore' (Santali).
            •        Hieroglyph: ran:ku = liquid measure (Santali) Rebus: ran:ku = tin (Santali)
            •        Hieroglyph: ran:ku a species of deer; ran:kuka (Skt.)(CDIAL 10559).
            •        Hieroglyph:  u = cross (Telugu) Rebus: dhatu = mineral (Santali)
            •        Hindi. dhā ‘to send out, pour out, cast (metal)’ (CDIAL 6771).

            These two hieroglyphs were inscribed on two tin ingots discovered in port of Dor south of Haifa from an ancient shipwreck. 
            Inscribed tin ingot with a moulded head, from Haifa (Artzy, 1983: 53). (Michal Artzy, 1983, Arethusa of the Tin Ingot, Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research, BASOR 250, pp. 51-55)  An additional hieroglyph on this third tin ingot is : human face. Hieroglyph: mũhe ‘face’ (Santali) Rebus: mũh ‘ingot’ (Santali). mũh opening or hole (in a stove for stoking (Bi.); ingot (Santali) mũh metal ingot (Santali) mũhã̄ = the quantity of iron produced at one time in a native smelting furnace of the Kolhes; iron produced by the Kolhes and formed like a four-cornered piece a little pointed at each end; mūhā mẽṛhẽt = iron smelted by the Kolhes and formed into an equilateral lump a little pointed at each of four ends; kolhe tehen mẽṛhẽt ko mūhā akata = the Kolhes have to-day produced pig iron (Santali).

            I suggest that the intermediation by Indus Script Corpora was an effective documentation of the metalwork of the Bronze Age from 5th millennium to 2nd millennium BCE. The Nahal Mishmar hieroglyphs are also meaningful archaeometallurgically in relation to creation of hard alloys together with copper PLUS zinc, tin. The 'Master of Animals' citd by Omid Oudbashi is comparable to a Mohenjo-daro seal showing an orthographic composition which has been compared with hieroglyphs on the Gundestrup Cauldron.

            I, therefore, suggest that the invention of the Indus Script writing system facilitated the network across Eurasia together with the seafaring merchants bringing in tin along the Maritime Tin Route from Hanoi to Haifa. This story of Bharatam Janam has to be told.

            Rishi Visvamitra in Rigveda prays for the welfare of Bharatam Janam, lit. bharata folk, extraordinary metalworkers creating भरिताचें भांडें working with भरती (p. 603) [ bharatī ] a Composed of the metal भरत alloy of copper, pewter, tin. (Molesworth. Marathi). These were the Meluhha merchants celebrated in the Shu-ilishu cylinder seal.

            Akkadian. Cylinder seal Impression. Inscription records that it belongs to ‘S’u-ilis’u, Meluhha interpreter’, i.e., translator of the Meluhhan language (EME.BAL.ME.LUH.HA.KI) The Meluhhan being introduced carries an goat on his arm. Musee du Louvre. Ao 22 310, Collection De Clercq 3rd millennium BCE. The Meluhhan is accompanied by a lady carrying a kamaṇḍalu.
            Since he needed an interpreter, it is reasonably inferred that Meluhhan did not speak Akkadian.
            Antelope carried by the Meluhhan is a hieroglyph: mlekh ‘goat’ (Br.); mr̤eka (Te.); mēṭam (Ta.); meṣam (Skt.) Thus, the goat conveys the message that the carrier is a Meluhha speaker. A phonetic determinant.mrr̤eka, mlekh ‘goat’; Rebus: melukkha Br. mēḻẖ ‘goat’. Te. mr̤eka (DEDR 5087)  meluh.h.a

            After Fig. 4 in Omid Oudbashi et al. 2012 opcit. Two bronze artefacts from Marlik gravs, Left: a spouted vessel decorated with lion reliefs, Right: fantastic statue of a deer (Negahban, 1999)



            After Fig. 6 in Omid Oudbashi et al. 2012 opcit. a) A 'Master of Animals' standard from Luristan, with detached man head held by 4 animals. b) The upper part of an Animal Headed Pin, Luristan that shows combination of two goats and a felidae. Falakolaflak Museum, Khorramabad, Iran. Photo: O. Oudbashi.

            See: C.P. Thornton. 2007 “Of brass and bronze in prehistoric Southwest Asia.”   In (S. La Niece, D. Hook, & P. Craddock, eds.) Metals and Mines: Studies in Archaeometallurgy.  London: Archetype Publications, pp. 123-135. http://www.cpthornton.info/Thornton2007-BrassBronze.pdf?attredirects=0

            See: http://www.ajaonline.org/sites/default/files/AJA1134Amzallag_0.pdf  Nissim Amzallag, From metallurgy to bronze age civilizations: the synthetic theory, in: American Journal of Archaeology 113 (2009). 497-519. This article notes the status of smelter as civilizing hero in ancient mythologies and distinguishes betwen crucible metallurgy and furnace smelting. Amzallag proposes a synthetic theory based on spread of furnace metallurgy from the southern Levant which generated a wide network linking Bronze Age societies.

            https://www.scribd.com/doc/282253832/Nissim-Amzallag-2009-From-metallurgy-to-bronze-age-civilizations-the-synthetic-theory-in-AJA-113-2009-497-519

            [Furnace metallurgy in th fifth millennium BCE (drawing by P. Jean-Baptiste) After Fig. 2 in Amzallag opcit.]

            [Furnace metallurgy in th fourth millennium BCE (drawing by P. Jean-Baptiste) After Fig. 3 in Amzallag opcit.]

            [Furnace metallurgy in the third millennium BCE (drawing by P. Jean-Baptiste) After Fig. 4 in Amzallag opcit.]

            [Furnace metallurgy in the second millennium BCE (drawing by P. Jean-Baptiste) After Fig. 5 in Amzallag opcit.]



            https://www.scribd.com/doc/155936341/Bronze-in-Archaeology-a-Review-of-the-Archaeometallurgy-of-Bronze-in-Ancient-Iran-1980-Omid-Oudbashi-S-Mohammadamin-Emami-and-Parviz-Davami

            Omid Oudbashi, S. Mohammadamin Emami and Parviz Davami (2012). Bronze in Archaeology: A Review of the Archaeometallurgy of Bronze in Ancient Iran, Copper Alloys - Early Applications and Current Performance -Enhancing Processes, Dr. Luca Collini (Ed.), ISBN: 978-953-51-0160-4, InTech, Available from:
            http://www.intechopen.com/books/copper-alloys-early-applications-and-current-performance-enhancingprocesses/bronze-in-archaeology-a-review-on-archaeometallurgy-of-bronze-in-ancient-iran

            https://www.scribd.com/doc/282254827/Of-brass-and-bronze-in-prehistoric-Southwest-Asia-Christopher-P-Thornton-2007


            About a New Book:

            Mekong Ganga Axis edited by Pankaj Mittal DK Printworld 2015

            India has a fascinating history of cultural relationship with South-East Asia, spanning across more than the last two millennia, mainly with the spread of Buddhism and Hinduism, deeply impacting the cultural, religious and social lives of people in countries such as Cambodia, Indonesia, Laos, South Korea, Sri Lanka, Thailand and Vietnam. The Hindu-Buddhist monuments in South-East Asia stand testimony of this peaceful and mutually beneficial interaction. The contents of this book — Mekong-Ganga Axis — centre around India's association with most of the countries of the region, especially those on either side of the Mekong River.
            Most of the South-East Asian countries were influenced by more than two foreign cultures, though they have an indigenous culture. The Chinese and Indian cultures had impacted them the most, in addition to the European influence. However, only India’s impact was peaceful and, to a great extent, non-political. This paved the way for many developments in architecture, religious engagements, interculturality, syncretism of cultures, inter-literariness, composite literary cultures, religious arts, trade relations and so on.
            This book thus critically engages one to all these topics and more, and recalls India's glorious relationship of the forgone era with these countries, showcasing somewhat a similar kind of cultural/religious affinity from South China to India. And two great rivers, Mekong and Ganga, are witness to it. It also reinstates the criticality of India to be engaged with these countries at present because of the compulsions of a globalized world.
            Book Contents
            Foreword — Asha Kadyan
            Preface — Kapil Kapoor
            Conference Rationale — Kapil Kapoor
            Keynote Address — J.C. Sharma
            Inaugural Address — Lord Diljit Rana
            Acknowledgement — Editors
            1. The Role of Classical Indian Theatre in Spreading the Cultural Influence of India to South-East Asia
            – M. Krzysztof Byrski
            2. Concepts for the Revival of Traditional Links between India and South-East-East Asia for Global Leadership
            — Bal Ram Singh
            3. Cultural Heritage of Champa Kingdom in Central Vietnam: Some Evidences of the Interaction of the Trade and the Religion between India and Vietnam in the Past
            – Do Thu Ha
            4. Colonial, Modern, or Traditional? How to Read the Indo-Saracenic Architecture of South and South-East Asia
            – Hawon Ku
            5. Cultural Relationship between India and South-East Asia
            – Tran Phuoc Phuong Thao
            6. Indian Trade Textiles for Thai Market
            – Prapassorn Posrithong
            7. Hindu–Buddhist Syncretism in the Trans-Himalaya and South-East Asia: An Attempt at a Comparative Study of Religious Literature of Tibet and Bali
            – Alexander Zorin
            8. Beyond the Horizon of Culture-Spectrum
            – Kakali Ghoshal
            9. Far from the Mother’s Womb
            – Madhu Kapoor
            10. Thailand and Karnataka
            – G Kavyashree and P. Nagabhushanagoud
            11. Global Ancient India and Suvarnabhumi (South-East Asia): A Historical Perspective
            – Shiva G. Bajpai
            12. The Interconnection between India and South-East Asia Especially Indonesia in Art, Culture and Architecture
            – Komang Santhi Arsa
            13. “Interculturality” in South Asia: With Special Reference to Dissemination of Ramakatha
            – Avadhesh Kumar Singh
            14. Syncretism of the Cultures of India with the Cultures of South and South-East Asia
            – S. Ram Mohan
            15. Understanding South Asia-South-East Asia Cultural Contacts: An Alternative Perspective
            – T.S. Satyanath
            16. Religious Art in Cambodia: Shaivism, Vaishnavism and Buddhism
            – Rajnish Kumar Mishra
            17. Buddhist Engagement in South-East Asia: A Case Study of Vietnam
            – Anita Sharma
            18. Shaivism in Ancient Cambodia as Revealed from Sdok Kak Thom Inscription
            – Bachchan Kumar
            19. Ramman Pattar Performance in the Central Himalaya and Its Parallels in the Balanese and Javanese Theatre
            – D.R. Purohit
            20. Reflection of Indian Culture in the Kambuja Empire of South-East Asia
            – Swati Raikhy
            21. Cultural Relationship between India and Thailand
            – Shyam Sunder Sharma
            22. Reinventing the Connectedness: Implications for India in Mainland South-East Asia
            – Sarita Dash
            23. Dakshini-Purvi Asia ke Deshon mein Ram ka Prabhava
            – Pawan Kumar
            24. Bharatiya Sanskriti Tatha Ramayana ka Thailand par Prabhava
            – Manju Bala
            Contributors

            Index


            Viewing all 11214 articles
            Browse latest View live


            <script src="https://jsc.adskeeper.com/r/s/rssing.com.1596347.js" async> </script>