Quantcast
Channel: Bharatkalyan97
Viewing all 11232 articles
Browse latest View live

NaMo, cancel all private mining leases of placer sands. They are nation's wealth of rare earths and thorium vital for nation's nuclear program.

$
0
0

NaMo,

Cancel all MoUs with ALL PRIVATE PARTIES for exploitation of placer sands in Andhra Pradesh coastline and all along the coastline of Bharatam.

The rare earths and thorium are so vital for the nation's nuclear program that the protection of the placer sand reserves should be entrused to a Joint Army Command, forthwith.

The coastal placer sands contain the riches source of Rare Earths including Monazite (which is the main source of thorium for the nation's thorium-based nuclear programme). The mining of these sands is a sacred responsibility of the Govt. of India and SHOULD BE STRICTLY CONTROLLED AND SAFEGUARDED by a JOINT ARMY COMMAND. Only Indian Rare Earths Limited (IREL) a Public Sector Undertaking under Dept. of Atomic Energy should be the licensed agency to mine these sands and conserve the nation's resources for the nation's developmental projects. Any involvement of private parties like Toyota Tsusho for dealing with rare earths should be strictly monitored to ensure that deposits of rare earths and thorium deposits are completely under the control of the Govt. of India for the beneficial use of projects initiated by India. See: http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2014-09-03/news/53522845_1_india-and-japan-irel-odisha-sand-complex India, Japan hope to revive earlier agreement to trade in rare earth minerals

So, NaMo, ban private mining of placer sands IMMEDIATELY and entrust the safeguarding of placer sand minerals to Indian Rare Earths Limited (IREL) of Dept. of Atomic Energy.

Also, cancel the DAE Notification of 18 January 2006 opening up atomic minerals under Open General Licence facilitating the ongoing loot of atomic minerals by private parties.

S. Kalyanaraman

Rameshwaram Ramasetu Protection Movement

December 16, 2014

A P Mineral Development Corporation 

Excerpt:
I. Introduction
The Andhra Pradesh Mineral Development Corporation Ltd., was incorporated on 24th Feb., 1961 and registered under the Companies Act 1956 with an authorised capital of Rs.50 lakhs with full participation by Government of Andhra Pradesh.  The Authorised capital is increased, from time to time, to Rs. 10 Crores.  The paid up capital is Rs. 630.62 Lakhs.
The Objectives of the Corporation are:
  • Development of mineral resources including exploration, exploitation, and beneficiation.
  • Development of mineral industry with private participation.
  • Identification of the Best Technology and Investment for development of Mineral Resources.
II.        MANPOWER
The Corporation is presently having total manpower of 360 and the annual budget towards salary & wages is about Rs. 6.50 crores.
III.ON GOING PROJECTS ...

.Exploitation of Heavy Mineral Beach Sands
The Corporation already filed applications for grant of MLs in Visakhapatnam, Vizianagaram and Srikakulam Districts covering 156.59 sq.kms.      M/s Bothli trade AG, Switzerland based company evinced interest to establish Titanium Sponge and Titanium Metal Industry with an investment of about of Rs.4,000 crores.   The GoAP entered into an MOU with M/s Bothli Trade AG on 18-4-2006 covering an extent of 82.37 sq.kms. and consequently the Corporation entered into an agreement on 24-08-2006 with M/s Bothli.   The Corporation proposes to consider additional extent of 33.33 Sq.Kms. subject to approval of GoAP.
 M/s V.V.Mineral, Chennai also evinced interest to form Joint Venture with  the Corporation for mining and mineral separation of Heavy Mineral Beach Sands and also establishment of Value added unit based on the deposits  in Srikakulam District over an extent of 14.78 sq.kms.   Accordingly the Corporation entered into an agreement with M/s V.V.Minerals Pvt.Ltd., on 30-12-2006 as approved by the GoAP.

Survey on to find thorium in coastal Andhra Pradesh



According to a senior official at AMDER, the department is surveying deposits of the two rare atomic minerals across the country with the help of its teams located at its seven regional centres, including Hyderabad. "This year, we recently started the process of identifying uranium and thorium reserves in the coastal districts of AP. The team is presently touring Srikakulam, Visakhapatnam and Vizianagaram," said the AMDER official on condition of anonymity. 

Thorium, a radioactive metal discovered in 1828 by Swedish chemist Jons Jakob Berzelius, is found in small amounts in most rocks and soils, especially beach sand. According to GV Ramesh of Nuclear Power Corporation of India Limited (NPCIL), who is the chief project engineer of the proposed Kovvada nuclear plant in Srikakulam, research is going on to ascertain the viability of setting up thorium-fueled power plants. 

"India accounts for over 32% of the estimated global thorium reserves of 63,55,000 tonnes and that too of high quality. Keeping this in mind, it may be best for India to explore thorium-fueled power generation in the coming years. However, currently no country in the world has thorium-fueled power plants as its viability is yet to be proved," Ramesh told TOI. 

Meanwhile, P Venkata Lakshmi Narayana, assistant professor, department of nuclear physics, Andhra University, said that thorium could emerge as the next generation fuel for nuclear plants across the globe.

The damage done by an illegal notification issued by DAE in January 2006 after the Indo-US nuke deal between Manmohan and Bush is obvious from the following reports.

Andhra Pradesh placer sands contain the highest reserves of monazite (thorium) deposits in the country accounting for 3.72 mt out of 11.93 mt of the country. These placer sands are mined by private parties under leases granted by the State Government.

All the atomic mineral reserves should be conserved and protected by DAE and national security agencies of Govt of India. As needed, the protection of these reserves should be entrusted to a Joint Army Command.

NaMo government should

1. Immediately cancel this notification so that atomic minerals are NO LONGER kept under Open General Licence for exploitation and export.

2. Immediaely cancel all MOUs and related leases granted to private parties to exploit mineral placer sands and entrust the responsibility for mining atomic-mineral containing placer sands only to Indian Rare Earths Limited, a Public Sector Unit operating under Dept. of Atomic Energy.

http://pib.nic.in/newsite/PrintRelease.aspx?relid=112033

Press Information Bureau 

Government of India
Department of Atomic Energy

Deposits of Rare Earths 


                 Atomic Minerals Directorate for Exploration and Research (AMD), a constitute unit of Department of Atomic Energy (DAE) has estimated the presence of 11.93 million tonnes of monazite resources in the beach sand mineral placer deposits along the coastal tracts of India. Monazite in general, contains about 55 – 60% total Rare Earth Oxide.   The state-wise resources of in situ monazite established by AMD so far are as follows:

State
Monazite
(Million tonne)
Odisha
2.41
Andhra Pradesh
3.72
Tamil Nadu
2.46
Kerala
1.90
West Bengal
1.22
Jharkhand
0.22
Total
11.93

            The resources of xenotime, another rare-earth bearing mineral, are negligible in India.  AMD has established about 2000 tonnes of xenotime-bearing heavy mineral concentrate containing 2% xenotime in the riverine heavy mineral placer deposits of Chhattisgarh and Jharkhand.
                        Monazite is a mineral mainly containing rare earths and thorium-a prescribed substance to be handled by the Department of Atomic Energy (DAE). Accordingly, Indian Rare Earths Ltd. (IREL) wholly owned by the Govt. of India, under the administrative control of the Dept. of Atomic Energy (DAE) utilises monazite mainly for production of rare earth compounds, and thorium, as needed in the Department of Atomic Energy.
           
              This information was given by the Minister of State in the Ministry of Personnel, PG & Pensions and in the Prime Minister’s Office Dr. Jitendra Singh in a written reply in the Rajya Sabha today.

Kalyanaraman

See http://bharatkalyan97.blogspot.in/2012/11/dae-cancel-and-withdraw-illegal.html

DAE notification S.O. 61(E) of 18 January 2006, gazetted on 20 Jan. 2006 which revised the list of Prescribed substances, Prescribed equipment and Technology IS ILLEGAL.
Parliament has not approved the changes proposed in the list of Atomic Minerals in First Schedule of the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957.
It was illegal to have issued and gazetted the DAE notification of 2006 WITHOUT FIRST ensuring approval of the Parliament to the proposed changes of the prescribed substances declared as Atomic Minerals under the Act.
DAE should IMMEDIATELY notify cancellation and withdrawal of the notification and prosecute action against those who have acted in contravention of the Rule of Law enunciated in the Act.
“Under the Ilmenite (Control of Export) Order, 1953, licences were issued for the export of ilmenite subject to the condition that samples of ilmenite to be exported had been examined and certified to contain less than 0.1 per cent of monazite to prevent clandestine export of monazite. This limit was subsequently enhanced to 0.25 per cent of monazite. At present, the export consignments of ilmenite are examined and certified by AMD. This was reviewed by DAE and it was found essential to retain monazite testing, and such testing continues to be carried out by AMD on behalf of AERB under the Atomic Energy (Radiation Protection) Rules, 2004. Many countries refuse to use any ilmenite containing more than 75 parts per million (ppm) of uranium and thorium, as it poses an environmental threat when used for the production of value added materials. Hence, analysis of ilmenite for its monazite content by AMD is a service that would be needed by exporters, and could be continued as a charged service to be availed of on a voluntary basis.” [National Mineral Policy, Report of the High Level Committee, Planning Commission 2006].
If none of these substances contain thorium and since it is possible to export them under the OGL, one may be reasonably safe in assuming that any form of the above testing is not being done. If so, the Government must decide whether the inadvertent export of radioactive thorium/uranium in undetermined and possibly in larger than trace quantities are in violation of the very same control regimes they have wholeheartedly endorsed against better judgment, or whether the OGL somehow allows for the legal trafficking of radioactive substances.
Now, it should be clear that the DAE notification of January 2006 has created a situation where AERB certification for transport/shipment of placer sands containing ATOMIC MINERALS was not enforced. DAE has a lot to answer for in conserving, safeguarding the nation's rare earth mineral wealth and protecting against shipments/transport of consignments with radioactive substances.
All the delisted minerals must be reinstated as prescribed substances.
Checks and balances put in place to safeguard national wealth must be clearly enunciated and available in the public domain.
Export quotas for all these minerals must be established on scientific and technological grounds and form a demonstrable part of the development plan.
An impetus and new lease on life must be given to IREL and other agencies to fulfil the tar-gets required if the thorium programme is to be saved from extinction.
DAE should reiterate the instructions banning the mining of ATOMIC MINERAL containing placer sands, transport and export of such minerals by private agencies. The IREL should be strengthened with adequate resources to ensure enforcement of Govt. policies to safeguard, protect and conserve the Minerals of National Importance so vital for the nation's energy programmes and the nation's strategic security imperative.
Atomic minerals include thorium, uranium monazite, zircon,ilmenite, rutile and leucoxene (Part B of First Schedule of the Act 1957)

It is the responsibility of the State to safeguard and protect these atomic minerals.

Please see First Schedule Part B. The prescribed substances list has NOT been amended by Parliament as of May 2012.
http://mines.nic.in/writereaddata/Filelinks/e342d686_MMDR%20Act%201957.pdf (embedded)

This means that DAE notification S.O. 61(E) of 18 January 2006, gazetted on 20 Jan. 2006 which revised the list of Prescribed substances, Prescribed equipment and Technology IS ILLEGAL. The notification could have taken effect only if the Parliament amended the Act (1957). Parliament has NOT amended the Act as of May 2012. Hence, the notification is NULL AND VOID. All acts done under this illegal notification have no authority in law.

Embedded is a letter written by DAE to Federation of Indian Mineral Industries. (DAE letter dated 02.02.2006 - Delisting of minerals)

Atomic minerals include thorium, uranium monazite, zircon,ilmenite, rutile and leucoxene (Part B of First Schedule of the Act 1957). Hence Atomic Energy Regulatory Board certificate is mandatory under law for all these minerals listed in First Schedule Part B of the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 Issued by CONTROLLER – GENERAL, INDIAN BUREAU OF MINES, NAGPUR (August 2012).

Kalyanaraman



http://www.docstoc.com/docs/135339895/mines-and-minerals-_development-and-regulation_-act_-1957-_No-67-of-1957_-as-amended-upto-10th-may_-2012 mines and minerals _development and regulation_ act_ 1957 _No. 67 of 1957_ as amended upto 10th may_ 2012 
http://www.docstoc.com/docs/135348893/fdipolicyformining-titanium-bearing-minerals-and-ores-2008 fdipolicyformining titanium bearing minerals and ores 2008 
Notification of October 19, 2012 by DAE perpetuates the illegality by not recognising the fact the prescribed substances under the Act 1957 continues to include ilmenite,zircon, leucoxine, rutile etc. The Press Note continues continue to cite the illegal DAE notification of 20 Jan. 2006 since the Parliament has NOT approved the changes proposed in DAE notification of Part B Atomic Minerals in First Schedule of the Act 1957.http://www.docstoc.com/docs/135349721/exportofmonazitefromindiathefactsoct19_2012exportofmonazitefromindiathefactsoct.19_2012
Exploitation of Heavy Mineral Beach Sand
The Corporation filed applications for grant of MLs in Vishakhapatnam, Vizianagaram and Srikakulam Districts covering 156.59 sq.kms

M/s. Bothli Trade AG, Switzerland based company evinced interest to establish Titanium Sponge and Titanium Metal Industry with an investment of about of Rs. 4,000 crores. The GoAP entered into an MOU with M/s. Bothli Trade AG on 18.04.2006 covering an extent of 82.37 sq. kms and consequently the Corporation entered into an agreement on 24.08.2006 with M/s. Bothli. The Corporation proposes to consider additional extent of 33.33 sq. kms subject to approval of GoAP.

M/s. VV Minerals, Chennai also evinced interest to form Joint Venture with the Corporation for mining and mineral separation of Heavy Mineral Beach Sands at a Project outlay of Rs. 75 crores and also establishment of value added unit based on the deposits at a Project outlay of Rs. 1,500 crores in Srikakulam District over an extent of 14.78 sq. kms. Accordingly the Corporation entered into an agreement with M/s. V.V. Minerals Pvt. Ltd., on 30.12.2006 as approved by the GoAP.
http://www.apmdc.ap.gov.in/proposed%20new%203.html

March 5 2007

Vizag sand to build planes 

The sands which beach-goers of the State casually kick around contain precious ilmenite, the most important source of titanium which is used to build aircraft and rockets. This vast reserve will now be exploited by the State. 

Experts have pointed out that the entire 950-km east coast, right from Srikakulam bordering Orissa in the north to Nellore near Tamil Nadu in the south, and the stretch between Kakinada and Itchapuram is rich in rare minerals such as ilmenite, rutile, garnet, monazite, silliminate, and zircon. “Ilmenite bears titanium that is used to make aircraft, artillery guns and other defence equipment because it is lightweight and non-corrosive,” said Prof. C. Kasipathi of the department of geology in Andhra University. 

Titanium remains intact in any kind of environment, another reason for its use in defence equipment. “There are huge reserves of ilmenite in the beach sands of north coastal Andhra,” he said. Titanium, a strong aluminium-like metal that is light weight and non-corrosive, can withstand high temperatures and melts only at 1,800º Centigrade and is twice as strong as steel. Titanium alloys are used in high tech aircraft parts, missiles, space vehicles and even in surgical implants. 

Of the total 375 million tonnes of ilmenite reserves across the country, the State has the largest quantum of 116 million tonnes which has been unexploited so far. There is huge demand for such minerals in the international markets as they are rare. India stands third in the quantity of ilmenite reserves but is only sixth in mining and production. “There are several reasons for this, including lack of political will,” said Mr Kasipathi. 

Now things are changing. The AP Mineral Development Corporation has recently signed three MoUs to mine these rare minerals by spending Rs 7,500 crores. APMDC would be getting 26 per cent equity in all the three ventures without any investment. The first MoU with Stork Handlges of Austria and Bothli Trades AG of Switzerland allows the companies to mine 8,237 hectares at Lawsons Bay, Bheemili, Konada, Kandivalasa and Koyyam in Visakhapatnam and Vizianagaram districts, and Bendi, Baruva and Donkur in Srikakulam district. 

This is expected to provide jobs to around 20,000 people in north coastal Andhra districts. Another MoU was signed with VV Minerals, which is being allotted 1,500 hectares in Srikakulam district. The third one was signed with Trimax, another local agency, to which 10,000 hectares is being allocated at Kalingapatnam and Bavanampadu. The Austrian and Switzerland firms will be extracting 10 lakh tonnes of ilmenite per year. 

“Only MoUs have been signed and we are awaiting statutory clearances,” said D. Radhakrishna, project officer of APMDC. In Hyderabad, State mining minister P. Sabita Indra Reddy said, “They agreed to establish the titanium producing units apart from mining in the State. It will be first unit in the country.” “Misra Dhathu Nigam Limited (Midhani) which getting large quantities of titanium from other countries is assured top priority supply,” the minister said. But there are problems like clearance from the Union environment ministry. The endangered marine turtle is the cause of worry. 

“If the companies mine across the fast lane, that is the upper layer of sand, the turtles will be forced to change their egg-laying places,” said marine biologist Dr Duggaraju Srinivasa Rao. “But as per studies the Orissa coast is the favoured destination for the turtles.” The State government on behalf of the companies has assured that all necessary precautions will be taken so that turtles and their egg laying sites are kept safe by providing passage to the amphibians. “We have informed the Centre that the foreign companies will take turtle protection measures,” the mines minister said. 

Source: Deccan.comhttp://www.andhranews.com/ftopic2556.htmlExploitation of Heavy Mineral Beach Sands
The Corporation filed applications for grant of MLs in Vishakhapatnam , Vizianagaram and Srikakulam Districts covering 156.59 sq.kms

M/s. Bothli Trade AG, Switzerland based company evinced interest to establish Titanium Sponge and Titanium Metal Industry with an investment of about of Rs. 4,000 crores. The GoAP entered into an MOU with M/s. Bothli Trade AG on 18.04.2006 covering an extent of 82.37 sq. kms and consequently the Corporation entered into an agreement on 24.08.2006 with M/s. Bothli. The Corporation proposes to consider additional extent of 33.33 sq. kms subject to approval of GoAP.
M/s. VV Minerals, Chennai also evinced interest to form Joint Venture with the Corporation for mining and mineral separation of Heavy Mineral Beach Sands at a Project outlay of Rs. 75 crores and also establishment of value added unit based on the deposits at a Project outlay of Rs. 1,500 crores in Srikakulam District over an extent of 14.78 sq. kms. Accordingly the Corporation entered into an agreement with M/s. V.V. Minerals Pvt. Ltd., on 30.12.2006 as approved by the GoAP.
http://www.aponline.gov.in/Quick%20Links/Departments/Industries%20and%20Commerce/A%20P%20Mineral%20Development%20Corporation/About/index_old.html

Coastline scarred


DC | U. Sudhakar Reddy | April 04, 2014, 06.04 am ISTPic for representation purpose
Pic for representation purpose
Hyderabad: The North Andhra coast is being rapidly denuded of its heavy mineral sand (HMS) by politicians and companies working hand in glove.
Praveen Prakash, the then chairman of AP Mineral Development Corporation, had  written to the state government on February 23, 2011, to cancel the joint venture agreement with Bothli Trade AG citing violations of the agreement. But the state government took no action in this regard. Instead, Mr Prakash was transferred out of the APMDC.
Mr Prakash had pointed out that in some cases there are no competitive bids, and listed 13 specific agreements including with Jindal, Anrak, Trimex and Bothli Trade AG (now in question).He  highlighted how rules have been flouted and estimated that APMDC would earn an additional Rs 11,049 crore if the contracts are renegotiated.
Civic activist E.A.S. Sarma has also been raising objections for the past five years, but consecutive governments have stuck to the agreements and given approvals and licences, flouting the rules.  
Currently, the state has granted three mining leases for these heavy mineral deposits over 809 hectares, and two prospecting licences over 4,000 hectares to different companies.
APMDC has applied for mining leases covering 15,659 hectares and entered  into an MoU with Bothli Trade AG, Switzerland, to establish a heavy mineral separation plant as well as 2,50,000 MTs of value-added products with an investment of about Rs 4,600 crore.
APMDC also signed a joint venture agreement with VV Minerals, a Chennai-based company for Ilmenite minerals namely Synthetic Rutile and Titanium Slag, with  an estimated outlay of Rs 1,800 to Rs 2,000 crore. APMDC is awaiting approval from the Centre to grant the mining leases which in turn will be sub-leased to the above SPV.
APMDC vice-chairman and MD T.R.K. Rao said, “Bothli failed to get  approvals from India Bureau of Mines and Atomic mineral division. So  no activity has started. They haven’t mined the sand. They didn’t have  environmental clearance. There was a delay of at least six years due to the elaborate procedures. As this delay is a violation of the MoU, the  then chairman Mr Praveen Prakash had written to the government for  cancellation of the agreement. Bothli got only prior approval for  prospective licensing for half of the area with which they have got  agreement.”
At present, two companies established by Transworld  Garnets Pvt Ltd and Beach Minerals Company Andhra Pvt, separate  garnet from the beach sand. At the time the licence was granted, Iimenite was a restricted mineral and they were not permitted to extract Iimenite.  
Subsequently, the Government of India liberalised the policy of granting of leases for Iimenite and hence M/s Transworld Garnets Pvt Ltd and  M/s Beach Minerals Company Andhra Pvt Ltd were entitled to extract  Iimenite and requested that Iimenite be included as an additional  mineral, which is under consideration of the government.
Mr Sarma said, “The irregularity here is that there so many minerals  apart from limenite are being extracted. The companies that get licence for extracting one mineral exploit everything available.”
He warned that these sand mining projects will have “serious adverse implications for the coastal environment of the northern coastline of the state. Sand mining is a prohibited activity in  Coastal Regulation Zone.
The Andhra Pradesh State Government should have  studied the track record of sand mining in Maharashtra, Goa, Kerala  and Tamil Nadu before hastily signing MoUs with private companies, that too, through questionable procedures of selection.
“There has been an attempt on the part of some political leaders and  civil servants to hand over the coastline to a few favoured groups at  the cost of public welfare and national security. We believe that the  sand mining franchises are a part of this. An investigation into the circumstances under which these franchises have been granted will  reveal the facts.”
Forum for Better Vishaka has written letters in this regard to APMDC, the Chief Minister and the Prime Minister since 2006 on various occasions but has got no response.



November 29, 2014

The damage done by an illegal notification issued by DAE in January 2006 after the Indo-US nuke deal between Manmohan and Bush is obvious from the following reports.

Andhra Pradesh placer sands contain the highest reserves of monazite (thorium) deposits in the country accounting for 3.72 mt out of 11.93 mt of the country. These placer sands are mined by private parties under leases granted by the State Government.

All the atomic mineral reserves should be conserved and protected by DAE and national security agencies of Govt of India. As needed, the protection of these reserves should be entrusted to a Joint Army Command.

NaMo government should

1. Immediately cancel this notification so that atomic minerals are NO LONGER kept under Open General Licence for exploitation and export.

2. Immediaely cancel all MOUs and related leases granted to private parties to exploit mineral placer sands and entrust the responsibility for mining atomic-mineral containing placer sands only to Indian Rare Earths Limited, a Public Sector Unit operating under Dept. of Atomic Energy.

http://pib.nic.in/newsite/PrintRelease.aspx?relid=112033
Press Information Bureau 
Government of India
Department of Atomic Energy
Deposits of Rare Earths 

                 Atomic Minerals Directorate for Exploration and Research (AMD), a constitute unit of Department of Atomic Energy (DAE) has estimated the presence of 11.93 million tonnes of monazite resources in the beach sand mineral placer deposits along the coastal tracts of India. Monazite in general, contains about 55 – 60% total Rare Earth Oxide.   The state-wise resources of in situ monazite established by AMD so far are as follows:

State
Monazite
(Million tonne)
Odisha
2.41
Andhra Pradesh
3.72
Tamil Nadu
2.46
Kerala
1.90
West Bengal
1.22
Jharkhand
0.22
Total
11.93

            The resources of xenotime, another rare-earth bearing mineral, are negligible in India.  AMD has established about 2000 tonnes of xenotime-bearing heavy mineral concentrate containing 2% xenotime in the riverine heavy mineral placer deposits of Chhattisgarh and Jharkhand.
                        Monazite is a mineral mainly containing rare earths and thorium-a prescribed substance to be handled by the Department of Atomic Energy (DAE). Accordingly, Indian Rare Earths Ltd. (IREL) wholly owned by the Govt. of India, under the administrative control of the Dept. of Atomic Energy (DAE) utilises monazite mainly for production of rare earth compounds, and thorium, as needed in the Department of Atomic Energy.
           
              This information was given by the Minister of State in the Ministry of Personnel, PG & Pensions and in the Prime Minister’s Office Dr. Jitendra Singh in a written reply in the Rajya Sabha today.

Kalyanaraman

See http://bharatkalyan97.blogspot.in/2012/11/dae-cancel-and-withdraw-illegal.html

DAE notification S.O. 61(E) of 18 January 2006, gazetted on 20 Jan. 2006 which revised the list of Prescribed substances, Prescribed equipment and Technology IS ILLEGAL.
Parliament has not approved the changes proposed in the list of Atomic Minerals in First Schedule of the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957.
It was illegal to have issued and gazetted the DAE notification of 2006 WITHOUT FIRST ensuring approval of the Parliament to the proposed changes of the prescribed substances declared as Atomic Minerals under the Act.
DAE should IMMEDIATELY notify cancellation and withdrawal of the notification and prosecute action against those who have acted in contravention of the Rule of Law enunciated in the Act.
“Under the Ilmenite (Control of Export) Order, 1953, licences were issued for the export of ilmenite subject to the condition that samples of ilmenite to be exported had been examined and certified to contain less than 0.1 per cent of monazite to prevent clandestine export of monazite. This limit was subsequently enhanced to 0.25 per cent of monazite. At present, the export consignments of ilmenite are examined and certified by AMD. This was reviewed by DAE and it was found essential to retain monazite testing, and such testing continues to be carried out by AMD on behalf of AERB under the Atomic Energy (Radiation Protection) Rules, 2004. Many countries refuse to use any ilmenite containing more than 75 parts per million (ppm) of uranium and thorium, as it poses an environmental threat when used for the production of value added materials. Hence, analysis of ilmenite for its monazite content by AMD is a service that would be needed by exporters, and could be continued as a charged service to be availed of on a voluntary basis.” [National Mineral Policy, Report of the High Level Committee, Planning Commission 2006].
If none of these substances contain thorium and since it is possible to export them under the OGL, one may be reasonably safe in assuming that any form of the above testing is not being done. If so, the Government must decide whether the inadvertent export of radioactive thorium/uranium in undetermined and possibly in larger than trace quantities are in violation of the very same control regimes they have wholeheartedly endorsed against better judgment, or whether the OGL somehow allows for the legal trafficking of radioactive substances.
Now, it should be clear that the DAE notification of January 2006 has created a situation where AERB certification for transport/shipment of placer sands containing ATOMIC MINERALS was not enforced. DAE has a lot to answer for in conserving, safeguarding the nation's rare earth mineral wealth and protecting against shipments/transport of consignments with radioactive substances.
All the delisted minerals must be reinstated as prescribed substances.
Checks and balances put in place to safeguard national wealth must be clearly enunciated and available in the public domain.
Export quotas for all these minerals must be established on scientific and technological grounds and form a demonstrable part of the development plan.
An impetus and new lease on life must be given to IREL and other agencies to fulfil the tar-gets required if the thorium programme is to be saved from extinction.
DAE should reiterate the instructions banning the mining of ATOMIC MINERAL containing placer sands, transport and export of such minerals by private agencies. The IREL should be strengthened with adequate resources to ensure enforcement of Govt. policies to safeguard, protect and conserve the Minerals of National Importance so vital for the nation's energy programmes and the nation's strategic security imperative.
Atomic minerals include thorium, uranium monazite, zircon,ilmenite, rutile and leucoxene (Part B of First Schedule of the Act 1957)

It is the responsibility of the State to safeguard and protect these atomic minerals.

Please see First Schedule Part B. The prescribed substances list has NOT been amended by Parliament as of May 2012.
http://mines.nic.in/writereaddata/Filelinks/e342d686_MMDR%20Act%201957.pdf (embedded)

This means that DAE notification S.O. 61(E) of 18 January 2006, gazetted on 20 Jan. 2006 which revised the list of Prescribed substances, Prescribed equipment and Technology IS ILLEGAL. The notification could have taken effect only if the Parliament amended the Act (1957). Parliament has NOT amended the Act as of May 2012. Hence, the notification is NULL AND VOID. All acts done under this illegal notification have no authority in law.

Embedded is a letter written by DAE to Federation of Indian Mineral Industries. (DAE letter dated 02.02.2006 - Delisting of minerals)

Atomic minerals include thorium, uranium monazite, zircon,ilmenite, rutile and leucoxene (Part B of First Schedule of the Act 1957). Hence Atomic Energy Regulatory Board certificate is mandatory under law for all these minerals listed in First Schedule Part B of the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 Issued by CONTROLLER – GENERAL, INDIAN BUREAU OF MINES, NAGPUR (August 2012).

Kalyanaraman



http://www.docstoc.com/docs/135339895/mines-and-minerals-_development-and-regulation_-act_-1957-_No-67-of-1957_-as-amended-upto-10th-may_-2012 mines and minerals _development and regulation_ act_ 1957 _No. 67 of 1957_ as amended upto 10th may_ 2012 
http://www.docstoc.com/docs/135348893/fdipolicyformining-titanium-bearing-minerals-and-ores-2008 fdipolicyformining titanium bearing minerals and ores 2008 
Notification of October 19, 2012 by DAE perpetuates the illegality by not recognising the fact the prescribed substances under the Act 1957 continues to include ilmenite,zircon, leucoxine, rutile etc. The Press Note continues continue to cite the illegal DAE notification of 20 Jan. 2006 since the Parliament has NOT approved the changes proposed in DAE notification of Part B Atomic Minerals in First Schedule of the Act 1957.http://www.docstoc.com/docs/135349721/exportofmonazitefromindiathefactsoct19_2012exportofmonazitefromindiathefactsoct.19_2012
Exploitation of Heavy Mineral Beach Sand
The Corporation filed applications for grant of MLs in Vishakhapatnam, Vizianagaram and Srikakulam Districts covering 156.59 sq.kms

M/s. Bothli Trade AG, Switzerland based company evinced interest to establish Titanium Sponge and Titanium Metal Industry with an investment of about of Rs. 4,000 crores. The GoAP entered into an MOU with M/s. Bothli Trade AG on 18.04.2006 covering an extent of 82.37 sq. kms and consequently the Corporation entered into an agreement on 24.08.2006 with M/s. Bothli. The Corporation proposes to consider additional extent of 33.33 sq. kms subject to approval of GoAP.

M/s. VV Minerals, Chennai also evinced interest to form Joint Venture with the Corporation for mining and mineral separation of Heavy Mineral Beach Sands at a Project outlay of Rs. 75 crores and also establishment of value added unit based on the deposits at a Project outlay of Rs. 1,500 crores in Srikakulam District over an extent of 14.78 sq. kms. Accordingly the Corporation entered into an agreement with M/s. V.V. Minerals Pvt. Ltd., on 30.12.2006 as approved by the GoAP.
http://www.apmdc.ap.gov.in/proposed%20new%203.html

March 5 2007

Vizag sand to build planes 

The sands which beach-goers of the State casually kick around contain precious ilmenite, the most important source of titanium which is used to build aircraft and rockets. This vast reserve will now be exploited by the State. 

Experts have pointed out that the entire 950-km east coast, right from Srikakulam bordering Orissa in the north to Nellore near Tamil Nadu in the south, and the stretch between Kakinada and Itchapuram is rich in rare minerals such as ilmenite, rutile, garnet, monazite, silliminate, and zircon. “Ilmenite bears titanium that is used to make aircraft, artillery guns and other defence equipment because it is lightweight and non-corrosive,” said Prof. C. Kasipathi of the department of geology in Andhra University. 

Titanium remains intact in any kind of environment, another reason for its use in defence equipment. “There are huge reserves of ilmenite in the beach sands of north coastal Andhra,” he said. Titanium, a strong aluminium-like metal that is light weight and non-corrosive, can withstand high temperatures and melts only at 1,800º Centigrade and is twice as strong as steel. Titanium alloys are used in high tech aircraft parts, missiles, space vehicles and even in surgical implants. 

Of the total 375 million tonnes of ilmenite reserves across the country, the State has the largest quantum of 116 million tonnes which has been unexploited so far. There is huge demand for such minerals in the international markets as they are rare. India stands third in the quantity of ilmenite reserves but is only sixth in mining and production. “There are several reasons for this, including lack of political will,” said Mr Kasipathi. 

Now things are changing. The AP Mineral Development Corporation has recently signed three MoUs to mine these rare minerals by spending Rs 7,500 crores. APMDC would be getting 26 per cent equity in all the three ventures without any investment. The first MoU with Stork Handlges of Austria and Bothli Trades AG of Switzerland allows the companies to mine 8,237 hectares at Lawsons Bay, Bheemili, Konada, Kandivalasa and Koyyam in Visakhapatnam and Vizianagaram districts, and Bendi, Baruva and Donkur in Srikakulam district. 

This is expected to provide jobs to around 20,000 people in north coastal Andhra districts. Another MoU was signed with VV Minerals, which is being allotted 1,500 hectares in Srikakulam district. The third one was signed with Trimax, another local agency, to which 10,000 hectares is being allocated at Kalingapatnam and Bavanampadu. The Austrian and Switzerland firms will be extracting 10 lakh tonnes of ilmenite per year. 

“Only MoUs have been signed and we are awaiting statutory clearances,” said D. Radhakrishna, project officer of APMDC. In Hyderabad, State mining minister P. Sabita Indra Reddy said, “They agreed to establish the titanium producing units apart from mining in the State. It will be first unit in the country.” “Misra Dhathu Nigam Limited (Midhani) which getting large quantities of titanium from other countries is assured top priority supply,” the minister said. But there are problems like clearance from the Union environment ministry. The endangered marine turtle is the cause of worry. 

“If the companies mine across the fast lane, that is the upper layer of sand, the turtles will be forced to change their egg-laying places,” said marine biologist Dr Duggaraju Srinivasa Rao. “But as per studies the Orissa coast is the favoured destination for the turtles.” The State government on behalf of the companies has assured that all necessary precautions will be taken so that turtles and their egg laying sites are kept safe by providing passage to the amphibians. “We have informed the Centre that the foreign companies will take turtle protection measures,” the mines minister said. 

Source: Deccan.comhttp://www.andhranews.com/ftopic2556.htmlExploitation of Heavy Mineral Beach Sands
The Corporation filed applications for grant of MLs in Vishakhapatnam , Vizianagaram and Srikakulam Districts covering 156.59 sq.kms

M/s. Bothli Trade AG, Switzerland based company evinced interest to establish Titanium Sponge and Titanium Metal Industry with an investment of about of Rs. 4,000 crores. The GoAP entered into an MOU with M/s. Bothli Trade AG on 18.04.2006 covering an extent of 82.37 sq. kms and consequently the Corporation entered into an agreement on 24.08.2006 with M/s. Bothli. The Corporation proposes to consider additional extent of 33.33 sq. kms subject to approval of GoAP.
M/s. VV Minerals, Chennai also evinced interest to form Joint Venture with the Corporation for mining and mineral separation of Heavy Mineral Beach Sands at a Project outlay of Rs. 75 crores and also establishment of value added unit based on the deposits at a Project outlay of Rs. 1,500 crores in Srikakulam District over an extent of 14.78 sq. kms. Accordingly the Corporation entered into an agreement with M/s. V.V. Minerals Pvt. Ltd., on 30.12.2006 as approved by the GoAP.
http://www.aponline.gov.in/Quick%20Links/Departments/Industries%20and%20Commerce/A%20P%20Mineral%20Development%20Corporation/About/index_old.html


Fraudulent Secularisation of Indian Constitution;Insertion of word ‘Secular’ in Indian Consitution on the Sly - Ram Kumar Ohri, IPS (Retd)

$
0
0
          Fraudulent Secularisation of Indian Constitution
           Insertion of word ‘Secular’ in Indian Consitution on the Sly 
-          Ram Kumar Ohri, IPS (Retd)
          
It is astounding that Minister for External Affairs, Sushma Swaraj, is being pilloried by our partisan media and  secular chatterati  largely consisting of  ignorant WOGS  (i.e., West Oriented Gentlemen) and their fellow travellers.  She has been targeted for suggesting that the Bhagwad Gita should be declared as Rashtriya Granth, or the  national book of  India.  Prima facie there is nothing wrong in the suggestion made by the euridite lady.  After all, Gita is the soul of the millennia old Indian civilization. It is the  song celestial sung by Sri Krishna to awaken and invigorate a faltering Arjuna in the battlefield at Kurukshetra. 
          It is  being argued by some inadequately-read  self-styled intellectuals and media mandarins that since our Constitutioin describes India is a ’secular’ nation, a religious book of Hindus,  like Bhagwad Gita,  cannot be designated as our national book.  Ah, secularism !   But who forced  the bogey called secularism into our Constitution ?
          Time has come to inform the comatose Hindu leaders and our slumbering masses about  the forgotten  truth that the word, ‘secular’, did not exist in the original text  of  the Indian Constitution when it was adopted in  November, 1950. The founding fathers   did not, repeat did not, describe India as a secular nation  despite compulsive obsession of  Pandit Nehru with this dogmatic western cult  which is frequently pitted against ‘ dharma’.   Equally important is  for us to remember that  there  was no mention of the word ‘socialist’  in the original  text of Indian Constitution.   A massive  deception  practiced by the unconstitutional  political rulers in 1977 was that the word  ‘secular’ was foisted  by late Indira Gandhi on the  gullible Indian mass on the sly during the dark era of Emergency.
Why was it done during the years of Emergency when all rights of the citizens had been suspended and press too, was totally gagged ?   No one knows, no one can explain.  The  questionable   word was forced into the Preamble   in a clumsy bid to consolidate the minority votebank  in 1977   by  the then Prime Minister and her kitchen cabinet.   She  added two mischievous  words into  the Preamble of the Constitution thereby converting India into a  ‘socialist and secular’  Republic.    Perpetrated during the Emergency it was a fraud of monumental proportions.
          This unwarranted intrustion into the Constitution was made  through the 42nd amendment in 1977 when  democracy was dead,  voice of  the people was  muzzled and  fundamental rights had been suspended. The Forty-second Amendment of the Constitution of India, officially known as The Constitution (Forty-second Amendment) Act, 1976, was enacted during the Emergency by  the  government headed by Indira Gandhi.  Most provisions of the amendment came into effect on 3 January 1977,  while  some other changes were enforced with effect from February 1, 1977.1 
           As highlighted on  the website of Wikipedia, the  “42nd amendment  is regarded as the most controversial constitutional amendment in Indian history. It attempted to reduce the power of the Supreme Court and High Courts to pronounce upon the constitutional validity of laws.  It laid down the Fundamental Duties of Indian citizens to the nation. This amendment brought about the most widespread changes to the Constitution in its history, and is sometimes called a "mini-Constitution"  or  the ‘Constitution of  Indira’.2  Almost all parts of the Constitution, including the  Preamble  and the amending clause, were changed by the 42nd Amendment, and some new articles and sections were inserted. The amendment's fifty-nine clauses stripped the Supreme Court of many of its powers.  Additionally, the amendments curtailed the democratic rights in the country, and gave sweeping  powers to the then Prime Minister.
          Among other things, the controversial  amendment  gave to the  Parliament  unrestrained power to amend any parts of the Constitution, without judicial review. It transferred more power from the state governments to the central government, eroding India's federal structure. The 42nd Amendment also amended the Preamble and changed the description of India from "sovereigndemocratic republic" to a “sovereign socialist  secular  republic”  which was never the intention of the founding fathers when they drafted and passed the Constitution.
          The Emergency era had been widely unpopular. But the  most controversial misconduct  was  the clampdown on civil liberties.  The Janata Party which had promised to "restore the Constitution to its original  condition as it was before the Emergency", won the 1977 general elections. They  then  brought  about  the  43rd and 44th amendments in 1977 and 1978 respectively, to restore the pre-1976 position to some extent. However, the Janata Party was unable to  achieve its full objective because the government could not last long enough due to  internal squabbles between party’s leadership.
          On 31 July, 1980, in its judgement on Minerva Mills v. Union of India, the Supreme Court declared two provisions of the 42nd Amendment which prevented any constitutional amendment from being "called in question in any Court  on any ground", and accord precedence to the Directive Principles of State Policy over the Fundamental Rights respectively, were  declared unconstitutional.   That  historic  judgement  of  the  Supreme Court was tantamount   to legal censure of the conduct of the government led by late Indira Gandhi in turning India into a secular State.
          It needs to be understood that in their infinite wisdom the founding fathers did not add the word ‘secular’, nor the word socialist  in the Preamble of Indian Constitution.  They knew that a Hindu-majority nation,  supremely believing in tolerance,  can never become a theocracy.   History is a witness to the fact that  our forefathers had magnanimously  given asylum to  the Parsis as well as the Jews when they were forced  to run away after being persecuted in their own homelands. The founding fathers  knew very well that according to our holy scriptures and millennia- old historical tradition  Hinduism can never become a narrow sectarian faith.
When the Parsis and the Jews were being hounded out from their native lands, it was the Hindu rulers who gave them  shelter  -  and that too, without imposing any pre-conditions.  That is why the founding fathers of the Constitution  did not declare India a secular State in the year 1950.  On the contrary  in spite of Pandit Nehru,  they boldly  affirmed the Hindu identity of  India by incorporating 20 paintings from our ancient history to embellish the hand-written first copy of the Indian Constitution. 
          The  twenty paintings displayed in  the Constitution constitute clear reiteration  of  India’s ancient heritage and  its Hindu identity  by the founding fathers. First and foremost, the paintings depicted Lanka Vijay by Shri Ram, Gita Updesh to Arjuna at Kurukshetra by Karamyogi Krishna, Ganga Anayan by Bhagirath and portraits of  Raja Vikramaditya, Gautam Buddha, Mahavira, Chhatrapati Shivaji, Guru Gobind Singh and Rani Lakshmibai  of  Jhansi. There is a painting of the  Nalanda University, too. In addition paintings of Mahatma Gandhi and Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose, the two 20th century icons of India’s freedom movement, are also there.3 
          There is also one painting  each of  Moghul king Akbar and Tipu Sultan of Mysore in the Constituton.  But these two paintings  could not be construed  by any means as the Constiuent Assembly’s endeavour  to erase the Hindu identity of India. The clumsy attempt to belittle  the Hindu identity of India,   presently  writ large all over the original Indian Constitution,  is a later day development carried out on the sly during the notorious years of Emergency by adding the word “secular” to the Preamble.  Prima facie there are reasons to believe that  a nefarious thought was occupying the mind of  by the ruling  sham-secularist gang and pro-left academia to conceal the truth from the future generations  of  India. At one time,  it was a hush-hush  rumour in the gossip bazaar of  Lutyen’s  New Delhi   that an attempt was being made to remove  these 20  important paintings from the Constitution.  But that was not done, could not be done. Perhaps the enormity of the proposed insult to the  Indian Constitution and the  fear of Hindu backlash did not allow the leftist seculars to venture ahead on that path. 
          Today’s youngsters do not know that the calligraphy of the hand-written copy of Indian Constitution was done by Prem Behari Narain Raina and it was embellished by Nandlal Bose and some  other artists. The hand-written Constitution was photo-lithographed at the Survey of India Office. Apparently, most journalists and tele-media analysts, too are  are unaware of these  facts.
          The aforesaid 20 paintings can be seen at the website Slide Share:http://www.slideshare.net/slideshow/embed_code/30459044.
          It is time that the present and future generations of India are made aware of the fact that the founding fathers never wanted India to be declared a ‘secular’ State.   Nor did they  consider it necessary to make India  a ‘socialist’ State. This important fact stands conclusively proved  by the  depiction of  20 paintings of  the glorious Hindu heritage and landmark ethos of our country permanently embedded  in the original hand-written copy of the  Indian Constitution. It was done ostensibly for the benefit of the posterity.   
          Time has come for Hindu nationalists to confront the morbid rants  of the  secularist ignoramuses by repetitively asserting  that India was  meant to be a secular State by the founding fathers !  In wisdom and strategic foresight the founding fathers  of the Indian Constitution were  much more far-sighted than Indira Gandhi and her atheist father, Pandit Nehru.  
                    Logically  the above mentioned amendments to the Constitution should have been rescinded immediately after the Emergency was over.  But  the governments led  by  Morarji Desai  and Chaudhry Charan Singh could not complete the task due to internecine warfare in the Janta Dal. Now with the fresh winds of reawakening  of national pride blowing across India, time has come to expunge the questionable  words secular and socialist from the Preamble of the Indian Constitution.  Most European countries have turned their backs on the suicidal cult of multi-culturalism which threatens to erase  the Christian identity of Europe.  
                                                   ************
References:
1.     Source: Wikipedia, the international encyclopedia.           
2.     Ibid.
3.    Source :  The World Digital Library and the website of  Indian Kanoon.


The Vedic Roots of China and Japan

$
0
0

The Vedic Roots of China and Japan

Published on Dec 14 2014 01:12 PM  |Posted Image

The cultural relations between India and China can be traced back to very early times. There are numerous references to China in Sanskrit texts, but their chronology is sketchy. The Mahabharata refers to China several times, including a reference to presents brought by the Chinese at the Rajasuya Yajna of the Pandavas; also, the Arthasastra and the Manusmriti mention China. According to French art historian Rene Grousset, the name China comes from "an ancient" Sanskrit name for the regions to the east, and not, as often supposed, from the name of the state of Ch'in," the first dynasty established by Shih Huang Ti in 221 B.C.

The Sanskrit name Cheena for China could have been derived from the small state of that name in Chan-si in the northwest of China, which flourished in the fourth century B.C. Scholars have pointed out that the Chinese word for lion, shih, used long before the Chin dynasty, was derived from the Sanskrit word, simha, and that the Greek word for China, Tzinista, used by some later writers, appears to be derivative of the Sanskrit Chinasthana. According to Terence Duke, martial arts went from India to China. Fighting without weapons was a specialty of the ancient Ksatriya warriors of India.

Until recently, India and China had coexisted peacefully for over two thousand years. This amicable relationship may have been nurtured by the close historical and religious ties of Buddhism, introduced to China by Indian monks at a very early stage of their respective histories, although there are fragmentary records of contacts anterior to the introduction of Buddhism. The Chinese literature of the third century is full of geographic and mythological elements derived from India.

Bhaarat: Teacher of China



Hinduism and Buddhism, both have had profound effect on religious and cultural life of China. Chinese early religion was based on nature and had many things in common with Vedic Hinduism, with a pantheon of deities.

The story of Sun Hou Tzu, the Monkey King, and Hsuang Tsang. It is a vicarious and humorous tale, an adventure story akin to the Hindu epic of Ramayana, and like Ramayana, a moral tale of the finer aspects of human endeavor which come to prevail over those of a less worthy nature. The book ends with a dedication to India: 'I dedicate this work to Buddha's Pure Land. May it repay the kindness of patron and preceptor, may it mitigate the sufferings of the lost and damned....'

(source: Eastern Wisdom, Michael Jordan, p. 134-151)

Hu Shih, (1891-1962), Chinese philosopher in Republican China. He was ambassador to the U.S. (1938-42) and chancellor of Peking University (1946-48). He said:

"India conquered and dominated China culturally for two thousand years without ever having to send a single soldier across her border."

Lin Yutang, author of The Wisdom of China and India:

"The contact with poets, forest saints and the best wits of the land, the glimpse into the first awakening of Ancient India's mind as it searched, at times childishly and naively, at times with a deep intuition, but at all times earnestly and passionately, for the spiritual truths and the meaning of existence - this experience must be highly stimulating to anyone, particularly because the Hindu culture is so different and therefore so much to offer." Not until we see the richness of the Hindu mind and its essential spirituality can we understand India...."

Posted Image

"India was China's teacher in religion and imaginative literature, and the world's teacher in trigonometry, quadratic equations, grammar, phonetics, Arabian Nights, animal fables, chess, as well as in philosophy, and that she inspired Boccaccio, Goethe, Herder, Schopenhauer, Emerson, and probably also old Aesop."

(source: The Wisdom of China and India, Lin Yutang, p. 3-4)

"I see no reason to doubt," comments Arthur Waley in his book, The Way and its Power, "that the 'holy mountain-men' (sheng-hsien) described by Lieh Tzu are Indian rishi; and when we read in Chuang Tzu of certain Taoists who practiced movements very similar to the asanas of Hindu yoga, it is at least a possibility that some knowledge of the yoga technique which these rishi used had also drifted into China."

Both Sir L. Wooley and British historian Arnold Toynbee speak of an earlier ready-made culture coming to China. They were right. That was the Vedic Hindu culture from India with its Sanskrit language and sacred scripts. The contemporary astronomical expertise of the Chinese, as evidenced by their records of eclipses; the philosophy of the Chinese, their statecraft, all point to a Vedic origin. That is why from the earliest times we find Chinese travelers visiting India very often to renew their educational and spiritual links.

"Neo-Confucianism was stimulated in its development by a number of Buddhist ideas. Certain features of Taoism, such as its canon and pantheon, was taken over from Buddhism. Works and phrases in the Chinese language owe their origin to terms introduced by Buddhism. while in astronomical, calendrical, and medical studies the Chinese benefited from information introduced by Indian Buddhist monks. Finally, and most important of all, the religious life of the Chinese was affected profoundly by the doctrines and practices, pantheon and ceremonies brought in by the Indian religion."

(source: Buddhism in China, Kenneth Ch'en, p. 3)

How China was part of the Indian Vedic empire is explained by Professor G. Phillips on page 585 in the 1965 edition of the Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society. He remarks,

"The maritime intercourse of India and China dates from a much earlier period, from about 680 B.C. when the sea traders of the Indian Ocean whose chiefs were Hindus founded a colony called Lang-ga, after the Indian named Lanka of Ceylon, about the present gulf of Kias-Tehoa, where they arrived in vessels having prows shaped like the heads of birds or animals after the pattern specified in the Yukti Kalpataru (an ancient Sanskrit technological text) and exemplified in the ships and boats of old Indian arts."

Chinese historian Dr. Li-Chi also discovered an astonishing resemblance between the Chinese clay pottery and the pottery discovered at Mohenjo daro on the Indian continent. Yuag Xianji, member of the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference, speaking at the C. P. Ramaswamy Aiyar Foundation, Madras, March 27 1984 said, "Recent discoveries of ruins of Hindu temples in Southeast China provided further evidence of Hinduism in China. Both Buddhism and Hinduism were patronized by the rulers. In the 6th century A.D. the royal family was Hindu for two generations. The following Tang dynasty (7th to the 9th century A.D.) also patronized both Hinduism and Buddhism because the latter was but a branch of Hinduism. Religious wars were unknown in ancient China.

Through its compassionate Buddhas and Bodhisattvas, and its promise of salvation to all alike, its emphasis on piety, meditation, its attractive rituals and festivals, its universality and its tolerance, "the religious life of the Chinese has been enriched, deepened, broadened, and made more meaningful in terms of human sympathy, love, and compassion for all living creatures." The doctrine of karma brought spiritual consolation to innumerable people. The concept of karma is to be found in all types of Chinese literature from poetry to popular tales.

Posted Image

India never imposed her ideas or culture on any nation by military force, not even on the small countries in her neighborhood, and in the case of China, it would have been virtually impossible to do so since China has been the more powerful of the two. So the expansion of Indian culture into China is a monument to human understanding and cultural co-operation - the outcome of a voluntary quest for learning. While China almost completely suppressed other foreign religions, such as Zoroastrianism, Nestorian Christianity, and to some extent Manichaeanism, she could not uproot Buddhism. At times, Buddhism was persecuted, but for two thousand years it continued to indianize Chinese life even after it had ceased to be a vital force in the homeland and long after it had lost its place as the dominant religion of China. In fact, Indianization became more powerful and effective after it was thought that Buddhism had been killed in China.

The introduction of Buddhism is one of the most important events in Chinese history, and since its inception it has been a major factor in Chinese civilization. The Chinese have freely acknowledged their debt to India, often referring to her as the "Teacher of China," and Chinese Buddhists have pictured India as a Western Paradise, Sukhavati. That Chinese philosophy blossomed afresh after the impact of Buddhism indicates both a response to and a borrowing of Indian ideas. The advent of Buddhism meant for many Chinese a new way of life, and for all Chinese, a means of reassessing their traditional beliefs. A new conception of the universe developed, and the entire Chinese way of life was slowly but surely altered. The change was so gradual and so universal that few people realized it was happening.

The Chinese Quietists practiced a form of self-hypnosis which has an indisputably close resemblance to Indian Yoga. The Chinese Taoist philosopher Liu-An (Huai-nan-tzu) who died in 122 B.C. makes use "of a cosmology in his book which is clearly of Buddhist inspiration."

Posted Image

The first mention of India to be found in Chinese records is in connection with the mission to Ta-hsia (Bacteriana) of a talented and courageous Chinese envoy, Chang Chien (Kien), about 138 B.C. Fourteen years later, having escaped after ten years as a captive of the Huns, he returned home and in his report to the Chinese Emperor he referred to the country of Shen-tu (India) to the southeast of the Yueh-chih (Jou-Chih) country. There are other traditional stories suggestive of earlier links, but Chang Chien's reference to Indian trade with the southwestern districts of China along the overland route corresponding to the modern Yunnan road indicates the existence of some sort of commercial relations well before the second century B.C. The find of Chinese coins at Mysore, dated 138 B.C. suggests maritime relations between India and China existed in the second century B.C. Passages in a Chinese text vaguely refer to Chinese trade relations with countries in the China Sea and Indian Ocean, such as Huang-che (Kanchi or a place in the Ganges delta), as well as to the exchange of diplomatic missions.

Trade & Commerce



There can be little dispute that trade was the main motivation for these early contacts. This is supported by finds of beads and pottery, in addition to specific references in historical texts. By the early centuries of the Christian era, Sino-Indian trade appears to have assumed considerable proportions. Chinese silk, Chinamsuka, and later porcelain were highly prized in India, and Indian textiles were sold in southwest China. The similarity between the Chinese and Indian words for vermilion and bamboo, ch'in-tung and ki-chok, and sindura and kichaka, also indicates commercial links. At least by the fifth century, India was exporting to China wootz steel (wootz from the Indian Kanarese word ukku), which was produced by fusing magnetic iron by carbonaceous matter.

With goods came ideas. It has often been contended that merchants were not likely to have been interested in philosophy or capable of the exchange of ideas. This is an erroneous belief which disregards historical evidence and, as Arthur Waley points out, is "derived from a false analogy between East and West. It is quite true that Marco Polo 'songeait surtout a son negoce'. But the same can hardly be said of Indian or Chinese merchants. Buddhist legend, for example, teems with merchants reputedly capable of discussing metaphysical questions; and in China Lu Puwei, compiler of philosophical encyclopedia Lu Shih Ch'un Chiu, was himself a merchant. Legend even makes a merchant of Kuan Chung; which at any rate shows that philosophy and trade were not currently supposed to be incompatible."

Land and Sea Routes



The art of shipbuilding and navigation in India and China at the time was sufficiently advanced for oceanic crossings. Indian ships operating between Indian and South-east Asian ports were large and well equipped to sail cross the Bay of Bengal. When the Chinese Buddhist scholar, Fa-hsien, returned from India, his ship carried a crew of more than two hundred persons and did not sail along the coasts but directly across the ocean. Such ships were larger than those Columbus used to negotiate the Atlantic a thousand years later. Uttaraptha was the Sanskrit name of the ancient highway which connected India with China, Russia and Persia (Iran). The trade routes between China and India, by both land and sea, were long and perilous, often requiring considerably more than two years to negotiate. The overland routes were much older and more often used, but the sea routes gained popularity with progress in shipbuilding and seamanship. Formidable and frightening as the physiography of the land routes was, the traffic through the passes and along the circuitous routes around the mountains was fairly vigorous.

According to the work of medieval times, Yukti Kalpataru, which gives a fund of information about shipbuilding, India built large vessels from 200 B.C. to the close of the sixteenth century. A Chinese chronicler mentions ships of Southern Asia that could carry as many as one thousand persons, and were manned mainly by Malayan crews.

Long before the northwestern routes were opened about the second century B.C. and long before the development of these indianized states, there were two other routes from India to China. One of these began at Pataliputra (modern Patna), passed through Assam (Kamarupa of old) and Upper Burma near Bhamo, and proceeded over the mountains and across the river valleys to Yunnanfu (Kunming), the main city of the southern province of China. The other route lay through Nepal and Tibet, was developed much later in the middle of the seventh century when Tibet had accepted Buddhism.

In addition to land routes, there was an important sea link between India and China through Southeast Asia. During the course of the first few centuries of the Christian era, a number of Indianized states had been founded all over Southeast Asia. Both cultures met in this region, and the Indianized states served as an intermediary stave for the further transmission of Indian culture and Buddhism to China.

Ancient Greek geographers knew of Southeast Asia and China (Thinae) were accessible by sea. Ptolemy mentions an important but unidentified Chinese port on the Tonkinese coast. Ports on the western coast of India were Bharukaccha (Broach); Surparka (Sopara); Kalyana; on the Bay of Bengal at the mouth of the Kaveripattam (Puhar); and at the mouth of the Ganges, Tamaralipti (Tamluk). At least two of these ports on the Bay of Bengal - Kaveripattam and Tamaralipti - were known to the Greek sailors as Khaberos and Tamalitis. At first Indian ships sailed to Tonkin (Kiao-Che) which was the principal port of China, Tonkin being a Chinese protectorate. Later all foreign ships were required to sail to Canton in China proper. Canton became a prosperous port and from the seventh century onward the most important landing place for Buddhist monks arriving from India. Generally Chinese monks set out for the famous centers of learning in India, like the University of Taxila, and Nalanda.

India had census enumeration earlier than China, since such enumeration is mentioned in Kautilya's Arthasastra (see study Coates-Caton10.doc). China had its first census in 2 A.D.

Contributions



Mathematics: "The Chinese were familiar with Indian mathematics, and, in fact, continued to study it long after the period of intellectual intercourse between India and China had ceased." (source: Cited in Sarkar, Hindu Achievements in Exact Science, p. 14)

Literature: The great literary activity of the Buddhist scholars naturally had a permanent influence on Chinese literature, one of the oldest in the world. In a recent study a Chinese scholar Lai Ming, says that a significant feature in the development of Chinese literature has been the "the immense influence of Buddhist literature on the development of every sphere of Chinese literature since the Eastern Chin period (317 A.D.)." The Buddhist sutras were written in combined prose and rhymed verse, a literary form unknown in China at the time. The Chinese language when pronounced in the Sanskrit polyphonic manner was likely to sound hurried and abrupt, and to chant the Sanskrit verses in monophthongal Chinese prolonged the verse so much the rhymes were lost. Hence, to make the Chinese sutras pleasant to listen to, the Chinese language had to be modified to accommodate Sanskrit sounds. Consequently, in 489, Yung Ming, Prince of Ching Ling, convened a conference of Buddhist monks at his capital to differentiate between, and define the tones of, the Chinese language for reading Buddhist sutras and for changing the verses. A new theory emerged called the Theory of Four Tones.

Mythology: The Chinese sense of realism was so intense that there was hardly any mythology in ancient China, and they have produced few fairy tales of their own. Most of their finest fairy tales were originally brought to China by Indian monks in the first millennium. The Buddhists used them to make their sermons more agreeable and lucid. The tales eventually spread throughout the country, assuming a Chinese appearance conformable to their new environment. For example, the stories of Chinese plays such as A Play of Thunder-Peak, A Dream of Butterfly, and A Record of Southern Trees were of Buddhist origin.

Drama: Chinese drama assimilated Indian features in three stages. First, the story, characters, and technique were all borrowed from India; later, Indian technique gave way to Chinese; and finally, the story was modified and the characters became Chinese also. There are many dimensions to Chinese drama, and it is not easy to place them accurately in history. However, the twelfth century provides the first-known record of the performance of a play, a Buddhist miracle- play called Mu-lien Rescues his Mother based on an episode in the Indian epic, the Mahabharata. The subject matter of the Buddhist adaptation of the story, in which Maudgalyayana (Mu-lien in Chinese) rescues the mother from hell, occurs in a Tun-huang pien wen. Significantly, the play was first performed at the Northern Sung capital by professionals before a religious festival.

Posted Image

Grammar: Phrases and words coined by Buddhist scholars enriched the Chinese vocabulary by more than thirty-five thousand words. As the assimilation was spread over a long period of time, the Chinese accepted these words as a matter of course without even suspecting their foreign origin. Even today words of Buddhist origin are widely used in China from the folklore of peasants to the formal language of the intelligentsia. For example, poli for glass in the name of many precious and semi-precious stones is of Sanskrit origin. Cha-na, an instant, from kshana; t'a, pagoda, from stupa; mo-li, jasmine, from mallika, and terms for many trees and plants are amongst the many thousands of Chinese words of Indian origin. Indian grammar also undoubtedly stimulated Chinese philological study. Chinese script consists of numerous symbols, which in their earliest stage were chiefly pictographic and ideographic.

The word used in the old Sanskrit for the Chinese Emperor is deva- putra, which is an exact translation of 'Son of Heaven.' I-tsing, a famous pilgrim, himself a fine scholar of Sanskrit, praises the language and says it is respected in far countries in the north and south. ..'How much more then should people of the divine land (China), as well as the celestial store house (India), teach the real rules of the language.'

Jawaharlal Nehru has commented:

"Sanskrit scholarship must have been fairly widespread in China. It is interesting to find that some Chinese scholars tried to introduce Sanskrit phonetics into the Chinese language. A well-known example of this is that of the monk Shon Wen, who lived at the time of the Tang dynasty. He tried to develop an alphabetical system along these lines in Chinese."

(source: The Discovery of India, Jawaharlal Nehru, p. 197-198)

Art: Indian art also reached China, mainly through Central Asia, although some works of Buddhist art came by sea. Monks and their retinues, and traders brought Buddha statues, models of Hindu temples, and other objects of art to China. Fa-hsien made drawings of images whilst at Tamaralipti. Hsuang Tsang returned with several golden and sandalwood figures of the Buddha; and Hui-lun with a model of the Nalanda Mahavihara. Wang Huan-ts'e, who went to India several times, collected many drawings of Buddhist images, including a copy of the Buddha image at Bodhgaya; this was deposited at the Imperial palace and served as a model of the image in Ko-ngai-see temple. The most famous icon of East Asian Buddhism know as the "Udayana" image was reported to have been brought by the first Indian missionaries in 67, although there are various legends associated with this image and many scholars believe it was brought by Kumarajiva. However, this influx of Indian art was incidental and intermittent, and was destined to be absorbed by Chinese art. This combination resulted in a Buddhist art of exceptional beauty.

One of the most famous caves - Ch'ien-fo-tung, "Caves of the Thousand Buddhas," because there are supposed to be more than a thousand caves. So far, about five hundred caves have been discovered. These caves were painted throughout with murals, and were frequently furnished with numerous Buddha statues and sculptured scenes from the Jatakas. Many other caves were initiated in the reign of Toba Wei Emperor, T'ai Wu. Some also contain images of Hindu deities, such as Shiva on Nandi and Vishnu on Garuda.

Images coming from India were considered holy, as suggested by Omura, in his History of Chinese Sculpture. This significantly underlines the depth of Chinese acceptance of Indian thought.

Music: The Chinese did not regard music as an art to be cultivated outside the temples and theatres. Buddhist monks who reached China brought the practice of chanting sacred texts during religious rites. Hence, Indian melody was introduced into Chinese music which had hitherto been rather static and restrained. Indian music was so popular in China, that Emperor Kao-tsu (581-595) tried unsuccessfully to proscribe it by an Imperial decree. His successor Yang-ti was also very fond of Indian music. In Chinese annals, references are found to visiting Indian musicians, who reached China from India, Kucha, Kashgar, Bokhara and Cambodia. Even Joseph Needham, the well-known advocate of Chinese cultural and scientific priority admits, "Indian music came through Kucha to China just before the Sui period and had a great vogue there in the hands of exponents such as Ts'ao Miao-ta of Brahminical origin." By the end of the sixth century, Indian music had been given state recognition. During the T'ang period, Indian music was quite popular, especially the famous Rainbow Garment Dance melody.

A contemporary Chinese poet, Po Chu-yi, wrote a poem in praise of Indian music. "It is little wonder," an official publication of the Chinese Republic says, "that when a Chinese audience today hears Indian music, they feel that while possessing a piquant Indian flavor it has a remarkable affinity with Chinese music."

Science: A major Buddhist influence on Chinese science was in scientific thought itself. Buddhist concepts, such as the infinity of space and time, and the plurality of worlds and of time-cycles or Hindu Kalpas (chieh) had a stimulating effect on Chinese inquiry, broadening the Chinese outlook and better equipping it to investigate scientific problems. For example, the Hindu doctrine of pralayas, or recurrent world catastrophes in which sea and land were turned upside down before another world was recreated to go through the four cycles- differentiation (ch'eng), stagnation (chu), destruction (juai), and emptiness (kung) - which was later adopted by Neoconfucianists, was responsible for the Chinese recognition of the true nature of fossils long before they were understood in Europe. Again, the Indian doctrine of Karma (tso-yeh), or metempsychosis, influenced Chinese scientific thought on the process of biological change involving both phylogeny and ontogeny. Buddhist iconography contained a biological element. Buddhism introduced a highly developed theory of logic, both formal and dialectical, and of epistemology.

Tantric Buddhism reached China in the eighth century and the greatest Chinese astronomer and mathematician of his time, I-hsing (682-727), was a Tantric Buddhist monk. While the work of Indian mathematicians was carried westward by the Arabs and transmitted to Europe, it was taken eastward by Indian Buddhist monks and professional mathematicians.

Astronomy: There is also some evidence that works on Indian astronomy were in circulation in China well before the T'ang period. In the annuals of the Sui dynasty, numerous Chinese translations of Indian mathematical and astronomical works are mentioned, such as Po-lo-men Suan fa (The Hindu Arithmetical rules) and Po-lo-men Suan King. These works have vanished, and it is impossible to assess the degree of their influence on Chinese sciences. However, there is definite evidence of Indian influence on Chinese astronomy and calendar studies during the T'ang dynasty. During this period, Indian astronomers were working at the Imperial Bureau of Astronomy which was charged with preparing accurate calendars. Yang Ching-fang, a pupil of Amoghavajra (Pu-k'ung), wrote in 764 that those who wished to know the positions of the five planets and predict what Hsiu (heavenly mansion) a planet would be traversing, should adopt the Indian calendrical methods. Five years earlier, Amoghavajra had translated an Indian astrological work, the Hsiu Yao Ching (Hsiu and Planet Sutra), into Chinese.

At the time there were three astronomical schools at Chang-an: Gautama (Chhuthan), Kasyapa (Chiayeh), and Kumara (Chumolo). In 684 one of the members of the Gautama school, Lo presented a calendar, Kuang-tse-li, which has been in use for three years, to the Empress Wu. Later, in 718, another member of the school, Hsi-ta (Siddhartha), presented to the Emperor a calendar, Chiu-che-li, which was almost a direct translation of an Indian calendar, Navagraha Siddhanta of Varahamihira, and which is still preserved in the T'ang period collection. It was in use for four years. In 729 Siddhartha compiled a treatise based on this calendar which is the greatest known collection of ancient Chinese astronomical writings. This was the first time that a zero symbol appeared in a Chinese text, but, even more important, this work also contained a table of sines, which were typically Indian. I-hsing (682-727) was associated with the Kumara school and was much influenced by Indian astronomy. Indian influence can also be seen in the nine planets he introduced into his calendar, Ta-yen-li. The nine planets included the sun, moon, five known planets, and two new planets, Rahu and Ketu, by which the Indian astronomers represented the ascending and descending nodes of the moon.

Medicine: According to Terence Duke, "Many Buddhists were familiar with the extensive knowledge of surgery common to Indian medicine and this aided them both in spreading the teachings and in their practice of diagnosis and therapy. Surgical technique was almost unknown within China prior to the arrival of Buddhism." The renowned Buddhist teacher Nagarjuna is said to have translated at least two traditional works dealing with healing and medicines in the first centuries of our era. A section of his Maha-Prajnaparamita Sutra is quoted by the Chinese monk I-tsing in his commentary upon the five winds (Chinese: Wu Fung; Japanese: Gofu)."

(source: The Boddhisattva Warriors: The Origin, Inner Philosophy, History and Symbolism of the Buddhist Martial Art Within India and China, p. 139-145)

Evidence of Indian influence on Chinese medicine is even more definite. A number of Indian medical treatises are found in Chinese Buddhist collections: for example, the Ravanakumaratantra and Kasyapasamhita. From its very inception, Buddhism stressed the importance of health and the prevention and cure of mental and physical ailments. Indian medical texts were widely known in Central Asia, where parts of the original texts on Ayur Veda have been found as well as numerous translations.

The T'ang emperors patronized Indian thaumaturges (Tantric Yogis) who were believed to possess secret methods of rejuvenation. Wang Hsuan- chao, who returned to India after the death of King Harsha had been charged by the Chinese Emperor in 664 to bring back Indian medicines and physicians.

Considering that Indian medicine, especially operative surgery, was highly developed for the time, it is not surprising that the Chinese, like the Arabs, were captivated by Indian medical skills and drugs. Castration was performed by Chinese methods but other surgical techniques, such as laparotomy, trepanation, and removal of cataracts, as well as inoculation for smallpox, were influenced by Indian practices.

Acupuncture: In modern day acupuncture lore, there is recounted a legend that the discovery of the vital bodily points began within India as a result of combative research studies undertaken by the Indian ksatriya warriors in order to discover the vital (and deadly) points of the body which could be struck during hand-to-hand encounters. It is said that they experimented upon prisoners by piercing their bodies with the iron and stone "needles' daggers called Suci daggers common to their infantry and foot soldiers, in order to determine these points.

This Chinese legend reflects and complements the traditional Indian account of its origins, where it is said that in the aftermath of battles it was noticed that sometimes therapeutic effects arose from superficial arrow or dagger wounds incurred by the ksatriya in battle.

(source: The Boddhisattva Warriors: The Origin, Inner Philosophy, History and Symbolism of the Buddhist Martial Art Within India and China, p. 139-145)

The alternative form of medicine known as acupuncture is believed to have originated in China. In Korean academics, students are correctly told that acupuncture originated in India. An ancient Sanskrit text on acupuncture is preserved in the Ceylonese National Museum at Columbo in Sri Lanka.

Martial Arts/Games



According to author Terence Duke:

"Fighting without weapons was a specialty of the Ksatriya (caste of ancient India) and foot soldier alike. For the Ksatriya it was simply part and parcel of their all around training, but for the lowly peasant it was essential. We read in the Vedas of men unable to afford armor who bound their heads with turbans called Usnisa to protect themselves from sword and axe blows. Fighting on foot for a Ksatriya was necessary in case he was unseated from his chariot or horse and found himself without weapons. Although the high ethical code of the Ksatriya forbid anyone but another Ksatriya from attacking him, doubtless such morals were not always observed, and when faced with an unscrupulous opponent, the Ksatriya needed to be able to defend himself, and developed, therefore, a very effective form of hand-to-hand combat that combined techniques of wrestling, throws, and hand strikes. Tactics and evasion were formulated that were later passed on to successive generations. This skill was called Vajramukti, [Vajramushti] a name meaning "thunderbolt closed - or clasped - hands." The title Vajramukti referred to the usage of the hands in a manner as powerful as the vajra maces of traditional warfare. Vajramukti was practiced in peacetime by means of regular physical training sessions and these utilized sequences of attack and defense technically termed in Sanskrit nata.

"Prior to and during the life of the Buddha various principles were embodied within the warrior caste known as the Ksatriya (Japanese: Setsuri). This title - stemming from Sanskrit root Ksat meaning "to harm," described an elite force of usually royal or noble-born warriors who were trained from infancy in a wide variety of military and martial arts, both armed and unarmed.

"In China, the Ksatriya were considered to have descended from the deity Ping Wang (Japanese: Byo O), the "Lord of those who keep things calm." Ksatriyas were like the peace force - to keep kings and people in order. Military commanders were called Senani - a name reminiscent of the Japanese term Sensei which describes a similar status. The Japanese samurai also had similar traits to the Ksatriya. Their battle practices and techniques are often so close to that of the Ksatriya that we must assume the former came from India perhaps via China. The traditions of sacred swords, of honorable self-sacrifice, and service to one's lord are all found first in India.

"In ancient Hinduism, nata was acknowledged as a spiritual study and conferred as a ruling deity, Nataraja, representing the awakening of wisdom through physical and mental concentration. However, after the Muslim invasion of India and its brutal destruction of Buddhist and Hindu culture and religion, the Ksatriya art of nata was dispersed and many of its teachers slain. This indigenous martial arts, under the name of Kalari or Kalaripayit exists only in South India today. Originating at least 1,300 years ago, India's Kalaripayit is the oldest martial art taught today. It is also the most potentially violent, because students advance from unarmed combat to the use of swords, sharpened flexible metal lashes, and peculiar three-bladed daggers.

"When Buddhism came to influence India (circa 500 BC), the Deity Nataraja was converted to become one of the four protectors of Buddhism, and was renamed Nar(y)ayana Deva (Chinese: Na Lo Yen Tien). He is said to be a protector of the Eastern Hemisphere of the mandala."

INDIA

Ksatriya Vajramukti
Simhanta
Bodhisattva Vajramukti
Trisatyabhumi
Trican Nata
Dharmapala
Mahabhuta Pratima

CHINA

Seng Cha
Pu Sa Chin Kang Chuan (Bodhisattva Vajramukti)
(Po Fu) (Huo Ming) (Pa She) (Pai Chin)
Seng Ping
Chuan Fa or Kung Fu
(Karate) (Tae Kwon Do) (Thai Boxing) (Ju Jitsu) (Judo) (Aikido)

(source: The Boddhisattva Warriors: The Origin, Inner Philosophy, History and Symbolism of the Buddhist Martial Art Within India and China, p. 3, 158-174 and 242)

The famous Shao-lin style of boxing is also attributed to Indian influence. Bodhidharma (5-6th century AD) who believed in a sound mind, in a sound body, taught the monks in the Shao-lin temple this style of boxing for self-defense for rejuvenating the body after exacting meditation and mental concentration.

According to the History Channel martial arts were introduced in China by an Indian named Bodhidharma, who taught it to the monks so that they could defend their monasteries. He was also said to have introduced the concept of vital energy or chi ("prana" probably corresponds to this). This concept is the basis of acupuncture.

Chuan Fa, the Buddhist martial arts, preserved many Ksatriya techniques in their original forms. The monks who practiced Chuan Fa were often the sole preservers of the Ksatriya art of Avasavidya, called in Chinese Huo Ming or Hua Fa.

During the first millennium, Indian racing games reached China. The well-known expert on the history of Chinese games, Karl Himly, on the authority of a passage from the Jun Tsun Su, a work of the Sung period (960-1279), suggests that the Chinese game t'shu-p'u was invented in western India and spread to China in the time of the Wei dynasty (220-265). T'shu'p'u is, in fact, the Chinese adaptation of the Indian chatus-pada (modern chupur). Chess was introduced from India, ca. 700. through the ancient trade route from Kashmir. The oldest and best of the native Chinese games, wei-ch'i, did not appear until 1000. Cubical dice (chu-p or yu-p'i), although found in ancient India and Egypt, are generally believed to have reached China from India, possibly quite early. Arthur Waley is of the opinion that the prominence of the number six in the Book of Changes was derived from the six sides of cubical dice.

Bhaarat's Influence on Japan



Hinduism and Buddhism went from India to China and Korea to Japan. Images of Ganesha and Vishnu have been found throughout Japan. Numerous Buddhist deities were introduced into Japan and many of these are still very popular.

According to D. P. Singhal, "...some Hindu gods, who had been incorporated into the Buddhist pantheon, were amongst them. For example, Indra, originally, the god of thunder but now also the king of gods, is popular in Japan as Taishaku (literally the great King Sakra); Ganesha is worshiped as Sho-ten or Shoden (literally holy god) in many Buddhist temples, and is believed to confer happiness upon his devotees. A sea-serpent worshiped by sailors is called Ryujin, a Chinese equivalent of the Indian naga. Hariti and Dakini are also worshiped, the former as Kishimo-jin, and the latter by her original name. Bishamon is a Japanese equivalent of the Indian Vaisravana (Kubera), the god of wealth.

Even Shinto adopted Indian gods, despite its desperate efforts after the Meiji Revolution to disengage itself from Buddhism. The Indian sea god Varuna, is worshiped in Tokyo as Sui-ten (water-god); the Indian goddess of learning, Sarasvati, has become Benten (literally goddess of speech), with many shrines dedicated to her along sea coasts and beside lakes and ponds. Shiva is well known to the Japanese as Daikoku (literally god of darkness), which is a Chinese and Japanese equivalent of the Indian Mahakala, another name of Shiva. Daikoku is a popular god in Japan. At the Kotohira shrine on the island of Shikoku, sailors worship a god called Kompera, which is a corruption of the Sanskrit word for crocodile, Kumbhira. The divine architect mentioned in the Rig Veda, Vishvakarma, who designed and constructed the world, was regarded in ancient Japan as the god of carpenters, Bishukatsuma. The Indian Yama, the god of death, is the most dreaded god of Japan, under the name of Emma-o, the king of hell.

The climbers wearing traditional white dress, who scale the sacred Mount Ontake as a religious observance, sometimes have inscribed on their robe Sanskrit Siddham characters of an ancient type. Sometimes they put on white Japanese scarfs (tenugui) which carry the Sanskrit character OM, the sacred syllable of the Hindus.

According to Terence Duke, "The Gagaku dances of Japan contain many movements derived from the Indian Nata and the Chinese Chuan Fa."

(source: The Boddhisattva Warriors: The Origin, Inner Philosophy, History and Symbolism of the Buddhist Martial Art Within India and China, p. 206)

The cultivation of cotton in Japan is traced to an Indian who had drifted to the shore of Aichi Prefecture in 799. To commemorate the event, the Japanese named the village where the shipwrecked Indian had landed Tenjiku; Tenjiku was the Japanese name for India, and means Heaven.

The popular Japanese game of sunoroku or sugoroku (backgammon) played at the royal of the Nara rulers and still popular in Japan is of Indian origin. In Japan the game is played as nard. Nard is generally regarded as an Iranian game, but the ninth century Arab scholar, Al Yaqubi, considered nard an Indian invention used to illustrate man's dependence on chance and destiny. According to Wei-Shu, sugoroku was brought to China in ancient times from Hu country, which at that time meant a country somewhere in the vicinity of India. Again, as Karl Himly has pointed out, the Hun Tsun, Sii, written during the Sung period (960-1279), states that t'shu-pu, another Chinese name for sugoroku, was invented in western India, that it was known in its original form as chatus-pada, and that it reached China during the Wei period (220-265).

There is some Indian influence on Japanese art. A similarity between Shinto rituals and Hindu rituals (for example ringing the bell as one enters the temple). Narushima (Narasimha) Bishamondo is a famous temple in Japan. (Source: India and World Civilization - Dr. D. P. Singhal)

Conclusion



In conclusion, it can be said that China was more influenced by India than India by China. Whilst Chinese monks came to acquire knowledge and take it back, the Indian monks went to China on specific religious missions to impart knowledge. There is hardly any evidence that the Chinese monks brought with them any work which was translated into an Indian language. It seems that during this period of Sino-Indian contact, the psychological atmosphere was one in which India was naturally accepted as the giver and China as the taker. Whilst the best in Indian thought was carefully studied and carried back to China, Chinese ideas filtered through India whether they represented the best of their culture or not.

According to Jawaharlal Nehru in his book "The Discovery of India":

"The most famous of the Chinese travelers to India was Hsuang Tsang who came in the seventh century when the great T'sang dynasty flourished in China and King Harshavardhana ruled over in North India. Hsuang Tsang took a degree of Master of the Law at Nalanda University and finally became vice-principal of the university.

His book, the Si-Yu-Ki or the Record of the Western Kingdom (meaning India), makes fascinating reading. He tells us of the system of the university where the five branches of knowledge were taught. 1. Grammar 2. Science of Arts and Crafts 3. Medicine 4. Logic and 5. Philosophy. Hsuang Tsang was particularly struck by the love of learning of the Indian people. Many Indian classics have been preserved in Chinese translation relating not only to Buddhism but also to Hinduism, astronomy, mathematics, medicine, etc. There are supposed to be 800 such works in the Sung-pao collection in China. Tibet is also full of them. There used to be frequent co-operation between Indian, Chinese and Tibetan scholars. A notable instance of this co-operation, still extant, is a Sanskrit-Tibetan-Chinese dictionary of Buddhist technical terms. This dates from the ninth century and is named the 'Mahavyutpatti.'

Soon after Hsuang Tsang's death in China, yet another famous pilgrim made the journey to India - I-tsing (or Yi-tsing). He also studied at Nalanda University for a long time and carried back several hundred Sanskrit texts. He refers to India as the West (Si-fang), but he tells us that it was known as Aryadesha - Arya means noble, and desha region - the noble region. It is so called because men of noble character appear there successively, and people all praise the land by that name. It is also called the Madhyadesha - the middle land, for it is in the center of a hundred myriads of countries. (source: The Discovery of India - Jawaharlal Nehru, p. 193-194)

Yet Chinese culture had some influence on India. The gabled roofs of houses on the western coast of India show a Chinese influence, as do the temples and houses in the Himalayan regions. Some Chinese influence is noted on Gupta coins. The use of a certain kind of silk (chinamsuka) in India, different kinds of fruits including pears (cinaraja-putra), peaches (cinani), and lichis, the technique of fishing in the backwaters, and the porcelain industry all owe something to Chinese influence. Indians also learned the art of papermaking from China.

India and China



It is a curious fact that Chinese culture, though so distinctive, all- pervasive and compulsive, could not come to India, or if it did come, it could not leave any lasting marks behind it.

Archaeologists and scholars tell us that Chinese ideas and ideals came to India with the Kushan Kings of the North, who were Tartars, but the influence that that dynasty has left on India is almost negligible. We are also told that there is influence of Chinese art on the Ajanta paintings. But that is only a theory, since there is nothing characteristically Chinese about these frescoes. The influence of India on China however is undeniable. It is not merely in religion that India influenced China, but in most subjects that go to make up national culture.

The Chinese, always proud of their civilization, looked upon the outside world with contempt. They called the tribes living to their North "Hun slaves," and the tribes living to the North-West "barbarians," while the Japanese were denominated by them "Dwarf Pirates." But their attitude towards India was different. India was known to them by a number of names, not one of which was contemptuous. She was called Hsin Tu, the Kingdom of the Hindus, or Ti Yu, the Western Land; to Buddhists she was Fu Kuo, the Land of the Buddhas.

Pre-Buddhistic Influence



It is probable that there was contact between India and China even before the birth of Buddha; certain similarities of thought and belief between pre-Buddhist Indians and pre-Confucian Chinese go to strengthen that theory. According to Hindus, the world sprang from the union of Purusha and Prakriti, the Male and Female Principles; the ancient Chinese writers thought the same - the Purusha and Prakriti of Indians being called Yang and Yin in China. There is also the worship of mountains in both countries; what the Himalayas have been to Hindus that Mount Tai has been to the Celestials. I do not think that these are mere coincidences due to the similarity of all early beliefs. There was a good deal of action and reaction of early Asiatic civilizations upon each other of which a proper history has yet to be written.

With the rise of Buddhism we are, historically speaking, on firmer ground. It is said that Asoka's missionaries had gone to China. There are however no records left of it. But we do know as a matter of historical fact that in 67 A.D., the Emperor Ming Ti received Kashyapamadanya from India, who bore with him presents of images and sculptures for the Chinese emperor. Since then the intercourse between the two countries continued uninterrupted till at least the eighth century. During that time it is estimated that between thirty to forty Indian scholars went to China, and some two hundred Chinese scholars came to India, who took back with them to their country Indian books, paintings, and statues.

The influence of India on China can be traced on Music, Architecture, Painting, Sculpture, Literature, Mythology, Philosophy and Science.

Influence of Hindu Music



We learn from Chinese writers that Indian music had displaced Chinese music in the seventh century in northern China; records of this music are said to be preserved in Japan. Although Chinese architecture is mainly wooden, still Indian architecture has succeeded in influencing it. There were certain temples built during the Tang Period in China which were the offspring of Indian and Chinese styles of architecture. Those temples are however in ruins now, and so they cannot be studied properly. But the Chinese pagoda fortunately still exists. It is called Chinese, though the country of its origin was Nepal. The Newars, a people living in the Valley of Nepal, evolved it by making certain alterations in the Hindu temple. Those alterations were: (1) They built the pagoda on a platform and not on the ground direct like the Hindu temple; (2) They tilted up the roof of their building, mainly because the rainfall in the country is very heavy. Mr. Ernest Havell is of opinion that the pagoda was a modification of the stupa, while Mr. Sylvain Levi thinks that it represents an Indian style of architecture which has now disappeared. When the pagoda went from Nepal to Tibet and from thence to China is not definitely known yet. The oldest pagoda in China is, I think, of the sixth century.

In painting, India influenced China considerably. From the East Chin dynasty to the Tang dynasty there was continuous intercourse between the two countries, and Indian paintings went to China in great numbers and influenced, if not actually displaced for a time Chinese painting in the North. This Indian School of Painting flourished in China till the rise to power of the Southern Sungs who favored the purely Chinese style of painting. I shall never forget the exquisite, ethereally delicate pictures painted on silk of this period which I saw at an exhibition at Messrs. Yamanaka's art galleries in New York in 1923. The manager of the galleries on seeing that I was an Indian, approached me, and pointing at the pictures in front of us, remarked with his inimitable Japanese smile, "They are all Indian really!" Then there are the wall paintings of the Tun Huang Caves (the Caves of the Thousand Buddhas) which Sir Aurel Stein and others have recently excavated in Chinese Turkestan.

A Chinese writer tells us that before the introduction of Buddhism there was no sculpture in three dimensions in China. But most of the early Chinese Buddhist sculpture was destroyed by an Emperor who was anti-Buddhist. There are, however, the rock sculptures and reliefs at Lo Yang and Lung Men of that period still left intact which show the influence of Indian sculpture on them. There are also sculptures to be found at Yung Kwang which closely resemble the Indo-Greek sculptures of Gandhara.

The Sanskrit language and literature have influenced China to a certain extent, since the Buddhist scriptures had to be translated into Chinese. On account of the study of Sanskrit - which, by the way, is the language of the Mahayana Buddhism and not Pali as some people imagine - the Chinese were inspired to invent an alphabetical system. This alphabetical system which has now disappeared, was called Ba-lamen Shu or Brahminical writing. Sakuntala, the masterpiece of the great Indian dramatist Kalidasa, was translated into Chinese, and is said to have influenced the Chinese drama. In mythology, many Buddhist deities of India were adopted by the Chinese; for example, Kwan Yin, the Chinese Goddess of Mercy, was the Indian Tara. It has been suggested that Lao Tze got his idea of Tao - the Way - from the Hindu Brahman, Universal Soul. It is likely that the Indian sciences of Astronomy and Medicine influenced the astronomical and medical sciences of the Chinese. There is very good scope for a competent scholar to make a full study of Indian influence on China and other Far-Eastern countries, and write a book on the subject.

2 Comments

SuchindranathSAiyer 
Yesterday, 01:43 PM
Ashoka created enormous monasteries for prosleytization to Imperial (Ashokan) Budhism revised from original Budhism as Paul, Charlemagne and Constantine had done with Christianity. with the application of Brahmin (Aryan) Wealth looted by him. Budhism took roots in the non "Brahmin" (majority) population of those lands as it did in India. However, Budhism had spread long before Ashoka and pre-Ashokan Budhist temples as far away as Japan proclaim their adherence to the Swastika of Aryavarta Dharma rather than the Chakra of Ashoka. Shinto's most sacred Holy of Holy Shrines at Isei has an ancient Bala Yantra and Shrichakra that pre dates the advent of Budhism to Japan. It is also to be noted that Gautam Rishi (The Budha) had just a handful of disciples, did not preach or propagate "Budhism" and signed off with a Mona Lisa smile when asked if there was a "Brahma". "Budhism" comprises, to a large extent, the conversion of Sanskrit Brahmin texts to Pali encapsulating the often contradictory "saankhya philosophy" of Gautama Rishi and propagated by Brahmins such as Padma Sambhava who took it to Tibet and Potala Bharadhwaja who took it to Japan. The Brahmin trinity of Virinchi, Narayana and Shankara the three aspects of Surya (The blonde and Blue eyed Savitur from Mitra's Surya common to Zoroastrianism and Shintoism as well and the living idol of Brahma, the presiding deity of the popular Brahma Gayathri) became Maha Sthana Praptha, Amitabha and Avalokiteshwara respectively in Budhism. In Imperial (Ashokan) Budhism, Pali was abolished and everything was brought back to Sanskrit with "Budha" replacing or suffixing the names of all the Brahminical deities as the priests acting under Imperial dispensation needed to control spiritual evolution into "religion". The resulting contortions of Brahminism into Budhism through these two translations are very amusing. In places where Budhism reached and took roots before the Imperial version followed it, the clash of Budhisms is very evident. A visit to Sanjusangendo Hall (Kyoto) where the 12 foot high Bronze Statues of the Aryan Ashta Dikpalaka (Indira, Varuna, Agni, Yama, Kubera, Vayu etc) stand and to the Asakusa Temple (Tokyo) where the Aryan trinity in their Budhist Names are consecrated with Indira and Varuna guarding the gates or to the Great Temple at Nara (where Empress Komyo established Budhism in Japan before Ashokan Budhism and where the Statue of Bharadhwaja sits and heals all those who rub it; are a living evidence of the foregoing from a culture that has not been through all the political contortions of "secular" India. It is interesting that the State religion of Thailand is "Brahminism" till this day. The King's name is Bhoomibol Athulyadej (Bhoomipala Athulyatheja a Sanskrit Kshathriya name if ever there was one) . It was so in Cambodia till theadvent of communism. Nara Uthama (Norodom) Sihanouk called himself a Kshatriya.
V.MUTHUKRISHNAN 
Yesterday, 02:53 PM
India never imposed her ideas or culture on any nation by military force, not even on the small countries in the neighborhood. The entire thing happened due to human understanding and cultural co-operation -   out of a voluntary quest for learning --- will it open our politician's mind and heart and will they leave the people to live in peace and not in piece. Great presentation  

Exposing evangelism: Shiva Kumaran

$
0
0

EXPOSING EVANGELISM: INDIAFACTS IMPACT STORIES

baptism
IndiaFacts carried several factual and original exposes in 2014 focusing on the rampant foreign-aided proselytization which marked the lost decade between 2004—2014. These original investigations exposed the Global Evangelical Organizations and their nexus with franchisee NGOs in India.
Given our visibility and reach, it is natural to ask if our stories made any impact. The first point is this: yes, of course, our stories revealed much that was barely known to Indians—even those who track evangelical activities regularly. However, more importantly, our stories have caused these Organizations to try and erase their tracks. Here are a few instances of the same.
16 March, 2014A Missionary Deception Named Veil of Tears was published on 16 March 2014. Veil of Tears was a documentary movie produced by the multi-national evangelical behemoth, Gospel for Asia as part of its portfolio of atrocity literature against Hinduism and India.
Impact: The website for the movie used to be accessible from Indian IP addresses until the IndiaFacts story came out. Since 22 March 2014, it is not accessible from India.
21 April, 2014Evangelist Modus Operandi in India: A Report caused much uproar among the readers and supporters of IndiaFacts. Through four Exhibits, it showcased the surreptitious and Adharmic activities of foreign-supported Evangelicals in India.
Impact-1: Exhibit-2 of that story featured Mike Amick Jr. who was the President ofInternational Paper India, and who was shown to be proselytizing in the homes of Lingayats in the Northern Karnataka region during weekends. The story was based on an article in a Baptist magazine which included a video. Furthermore, it was based on a lecture delivered by Mr. Amick as a Plenary Speaker in an Evangelical networking conference held in Tennessee during March 21-22, 2014.
Impact-2: Exhibit-4 of that story featured a video where a Sepoy, Avia Ngwazah was seen talking to his handler (Allan Witkowski) from an Evangelical Organization called Team Expansion. The video is likely to have been filmed in Arunachal Pradesh.
  • The video and its description were available here before the publication of our story. It vanished in a week’s time after our story.
  • The Evangelical Conquest of that region was also narrated by an accomplice of Witkowski, Pastor Brian Jones (of Christ’s Church of the Valley, Philadelphia) in a blog. That Post too vanished within a week of the IndiaFacts story.
21 July 2014Evangelical NGO Operation Mobilisation’s Foreign Funding introduced a new analysis to the audience of IndiaFacts. For the first time, the potential of reverse analysis of FCRA data was demonstrated—that is, given the name of a foreign organization, can one obtain the network of its recipients in India?
Operation Mobilisation is once again an Organization (a hydra, in fact) which falls under the broad category of Breaking India.
Impact: The Indian arm located in Ranga Reddy District, Telengana used to be calledOperation Mobilisation India on FCRA recordsAfter our story was published, its name has been changed to Operation Mercy India Foundation.
7 September, 2014: Gospel for Asia and Its Indian Connections followed the same methodology as outlined in the Operation Mobilisation story and identified the flow of Evangelical Funds from Gospel for Asia Inc(GFAI), Texas. A key element uncovered in that story was the establishment of 13 Limited Liability Companies(LLCs) in Texas by GFAI, through which enormous sums of money were channelised to its franchisee FCRA-NGOs in Kerala for the purpose of converting Hindus to Christianity.
Impact: The mailing address of all the 13 LLCs on the website of Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts used to be 1800, Golden Trail CT, Carrollton, Texas 75010-4649(which is the address of GFAI). After the story was published on IndiaFacts, the addresses of all the LLCs on the Texas Govt. website have been changed to 116, St. Thomas Way, Wills Point, Texas 75169.
The stories used a simple methodology:
(i) theFCRA returns filed by the franchisee NGOs with Government of India
(iii) the Company Master Data of Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Government of India.
Sequencing all these together, it was established that Mission India, an Evangelical Organization based out of Michigan, was not only financing two FCRA-NGOs inRanga Reddy District, Telengana—that is, Seva Bharat and Letha Charitable Trust—via FCRA, but had also established a company therein called DTK Hospitality Tours Pvt. Ltd which acted as a shell for the FCRA-NGOs to operate from.
This IndiaFacts story provided the first smoking gun that foreign evangelical organizations support the work of the Kingdom of the Christian God via the company route as well (for more information, read theBusiness as Mission model).
Impact-1: The Advisory Board of Christian Social Forum, Secunderabad (cited in our Story as Ref. 6) used to show Rev. J. Chiranjeevi as General Director, Seva Bharat.His name was deleted sometime in November 2014 after the IndiaFacts story appeared.
Impact-2: The Board of Directors of Hyderabad Institute of Theology and Apologetics (HITHA) (cited in our Story as Ref. 10) used to show Dr. Kamala Chiranjeevi as Director, SevaBharath (IndiaFacts Note: Typo in NGO name reproduced for the sake of accuracy). Her name was deleted, again, sometime in November 2014 after the IndiaFacts story appeared. Strangely, while some other Board members whose names were also removed are shown under “Former Members of HITHA Board”, Dr. Kamala Chiranjeevi’s name went missing even under this list.
Impact-3: A video of an Annual celebration of a Telugu Evangelical channel,Aradhana TV was available on youtube. At 1m50s, Rev. J. Chiranjeevi’s name was called to occupy his seat on the dias. The same was mentioned in our storyThis video has been made private after our story broke.
Impact-4: Mission India’s (Michigan) webpage used to list David Bustraan (one of the Directors of DTK Hospitality Tours Pvt. Ltd.) as a contact for receiving gifts on its behalf. The same was mentioned in our Story. His name alone went missing from that webpage sometime in November after our story.
Impact-5: On the Ministry of Consumer Affairs database, DTK Hospitality Tours Pvt. Ltd. was listed to have had only three Directors – all foreign nationals. After our Story broke, a fourth name, who happens to be an Indian national, was added.This IndiaFacts Impact was covered here as a separate impact story.
Needless to state, IndiaFacts will continue to track and expose such missionary and evangelical shenanigans that have the potential to alter India’s social fabric and pose serious threat to national security. We leave it to our readers to figure out the reason(s) behind such webpage cleanups, director-level changes etc.

Summary

IndiaFacts carried several stories on Proselytizing Organizations this year. These were based on publicly verifiable evidences. Despite the attempts to erase/modify some of these evidences, our stories remain. We remain true to our cause – of bringing outfacts and featuring investigations and exposes that mainstream media shies away from.
(With inputs from IndiaFacts supporter, reader, and contributor, Shiva Kumaran who can be followed on Twitter @sighbaboo).
Article Summary
Article Title
Exposing Evangelism: IndiaFacts Impact Stories
Author
Description
A summary of the impact created by IndiaFacts' articles on missionary activities.
http://www.indiafacts.co.in/exposing-evangelism-indiafacts-impact-stories/#.VJAN7NKUeSq

Jihad attack on Pakistan school: 128 killed

$
0
0
A Pakistani girl, who was injured in a Taliban attack in a school, is rushed to a hospital in Peshawar, Pakistan, 16 December 2014
Most of those hurt in the attack are believed to be aged under 15.http://www.bbc.com/news/live/world-asia-30491113
On second thoughts. may b it is better to "condom" terrorist attacks. It will prevent more from being born




  1. My heart goes out to everyone who lost their loved ones today. We share their pain & offer our deepest condolences.
  2. It is a senseless act of unspeakable brutality that has claimed lives of the most innocent of human beings - young children in their school.
  3. Strongly condemn the cowardly terrorist attack at a school in Peshawar.


Scores killed in attack on Pakistan school

Children among 126 dead in raid claimed by Pakistani Taliban, as military starts an operation on the Peshawar school.

Last updated: 16 Dec 2014 11:01
The army said in a statement that many hostages had been evacuated but did not say how many [Reuters] 
Army chief en route from Quetta to Peshawar, as rescue operation continues, confirms @AsimBajwaISPR
At least 126 people, mostly students, have died in an attack by Pakistani Taliban fighters on a military-run school in Peshawar in Pakistan's northwest, according to a senior official, as military started an ongoing operation on the compound.






Pervez Khattak, the chief minister of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province, told local media that Peshawar's Lady Reading Hospital had taken 24 of the dead, while the Combined Military Hospital had taken at least 60.


Dozens were injured, Khattak said, when the fighters stormed the Army Public School on Tuesday morning.
Several explosions have been heard coming the compound.
It is thought at least four Taliban fighters had been killed in the military operation to retake the school.
At least six Taliban fighters entered the school via a neighbouring graveyard, Al Jazeera's Kamal Hyder said.
"Most of the younger pupils escaped the school, but the senior students were not so lucky," our correspondent said.
"An attack on a school on this scale is unheard of, there will be serious questions asked as far as security of the school is concerned. There will be considerable anger across the country."
At least 126 people, mostly students, have died in an attack by Pakistani Taliban fighters on a military-run school in Peshawar in Pakistan's northwest, according to a senior official, as military started an ongoing operation on the compound.
Pervez Khattak, the chief minister of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province, told local media that Peshawar's Lady Reading Hospital had taken 24 of the dead, while the Combined Military Hospital had taken at least 60.
Dozens were injured, Khattak said, when the fighters stormed the Army Public School on Tuesday morning.
Several explosions have been heard coming the compound.
It is thought at least four Taliban fighters had been killed in the military operation to retake the school.
At least six Taliban fighters entered the school via a neighbouring graveyard, Al Jazeera's Kamal Hyder said.
"Most of the younger pupils escaped the school, but the senior students were not so lucky," our correspondent said.
"An attack on a school on this scale is unheard of, there will be serious questions asked as far as security of the school is concerned. There will be considerable anger across the country."

A spokesman for a faction of the Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP), or Pakistani Taliban, said the attackers had been ordered to shoot older students during the raid that started on Tuesday morning.
Shaukat Yousafzai, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa's health minister, said a school function had been going on in the senior section of the school when an explosion went off.
"The matter has largely come under control now. The operation is now complete on the students side, and has moved to the administration block of the school," he said.
"There are no negotiations ongoing at the moment, there is a security forces operation ongoing.
"They have been cleared from the junior section. The explosion occurred in the senior section where there was a [school] function ongoing."
Hostages evacuated
The armed men attacked the Army Public School where about 500 students and teachers were present, military officials said.
The attack began at about 11am local time (06:00 GMT).
An initial blast as the attackers hit the school was followed by a second explosion. Small-arms fire was heard throughout the raid as security forces tried to retake the school.
A breakdown of Pakistan's armed groups
A heavy contingent of security forces arrived at the school shortly after the attack began and launched the rescue operation.
The army said in a statement that many hostages had been evacuated but did not say how many.
"Rescue operation by troops under way. Exchange of fire continues. Bulk of student(s) and staff evacuated. Reports of some children and teachers killed by terrorist," the army said in a brief English-language statement.
Muhammad Khorasani, TTP spokesperson, told Al Jazeera that six suicide bombers had been sent to the school.
He said the attackers had been given orders to allow the youngest students to leave but to kill the rest.
The attack was in retaliation for an ongoing Pakistan Army operation against the TTP and its allies in the North Waziristan tribal area, Khorasani said.
The TTP said many of their family members had been killed in the campaign, and said the attack on the school was in revenge for those deaths.
"Many TTP members have lost their family members and they have said they want to inflict pain," Al Jazeera's Kamal Hyder said.
"But many ordinary people put their children in military schools because of the relatively higher standard of education, so normal people have been hit as well by this."
The Pakistani military began Operation Zarb-e-Azb against the TTP and its allies on June 15, and says that it has so far retaken larges areas of territory from the group, killing more than 1,270.
The army is also carrying out a military operation in Khyber Agency, which borders Peshawar, where it says it has killed at least 179 fighters.
"This is a soft target. No one would expect a school to be attacked and children would be involved," our correspondent said.
"This will only strengthen the public's resolve to carry on supporting the army."
Asad Hashim contributed to this report from Islamabad. http://www.aljazeera.com/news/asia/2014/12/fighters-attack-army-run-school-pakistan-20141216742794184.html






Continue reading the main storySlide Show


SLIDE SHOW|8 Photos

Scores Killed in Taliban Attack on School

Scores Killed in Taliban Attack on School

CreditMohammad Sajjad/Associated Press

Continue reading the main storyShare This Page
ISLAMABAD, Pakistan — In one of Pakistan’s bloodiest attacks in recent years, scores of people were killed after a group of Taliban gunmen stormed a school in northwestern Pakistan, officials and rescue workers said on Tuesday. Hundreds of students remained trapped inside the compound as security forces exchanged fire with the gunmen, officials said.
The toll of dead and injured remained uncertain, but a regional official said that as many as 100 had been killed and 80 wounded in the attack, most of them students.
The siege started Tuesday morning around 10 a.m. when at least five to six heavily armed Taliban gunmen entered Army Public School and Degree College in Peshawar, the capital of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Province. According to initial reports, the gunmen opened fire on students and have taken dozens of them as hostages. Some students managed to escape the school compound, the local news media reported.
The gunmen entered the school after scaling a wall at the rear of the main school building. They opened fire and took dozens of students hostage in the main auditorium of the building, the news media reported.
Local television news networks broadcast images of panic-stricken students, wearing the school uniform of green sweaters and blazers, being evacuated from the school compound. The wounded have been taken to Lady Reading Hospital in Peshawar, where a state of emergency has been declared.
Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif has left the capital, Islamabad, for Peshawar, state-run news media reported, saying he would personally supervise the operation against the militants.
A spokesman for the Pakistani Taliban claimed responsibility for the attack and said it was in retaliation to the military’s offensive against militant hideouts in the North Waziristan tribal region. Pakistani military carried out an offensive, “Operation Zab-e-Azb,” in June and have claimed to have cleared 90 percent of the restive region that has long been a redoubt of local and foreign militants.
Pervez Khattak, the chief minister of the province, said that as many as 100 teenage students have been killed, while 83 were wounded in the attack. Mr. Khattak said the gunmen were wearing the uniforms of a paramilitary force and were armed with suicide vests.
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/17/world/asia/taliban-attack-pakistani-school.html?hp&action=click&pgtype=Homepage&module=a-lede-package-region&region=top-news&WT.nav=top-news&_r=0

  1. Pakistan School Attack in Peshawar - Many Students Killed in Taliban Milatary School Attack

    • 2 hours ago
    • 301 views
    A Pakistani hospital official says 20 students and one soldier have been killed in a Taliban attack on a school in the northwestern ...
    • NEW
  2. Taliban School Attack Peshawar (VIDEO) Pakistan Children Shot Dead in Army School

    • 1 hour ago
    • 301 views
    Terrorist Attack on Army School in Peshawar Pakistan December 16 2014 LIVE: Insanity in Pakistan, over 100 school children ...
    • NEW
  3. Live : Terrorist Attack on Peshawar Army School in Pakistan (Hostage Held in Peshawar)

    • 3 hours ago
    • 165 views
    Terrorist Attack on Army School In Peshawar Pakistan December 16 2014 LIVE: Insanity in Pakistan, over 100 school children ...
    • NEW
  4. Pakistan Taliban 'kill 100' in assault on Peshawar school

    • 1 hour ago
    • 17 views
    Taliban storms Pakistan military school, killing dozens of students Pakistan Taliban 'kill 100' in assault on Peshawar school BBC ...
    • NEW
  5. Taliban Militants attack Army school in Peshawar 84 children among 104 are dead

    • 52 minutes ago
    • 1 view
    Taliban Militants attack Army school in Peshawar 84 children among 104 are deadAround 104 people including 84 students have ...
    • NEW
    • HD
  6. Taliban School Attack in Peshawar, Pakistan | Dozens of Children Shot & Killed in Army School | 2014

    • 1 hour ago
    • 29 views
    The latest from Peshawar in northern Pakistan, where six Taliban gunmen have stormed an army-run school, killing at least 84 ...

Aircel-Maxis ghotala: PC goose grilling by CBI, to continue

$
0
0

CBI GRILLED PC ON DEC 6, MAY QUIZ HIM AGAIN

Wednesday, 17 December 2014 | PNS | New Delhi

The noose is tightening around former Finance Minister P Chidambaram with the CBI questioning him in the Aircel-Maxis case in which the agency has already chargesheeted former Telecom Minister Dayanidhi Maran and his brother Kalanidhi.
While CBI remained tight-lipped on Chidambaram’s questioning, agency sources said he was examined on December 6 and his statement recorded after three hours of grilling. The sources said Chidambaram will be called again for questioning after corroborating his statement with the documents relating to the FIPB approval about the dubious deal.
Meanwhile, Enforcement Directorate also swung into action and sought details from RBI on financial transactions of Chidambaram’s son Karti-controlled companies involved in the Aircel-Maxis deal.
During the questioning on violations of rules in the grant of FIPB approval, Chidambaram claimed that that “these were the practices going on that time,” the sources said. 
During his examination, the CBI sleuths asked him why he did not seek the approval of the Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs (CCEA) before granting approval to Malaysia-based Maxis Company when the FDI in the deal was valued at around Rs 4,000 crore. In 2006, the FIPB was entitled to clear FDI investment up to Rs 600 crore only.
According to sources, “literally the former Finance Minister has no answer” on the Maxis’ declaration to Malaysian stock exchange on takeover of more than 99 per cent of shares in Aircel. As per the norms then only 74 per cent of FDI was allowed in the telecom sector.
Chidambaram, sources said, also fumbled before CBI investigators on the discrepancy of share values in the deal.
According to the deal, 74 per cent of Aircel’s shares were allotted to Maxis for Rs 3,000 crore.
During the same period Apollo Hospital Group-linked company was granted 26 per cent shares at a pittance of below Rs 30 crore. Chidambaram could not answer to these irregularities, the said sources.
The ED on its part has asked RBI about the entire money transaction details of Karti-controlled three companies with certain banks. There was huge transfer of money to Singapore from Karti-controlled companies during the Aircel-Maxis deal in mid-2006.
Advantage Strategic Consulting Private Limited, Ausbridge Holding and Investments Private Limited and Kaiser Surya Samudra Resorts are the Karti-linked companies under the ED’s radar in connection with Aircel-Maxis money trail. ED has sought details from RBI’s Foreign Exchange Department in the last week of November. RBI has not yet furnished the data of Karti controlled companies from 2004 to 2012.
The CBI has already mentioned Chidambaram’s name for the alleged FIPB violation in the chargesheet against former Telecom Minister Dayanidhi Maran. Apart from Aircel-Maxis scam, CBI is also probing Chidambaram’s role in the violations in the approval of Swan-Etisalat deal worth Rs 4,500 crore in mid 2008. CBI has already registered Preliminary Enquiry on this matter in November.
Meanwhile, in the evening Chidambaram told PTI “they (CBI) took a brief statement from me on the FIPB approval. I repeated what I said in my Press statement earlier. Nothing more than that.”
Chidambaram had said in September that the file regarding the case was put up before him by officials and he approved it “in the normal course”.

My son was in uniform in the morning. He is in a casket now -- Tahir Ali. Weep, Nawaz, disband the Jihadi Army. We are all Bharatam Janam.

$
0
0
My son was in uniform in the morning. He is in a casket now
Tahir Ali
Father of Abdullah, 14, who was killed in the school


Wednesday , December 17 , 2014 |

India stands by Pak, minus the usual sting

A father mourns the death of his son at a hospital in Peshawar on Tuesday. (AFP)
New Delhi, Dec. 16: A telephone call, a cancelled dinner, multiple messages of condolences and a trademark jibe missing — the slaughter of schoolchildren today in an army school in Peshawar by Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan fidayeen brought a departure from convention.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi, foreign minister Sushma Swaraj and the foreign office condemned the attacks and offered sympathies without lacing their statements with a sting that has marked most past responses to terror strikes in Pakistan.
Modi telephoned Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif late this evening to offer condolences. In his conversation with Sharif, Modi described the assault as “not only an attack against Pakistan, but an assault against the entire humanity”.
“It is a senseless act of unspeakable brutality that has claimed lives of the most innocent of human beings — young children in their school,” Modi tweeted earlier in the day, as Pakistan’s armed forces were battling seven terrorists inside the Peshawar school. “My heart goes out to everyone who lost their loved ones today. We share their pain and offer our deepest condolences.”
India’s foreign office — very often the Prime Minister too — routinely condemn terror attacks abroad, including in Pakistan, offer commiserations, and at times, even intelligence support or resources.
But India’s official responses to terror acts in Pakistan are often also an opportunity for New Delhi to send a message to Islamabad, and key nations across the world. New Delhi, on these occasions, reminds them that the very tool of extremist terrorism, reared by Pakistan as a strategic tool against India, bites back at Islamabad.
A statement issued by the foreign office just a month back, after the terror attacks in Wagah in Pakistan bore that stamp.
“We believe that the firmest and most comprehensive action against all terror groups without any distinction is the only way to defeat this evil scourge,” the ministry of external affairs statement on November 3 had said, after condemning the attacks.
India has long argued for a United Nations Comprehensive Convention against Terrorism that bars nations from distinguishing between terrorists based on their strategic goals, and punishes countries that support any terror group. Pakistan and several other Islamic states are demanding that the convention draw a distinction between terrorists and “freedom fighters” — a term they use to describe militants in Kashmir.
Today, the foreign office, too, skipped any reference to its traditional allegations against Pakistan. “No words will capture the feeling of deep revulsion and horror we feel about this terror attack against innocent children,” foreign office spokesperson Syed Akbaruddin said.
The foreign minister had invited several parliamentarians home for dinner, but at 6pm, changed her mind. “In view of the massacre of innocent children in Pakistan, tonight’s dinner hosted by me for Members of Parliament is hereby cancelled,” Sushma tweeted.
Cong tempers stand
The Congress appealed to the global community to join hands in crushing exporters of terrorism in Pakistan. But Sonia Gandhi and Rahul issued much sober statements.
Although the party’s official statement by spokesperson Randeep Surjewala said “we are with the Pakistani government in this hour of crisis”, it focused on dismantling of terror hubs and asked Islamabad to understand “terrorists were nobody’s friend and enemy of the society”.
He also reminded Pakistan of the need to act against Masood Azhar, Haifiz Sayeed, and Dawood Ibrahim.
Rahul, however, said: “Deeply shocked at the barbaric killing of schoolchildren by terrorists in Peshawar…. We stand united with the people of Pakistan in their resolve to fight the menace of terrorism.”
Congress president Sonia said: “Strongly condemn the dastardly killing of innocent schoolchildren…. This barbaric act has caused universal outrage and painfully underscores the threat posed by organised terrorist groups to humankind.”
http://www.telegraphindia.com/1141217/jsp/frontpage/story_19224718.jsp#.VJDvqtKUeSo

School motto: Rise & Shine

A woman breaks down as she arrives near the attack site in Peshawar along with another person. (AFP)
Dec. 16: The Army Public School and Degree College in Peshawar is part of a nationwide network of elite institutions run under the auspices of the Pakistan Army.
The titular head of such Army Public Schools is the Pakistani chief of army staff (COAS), and they are usually located within cantonment limits.
Students of the institution go with the common motto: “I shall Rise and Shine.”
There are 146 such schools all across Pakistan, all of them administered by a central body called the Army Public Schools and Colleges Systems Secretariat (APSCSS). The essential mandate of the APSCSS is to ensure smooth administration and maintenance of quality standards across the country.
Although their affairs are overseen by the Pakistan Army — and preference is given to children of those that serve in the armed forces — admission to such schools is, at least on paper, open to all.
But they are different from privately-run public schools, of which, too, there are several in Pakistan.
“The army schools are really elite schools where the children of the affluent and the influential go. It is considered a thing of privilege to be able to send your child to one of these schools if you are not in the armed forces,” a senior Islamabad-based journalist told The Telegraph over phone.
“For a lot of students that come from armed forces background, such schools also serve as training grounds, or platforms, to get into the defence services at a later stage,” the journalist added.
http://www.telegraphindia.com/1141217/jsp/frontpage/story_19224721.jsp#.VJDvgNKUeSo

The face of a student who was killed in the attack in Peshawar is seen through the coffin?s lid. (Reuters)

He shot her until sound stopped: Boy

Peshawar, Dec. 16 (Reuters): Students pored over their books. Teachers ruffled through their notes and gave lectures. It began like any other morning in Pakistan’s Army Public School in the northwestern city of Peshawar.
In an instant, the peace was shattered — gunfire, smoke and dead bodies strewn across the school’s halls and corridors, with crazed militants rushing from room to room shooting randomly at pupils and adults.
As many as 130 children were killed in the daylight attack on the military-run school on Tuesday, an assault lauded by Taliban insurgents as revenge for the killings of their own relatives by the Pakistani army.
Reuters interviews with witnesses showed most victims were shot in the first hours of the assault when gunmen sprayed the premises with bullets in an indiscriminate massacre.
It was possible that some were also killed in the ensuing gunfight with Pakistani armed forces who stormed the building.
The school in Peshawar, a Pakistani city on the edge of the country’s turbulent tribal belt, is operated by the army. Although it enrols some civilian students, many of its pupils are children of army officials, the Taliban’s intended target.
The assault began around 10am local time.
The militants — some said they were wearing Pakistani army uniforms — bypassed the heavily guarded main entrance and slipped in through a less frequently used back entrance, the witnesses added.
Shahrukh Khan, 15, was shot in both legs but survived after hiding under a bench. “One of my teachers was crying, she was shot in the hand and she was crying in pain,” he said as he lay on a bed in Peshawar’s Lady Reading Hospital.
“One terrorist then walked up to her and started shooting her until she stopped making any sound. All around me my friends were lying injured and dead.”
As the gunfight between the Taliban and Pakistani forces intensified, at least three of the militants blew themselves up, resulting in several charred bodies of bombers and victims.
A Reuters correspondent visiting the city’s Combined Military Hospital said its corridors were lined with dead students, their green-and-yellow school uniform ties peeping out of white body bags.
One distraught family member was given a wrong body because the faces of many children were badly burned as a result of the suicide bomb explosions.
Khalid Khan, 13, said he and his classmates were in a first-aid lesson in the main hall when two clean-shaven armed men wearing white clothes and black jackets entered the room.
“They opened fire at the students and then went out. The army doctor and soldiers managed to escape and we locked the doors from inside,” he said. “But very soon they came, broke the doors and entered and again started firing.”
He said many tried to hide under their desks but were shot anyway, adding that there were around 150 students in the hall around the time of the attack. “They killed most of my classmates and then I didn’t know what happened as I was brought to the hospital,” said Khan, breaking down in sobs.
Another student, Jalal Ahmed, 15, could hardly speak, choking with tears, as Reuters approached him at one of the hospitals.
“I am a biochemistry student and I was attending a lecture in our main hall. There are five doors in the hall. After some time we heard someone kicking the back doors. There were gunshots but our teacher told us to be quiet and calmed us down.
“Then the men came with big guns.”
Ahmed started to cry. Standing next to his bed, his father, Mushtaq Ahmed, said: “He keeps screaming: ‘take me home, take me home, they will come back and kill me’.”
A nine-year-old boy, who asked not to be named because he was too afraid to be identified, said teachers shepherded his class out through a back door as soon as the shooting began.
“The teacher asked us to recite from the Quran quietly,” he said. “When we came out from the back door there was a crowd of parents who were crying. When I saw my father, he was also crying.”
http://www.telegraphindia.com/1141217/jsp/frontpage/story_19224719.jsp#.VJDvXNKUeSo

HANG YOUR HEADS IN SHAME, HUMANS
132 kids slaughtered in Pak

Two schoolchildren rescued from the Army Public School in Peshawar being escorted by a soldier on Tuesday. (Reuters)
Islamabad, Dec. 16: Pakistan was tonight preparing to bury the flower of a generation: 132 children killed in a Peshawar school in a terror attack whose savagery appeared unparalleled because of the abrupt and cold-blooded manner in which it was executed.
Altogether 148 people — 132 children, nine employees and seven terrorists — had been killed by the time the eight-hour siege of the Army Public School and Graduate College ended in the evening.
Officials said 121 pupils and three staff members were wounded. A local hospital said the dead and injured were aged between 10 and 20.
The Taliban gunmen broke into the school just when the world was recovering from the “lone-wolf” stand-off in Sydney 24 hours ago.
The terrorists made no demands and started killing children as soon as they entered the building, the chief military spokesperson said. “They didn’t take any hostages initially and started firing in the hall,” said Maj. Gen. Asim Saleem Bajwa.
But the militants had brought rations for several days, he said, implying that they may have intended to take students hostage. It is not clear whether and why the plans were changed.
Pakistanis, used to almost daily militant attacks, were shocked by the scale of the massacre and the loss of so many young lives.
The massacre recalled the 2004 siege of a school in Russia’s Beslan by Chechen militants that ended in the death of more than 330 people, half of them children. In Beslan, the children were taken hostage and the crisis had spilled over to three days and some questions remain unanswered on what triggered the explosions that killed many hostages.
In Peshawar, wounded children taken to nearby hospitals told Reuters that most of the victims died when gunmen, suicide vests strapped to their bodies, entered the compound and opened fire indiscriminately on boys, girls and their teachers.
The corridors of the city’s Combined Military Hospital were lined with dead students, their green-and-yellow school uniform ties peeping out of the white body bags.
The Pakistan Taliban, waging war in order to topple the government, immediately claimed responsibility.
“We selected the army’s school for the attack because the government is targeting our families and females,” said Taliban spokesperson Muhammad Umar Khorasani. “We want them to feel the pain.”
The Pakistani Taliban had vowed to step up attacks in response to a major army operation against the insurgents in the tribal areas in June.
So far, the Taliban have targeted mainly security forces, military bases and airports. Attacks on civilian targets with no logistical significance are relatively rare, though many children were killed in an attack on a church, also in Peshawar, last year.
Despite the crackdown this year, the military has long been accused of being too lenient towards militants who critics say are used to carry out its bidding in places such as Kashmir and Afghanistan.
Some witnesses said the gunmen addressed each other in a language they could only recognise as either Arabic or Farsi — a possible testament to the Taliban’s network of hundreds of foreign fighters holed up with them in the remote mountains on the Pakistan-Afghanistan border.
The terrorists managed to slip past the school’s tight security because at least some of them were wearing Pakistani military uniforms, the witnesses said.
Around 960 pupils and staff members were evacuated from the school attended by over 1,100 people, many of them children of army personnel.
The attack struck at the heart of Pakistan’s military establishment and could push the armed forces into a more drastic response. “These terrorists have struck the heart of the nation. But our resolve to tackle this menace has gotten a new lease of life. We will pursue these monsters and their facilitators until they are eliminated for good,” army chief Raheel Sharif said.
Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif used similarly strong words. “We will take revenge for each and every drop of our children’s blood that was spilt today,” he said.
Bajwa, the military spokesperson, suggested Afghanistan, from where Pakistan Taliban chief Maulana Fazlullah is said to be operating, would no longer be a safe haven. “We will chase even sympathisers, facilitators and abettors of these militants,” the officer said.
The Afghan Taliban, separate from the Pakistan Taliban, condemned the attack as “against the basics of Islam”.
India gesture
New Delhi responded with sensitivity, going beyond the usual platitudes. Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi spoke to Nawaz Sharif, expressed condolences and told him that India was “ready to provide all assistance during this hour of grief”.
Modi appealed to students in all schools in India to observe silence for two minutes on Wednesday as a mark of solidarity.


http://www.telegraphindia.com/1141217/jsp/frontpage/story_19224738.jsp#.VJDu9dKUeSo

Kaalaadhan: white lies & colourless truth -- Virendra Parekh. NaMo, ordinance nationalise kaalaadhan.

$
0
0
Black money, white lies and colourless truth
by Virendra Parekhon 17 Dec 2014


Has the Modi government bitten off more than it can chew on black money? Black money is a vast issue, but the current public debate is centred on the illicit wealth stashed away in foreign banks; more accurately on BJP’s promise to bring it back. No doubt this was among the most titillating promises made by Narendra Modi while campaigning for the election that swept him to power in Delhi. Since coming to power, he has reiterated it not only at home but even at international gatherings. “Repatriation of black money kept abroad is a key priority for India” he told the gathering of global worthies at Brisbane.

It is nice to hear such things, especially from Narendra Modi. He has a reputation for backing words with action. On black money, his government has not been inactive; but what it has done falls far short of high expectations aroused by its own earlier rhetoric. Its activeness could be attributed partly to increasing pressure from the Supreme Court, which is hearing a public interest petition filed by noted lawyer Ram Jethmalani in 2009. In July 2011, the Supreme Court directed the government to appoint a Special Investigation Team (SIT) to probe the issue.

By then the UPA government had received information from Germany about account holders in Liechtenstein Bank. Then again, Herve Falciani, a former employee of HSBC, Geneva, stole some data about the account holders and gave it to the French government. The French government, in turn, decided to share the details with our own government.

The court insisted that the information be disclosed to the SIT. The UPA government refused to comply, citing some provisions of the Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA) under which it claimed to have received the information. No SIT was formed. Instead the government filed a review petition asking the court to take back the judgment. After that the matter went into hibernation until the new government took over.

The very first act of the Modi Government was to appoint the SIT, which the UPA had been stalling. Under court orders, all investigations of black money stood transferred to the SIT. The Modi government also handed over to the SIT a list of all individuals with foreign bank accounts as early as June.

Some information has since transpired into the public domain, but it is sketchy and inspires little confidence about billions of dollars returning home for the benefit of India’s poor.

Putting together the bits and pieces of information released by the finance minister Arun Jaitley, SIT and Attorney General Mukul Rohatgi, we learn that there was no amount shown in 289 HSBC Geneva entries out of a total of 627, while 122 of them were repeated twice in the same list. “The SIT found that the biggest impediment in taking action was that there were no details about the operations of these accounts. It was not reflected in the list as to when these accounts were opened and what their transaction history was.” The SIT report said the Income Tax department had undertaken 150 search or survey operations against those named in the list, but prosecution proceedings were yet not finalised against them.

Details of account holders pertain to 2006 and were supplied by the French government to the Centre in 2011. Most transactions took place during 1999 and 2000. The identity of 427 account holders has been established and 250 of them have admitted to having these accounts. The government would initiate prosecution against the offenders but there is no time frame by when it would be done.

There is no doubt that the Modi government has shown greater urgency in this matter than any of its predecessors. Yet, its credibility has been damaged because, either by design or default, it is trapped in the same web of deceit crafted by the UPA government. On some important aspects, it repeats the same arguments that the previous government made.

Mr. Jailey, for example, dismissed the Opposition’s demand to disclose the names of the account holders as “suicidal course” and asserted the government would follow a “foolproof procedure” against the culprits. This is the same stand that the UPA government took. He has persisted with the argument of the Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA) and its obligation of confidentiality. It is said that the DTAA prohibits the disclosure of information received under its provisions till prosecution proceedings are started. The names could not be disclosed even to the court which was overseeing the investigation into the cases.

This was precisely the argument of the UPA, which the Supreme Court in its judgment of July 2009 overruled. Yet, the Modi government told the court that its directive to disclose names overriding the DTAA was impeding the government’s efforts to secure an Inter Governmental Agreement (IGA) with the US for exchange of banking information. The IGA has the same provisions regarding disclosure as the DTAA with the US and most other nations.

There is a double deceit here: the focus on tax and the obligation of confidentiality under the foreign treaties.

The UPA government was never serious about investigating black money, either at home or abroad. It knew where the trail of illicit wealth would lead to. While it paid lip service to the cause, not a single bit of information has been secured by its efforts. Even when information was pushed under its nose by other countries, as it were, its natural tendency was to turn its face away. Since that could not be done overtly, it resorted to ruses and subterfuges.

One such ruse was to seek information about tax evasion. It is an old one. Rajiv Gandhi government would ask the Swiss government for information about recipients of commission in the Bofors deal on the ground that they had evaded tax in India. Switzerland would reply that tax evasion in India is not an offence in Switzerland; so it could not force its banks to disclose details. The Indian government would fool the people here by pleading helplessness in the face of “rigidity” of Swiss banking law. It was a white lie. The Indian government knew all along that if information were sought under some other head (e.g. bribe), Swiss authorities would be more cooperative. 

Some years ago, a horse trainer in Pune named Hasan Ali was found to hold $8 billion in foreign banks. As details kept surfacing, finance minister Pranab Mukherjee would issue one statement after another about the tax that Ali was liable to pay. The amount of tax liability would keep rising with every statement. The finance minister would never pause to inquire whether the money really belonged to Ali, if so, how he made it; if it did not belong to Ali, whose money it was and how and why it was entrusted to him.

According to Mr. Jethmalani, the correspondence between the Government of India and the German authorities, which was supplied to him under court orders, clearly establishes that the DTAA was invoked first by Finance Minister P. Chidambaram, who sought information only about Indian taxpayers and not about the criminals who did not pay any tax at all; India deliberately did not avail of the offer made by the German government to share information with any country without cost or condition, even though Chidambaram was aware of this open offer.

Invoking DTAA in this context is another white lie. It can be nailed on several counts. First and foremost, it is not clear why DTAA is being used at all in the present context. The DTAA by definition applies to legitimate business activity. Its purpose is to ensure that businesses and businessmen with operations in more than one country are not made to pay tax on the same income in both countries. But the money we are discussing is anything but legitimate. It is nothing short of loot or embezzlement. Its origin and legitimacy of its ownership are far more important than tax liability attached to it. It would be far more pertinent to invoke United Nations Convention against Corruption (UNCAC).

Secondly, it is important to understand that the 627 HSBC account holders’ names were not provided to us under the provisions of any Double Taxation Avoidance Treaty. So, they do not attract the confidentiality requirement. The DTAA only applies when information is called under Section 90 of the Income Tax Act of India dealing with persons who on the same income are liable to pay tax in two or more countries.

Finally, the hard fact is that the DTAA with France does not prohibit disclosure of information on the account holders in HSBC, Geneva, received from France in public court proceedings. The agreement stipulates that if originally the information was secret in the hands of France (the sender) it shall be kept secret by India (the receiver). Now, the names were not a secret for France; otherwise, why would it share them with India? And Indian law permits their disclosure to the court. They would presumably be secret in Switzerland, but that country has not furnished any information so far.

Quite a few supporters of the current dispensation are unhappy with the fact that the NDA government has chosen to tread the same path as the UPA government, although there was, and still is, a better alternative available to it.

That alternative was articulated years ago by none other than Mr. Ajit Doval, now the National Security Adviser. In an article “India’s Plundered Money Abroad - Can We Get It Back?” published in February 2011, he outlined a two-step action plan.

The government of India should enact a law to declare itself as the sole owner and beneficiary of all Indian monies, assets and bank accounts held abroad by or the dependants of Indian nationals without due declaration to the Indian authorities. Exception may be made for those who can prove that the assets held by them were acquired through proper means and the non-declaration was merely a technical default. On the strength of this law, the Government of India can ask the world governments and foreign banks, like Swiss Banks, to recognise the Indian government as the beneficiary of the undeclared wealth and freeze the accounts till the currents owners prove that they had acquired it by fair and lawful means.  

It could inform them that a large part of this wealth may have its origin in criminal activities like drug traffic, terrorist funding, ransom, fraud, extortion, misappropriation of government funds, cheating, organised crime, etc.

Secondly, the government should suo moto register an omnibus criminal complaint against unidentified persons who have been indulging in criminal activities and illegally transferring the money to tax havens abroad. The case may be given to a special team of the CBI and investigated under supervision of the Supreme Court. Registration of the criminal case will enable the investigation agencies to summon people for questioning, interrogate suspected persons, seize incriminating documents, conduct raids, make arrests, examine documents etc. It would also enable the government to seek assistance of foreign police and also approach foreign banks and their governments for information about the money trails as they pertain to criminal cases.

The law and the criminal complaint suggested by Mr. Doval should have been the first steps to be taken by the finance ministry. Even now, such a course of action is open to it.

However, it is highly doubtful if such an exercise would yield any worthwhile results. Black money stashed abroad has been subject of a noisy public debate for about eight years. That period is long enough, more than enough, for the crooks to become alert and transfer the money to safer places. Switzerland is known even to the layman. But there are about two dozen countries that provide shelter and secrecy to unaccounted wealth. There is a strong possibility that the big fish have already cleaned up and closed their accounts long back. Why should any country volunteer information about accounts that ceased to exist years ago?

Such account holders would include top political leaders cutting across party lines, business houses that fund major political parties and mafia leaders. They might already have struck deals with the government that would save them from too onerous consequences. The 250 people who have admitted to holding accounts abroad, would they wait until they are publicly named, prosecuted and punished?

It may be possible to embarrass some parties, leaders and public figures by disclosing names. But it is unrealistic to expect that such an exercise would lead to an avalanche of dollars and end of India’s poverty?

In the common man’s imagination, there are pots of dollars and valuables hidden away in dark chambers in distant lands which India’s brave officers would fetch home. The reality is quite different. To begin with, the illicit wealth need not be held as cash lying in an “account”. It can take the form of a high-end property in Alps or Manhattan, a cruise ship floating on the Mediterranean or shares of a blue-chip company held through an offshore fund manager.

The unaccounted money, like legitimate money, is not held captive at one place; it gets transferred from place to place in search of better returns. When Indian stock markets are booming, when Indian bonds offer much higher yield than, say, US treasury, and when the economy is set to turn the corner, the best course of action will be to invest it in India, through offshore entities if necessary. Just look up the inflow of FII investments in stocks and bonds, the rigidly high real estate prices even when there is no demand, spurt in exports of select items defying global trends.

Probably the government has realized this. Six months into office, Mr. Modi has discovered that this is too serious an issue to be sorted out in 100 days. The climb down has begun. First, Mr. Modi said in a radio interview that the quantum of black money kept in foreign bank accounts is not known to anybody. Then there were media reports suggesting that the PMO has prepared a note stating that there is no legal mechanism to bring back the black money stashed in foreign countries to India. The Revenue Secretary has recently stated that the problem of domestic black money is far more critical than overseas black money. The finance minister Arun Jaitley has said, following the SIT recommendation, that India would seek a change in the treaties with certain countries, which would allow repatriation of black money. All this suggests that the debate may become less sensational but more sensible in the months to come.    
http://vijayvaani.com/ArticleDisplay.aspx?aid=3426

Missionaries in India: Conversion or Coercion? -- Philip Goldberg. Answer: Ghar wapasi (homecoming)

$
0
0




Imagine you're poor and living in a rural area. Your child gets sick. You manage to transport her to a hospital or clinic. To your relief, the condition is treatable. But the cost of treatment is not just beyond your means, it's beyond your imagining. However, says the kindly health care worker, you can get the treatment free of charge. All you have to do is renounce the centuries-old traditions of your people and convert to a foreign religion.
Such offers are being made to desperate people in the villages and tribal areas of India.
I just returned from a month in that country, to mark the Indian publication of my book, American Veda. In the 18 cities I visited, the most frequently mentioned topic was the shady tactics of certain missionaries.
Not all of them, mind you. Not the intrepid souls who work selflessly to help the poor, the afflicted, and the illiterate, in the spirit of their savior's exhortation to serve "the least of these." Such missionaries have been welcome in India for centuries, and the Hindus I spoke to are grateful for their good works. What is causing consternation and anger is a new breed of zealots, heavily financed by American fundamentalists, who seem driven to pile up numbers like door-to-door salesmen racking up commissions. Determined, fervent, and creative in pursuit of souls to save, they sound more like the snake-oil hucksters of legend than servants of Christ.
Targeting mainly the impoverished and uneducated, some of their tactics make the hospital bargain I described earlier look as reputable as ordering a book from Amazon. I was told of missionaries giving people temporary jobs in return for converting, and then threatening them with job loss -- not to mention eternal damnation -- if they reconvert to Hinduism. Families have apparently been torn apart because the converts are made to disassociate from the heathen.
I heard about missionaries who dress in orange robes to look like swamis. Gullible and desperate villagers are told that their traditional gods are actually corrupted versions of Christ; that the venerable saints and sages of India's past were really Christians; that the three horizontal stripes traditionally drawn on the foreheads of Shiva devotees stand for the Holy Trinity; that the Upanishadic prayer that includes "Lead us from darkness to light" was meant as a cry for Jesus to save them.
A mother is sick? A father loses his source of income and can't feed his family? The bus filled with youngsters suddenly "stalls" on a dangerous mountain road? Well, say the missionaries, try praying to your Hindu gods. Hmmm, imagine that: nothing changes. Well then, see what happens if you pray to Jesus. Wow! Lo and behold! The mother receives medicine. The father gets a one-day job that puts rice on the table. The bus engine starts again! If one prayer to Jesus produces miracles like those, imagine what converting will do!
I heard about people being told that their misfortune derives from their worship of Hindu deities, because the idols are really forms of the Devil; about village strongmen being paid to coerce conversions from other villagers; about women given a choice of walking a mile to haul water from their usual source or using the new well conveniently dug in front of a church. The price? Conversion, of course.
I don't know if these egregious actions are commonplace or rarities. I do know that they are dishonorable. They're about coercion, not spiritual conversion; extortion, not the exchange of ideas. And, if I may say so as a non-Christian, they are an affront to Jesus, whom every Hindu I've ever met regards as a holy man of the highest order if not an incarnation of God. I can't help thinking that he would be as outraged by the deception being perpetrated in his name as he was about the moneylenders in the temple.
I told people in India that most American Christians would be appalled if they knew what was being done by their overly aggressive brethren. I was tempted to wait until after Christmas to test that thesis, but I decided that this season of goodwill might be the ideal time. So, what do you think, my Christian sisters and brothers? Is there some cosmic war for souls going on, in which anything goes? Or are there rules of engagement that civilized people should observe? What would Jesus say?

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/philip-goldberg/missionaries-in-india_b_4470448.html

When will India start to honour those who fought in its name? -- Rajeev Chandrasekhar

$
0
0

When will India start to honour those who fought in its name? 

December 16, 1971, is an unforgettable date for anyone who lived through the Bangladesh War.
Vijay Diwas, as the day is known, commemorates not just an absolute military triumph, unparalleled in modern Indian history, but also the triumph and heroism of the professional Indian soldier. 
Three-thousand, eight-hundred and forty-three Indian soldiers died in 1971. About three times that number, 9,851, were injured. 
The war also saw 1,313 Indian soldiers receiving gallantry awards, many posthumously. Four were awarded India’s highest battle honour, the Param Vir Chakra. 
These four men represented the best of India, and yet they came from diverse backgrounds. 
Lance Naik Albert Ekka was born in a small village near Ranchi. 
Second Lieutenant Arun Khetarpal from Pune, was just 21 when he died in his tank, having single-handedly crippled the Pakistani armoured advance at the Battle of Basantar. 
Leadership 
Flying Officer Nirmaljit Singh Sekhon, literally the Flying Sikh, defended the skies above Srinagar, taking on and outgunning F-86 Sabres in his slower and smaller Gnat. 
Finally, there was Major Hoshiar Singh, who braved heavy shelling and went trench to trench, urging his men to fight on and capture an important Pakistani position in the Shakargarh Sector.
What motivated these men and thousand others? Under the inspiring leadership of men like Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw, these men weren’t just “doing a job”; they were going well beyond the call of duty, showing extraordinary calm and determination and sheer, audacious bravery to fulfil the national objective despite overwhelming odds. 
It is important to recall and remember these achievements, and distinguish this from the self-congratulation of a political and sarkari bandobast on every Vijay Diwas. 
Politicians and bureaucrats in the Ministry of Defence have essentially spent the past four decades riding on the valour, the grit and the hard-won successes of those heroes of 1971. 
And how have they appreciated these men? The general who led us in 1971, Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw, was an authentic Indian legend. 
When he died in 2008, the Government of that time did dishonour. Let alone their presence, no wreaths were placed on behalf of the President and the Prime Minister. The Defence Minister was too busy with political meetings in Delhi. Instead, he sent his Minister of State – the most senior government representative at Sam Manekshaw’s funeral. 
Was this an unconscionable, one-off oversight? I would argue it betrayed a certain attitude and mind-set that has long since treated soldiers as cannon fodder to be used and discarded. 
Let me tell you another story, also from 1971, though not from the war. 
It begins with an earlier war, that of 1965, and with the martyrdom of Babaji Jadhav, a jawan of the Maratha Light Infantry, who was killed in Jammu & Kashmir. 
Dispute 
He left behind a pregnant wife, so traumatised that a few months later she delivered a stillborn child. 
Life was hard for this martyr’s widow. She began with menial jobs, including one as a tailor’s assistant. Later, she became a teacher in a village primary school. 
Just before he died, Babaji had applied for an agricultural plot under a scheme that gave soldiers priority while allotting government land to landless peasants. 
Indira Jadhav, Babaji’s widow, pursued the case. It took her six years, until 1971, to get an assurance that the Government’s promise to her husband would be honoured. 
In July 2014 Indira Jadhav had approached the Bombay High Court. Not only had she not got an inch of the promised land, she was being asked to pay market rates – 2014 rates – by the district administration of Ratnagiri. 
At the end of her wits, the lady went to court. She must have asked herself a hundred times: is this the country and people my husband fought and died for? 
In 2010, the case of Pushpa Vanthi came to light. Living in Meerut, this 90-year-old widow of a retired Major was being paid a monthly pension of Rs 80. She was entitled to Rs 27,000 and had been battling the Ministry of Defence for 13 years, since her husband’s death. 
She believed her husband died of war wounds sustained years earlier. The Ministry claimed he died of an illness not related to the wounds. 
As the dispute festered, the due pension was held up – and a soldier’s grieving widow was left to survive on Rs 20 a week. 
Appalled and ashamed, my foundation – The Flags of Honour Foundation – stepped in and offered to pay a monthly stipend to Pushpa Vanthi. It was the least we could do. 
Grievances 
Why should our old soldiers and their families, the wives and dependents of our martyrs, continue to be the step-children of Vijay Diwas? 
If we are to address this, the new Defence Minister has to take up as his mandate a set of long-pending demands and grievances of the Armed Forces. 
The setting up of a Veterans’ Commission, as a statutory institution to which old soldiers and their families – such as Indira Jadhav and Pushpa Vanthi – can go for help, is overdue. So is a uniform policy on gallantry award winners. 
Currently, this varies from state to state. Clear, rigorous and expeditious implementation of the One Rank, One Pension policy, and a mechanism to look into the problems of disabled soldiers, for a lifetime, are other essentials. 
We owe this to the men and women who defend us. It is the unfinished business of Vijay Diwas year after year for the past 43 years. 
The writer is a Rajya Sabha MP 
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/indiahome/indianews/article-2875141/When-India-start-honour-fought-name.html

Why not a Victory in Bangladesh Day?

December 16, 2014 14:07 IST
'The failure to remember the martyrs on a grand scale is a national problem. As a nation-State, India time and again fails to honour its true heroes: The men in uniform, says Nitin A Gokhale.
Then Army Chief General Sam Maneckshaw with his troops during the 1971 War.On Tuesday, December 16, morning, Defence Minister Manohar Parrikar, accompanied by the three service chiefs, followed a ritual that has become a practice for the past 42 years: Laying a wreath at the Amar Jawan Jyoti, paying tribute to the fallen soldiers in the 1971 war.
After that, it's business as usual.
Parrikar has been defence minister for less than two months, so to expect him to try and change the well-established procedure is unrealistic.
The failure to remember the martyrs on a grand scale is a national problem. As a nation-State, India time and again fails to honour its true heroes: The men in uniform.
It is therefore no surprise that December 16, the original Vijay Diwas, designated so after winning the war in 1971, is all but forgotten.
Well, someone can say we celebrate the Kargil Vijay Diwas on July 26, so what's the big deal?
Yes, Kargil is remembered chiefly because it was India's first televised war, but in doing so there is no reason why India's finest politico-military victory should be so completely forgotten.
Image: Then Army Chief General (later Field Marshal) Sam Maneckshaw with his troops during the 1971 War.
How many of us remember that for the first time after World War II a nation was created through a combination of people's resistance and military action?
The Mukti Bahini played a stellar role in harassing and softening up the Pakistani army in what was then East Pakistan, but it was the Indian military that dealt the decisive blow in December 1971 to defeat a numerically superior adversary.
Over 3,000 Indian soldiers made the supreme sacrifice. Nearly 10,000 soldiers were wounded. 93,000 PoWs were taken.
Yet, in our collective consciousness, 1971 is but a blurred memory.
How many of us remember for instance that for the first time after World War II, a large-scale airborne assault was launched by Indian paratroopers, hastening the end of the war?
Do we even remember the daring raid by the missile boats on the Karachi harbour that immobilised West Pakistan?
Mrs Sekhon receives the Param Vir Chakra her husband Flying Officer Nirmal Jit Singh Sekhon won for his courage from President V V Giri.We perhaps don't even know that the Indian Air Force won its only Param Vir Chakra, thanks to the daring of the young fighter pilot named Nirmal Jit Singh Shekhon who in his tiny Gnat combat plane, took on the mighty Sabres and forced them to turn back during an attack on the Srinagar airbase.
We have surely forgotten the exploits of Albert Ekka and Arun Khetrapal, two more Param Vir Chakra winners in the 1971 war.
Image: Mrs Sekhon receives the Param Vir Chakra her husband Flying Officer Nirmal Jit Singh Sekhon won for his courage in the 1971 War from then President V V Giri.
If we don't remember them, we surely don't recall smaller, but equally significant contribution of countless soldiers.
For instance, had it not been for a young paratrooper Captain P K Ghosh, who spent 10 days behind enemy lines, the para-drop would not have gone like clockwork.
Or of many 'trainers' and 'liaison officers' of the Border Security Force and the Research and Analysis Wing who risked their lives to facilitate a resistance movement inside East Pakistan once the Mukti Bahini got off the ground.
A nation that does not remember the valour of its soldiers and protectors, is doomed to fail. The sheer courage displayed by Major (later Major General) Ian Cardozo in cutting off his own leg after he stepped on a landmine, post the termination of the conflict, is not known as widely as it should be.
The daring displayed by Captain (later Colonel) Ashok Tara in rescuing Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rehman's family members (including current Bangladesh Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina) from the clutches of a Pakistani army group, is not told often enough.
Just as Pakistan does not and cannot live down its defeat in 1971 and therefore continues to wage a proxy war, India should not let the memory of that spectacular victory fall through the cracks.
The world celebrates Victory in Europe Day or VE Day with great pomp and show. Even the contribution of Indian soldiers in World War I has been hailed across the globe and commemorated in different capitals throughout 2014.
So why not designate December 16 Victory in Bangladesh Day or VB Day every year? In doing so, India will be honouring itself.
Nitin A Gokhale is one of India's best-informed commentators on national security issues.

http://www.rediff.com/news/column/why-not-a-victory-in-bangladesh-day/20141216.htm

Desert war on ISIS from a floating city of USA -- Eric Schmitt. A stunning report. NaMo, announce United Indian Ocean States.

$
0
0
Continue reading the main storySlide Show
SLIDE SHOW|12 Photos

Attacking ISIS, From 5 Acres of U.S. Territory

Attacking ISIS, From 5 Acres of U.S. Territory

CreditTyler Hicks/The New York Times
Continue reading the main storyShare This Page
ABOARD THE U.S.S. CARL VINSON, in the Persian Gulf — More than a dozen Navy F/A-18 warplanes roar off this aircraft carrier every day to attack Islamic State targets in support of Iraqi troops battling to regain ground lost to the militants in June.
These Navy pilots face an array of lethal risks during their six-hour round-trip missions. Surface-to-air missiles and other enemy fire lurk below, as the downing of an Iraqi military helicopter late Friday underscored. About 60 percent of the aircrews are still learning the ropes on their first combat tours.
The United States-led coalition improvises how the Iraqis call in airstrikes: Iraqi troops talk by radio to American controllers at Iraqi command centers, who in turn talk to the Navy pilots to help pinpoint what to hit. Senior commanders have said that placing American spotters with the Iraqi troops would be more effective, but they have yet to recommend that step knowing that President Obama opposes it.
In the initial weeks of an air campaign that started in August, Iraq’s troops were tentative. Fighters from the Islamic State, also called ISIS or ISIL, quickly learned not to move in large numbers to avoid being struck. Three out of every four missions still return with their bombs for lack of approved targets.
Continue reading the main story

GRAPHIC

Areas Under ISIS Control

A visual guide to the crisis in Iraq and Syria.
 OPEN GRAPHIC
But in recent days, the Iraqis have been advancing, forcing ISIS to fight more in the open. The airstrikes are severing the militants’ supply lines, killing some top leaders and crimping their ability to pump and ship the oil that they control.
“It wasn’t going so well there for a while, but the momentum seems to have reversed,” said Cmdr. Eric Doyle, a 41-year-old F/A-18 Hornet pilot from Houston who also flew combat missions in the Iraq and Afghanistan wars.
About one quarter of the 1,200 total airstrikes in Iraq and Syria so far have been flown off a carrier — the other missions began from bases around the gulf — an enduring symbol of American power in the Middle East.
After ISIS fighters rolled south into Mosul six months ago and threatened Baghdad, the Pentagon rushed the carrier George H.W. Bush to the Persian Gulf from the coast of Pakistan, where it was flying missions in support of American troops in Afghanistan.
Within two days, the carrier was sending surveillance and reconnaissance flights over Iraq and Syria. It was weeks before the United States ironed out arrangements with regional allies to allow land-based planes to carry out strikes. The Vinson relieved the Bush in mid-October, and will stay until next spring.
“You don’t have to ask anybody for permission to use a carrier,” said Vice Adm. John W. Miller, commander of the Navy’s Fifth Fleet in Bahrain. “It’s five acres of sovereign U.S. territory.”
This ship has an unusual place in the annals of the campaign against terrorism. Some of the first airstrikes of the Afghan war in October 2001 were by jets from the Vinson; nearly a decade later, it was here that Navy SEALs brought Osama bin Laden’s body after the raid in Pakistan, and buried it at sea after religious rites on the lower hangar deck.
The flight deck is the bustling hub of this nuclear-powered behemoth, which is home to 5,200 sailors and officers for nearly 10 months at a time. Sailors in light helmets and goggles, mostly in their early 20s, scurry about in vests and long-sleeve shirts color-coded to their jobs — red shirts handle bombs, purple shirts handle fuel, yellow shirts handle the flights.
Racks of bombs and missiles rise from elevators below deck amid the din. MH-60 Seahawk search-and-rescue helicopters buzz overhead on their way out to sea.
It is like a crowded suburban parking lot, except these are $57 million jets taxiing for takeoff with 500-pound laser-guided bombs tucked under their wings. The slightest misstep around these high-performance jets and turboprop planes could be fatal. “Beware of Jet Blast, Propellers and Rotors” is emblazoned in large yellow letters on the ship’s superstructure, lest anyone forget.
Continue reading the main storyVideo
PLAY VIDEO|5:20

The Evolution of ISIS

The Evolution of ISIS

Key points in the terror group’s rapid growth and the slowing of its advance as it faces international airstrikes and local resistance.
 Video by Quynhanh Do on Publish DateDecember 13, 2014. Photo by Islamic State.
It is a dangerous business, even when the ship is not at war. In September, while training in the western Pacific, two F/A-18s from the Vinson collided in midair soon after takeoff. One pilot was rescued in the accident, but the other was killed. His body was never found in waters nearly three miles deep.
About 20 percent of the 100 daily flights are strike missions into Iraq and Syria. The others are a mix of training, supply, reconnaissance and other flights, usually between 10:30 a.m. and 11 p.m.
About an hour before takeoff, fighter pilots in flight suits stride to their planes for a final inspection. Tiny black bombs are stenciled below the cockpit for each weapon dropped from that aircraft. A giant steam-powered catapult then hurls the jets off the ship, from a dead start to more than 125 miles an hour in less than three seconds.
By then, the pilots have studied their routes, the weather and the targets assigned by an American air command center in Qatar, a tiny gulf state. Targeting specialists have selected bombs big enough to do the job but mindful of the risk to civilians.
The allied jets are operating under some of the strictest rules intended to prevent civilian casualties in modern warfare. “If there’s any doubt, we do not drop ordnance,” said Capt. Matt Leahey, a 44-year-old Naval Academy graduate from Lewiston, Me., who commands the 2,100 personnel and 63 aircraft in the carrier’s air wing.
The Vinson has steamed to the northern part of the gulf to shorten flight times as much as possible, but it is still 450 miles to Baghdad and much farther to Syria. The F/A-18s burn 5,700 gallons of fuel on a typical mission, and pilots must refuel in midair three or four times.
The jets fly well above 20,000 feet, out of the range of most antiaircraft guns. ISIS has surface-to-air missiles and has downed a few Iraqi helicopters, so pilots cannot fly as low as they would like to get the best look at their targets. “Manpads are a real threat,” said Commander Doyle, referring to Man-Portable Air Defense Systems.
In some cases, pilots are striking specific, planned targets such as headquarters buildings. But most of the Vinson’s missions are targets of opportunity while safeguarding Iraqi troops below.
Pilots fly over designated grid areas, typically 60 miles square, searching for fighters, artillery and other signs of the enemy. An aerial armada of surveillance planes with names like Joint Stars and Rivet Joint track militant movements on the ground and intercept their electronic communications, feeding a steady stream of information to pilots.
“It can be pretty boring, then all of sudden it gets heated and you’ve got a whole lot of work to do in 120 seconds,” said Commander Doyle, who has flown eight strike missions so far. “We’re trying to find things and kill them.”
Working with the American air controllers in the Iraqi command centers — special operations troops in contact with Iraqi or Kurdish ground troops — pilots say they are aiming to weaken ISIS’ war machine in a fight they caution could take months or even years.
“We’re taking away the enemy’s ability to reinforce and resupply,” said Lt. Adam Bryan, 31, an F/A-18 Super Hornet pilot from northwestern Connecticut. “It’s a pretty dynamic situation.”

http://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/16/world/middleeast/attacking-isis-from-an-american-aircraft-carrier.html?emc=eta1&_r=1

Make in India makes sense, Dr. Rajan -- Sanjeev Nayyar. Mind your RBI business, Rajan, scrap PNotes first -- Kalyan

$
0
0
Dec 17, 2014

Make in India makes sense, Dr Rajan; countries cannot be run by economic theory alone

By Sanjeev Nayyar
The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) Governor Raghuram Rajan recently said the following: “There is a danger when we discuss ‘Make in India’ of assuming it means a focus on manufacturing, an attempt to follow the export-led growth path that China followed. I am...cautioning against picking a particular sector such as manufacturing for encouragement, simply because it has worked well for China. India is different, and developing at a different time, and we should be agnostic about what will work.”
Excerpts from a Business Standard (BS) editorial of 15 December have this to say: “Make in India sounds too close to import substitution and old-style industrial policy for comfort. Further, it has been reported that the prime minister himself has asked secretaries to the government to appraise imports on a quarterly basis and work out how to reduce them.”
These words have raised doubts on the Prime Minister’s Make in India (MII) campaign. Using examples, this article throws light on what MII actually means.
One, according to this Mint report, India imported $31 billion worth of electronic items in 2013-14, including $10.9 billion of mobile phones. This could rise to $296 billion by 2020 – which could surpass even our oil import bill. This is simply unsustainable, unless a part of the import demand is met by domestic production.
MII means that this equipment should also be made in India. After all why, should India’s telecom backbone be made in China? “Now, it has been reported that the National Security Council (NSC) has specifically warned that imports from China, which are over half of imports in the relevant category of telecom equipment, pose significant national security hazards.”
As and when a domestic manufacturer achieves scale, it can begin to export. If Bharti Airtel had built a plant to manufacture telecom products and equipment to cater to its domestic needs, it could have sourced some of it for their Africa operations from India. Here MII combines catering to domestic and export markets.
Two, the programme of blending ethanol with fuel has failed to take off. MII means allowing oil marketing companies (OMCs) to set up 100 percent ethanol plants (these plants can make ethanol directly from cane). This way farmers can sell cane directly to the OMCs, and would be paid promptly, saving the country dollars.
Three, according to this report, “A committee has been set up to evaluate which Indian defence shipyards can build six high-tech, conventional submarines under Project 75I at an estimated cost of Rs 50,000 crore”.
MII means orders are given to Indian companies rather than imported from, say, Germany. This would create jobs, and the expertise to build submarines which could earn from exports too. In defence, exports are invariably linked to gains in foreign policy.
Four, according to a 2014 Forbes India report, 2.6 lakh Indian students spent Rs 27,000 crore to study abroad. Indians are paying the salaries of foreign teachers and sustaining foreign universities.
MII means that the government (state governments have a key role to play) creates a framework that encourages the setting up of high quality educational institutions which can attract more students in India. Thus, even if 40 percent of students stay back to study in India, imagine the multiplier effect of Rs 10,800 crore of educational spending!
Five, according to this report by the Indian Electrical & Electronics Manufacturers Association, “during the years 2005-06 to 2012-13, India's imports of electrical equipment have increased at a compound annual growth (CAGR) of 24.67 percent in rupee terms, touching Rs 64,674 crore in 2012-13.”. Further, China’s share in Indian imports of such equipment stood at 44.92 percent. This has resulted in under-utilisation of domestic capacity, loss of employment and possibly NPAs for PSU banks.
MII means providing domestic industry with a level playing field. There is no harm in raising tariffs if the exporting country gives subsidies which help its companies have an unreasonable competitive advantage. Import substitution through a diktat will not work but taking concrete steps to improve competitiveness will. Simultaneously, agreements with private power producers should support domestic industry.
Six, “Globally, medical tourism is estimated to be a $100-billion market, of which the US has the lion’s share in value terms — if not in terms of the number of patients”.
MII means getting more foreign patients to India for treatment. It has huge employment potential and improves India’s brand equity. Also, ObamaCare is fast ensuring that healthcare companies are migrating patients to make medicare cheaper; the depreciating rupee makes Indian medical tourism more viable.
Seven, according to this Hindu report,  “Markets across Indian towns and cities are flooded with Chinese products, more so around festivals such as Deepavali. From furniture and gadgets to industrial equipment, India is importing almost all products from its neighbour, even yarn for saris”. China used a low-cost production strategy to ensure that the manufacture of such products became unviable in the US. This affected the SME sector, resulting in a loss of jobs and adversely impacting the trade deficit.
MII means the government has to help India’s SME sector become competitive so Indian consumers buy their products. This requires reform of labour and factory laws, redefining financial limits for SMEs, etc.
A Myanmar trader at the border town of Moreh recently told this writer that the quality of Indian cycles and plastic crockery was far superior to China’s, but for customers it is all about price. The game is all about volumes, per unit cost and quality.
Eight, in the 1980s, India imported the Bofors gun. The subsequent payoffs controversy ensured that no more imports were permitted to the detriment of the Indian Army. According to this Economic Times report, Bharat Forge’s joint venture with Elbit Systems will initially work on a 155mm howitzer modernisation programme. The company has also built a howitzer from scratch that has far greater firepower than even the Bofors gun that's currently in use.
MII means working with a foreign partner for the domestic production of howitzers.
Nine, according to a commerce ministry strategy paper, “The burgeoning imports of edible oils, pulses, fertilisers, coal and now iron ore, even cell phone instruments, have all benefited from domestic industrial policy, which at best was negligent, or worse, downright hostile” (to domestic manufacturers).
MII means motivating farmers to produce edible oils and pulses and creating a policy that motivates industry to set up new fertiliser plants.
If understood and implemented correctly, Make in India is a timely campaign. We cannot rely on exports in services and remittances alone to fund the trade deficit.
The above examples, though not exhaustive, seek to create an Indian model for manufacture, ie based on our unique needs.
However, there is no gain in saying that the government needs to make the business environment friendly and reduce the costs of doing business. At the same time industry must not leave everything to the government.
Nations cannot be driven by economic theory alone. India needs an integrated approach that combines economics, national strategy and security.
The author is an independent columnist
http://firstbiz.firstpost.com/economy/make-india-makes-sense-dr-rajan-countries-run-economic-theory-alone-113580.html

India Ideas Conclave, 2014 in Goa from December 19

$
0
0

India Ideas Conclave, 2014 in Goa from December 19

DEC 17, 2014
The three-day conclave, which starts from December 19 has several sub-themes on which lectures, panel discussions and symposia will be held.
The three-day conclave, which starts from December 19 has several sub-themes on which lectures, panel discussions and symposia will be held.

India Foundation, an independent research centre on Indian polity, in association with Government of Goa is organising India Ideas Conclave, 2014 in Goa on the central theme of ‘Integral Human Development’.

The Conclave will bring together brilliant minds across disciplines that impact human affairs. More than 70 eminent scholars and thinkers will address a select group of over 400 participants that include eminent academics, global CEOs, renowned scientists, technologists, senior political thinkers and practitioners and media luminaries.

Prominent speakers of the conclave include Union Ministers Sushma Swaraj, Ravi Shankar Prasad, Piyush Goyal, Nirmala Sitharaman; Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan, senior BJP leaders Subramanian Swamy, MJ Akbar, spiritual leader Sri Sri Ravi Shankar, Convener of Hindu Acharya Dharma Sabha Swami Dayananda Saraswati, RSS Sahsarkaryavaha Dattatreya Hosabale; Sri Lankan Minister for Water Supply and Drainage Dinesh Gunawardane, former Prime Minister of Slovenia Alojz Peterele, former CAG Vinod Rai, former Prime Minister of Jordan Abdelsalam Al-Majali, Former Prime Minister of Bhutan Dasho Jigmi Y Thinley and former Prime Minister of Netherlands Ruud Lubbers.

The three-day conclave, which starts from December 19 has several sub-themes on which lectures, panel discussions and symposia will be held. They include Role of politics in integral development, Connecting the continents on shared values, Dialogue between civilisations, Role of business in integral development, Role of faith leaders in imparting values and Environment & humanism.  The Conclave will host critical keynote lectures, high-octane debates, dynamic panel discussions, informed seminars and enlightening book discussions and releases.

“India Ideas Conclave – 2014 is India’s most eclectic and thought-provoking platform for global thought leaders and renowned subject matter experts to discuss cutting edge ideas in various fields of human development,” reads the website of India Foundation.

http://www.niticentral.com/2014/12/17/india-ideas-conclave-2014-goa-december-19-291809.html

CBI forcing me to name CM: Madan. CPM leaderless, though cadre has overome fear of Mamata mobs

$
0
0
Wednesday , December 17 , 2014 |

CBI forcing me to name CM: Madan
Record voice? Court says ‘no’

Calcutta, Dec 16: Madan Mitra today accused the CBI of coercing him to name Mamata Banerjee as one of the beneficiaries of Saradha’s cash, handing his party the chance to intensify its protests against his arrest.
“The CBI is forcing me to name Mamata Banerjee…. Some 50-odd people are threatening me. They are asking me to name people from the party. The CBI is terrorising me,” the sports and transport minister said in the CBI court at Alipore while pleading for bail.
Mitra’s allegation came within hours of Trinamul MPs staging a walkout in Parliament to protest the “misuse” of the CBI in the Saradha probe.
A CBI source contested Mitra’s claims, saying the agency had not deviated from the norms that protect an accused in custody.
“One of Mitra’s lawyers has been visiting him every day. Had we been coercing him, why did his lawyer not raise the issue in court today? Why was there no word from him on these lines?” asked a senior CBI officer.
CBI sources said the minister might have made the allegation in the courtroom to send the message to his party leadership that he was not buckling under pressure.
Some senior Trinamul leaders said the minister’s statements, which stunned the packed courtroom into silence, would become the rallying point to raise the pitch against the BJP government.
“What Madan said in court is a pointer to how the country’s premiere investigative agency has been reduced to a tool in the hands of political parties in power. A meeting has been called and we will soon hit the streets,” a senior Trinamul leader said.
In the court, Mitra’s appeal against police custody was turned down and his remand extended by three days.
“They (CBI) are trying to mentally murder me. Am I a thief? Am I a robber? I am shattered,” Mitra said in a low but clear and unwavering voice.
“They are trying to record my voice forcibly, using a laptop. They are pressing my vocal cords. Sir, I am not well. I have problems of sleep apnoea and am passing blood through urine. I am being treated for psychiatric problems at the Institute of Psychiatry,” he added.
Arguing for his bail, Mitra said his family has been living in Calcutta for long and added that he would not flee. He named two SSKM doctors who were treating him.
“I will accept whatever punishment you will give but please don’t send me to police custody,” Mitra said.
After hearing the lawyers of the CBI and Mitra for over three hours, judge Haradhan Mukherjee remanded the minister in police custody till December 19. The judge, however, turned down a CBI plea to allow it to record Mitra’s voice for the probe.
The hearing began with the central agency claiming to have seized some “electronic data”, which would be sent to a forensic laboratory for tests.
“We need to record the minister’s voice to check the veracity of the evidence collected. The data have revealed facts that need to be examined,” said Partha Sarathi Dutta, the CBI counsel.
Mitra’s lawyers said one could not be forced to agree to a voice test and that under no circumstance could an accused be coerced to give evidence that could go against him.
Late tonight, CBI sources said they could move a higher court, questioning whether an additional chief judicial magistrate of a lower court could pass an order restraining the agency from collecting a voice sample.
Contempt plea
A contempt application was filed in the Supreme Court today seeking action against Mamata Banerjee and her cabinet colleagues Aroop Biswas and Arup Roy for allegedly instigating Trinamul workers to protest the arrest of party leaders in the Saradha scam.

http://www.telegraphindia.com/1141217/jsp/bengal/story_19224471.jsp#.VJGWetKUeSo

Cadres conquer fear but CPM leaders disappoint

Calcutta, Dec. 16: The cadres have overcome their fear of Trinamul but most of their leaders let them down.
“Trinamul-er bhoita kete gechhe, tai elam (The fear of Trinamul is no longer there, so we came),” said Barrackpore resident Nitai Das while CPM state secretary Biman Bose was addressing a gathering of around 80,000 people at the Shahid Minar grounds today.
Das is not a CPM cardholder. The self-employed 30-something belongs to a family of Left loyalists in a North 24-Parganas constituency that had been a red bastion till Trinamul’s Dinesh Trivedi triumphed over seven-time Barrackpore MP Tarit Topdar in the 2009 Lok Sabha polls.
“I did not take the risk of coming to last year’s Brigade rally as I was apprehensive about the fallout. But I think that phase of fear is over,” he said.
The fear among Left cadres because of Trinamul’s “terror tactics” seems to have ebbed, Alimuddin Street sources said. Today’s turnout, they said, bore testimony to that. The rally was held by the CPM’s North 24-Parganas unit to protest “ceaseless Trinamul attacks” and the murders of 18 cadres in the district in the past year.
Although the CPM had initially planned to hold the rally in front of Victoria House in Esplanade, the party agreed to shift it to the Shahid Minar grounds after the police denied permission to use the first venue.
Amid questions on whether the retreat exposed the CPM’s weakness at a time the BJP won a court battle against the government after being denied the use of the Esplanade venue, the attendance today satisfied the leadership.
“We will hold a rally at Brigade in March and break all records,” thundered Opposition leader Surjya Kanta Mishra, the last speaker.
Mishra’s voice was brimming with confidence, which was missing till a few months ago. The fact that people like Das said they were no longer afraid of Trinamul was the biggest takeaway for the beleaguered CPM.
Although party supporters turned up in hordes to make the rally a success, some in the audience said the leaders let them down, a pointer to the CPM’s biggest problem — lack of leadership.
The absence of Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee and ailing district secretary Gautam Deb, whose 10-minute speech was shown on a screen at the rally, disappointed the gathering. A lacklustre speech by party secretary Bose and the indecision over who to be attacked more — Trinamul or the BJP — did not find much appeal.
Many in the crowd were of the opinion that Trinamul and Mamata Banerjee were enemy No. 1 but most speakers, especially Bose, spent more time elaborating on the “dangers of the BJP’s communal politics” and highlighting the Centre’s “anti-people” measures.
The preference of the audience was clear as every time Mishra dwelt on “Trinamul misrule” and the party’s alleged links with the Saradha scam, the crowd applauded loudly.
“I have doubts whether our CM can still be called ‘honourable chief minister’ after the Saradha revelations. If she had any self-respect or dignity, she would have resigned, owning moral responsibility. Bengal’s pride has been demolished because of her. The chief minister is a shame for Bengal,” Mishra said. The crowd stood up and cheered.
The comments against the BJP did not evoke a similar response.
“Surjyada spent a long time explaining that the prices of petro products had come down because of a dip in international crude prices and accused the Centre of not passing on the entire benefit to the people. There was hardly any response from the audience. It is true that the BJP is a rival, but for most of our supporters, Trinamul is enemy No. 1. Our leaders probably forgot that,” said a senior CPM leader from North 24-Parganas.
Nepaldeb Bhattacharyya, a CPM leader from the district, said: “We are not going to yield ground to the BJP. Look at today’s rally. That’s the message the crowd has given to us.”
Several participants, however, took a different line.
“Trinamul is on shaky ground. This is the time to come out in the open and show our strength. Today’s turnout was very good,” said Sanjoy Ghosh, an insurance company employee who came with 30 others from Panihati.
The hiring of a fleet of private buses to ferry supporters to the rally venue was another pointer to the upbeat mood in the CPM camp.
“Earlier, we could not organise transport like this because of Trinamul threats. But the transport minister (Madan Mitra) is in jail now and so, Trinamul’s hold over bus unions has weakened. Most bus owners we approached agreed to hire out their vehicles to us,” said Swapan Maji, a Citu leader from Rajarhat.

http://www.telegraphindia.com/1141217/jsp/bengal/story_19224474.jsp#.VJGYINKUeSo

Saradha scam: Sorting out Sen-Bapi Karim-Madan and movements of pockets of cash

$
0
0
Thursday , December 18 , 2014 |

CBI's Madan posers for Sen

- Agency plans to seek court nod to crosscheck information
Sudipta Sen 
Calcutta, Dec. 17: The CBI is planning to seek court permission to question Saradha chief Sudipta Sen in jail to crosscheck some of minister Madan Mitra's statements in custody.
The central agency is also preparing to collect more details on Mitra's alleged transactions with Sen.
Mitra, who was arrested on Friday and is in police custody, has apparently told interrogators that only Sen could say why the Saradha chief withdrew certain amounts of cash at regular intervals through cheques drawn on "self" and if he had ever handed over packets of cash to the sports and transport minister's former confidential assistant Bapi Karim.
"The details of the daily business reports of the Saradha Group reveal that Sen had issued several 'self' cheques, which suggest they were meant for cash withdrawals," said a senior CBI officer. "On a few occasions, it appears Karim met Sen within a few days of such withdrawals."
When the CBI recorded Karim's statement in August, he apparently said he had visited Saradha's Midland Park headquarters late in the night on several occasions at the behest of Mitra and left with cash in brown envelops. The driver of the car Karim had used made a similar claim while deposing before the CBI.
When CBI sleuths confronted Mitra with Karim's claims, the minister reportedly denied them. Mitra apparently told the interrogators that if Karim had collected money from Saradha's office, it was for his personal use. Sources said the minister had even challenged the interrogators to prove that Karim had acted on his instructions.
Madan Mitra
"There are a few gaps that we need to fill while trying to find out how depositors' money reached some influential persons," the CBI officer said.
Sen, now in judicial custody, has been lodged in Alipore central jail for the past few months. He was produced in a Siliguri court today in connection with a Saradha case. The CBI can appeal in Alipore court for permission to question Sen only after he returns.
According to the rule, an investigating officer can meet an accused in judicial custody only after seeking a court's permission.
If the Alipore court agrees to the CBI's plea, the investigating officer will meet Sen in a designated interrogation room of the Alipore jail in the presence of a prison official.
"Since Mitra has been charged in the Saradha Realty case, the appeal will have to be made in the Alipore court, where the FIR has been lodged and the case is being heard," said a senior officer of Alipore police station.
Sen didn't mention Mitra in his purported letter to the CBI.
One of the reasons that prompted the CBI to summon minister Mitra is a suspicion that several names were omitted from the purported letter, sources had said last week. The CBI sources had confirmed claims that the letter was not penned by Sen but by someone else who acted under instructions and took care to omit some names while describing how the multi-crore bubble went bust.

http://www.telegraphindia.com/1141218/jsp/bengal/story_4020.jsp#.VJIKLdKUeSo

Will the world wake up after Peshawar? -- Kanchan Gupta. Sleeping heartless idiots pretending to be asleep.

$
0
0



Will the world wake up after Peshawar?



The heart-rending wail of a father captures the sorrow of the parents who lost their children, “My son went to school in his uniform, he has returned home in a coffin. He was my dream, my dream has died.” Hundreds of dreams died and transmogrified into nightmares on Tuesday.

The Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan, or one of its factions, has issued a statement owning up responsibility for the crime. The statement came even while the carnage was on, with a spokesman declaring that the seven jihadis, among them two suicide bombers, who had attacked the school had been instructed to kill “older students”. The chilling disclosure has only served to underscore that terrorism is the antithesis of all that is human, that terrorists are no better than rabid dogs.

Yes we grieve, like all decent, democratic and humane societies should, over the tragedy that has visited Peshawar. But our grief also tells a story that cannot but discomfit those who repudiate everything that terrorism and terrorists stand for. It tells us that proximity alerts us to Islamist barbarism that distance tends to dull.

When 200 teenaged girls were abducted by Boko Haram and pressed into sex slavery in Nigeria, we barely took note of that crime. When the Islamic State militia massacred Yezidis, forcing survivors to take shelter in the barren Sinjar mountains where children died like flies, we merely took note of it. Earlier, when terrorists attacked a school in Beslan, Russia, in September 2004, leaving 385 dead, among them 186 children, we wondered what it was all about.

Just as the story of global trans-border terrorism does not begin with the devastatingly spectacular attacks of 9/11, the story of innocents being massacred in the name of jihad does not begin with the ghastly attack on the school in Peshawar. These are stories with prologues and preceding chapters; each day, each week, each month a new chapter is added to these stories.

Let us not forget that on November 26, 2008, parents, wives, husbands, friends and families were grieving in Mumbai as Pakistani terrorists went on the rampage. By the time the bloodletting was over, 164 people were dead; many more scarred for the rest of their lives.

This is not an occasion, at least not an apt occasion, to remind those who claim to govern Pakistan, the rickety civilian Government and the all-powerful Army, that the mess in which that country finds itself today is of their own creation. As Farahnaz Ispahani, a highly respected former Member of Pakistani Parliament and public policy analyst, tweeted, “We are eating ourselves up from the inside. Stop blaming neighbours / West. These monsters are our creation. Our children are dead.”

Denial in the face of overwhelming evidence; pandering to Islamist extremism for ‘strategic’ gains; breeding and feeding monsters to use them against others, notably India and Afghanistan; sheltering wanted terrorists like Osama bin Laden; and using terrorism as an instrument of state policy.

The list is long, the details are known to the world. That Hafiz Saeed, wanted for masterminding the Mumbai attacks, walks freely around and routinely calls for jihad, protected by the Pakistani state, is not exactly a secret. That Pakistan has repeatedly rejected incriminating evidence related to 26/11 is not unknown to its patrons and friends.

That none of the leaders of Pakistan, men who thump their chests and threaten fire and brimstone, had the courage to name the Tehreek-e-Taliban while shedding crocodile tears over the innocent victims of Peshawar bears testimony to their cowardice. Worse, it reinforces the widely documented belief that they are complicit and in cahoots with the Tehreek-e-Taliban.

The Pakistani Army, which has been dragooned into raiding Taliban hideouts in North Waziristan by the US which has made funds conditional to anti-terrorist operations in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, has used the Taliban, in Pakistan and Afghanistan, as a ‘strategic asset’. Recall the attack on the Indian Embassy in Kabul on July 7, 2008. Recall too the attack on the Indian Consulate in Herat days after Narendra Modi took charge as Prime Minister.

The ISI, a unique institution that is answerable to none other than the Generals of Rawalpindi, has long been engaged in inflicting a million wounds on India. From Punjab to Kashmir to Kanyakumari, rare is the Indian State that has not been scorched by the evil of terrorism aided, sponsored and plotted by the ISI. We have grieved and raged over our dead, we have mourned the death of our soldiers, we have repeatedly sought to draw the world’s attention to the incubator, the epicentre, of terrorism to our west.

But the world has slept all these years and decades. It has slept through India’s sorrow, it has slept through the atrocities on Shias and Ahmediyas and Christians and Hindus in Pakistan. It has slept through the taunting display of jihadi terror by the Pakistani Establishment. It has slept through the eruption of multiple faultlines across the arc of Islamic countries.

It is only now, as jihadis strike with ferocity in places as distant as Canada and Australia, as the Middle East slides into devastating chaos and destruction, as the Islamic State, Al Qaeda, Taliban, Boko Haram and numerous offshoots of violent Islamism compete with each other to emerge as the most ruthless, and now as children are massacred in so horrific a manner inside a school, that the world is stirring awake. It is yet to act.

In that lethargy can be found the real tragedy of our times.

http://www.abplive.in/author/kanchangupta/2014/12/17/article456325.ece/Will-the-world-wake-up-after-Peshawar

Rajya Sabha logjam and the way out. Stay with the extant Parliamentary practices

$
0
0
NaMo made a perceptive comment in one of his speeches during the revolutionary campaign that there is need for action, NOT more laws.

Since independence in 1947, the nation has passed an enormous littany of laws and produced tons of Law Commission Reports, apart from reams of court judgements all seeking to create a duststorm of rule of law.

What the nation is needs is NOT more laws but strict enforcement of existing laws. 

Laws proposed like FDI in insurance are NO big deal and can  wait till NaMo governance gets absolute majority in Rajya Sabha also, in due time.

There is no hurry to rush through the legislations, panicking and succumbing to chamchagiri rampant in the present state of political grandstanding by political parties who have no clue as to what has hit them in 2014. They are listless because they are left searching for the make-believe dynasty rule.

It is time for everyone to realise that Bharatam Janam have arrived and given a resounding mandate to NaMo's government. The mandate for this government to render service to Bharatam Janam and not seek recourse to wasted time discussing laws as though the wisdom of the elected reps can only find expression in discussing bills and amendments.

Let the extant procedures of Parliamentary practices continue. Let Lok Sabha which is functioning with grace under he Speakership of Susri Mahajan do its job. Let them pass the finance bills as usual for the Budget 2015. Dare the Rajya Sabha to act on the Lok Sabha enactment of finance bills. If the chamchagiri continues and logjam is allowed to grab fleeting TV channel footages, then and then alone should a Joint Session be called to resolve the logjam.

Let not the mockery of offering excuses and asking the PM to come and speak stop. NaMO should NOT accede to such demands from toothless, defeated opposition.

If Rajya Sabha members of the opposition do not want to allow the institution to function and discharge their responsibilities, they will soon realise that time is running out and they will get back home after the composition of RS undergoes a change after the Congress-mukt Bharatam is firmly in place.

Photo-ops? Go for them. After all the photo journalists have to make their living. If members want samosas from the canteen, nothing prevents them from raising calling attention notices and seek suspension of question hours. They can get their subsidised samosas and chai.

By the meaningless shoutings, and walks to the well of the chairperson, a great Parliamentary institution under the Constitution is being held to ranson. Let this tamasha continue till the members realise that their is pathetic and calls for no compassion. Certainly, no message is being delivered to the nation, certainly, this aint no address to the nation from the members who are living off the salaries financed by tax payers.

Is there a law to prevent anyone from choosing a profession of a buffoon? Maybe, there should be none. We have enough of them, the laws I mean.

Kalyanaraman

Gondwana, Indus script on 19 pictographs from a cave in Talwarghatta, Hampi, Godavari river basin

$
0
0
Mirror: 
https://www.academia.edu/9818724/Gondwana_Indus_script_on_19_pictographs_from_a_cave_in_Talwarghatta_Hampi_Godavari_river_basin
This is a photograph of the inscription with 19 pictographs. 

Reference earlier post, one pictograph, 'standing person' is clearly identifiable as comparable to the Indus Script corpora of 'signs' and 'pictorial motifs'. In the corpora, the hieroglyph is read rebus as: 

meḍ  'body' (Santali. Munda)
Rebus: meḍ ‘iron’(Munda)kāṭi 'body stature; Rebus: fireplace trench.

Identification of other 18 pictographs of the cave inscription will help match with comparable deciphered hieroglyphs of Indus writing.

Kalyanaraman


Published: January 20, 2014 00:00 IST | Updated: January 20, 2014 08:46 IST

Gondi manuscript translation to reveal Gondwana history

S. Harpal Singh
The University of Hyderabad team interacts with the Gonds while translating Gondi manuscripts in Adilabad district on Sunday. — PHOTO: S. HARPAL SINGH
The University of Hyderabad team interacts with the Gonds while translating Gondi manuscripts in Adilabad district on Sunday. — PHOTO: S. HARPAL SINGH
A hidden, tiny and yet, extremely important part of India’s modern history will soon be revealed to the world once the translation of the Gunjala Gondi manuscripts is completed within the next week. The manuscripts, written in the extinct Gondi script, subsequently named the Gunjala Gondi script, were discovered in the sleepy village of Narnoor mandal in Adilabad district in 2011, leading to a whole range of possibilities, especially in historical research.
The Centre for Dalit and Adivasi Studies and Translation (CDAST) of the University of Hyderabad, with Professor V. Krishna as its coordinator, has undertaken translation of ten manuscripts which talk of the history of the Gond Kingdom of Chandrapur (in present day Maharashtra), besides depicting Gondi culture in the form of the Ramayana. A team from CDAST is currently translating the manuscripts dating back to 1750 at Gunjala with the help of Gondi pandits.
The manuscripts will be translated to Hindi and Telugu for the benefit of the Gond community spread across six States, as well as non-Gonds. Meanwhile, the font for the Gunjala Gondi script has already been finalised.
“The manuscripts talk about the freedom struggle of the Chandrapur Gond Kings who fought against the British, and the history of the Pardhan tribe which has an intrinsic and inseparable connection with the Gonds. One of the episodes relate to the rebellion of the legendary Ramji Gond who fought the British at Nirmal town in Adilabad district with the help of Rohillas,” said Professor Jayadheer Tirumal Rao, visiting Professor at CDAST, who was instrumental in bringing to light the discovery.
One of the important aspects in the life of Gond Kings highlighted in the manuscripts was their relationship with Myanmar (then known as Burma). The relationship was forged by people from the Pardhan community in the 6th or 7th Century CE.
“There is a record of the origins of the famous Nagoba Jatara at Keslapur in Indervelli mandal which is an important chapter in the history of Gondwana. The translation will also help us understand the relation between different communities in those times,” Mr. Rao added.
http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/tp-national/tp-andhrapradesh/gondi-manuscript-translation-to-reveal-gondwana-history/article5595317.ece
Published: December 16, 2014 23:46 IST | Updated: December 17, 2014 00:55 IST

Gonds may have migrated from Indus Valley

S. Harpal Singh
CRUCIAL LINK TO THE PAST: The photograph found in a cave in Hampi. Photo: Special Arrangement.
The Hindu
CRUCIAL LINK TO THE PAST: The photograph found in a cave in Hampi. Photo: Special Arrangement.
“On the goddess Kotamma temple woollen market way there is a rocky roof shelter for shepherds and sheep to stay at night up to morning.” This innocuous sounding statement could actually be a revolutionary find linking the adivasi Gond tribe to the Indus Valley civilisation, which flourished between 2500 B.C. and 1750 BC.
The sentence emerged after a set of 19 pictographs from a cave in Hampi were deciphered using root morphemes of Gondi language, considered by many eminent linguists as a proto Dravidian language. Eleven of the Hampi pictographs resemble those of the civilisation, according to Dr. K.M. Metry, Head and Dean, Social Sciences, Kannada University, Hampi; Dr. Motiravan Kangali, a linguist and expert in Gondi language and culture from Nagpur, Maharashtra; and his associate Prakash Salame, also an expert in Gondi.
They were in Utnoor to participate in the 4th National workshop on standardisation of Gondi dictionary when they spoke to The Hindu about their study of the pictographs. Though the ‘discovery’ is yet to be authenticated, Dr. Metry and his associates are very optimistic about their work.
“Instead of looking at the painting from an archaeological or purely linguistic point of view, we took the cultural way to decipher the pictographs. Gondi culture being totemic, has a lot of such symbols also associated with Ghotul schools,” said Dr. Metry.
“Gondi is a proto Dravidian language and gives enough scope for studying the pictographs though its root morphemes,” observed Dr. Kangali. “Application of the root morphemes helped us in deciphering the 19 pictographs,” he added.
If the discovery stands the scrutiny of experts in the field, it would mean that the Gonds living in central and southern India could have migrated from the Indus Valley civilisation. “Meanwhile, we will continue with our work applying it to other paintings in the Hampi area to establish a Gondi-Harappan link,” the Professor said.
http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/telangana/gonds-may-have-migrated-from-indus-valley/article6698419.ece

WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 17, 2014

Gondi Pictographs and the Indus Valley Script

The mysterious writing left behind by the Harappan or Indus Valley civilization has frustrated every attempt at translation. In fact it has proved so difficult to extract any meaning from the brief strings of signs that are all we have of the script that some linguists have argued that it can't really be a written language at all.
Which is why people are paying attention to this obscure news itemfrom India.
“On the goddess Kotamma temple woollen market way there is a rocky roof shelter for shepherds and sheep to stay at night up to morning.” This innocuous sounding statement could actually be a revolutionary find linking the adivasi Gond tribe to the Indus Valley civilisation, which flourished between 2500 B.C. and 1750 BC.

The sentence emerged after a set of 19 pictographs from a cave in Hampi were deciphered using root morphemes of Gondi language, considered by many eminent linguists as a proto Dravidian language. Eleven of the Hampi pictographs resemble those of the civilisation, according to Dr. K.M. Metry, Head and Dean, Social Sciences, Kannada University, Hampi; Dr. Motiravan Kangali, a linguist and expert in Gondi language and culture from Nagpur, Maharashtra; and his associate Prakash Salame, also an expert in Gondi.
The Gondi people are scattered around central India, mainly in hilly areas, and were generally considered primitive by their valley and town dwelling neighbors. While those neighbors spoke Hindi or some other Indo-European language, Gondi is a Dravidian language quite close (some say) to the root language from which the many Dravidian tongues of south India derive. One odd thing about this new story is that it says nothing about the age of the Gondi inscription; just based on the photograph I would say it can't be more than a few hundred years old. It would be quite amazing if a system of signs used by seventeenth-century shepherds provided read clues toward the translation of the Indus script, lost since 1700 BCE.

Of course many people have tried before to render the Indus script into proto-Dravidian, without any success. People want the Indus script to be written Dravidian because of Indo-European linguistics. Most languages of northern India derive from Sanskrit, which is an Indo-European language related to Old Persian, and the simplest way to get Sanskrit into India is to imagine a wave of invaders from central Asia sweeping over the Hindu Kush just like the Muslim invaders of medieval times. The most sensible time for this to have happened is the second millennium  BCE, that is, just after the Indus Valley civilization collapsed. If the Indus script was Dravidian, that fits perfectly with this model. On the other hand there is pretty much no archaeological evidence for such an Indo-European invasion, and these days most Indian nationalists hate it.

This may be just another crazy idea cooked up by some overly imaginative professors, but I find myself hoping that this particular crazy idea turns out to have something to it.
http://benedante.blogspot.in/2014/12/gondi-pictographs-and-indus-valley.html

 

The Eternal Harappan Script Tease

New findings raise an old question: Do South Indians belong to the Indus Valley Civilisation?

ARCHAEOLOGY

Dr KM Metry, Professor of Tribal Studies at Kannada University, who discovered what appear to be rock paintings of the Harappan script in Hampi (Photo: MANOJ PATIL)

Dr KM Metry, Professor of Tribal Studies at Kannada University, who discovered what appear to be rock paintings of the Harappan script in Hampi (Photo: MANOJ PATIL)
Around two kilometres away from the famous Vittala Temple in Hampi, Karnataka, through a dirt road that few individuals use, one reaches an abandoned area with banana plantations on one side and hills dotted with oversized boulders on the other. Locals tend to leave the caves on these hills alone since it isn’t uncommon to find sloth bears and cheetahs in them. Around 10 years ago, KM Metry, a Kannada University professor of Tribal Studies who was researching instances of human-bear conflict in the area and visiting sites in search of stone tools used by tribals of the olden days, was walking alone on this dirt road when he saw what he thought was a light scribble on a rock in the distance.
Professor Metry climbed the hill on which the rock stood and started splashing it with water to get a clearer look at what he had spotted. It turned out to be nothing like he had seen before. It was an ancient rock painting, drawn, he says, with some form of vegetable oil, and containing as many as 22 symbols. He continued to discover similar rock paintings with different symbols around Hampi after that.
In the following years, his research on Gondi culture and visits to tribal areas in Chhattisgarh convinced him that the rock paintings he had encountered in Hampi were Gondi symbols. This led him to believe what quite a few other scholars also claim—that all speakers of Dravidian languages, and by extension the people who live in South India, owe their ancestry to the Gond tribe. Some years ago, he chanced upon a book by a Gond scholar who argued that the yet- undeciphered script of the Indus Valley Civilisation is a combination of Gondi symbols. After several years of persuasion, last month, Metry was able to convince the author of the book, Motiravan Kangale, to visit the spot where he had discovered the rock paintings. Of the 22 characters, Kangale was able to identify and interpret the meaning of five that occur both in Gond culture and the Indus Valley Civilisation. The other characters, Kangale says, were not clear enough to identify easily.
“This is a major find,” Metry says. “Not only does it show that the Indus script is connected to Gondi language and culture, it proves that the modern-day Gond [Tribals] and South Indians are people of the Indus Valley Civilisation. The Harappans migrated from the Indus Valley to South India.”
+++
The Indus Valley Civilisation has puzzled archaeologists and researchers ever since it was first discovered in the early twentieth century. Who were these ancient people who lived along the Indus River between 3,300 and 1,300 BCE? What could have happened to the builders of perhaps one of the greatest ancient civilisations? Could they have been wiped out by a flood or a superior military force, as some researchers argue? Or did they abandon the northwest part of the subcontinent because the river they depended upon dried up, or changed course, to migrate to other parts like South India, as Metry suggests?
Most researchers have turned to the tiny symbols and inscriptions on the seals and tablets found at Indus Valley sites for answers to these questions. And therein lies the perplexity. So far, despite several attempts to study the 417 identified Indus Valley symbols that have been found on over 4,000 objects, no one has come close to deciphering the script. Objects bearing it have been found all over, from the Indus Valley sites of Mohenjo-daro and Harappa to far-off places in West Asia. Each object typically has five or six symbols, and these occur in various sequences. Some researchers have even claimed that the symbols do not represent a language at all, and are merely pictograms of political or religious icons.
The likes of Metry and Kangale claim that the ability to decipher the script has proven elusive because no one has attempted to study the script using Gondi symbols and language. They point out how many of the symbols in the script resemble those found in Ghotuls, the traditional learning centres for unmarried Gond youngsters found in some of their villages. They claim that the famous Pashupati seal with the figure of a man with horns echoes the old Gondi practice of wearing a crown of horns for religious occasions. “When you start looking at the script keeping in mind Gondi symbols, then everything becomes clear,” Kangale says. “It shows that the Harappans travelled via central India to the south, with some of them settling in Central India and a majority of them in the South.”
One of the most interesting projects on the Indus script is being undertaken at Mumbai’s Tata Institute of Fundamental Research (TIFR). In league with researchers from the University of Washington, and using mathematics and computer science, TIFR researchers have been able to establish that Indus symbols constitute a language. The researchers analysed the statistical pattern of the script, calculating the degree of randomness in successive symbols of a sequence, and compared them to non-linguistic systems such as human DNA, protein sequences and also four linguistic scripts—English, Old Tamil, Rig Vedic Sanskrit and Sumerian. They also compared the Indus script to Fortran, a computer programming language. The results, published in the journal Science in 2009, showed that the Indus inscriptions are indeed linguistic in nature, display- ing the same level of randomness and patterns as the languages used for comparison, and differing from Fortran and other non-linguistic systems.
According to Mayank Vahia, an astrophysicist at TIFR and one of the researchers studying the script, the theory of Indus Valley people having migrated to South India has very little basis in scientific evidence, and artefacts being found in the South are unremarkable in themselves. “Since the people of the Indus Valley Civilisation were in contact with people from as far as Mesopotamia, exchanges with people from South India are likely,” he says.
In support of their argument, those who propose the migration theory point to the discovery in Tamil Nadu eight years ago of a ‘celt’—a hand-held axe of the Indus Valley Civilisation. A school teacher from Sembian-Kandiyur, near Mayiladuthurai in Tamil Nadu’s Nagapattinam district, had dug up two ‘celts’ in his backyard. One of them was inscribed with four symbols from the Indus script. But, as Vahia says, “An axe with Indus inscriptions on it has never been [found at] the Indus sites, but even if it were to be genuine, the axe is a movable object and it very likely could have travelled there.”
What is often missed in these arguments is that script and language are distinct from each other. Seals with Indus symbols, in sequences that are different from the Indus Valley’s, have been found in modern-day Iraq and Bahrain, suggesting that the Indus script was being used as part of a different language or information system in those parts (with which there is evidence of ancient trade links). If an Indus script discovered in South India somehow bears resemblance to a Dravidian language or culture, it does not necessarily mean that speakers of Dravidian languages are descendants of Indus Valley people. The historian Michel Danino rubbishes the theory of the latter’s southward migration in a paper he presented at the International Symposium on Indus Civilisation and Tamil Language in 2007. He wrote: ‘There is no archaeological evidence of a southward migration through the Deccan after the end of the urban phase of the Indus- Sarasvati civilization… The only actual evidence of movements at that period is of Late Harappans migrating towards the Ganges plains and towards Gujarat... Migration apart, there is a complete absence of Harappan artefacts and features south of the Vindhyas: no Harappan designs on pottery, no Harappan seals, crafts and ornaments, no trace of Harappan urbanism… Cultural continuity from Harappan to historical times has been increasingly documented in North India, but not in the South… This means, in effect, that the south-bound Late Harappans would have reverted from an advanced urban bronze-age culture to a Neolithic one! Their migration to South would thus constitute a double “archaeological miracle”: apart from being undetectable on the ground, it implies that the migrants experienced a total break with all their traditions. Such a phenomenon is unheard of.’
Nisha Yadav, who has been researching the Indus script with Vahia, points out that even if the rock paintings with the alleged Indus script are ancient, someone could well have imitated the script. “The Indus script has always been small, and found on tablets or seals. The length of the average inscription is five signs and the longest so far found is 17 signs long. But the size of the symbols in Hampi is large and is 22 characters long. Also, no one has ever found the Indus script as rock paintings.”
The claim of the Indus Valley Civilisation being proto-Dravidian—or even linked to the Vedic age, as some have claimed in the past—has implications for a long-running political debate over the subcontinent’s original inhabitants. The migration theory, for example, gels with the theory that Indo- Iranians, or Aryans, came from the Caspian Sea area with their Vedic culture and drove the Indus Valley’s Dravidian inhabitants to the southern parts of the peninsula. Up against this is the assertion that Indus Valley was part of a Vedic culture of early Hinduism, an alternate theory that bolsters the claim that Vedic beliefs had their origin in the sub- continent and there had never been an Aryan invasion of north India.
After the discovery of the celt, the then Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M Karunanidhi of the Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam was reported to have said at an election rally, in the presence of former Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, that archaeological findings reveal that Tamils belong to a race of Dravidians who lived in the Indus Valley, and how he himself was a descendant of theirs.
According to Vahia, the Harappans were neither connected to the Vedic age, nor proto-Dravidians who moved to South India. One of the chief inconsistencies of the Indus-as-Vedic theory is the complete absence of references to horses in Indus Valley artefacts, while horses were integral to most Rig Vedic rituals and customs. Vahia says, “The Harappans belonged to the ancient Homo sapiens who migrated from Africa as early as 60,000 years ago. A part of this group travelled to the Mediterranean and another travelled along the coast of the Arabian Sea, and some of them settled in the Indus Valley region. At the end of the Ice Ages, the group that went to the Mediterranean moved east and enter- ed India, where they met the earlier migrants who had come along the seas, sometime around 2,500 years BCE. The new entrants, Indo-Iranians, composed the Vedas and later included the learning of the Harappans.”
Writes Vahia writes in an academic paper: ‘It seems logical that post 2000 BC, the Harappans merged with the migrants of Central Asia and then drifted farther east into the Gangetic planes… It is therefore more logical to assume that the Harappan people and the Vedic people merged into a single human group.’
+++
Another novel research study is currently being conducted to understand who the Harappans were and if their descendants could be living among us. In collaboration with researchers of Seoul National University College in Korea and the Archaeological Survey of India, researchers from Pune’s Deccan College Postgraduate and Research Institute (DCPRI) are trying to excavate burial mounds in Rakhigarhi, an Indus Valley site in Haryana, to find parasite eggs that might have once existed in the stomachs of Indus Valley people. “If these parasite eggs are found, it could lead to something remarkable. We could be able to isolate the DNA of their host,” says Vasant Shinde, a senior archaeologist and vice chancellor at DCPRI.
An earlier attempt to undertake DNA and genome sequencing of skeletons found in Farmana, another Indus site in Haryana, had proved unsuccessful since the wet acidic soil of the region had destroyed all DNA in the remains of the dead. However, earlier this year, the researchers were able to locate a cattle bone whose marrow appeared fit enough for study. According to Shinde, the bone appears to be intact, although they can’t identify what exact animal it belonged to or what part of the skeleton it is. “So far, the bone looks good enough,” he says. “We can’t say what exactly this bone will reveal, but we hope it will be able to tell us something about the connection between the animal and its master.”
While the Indus script still remains shrouded in mystery, and we are as still nowhere close to understanding who the Indus Valley people were or what happened to them, there has been some remarkable progress of late.
Earlier this year, the team led by Shinde discovered two new mounds in addition to the seven already discovered in Rakhigarhi, taking the total area of the site to around 350 hectares. This is much larger than Mohenjo-daro, which was once considered the largest Harappan settlement. “Much of Rakhigarhi is still under a present-day village with around 5,000 inhabitants. So in actuality, it is larger than anyone has ever imagined,” Shinde says.
Rakhigarhi, along with other Harappan sites, had been discovered way back in the 1960s. It had always been thought that the ancient civilisation had its origin in Sind, where Mohenjo-daro and Harappa are located, and later spread to distant sites in modern day Haryana. But archaeologists are now considering the possibility that it was here that the Indus Valley Civilisation first flourished. “The excavations in Haryana are throwing up really early dates, where the early Harappan phase could go back to even 5000 BCE. We still need to confirm that, but Rakhigarhi looks like the place where the civilisation began.”
The TIFR group under Vahia has also discovered two structures used for astronomy in the Indus Valley, proving for the first time that the civilisation was far from primitive in this field of exploration. The two circular structures, located exactly on the Tropic of Cancer, at Dholavira in Gujarat’s Kutch district, were initially thought to be servant’s quarters. “It is implausible that an advanced civilisation like the Indus Valley did not have any knowledge of astronomy,” Vahia says, seated in his office at TIFR, surrounded by shelves packed with books on the subject. “Yet, no one had ever discovered any evidence of it. These structures we discovered were probably useful to understand the time of the day and night, seasons, years, and perhaps even longer periods.”
Since having established that the Indus script is neither random nor dis- orderly, TIFR researchers have also been working on uncovering the subtleties of the script’s structure. They have identified specific signs that begin and end the texts. They have found that the script displays a remarkable uniformity across vast stretches of terrain. They have also found the sequence of Indus symbols used in inscriptions found in West Asia—with whom the Harappans are believed to have had trade links—to be different from those found in Indus Valley; the same script, in effect, being used to represent a different language.
Since there exist frequently-occurring sign combinations that tend to appear at specific locations in the texts, the researchers have also been able to predict illegible or incomplete text found on broken or damaged objects with about 75 per cent accuracy.
One issue that has posed an obstacle to researchers is the presence of what appear to be composite symbols, or symbols that look like an amalgamation of two or more other symbols. Had the Indus Valley people devised shorthand, or do these composites convey meaning combinations of their constituent symbols? TIFR researchers, using computational methods, have been able to compare the ‘environment’ (the signs that precede or follow an inscription sequence) of given constituent and composite symbols, and shown that the Indus people did not write in abbreviations, and that since the environments of composite and constituent symbols are different, the meaning of a composite symbol is not the simple addition of two constituent symbols.
Tapping her fingers on a glass table with images of the Indus script, Yadav says, “Gradually, we are learning to understand the structure of the Indus script. We don’t know what it means. We probably will never know what the symbols are telling us until we discover something like the Rosetta Stone [the stone with a decree inscribed in three scripts, ancient Egyptian hieroglyphs, Demotic script, and ancient Greek, the discovery of which helped researchers translate Egyptian hieroglyphs]. But we are learning its structure, its patterns and sequences. We hope to, with our work, be able to help future attempts to interpret the language.”
At this point, Vahia joins in, pointing at Yadav, who is seated across another table. “The two of us will soon be able to write to each other in flawless Harappan. But we won’t understand a word or letter of what we are writing.”

Comment

The Indus valley symbols do not represent any language or script. They were essentially a non-literate (no written language) civilization. This is not to belittle that civilization. There were many great civilizations without any script/writing. It is futile to find literary meanings in the Harappan symbols. Read papers by Steve Farmer and Michael Witzel.
http://www.openthemagazine.com/article/nation/the-eternal-harappan-script-tease
Updated: November 5, 2014 07:42 IST

Drawings of Harappan era discovered near Hampi

SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT

Pictographs of the Harappan era in Gondi dialect found near Hampi, Karnataka. Photo: Special Arrangement
Pictographs of the Harappan era in Gondi dialect found near Hampi, Karnataka. Photo: Special Arrangement

As many as 20 drawings were found on a boulder on top of a hill near Talwarghatta, adjacent to river Tungabhadra.

Pictographs of the Sindu (Harappan) culture have been discovered on rocks near the world famous Hampi. As many as 20 drawings were found on a boulder on top of a hill near Talwarghatta, adjacent to river Tungabhadra.
Experts in Gondi script, including Dr. Moti Ravan Kangale and Sri Prakash Salame of Nagpur, have identified them as Sindu (Harappan) culture-based script in Gondi dialect.
Gond culture
They also pointed out that such drawings are found in Chhattisgarh and also in interior structures of Gotuls (learning centres for youths) in Bastar region, K.M. Metry, Professor and Head Department of Tribal Studies, Hampi Kannada University told The Hindu.
“Dr. Kangale identified as many as five of the 20 pictographs of Gondi dialect – aalin (man), sary(road/way), nel (paddy), sukkum (star/dot), nooru (headman).
His observations strengthen the belief that Gond culture has been transmitted to the Tungabhadra basin,” Prof. Metry said. Prof. Metry felt that with this discovery, there was need for a thorough research to find out Gotuls in and around Hampi.
Decipherment of INDUS VALLEY script in GONDI language
Posted on November 10, 2014 by admin
Dr Motiravan Kangale who had claimed deciphering the Harappa script relating it to the ancient tribal Gondi script, are helping decipher the writing found in Hampi, Metry said. The discovery was made near Talwara Ghatta on the way to Vijaya Vittala Temple in the UNESCO World Heritage Site.
“Dr Kangale and Salame were in Hampi between August 24 and 29 for a seminar on the Gondi language. I took them to these writings. On the spot, Kangale was able to decipher five of the 20 characters,” Metry said. The professor said that the symbols resemble symbols on the famous Pasupati Seal found in Mohenjo-Daro. “There are other such writings of symbols similar to these in other places in Hampi. Once all are studied, we can prove that the Harappans migrated to South India and a crucial link in our prehistory can be established.”
However, historians are calling for caution. Eminent historian Dr S Shettar said, “Recently there were claims of a Harappan engraving on a piece of stone in Tamil Nadu. But unlike a rock face, stone pieces and seals can travel long distances. In this case too, we need very solid evidence. If the discovery is true, it is wonderful. But it has to be viewed very carefully. From about 2000 BCE when the Harappan/Indus civilisation ended and the times of Ashoka in the 3rd Century BCE, we do not have clarity of the continuity in Indian history. The Indus civilisation has been demarcated as Early, Mature and Late Harappan.
“But the writings found there are not as clearly demarcated. Even the true nature of the Harappan writings is in question. So if you find a discovery beyond the conventional Indus Civilisation area, you have to be very careful while making any claims. You need to say which language was used, which script was used and the continuity. A language or script cannot remain stagnant for 1,000 years. This cannot happen with a single find. Let there not be empty speculation,” he said.

http://jayseva.com/decipherment-of-indus-valley-script-in-gondi-language/


Prof sees Harappan script in Hampi


Prof sees Harappan script in Hampi
One of the paintings seen on a wall near Talwara Ghatta at Hampi, which Prof. KM Metry (inset) claims to be Late Harappan writing
Historians call for caution in reading too much into hilltop paintings near heritage site

This could turn out to be one of the biggest archaeological finds in South India. Dr KM Metry, professor of tribal studies at the Kannada University, Hampi, has found prehistoric paintings on a hilltop in Hampi, which he claims is Late Harappan writing. 

The series of 20 characters found resembles the Late Harappan writing of the Indus Valley Civilisation, says Metry. The professor claims that this shows that after the collapse of the civilisation situated in North-West India, the Harappans moved to other parts of the country including the Deccan. 

Speaking to Mirror, Metry said, "There is a direct link between the Late Harappan and the writings that have been discovered. This proves that the people of Indus Valley Civilisation moved to South India after the collapse of the Late Harappan stage." 

Dr Motiravan Kangale and Prakash Kalame, who had claimed deciphering the Harappa script relating it to the ancient tribal Gondi script, are helping decipher the writing found in Hampi, Metry said. The discovery was made near Talwara Ghatta on the way to Vijaya Vittala Temple in the UNESCO World Heritage Site. 

"Dr Kangale and Kalame were in Hampi between August 24 and 29 for a seminar on the Gondi language. I took them to these writings. On the spot, Kangale was able to decipher five of the 20 characters," Metry said. The professor said that the symbols resemble symbols on the famous Pasupati Seal found in Mohenjo-Daro. "There are other such writings of symbols similar to these in other places in Hampi. Once all are studied, we can prove that the Harappans migrated to South India and a crucial link in our prehistory can be established." 

However, historians are calling for caution. Eminent historian Dr S Shettar said, "Recently there were claims of a Harappan engraving on a piece of stone in Tamil Nadu. But unlike a rock face, stone pieces and seals can travel long distances. In this case too, we need very solid evidence. If the discovery is true, it is wonderful. But it has to be viewed very carefully. From about 2000 BCE when the Harappan/Indus civilisation ended and the times of Ashoka in the 3rd Century BCE, we do not have clarity of the continuity in Indian history. The Indus civilisation has been demarcated as Early, Mature and Late Harappan. 


"But the writings found there are not as clearly demarcated. Even the true nature of the Harappan writings is in question. So if you find a discovery beyond the conventional Indus Civilisation area, you have to be very careful while making any claims. You need to say which language was used, which script was used and the continuity. A language or script cannot remain stagnant for 1,000 years. This cannot happen with a single find. Let there not be empty speculation," he said.


A BYGONE ERA

Out of the 20 symbols, Kangale and Kalame were able to immediately decipher five, says Metry. "They are: Sl No 1, which means aalin in Gondi,manava in Kannada, and man in English; Sl No 3, nel in Gondi, nela/nellu in Kannada, paddy field in English; Sl No 8, sary in Gondi, sari/daari inKannada, way/path in English; Sl No 15, sukkum in Gondi, chukke in Kannada, star/dot in English; and Sl No 16, nooru in Gondi, nara manava/mukhanda in Kannada, headman in English. 


Note: From the photograph which appeared in Bangalore Mirror , it is possible to identify clearly, "standing person' symbol which is an Indus script sign.
It will be necessary to get from Prof. KM Metry, the complete set of symbols and specific symbols he sees as comparable to signs of Indus script.

From my decipherment, the 'standing person' symbol has two rebus readings: See http://bharatkalyan97.blogspot.in/2014/09/stature-of-body-meluhha-hieroglyphs-48.html 

meḍ  'body' (Santali. Munda) Rebus: meḍ ‘iron’(Munda); मेढ meḍh‘merchant’s helper’(Pkt.)  meḍ  iron (Ho.)  meṛed-bica = iron stone ore, in contrast to bali-bica, iron sand ore (Munda)
kāṭi 'body stature; Rebus: fireplace trench.
काठी [ kāṭhī ] f (काष्ट S)  (or शरीराची काठी) The frame or structure of the body: also (viewed by some as arising from the preceding sense, Measuring rod) stature (Marathi) B. kāṭhā ʻ measure of length ʼ(CDIAL 3120).

Rebus: G. kāṭɔṛɔ m. ʻ dross left in the furnace after smelting iron ore ʼ.(CDIAL 2646)
Rebus: kāṭi , n. < U. ghāṭī. 1. Trench of a fort; அகழி. 2. A fireplace in the form of a long ditch; கோட்டையடுப்பு காடியடுப்பு kāṭi-y-aṭuppu , n. < காடி; +. A fireplace in the form of a long ditch used for cooking on a large scale; கோட்டையடுப்பு.

The transcription of other symbols on the Rock inscription of Hampi and possible comparison with Indus Script sign or pictorial motif sets have to be further analysed and investigated.

Kalyanaraman
Sarasvati Research Centre
December 18, 2014
http://bharatkalyan97.blogspot.in/2014/11/the-eternal-harappan-script-tease.html

Are Hindu Marriage Vows Misogynistic? -- Aditi Banerjee

$
0
0
Are Hindu Marriage Vows Misogynistic?
Aditi Banerjee's profile photoAditi Banerjee is a practicing attorney at a Fortune 500 financial services company in the greater New York area. She is on the Board of Directors of the World Association for Vedic Studies (WAVES) and has organized and presented at global conferences on matters related to Dharma. She co-edited the book, Invading the Sacred: An Analysis of Hinduism Studies in America, and has written widely on Hinduism and the Hindu-American experience.

17 Dec, 2014

Should Hindu Marriage vows  be rewritten to suit the times? The answer, as a study of the shastras show, is an emphatic No.
As quoted by Swami Vivekananda, in the Ramayana, once Rama and Sita had gone to visit a female sage in the forest during their banishment:
“Sita approached this sage and bowed down before her. The sage placed her hand on the head of Sita and said: “It is a great blessing to possess a beautiful body; you have that. It is a greater blessing to have a noble husband; you have that. It is the greatest blessing to be perfectly obedient to such a husband; you are that. You must be happy.”
Sita replied, “Mother, I am glad that God has given me a beautiful body and that I have so devoted a husband. But as to the third blessing, I do not know whether I obey him or he obeys me. One thing alone I remember, that when he took me by the hand before the sacrificial fire — whether it was a reflection of the fire or whether God himself made it appear to me — I found that I was his and he was mine. And since then, I have found that I am the complement of his life, and he of mine.”
Groom to Bride during the Hindu wedding ceremony (translated from Sanskrit):
I am the sky, you are the earth. I am a song of the Samaveda, you are a Rik, a couplet of the Rigveda; I am thee and thou art me. We are married. Let us get virtuous progeny, who will be lovable, lustrous for us. Let us lead a long life in togetherness to enjoy one hundred autumnal seasons.”
A Hindu Wedding
A Hindu Wedding
In a recent column in Business Standard, Mitali Saran argues that Hindu wedding vows should be updated or rewritten by couples for the sake of gender equality. Her basic complaint is that the Sanskrit shlokas used for the wedding ceremony envision a specific division of labour (the woman doing the household work and the man earning for the family while being served by his wife at home) that is unfair to working women in today’s world. The column is rather shallow and gratuitously provocative, but raises two serious questions that deserve to be answered:
1. Are the Hindu marriage vows inherently misogynistic?
2. Even if those vows were once appropriate, have they become obsolete today?
There is enormous intricacy and subtlety in the rites of Hindu marriage, and there is also significant variation across different regions,sampradayas (religious traditions), and jatis (clans / socioeconomic groups). The importance of various rites and their different layers of meaning and symbolism deserves its own series of articles, but the focus of this piece will be on the saptapadi mantras, which are the mantras uttered during the seven rounds taken by the bride and groom around the consecrated fire.
The groom leads the bride around the fire for the first three rounds; the bride leads during the last four (which also shows their inherent equality in stature—sometimes the husband leads, sometimes the wife).
The vows themselves are as follows:
Bride and Groom together: 
Let us walk together, hand in hand, the seven steps symbolic of the aspirations below:
May We take the first step together for sap (nourishment),
May We take the second step together for vigour,
May We take the third step together for thriving wealth,
May We take the fourth step together for comfort,
May We take the fifth step together for offspring,
May We take the sixth step together for the various seasons,
May We take the seventh step together for everlasting friendship.
You be my unswerving partner; (let us have many auspicious progeny who shall see long life crossing 80 years)
Personally, I find these vows to be extraordinarily rich and multifaceted, reflecting deep psychological and sociological insight into the various needs and phases that a married couple goes through. We do not see in these vows the misogyny alleged by Saran.
However, there is variation in the exact customs followed across regions and sociocultural groups according to various Grihya Sutras, and there appear to be certain interpretations or variations of these vows where the bride promises to cook for and please the groom, which is Saran’s main grievance.
Without getting into a lot of arcane debate about whether these alternative interpretations are authentic or interpolations, let us assume for the sake of argument that Saran is correct that in these vows there is emphasis on the bride’s promise to take care of the family, feed the family and serve and please her husband with no such corresponding vow required on the husband’s part. Even in such a scenario, the basic point is that a division of labour is not in and of itself unequal or derogatory towards woman.
There are differences in male and female psyches that lead to certain qualities predominating in men and others in women—as a general matter, not to be taken to extremes—and specialization in certain roles tends to optimize the different qualities in men and women for the benefit of all. (In fact, to characterize the role of women in the household as being secondary to office work or business is based on the sexist premise that the domain of the home is inferior to the domain of the workplace. Perhaps it is the husband who should be considered oppressed because he does not get to spend enough time at home!)
This does not mean that those gender roles are ossified for all times and in all circumstances—this is one model for society, and in the context of that model, these vows are entirely appropriate and cannot be considered to be derogatory towards women.
Saran’s chief complaint is that the bride is reduced to the lowly status of a maidservant. But in the Hindu conception of marriage and womanhood, as reflected in the shastras and the ordained rites, the bride is not at all a maidservant—rather, she is the one who reigns over the household.
Kanyadaan
Kanyadaan

The Sanskrit term for a wife is grhini, which means the owner of the house, whereas the term for husband, grhastha, means a mere resident of the house. If the wife were to have the same status as the husband, she would be known as a grhasthaa. In Tamil, too, the wife is illaal, one who owns the house, whereas the husband is illarattaan, one who performs the dharmic rites in the house.
The conception of the wife as reigning over the household stems from the Vedas themselves. In the Rg Veda, we find these beautiful quotations:
“Happy be you (as wife) and prosper with your children here (in the house): be vigilant to rule your household in this home (i.e. exercise your authority as the main figure in your home). Closely unite (be an active participant) in marriage with your husband. So shall you, full of years, address your company (i.e. have authority to speak over household matters).” (10.85.27);
“O Bride! May your father-in-law treat you as a queen. May your mother-in-law treat you as a Samrajni (queen). May the sisters and brothers of your husband treat you as a queen.”(10.85.46).
If we have fallen away from these ideals in the recent past, the fault lies in social decay and not in the beliefs and traditions that our rishis have passed down to us.
Unlike Saran, who seems to think that the work a woman does at home is demeaning, our acharyas and rishis held women in great reverence for the importance of their work and role, not just in the family but in society, and for the depth of their devotion and sacrifice.
In traditional Hinduism, the wife plays a fourfold role: she is ardhangini(the other half of her husband, metaphorically speaking); sahadharmini(partner in the fulfilment of human and divine goals—principally, the fourpurushartha, or aims of human life: dharmaartha (accumulation of wealth through righteous means), kama (fulfillment of desire through appropriate means) and moksha (self-realization; liberation from the cycle of birth and death)); sahakarmini, (partner in all acts and actions), andsahayogini (partner in all ventures).
Ardhanari depicts the duality of human nature, where both man and woman play equally important roles.
Ardhanari depicts the duality of human nature, where both man and woman play equally important roles.
Moreover, the wife’s role was not merely to ‘please’ her husband:
“It must be noted that a wife creates well-being for the world even as she does the work of cooking or as a source of sensual gratification for her husband… It is not that she cooks for the husband alone. She has to provide food every day to the guests, to the sick and to the birds and beasts and other creatures. This is how she serves the purpose ofatithyam (serving unexpected guests) and vaisvadevam (serving sentient beings).”
In Hinduism, the role of cooking and feeding is not that of a lowly servant—it is a divine role manifested in the form of Annapurna Devi, the goddess of food and nourishment, from whom even Lord Shiva receives bhiksha(food gathered as alms through begging).
As eloquently explained by Swami Vivekananda:
“Why should the Hindu mother be worshipped? Our philosophers try to find a reason and they come to this definition: We call ourselves the Aryan race. What is an Aryan? He is a man whose birth is through religion. This is a peculiar subject, perhaps, in this country; but the idea is that a man must be born through religion, through prayers. If you take up our law books you will find chapters devoted to this—the prenatal influence of a mother on the child.
I know that before I was born, my mother would fast and pray and do hundreds of things which I could not even do for five minutes. She did that for two years. I believe that whatever religious culture I have, I owe to that. It was consciously that my mother brought me into the world to be what I am. Whatever good impulse I have was given to me by my mother—and consciously, not unconsciously.
The mother has to eat last. I have been asked many times in your country (the United States) why the (Hindu) husband does not sit with his wife to eat—if the idea is, perhaps, that the husband thinks she is too low a being. This explanation is not at all right.
Stay Connected to Swarajya on Facebook 
The first part of the food—when it is ready—belongs to the guests and the poor, the second to the lower animals, the third to the children, the fourth to the husband, and last comes the mother. How many times I have seen my mother going to take her first meal when it was two o’clock. We took ours at ten and she at two because she had so many things to attend to. [For example], someone knocks at the door and says, “Guest”, and there is no food except what was for my mother. She would give that to him willingly and then wait for her own. That was her life and she liked it. And that is why we worship mothers as gods.”
The late Shankaracharya of Kanchi Kamakoti Peetham, Sri Sri Chandrasekharendra Sarasvati Svami, explains that one of the three objectives of marriage is “to create a means for women (and men) to be freed from worldly existence. A man who is not yet fully mature inwardly is assisted in his karma by his wife. By doing so, by being totally devoted to her husband, she achieves maturity to a degree greater than he does.
In return for the indispensable help a dharma-patni renders to her husband in carrying out his dharma and evolving spiritually, half of whatever punya karma (spiritual merit) the husband attains is transferred to her. On the other hand, none of the paapa karma (spiritual demerit) of her husband inures to her, and none of the punya karma of the wife is transferred to the husband.
So we see that in the marriage vows themselves and in the Hindu conception of woman and her role as a wife, she was in no way a mere maidservant or meant to be an appendage to serve her husband. Her role was much greater than that, and she was given due respect, reverence and recognition for her devotion and sacrifice that benefitted not just her husband, but also her own spiritual evolution and the society at large.
We now come to the second question, which is whether changes in the modern woman’s role at home and in the workforce render the Hindu wedding vows somehow obsolete. The question itself is based on a false premise that these vows are meant to be prescriptive in a literal sense. The Hindu conception of marriage is much more nuanced and diverse than that.
Marriage rituals need to be viewed from a broader perspective.
Marriage rituals need to be viewed from a broader perspective.
Traditionally, Hinduism recognizes eight forms of marriage: brahma(considered to be the highest form of marriage, where the groom’s parents approach the bride’s parents for kanyadana (giving away of their daughter to the others’ son)—here, the bride is sought out by the groom’s family); daiva (where the bride’s parents seek a groom in the area where sacrifices are performed and marry her to a priest who officiates the yajna); arsa (where the bride is given in exchange for two cows from the groom’s family, or alternatively, where the bride is married to a rishi);prajapatya (the same as the brahma style, but the bride’s parents must approach the groom’s parents instead); asura (where the groom is not a match for the bride, but money is given to the bride and her family in exchange); gandharva (where the bride and groom unite out of their own desires); raksasa (forcible abduction of the bride against the wishes of her family (but not necessarily of the bride herself)—this is the form in which Sri Krishna married Rukmini); and paisaca (where the bride does not or is unable to consent—for example, when a man seduces a girl who is unconscious or mentally incapacitated).
Even though the last two forms of marriage are generally discouraged by the shastras and our acharyas, they are recognized for a reason. In Hinduism, shastras are made for man; man is not made for the shastras. In other words, the shastras are developed based on the sociological reality of the day. That is why the smrti are ever-changing, and it is only the Vedas (sruti, that which has been revealed or heard) that are unchanging and eternal.
The Dharmashastras are meant to apply based on time, place and circumstance. Our shastras are not meant to be one-size-fits-all, and thus provision is made for diversity in cultures, customs and personality types. For example, those who are more accustomed to pleasure and sense gratification would be more likely to engage in the gandharva form of marriage.
Similarly, even though the raksasa and paisaca forms of marriage may be unethical, our shastras grant them some recognition so that, to the extent they occur, some provisions may be made for safeguarding the honour and dignity of the woman; however, because they are expressly disapproved of, their occurrence is meant to be minimized as much as possible.
No matter which form of marriage applies, the marriage vows are, at the core, the same. Why? Because there is a bhavana (feeling / state of mind / attitude) and code of values that underlies these Sanskrit shlokas that is universal—they are meant to promote certain vrttis (waves within our consciousness) and lakshanas (qualities that promote masculine virtues for the groom and feminine virtues for the bride).
The vows are not just the bride and groom promising fidelity to each other, but, at a deeper level, are a commitment to being partners who will together care for their families, observe together all of the rites and sacrifices enjoined by the Vedas in the spirit of loka sangraha (wellbeing for the world/ cosmos) and be companions who give comfort and strength to each other. These mantras sanctify and cement a bond between husband and wife and their respective families, and they promote social harmony by guiding couples on how to perform their individual and familial dharma.
No matter what form of marriage is chosen or what socioeconomic roles are assumed by the husband and wife, these core vows are applicable to all—they are the bonds through which a lifelong partnership are formed.
These mantras encode the blessings and tapasya (spiritual power) of our ancestors and devas, our rishis and acharyas, who are invoked through the marriage ceremony, and such mantras are not to be tampered with lightly.
It is not equivalent to the modern practice of couples writing vows to each other based on their personal feelings—there is nothing wrong with that practice but such vows should supplement, not supplant, the core mantras from the vivah samskara (the Hindu marriage rites).
There is a current of energy, of blessings and power in these mantras and rites, which transforms a marriage from a social contract and emotional bonding to a sacred covenant that is strong and lifelong (or, rather, seven lifetimes long).
The taking of Hindu marriage vows with utter sincerity and faith does not preclude a husband and wife from arranging (and rearranging) between themselves their roles within and without the household in new ways.
Hinduism does not promote a cookie cutter mould of our marriage—ours is a tradition that honours the Panchakanya (Ahalya, Draupadi, Sita or Kunti, Tara and Mandodari), venerated as the five ideal Hindu wives, although, in their own way, each of them led an unconventional married life.
The conception of Hindu marriage does not preclude a woman from working or a man from being a house husband. But there needs to be serious reflection on all of the important roles played by a married couple in the Hindu conception of society and how those roles and responsibilities may be carried out equitably in these new scenarios.
We cannot just discard those duties that have been enjoined upon as, but we can find new ways of carrying out those duties—for example, if people feel that Karva Chauth is too one-sided, nothing stops the husband from also fasting on that day (as I know many men do nowadays).
That would be a much healthier alternative than simply stopping the observance of Karva Chauth, as this is a vrata that strengthens the marital bond and also the bond between the bride and her new family. The integration of worship with the marital relationship in Hinduism makes Hindu marriages uniquely sacred and powerful, and we cannot lose that sacred link out of some cheap politicization of the gender wars.
When we understand the spirit of the Hindu wedding rites and mantras, the depth of feeling and philosophical intent behind them, it is impossible to think that they are inherently misogynistic.
Yes, it is true that the rites and mantras have been, through social custom, often interpreted in misogynistic ways. But that was not the original intent of the vivaha mantras. These mantras can be and should be understood, in spirit, in a way that is in harmony with the world in which we live today. That has always been the Hindu way.
That is why there are so many different Dharmashastras / Grihya Sutras—they have to be relevant to differing times, places and circumstances. That is what makes our spiritual tradition so unique—the flexibility of ourshastras to encompass a wide variety of practices, beliefs and traditions while still retaining a universal framework of principles and values that applies to them all.
with special contributions from Dr BVK Sastry 

Kaalaadhan: Menace of Black Money: Bring back Nizam’s wealth first -- Ashok B Sharma. NaMo, nationalise kaalaadhan.

$
0
0
Menace of Black Money: Bring back Nizam’s wealth first
by Ashok B Sharmaon 18 Dec 2014


There is a lot of talk of bringing back black money of Indians stashed away in different tax havens abroad. The ruling BJP had made this an issue in the election campaign before coming to power. It had accused the then Congress-led UPA government of being unable to bring back the black money which according to its estimate ranges between $500 billion and $1,400 billion. A study by Global Financial Integrity put the current value of illicit money outflow to be $462 billion. 

The UPA Government stated in Parliament that the CBI Director’s statement on $500 billion of illegal money was an estimate based on a statement made to the Supreme Court in July 2011. Some reports claim a total of $1.4 trillion stashed away in Swiss banks, while the Swiss Bankers’ Association and government have denied these reports as “false and fabricated”. 

Such are the wild guesses about the quantum of black money stashed away in safe havens abroad. The BJP had earlier accused the Congress-led UPA government about its incapability to bring back the black money, while smaller countries like Vietnam and South Korea had taken firm steps and recovered their wealth.

The issue is what have governments, past and the present, done to bring back the known amount of money stashed in the Royal Bank of Scotland about 66 years ago? The amount is estimated to be 30 million pounds or over Rs 3 billion. The tale of this money dates back to the time of Independence and Partition, when the seventh and last Nizam of Hyderabad, Mir Osman Ali Khan’s finance minister Moin Nawaz Jung transferred 10,07,940 pound sterling and nine shillings in the name of the then Pakistan High Commissioner in London HI Rahimtoola in the National Westminster Bank, which is now called Royal Bank of Scotland. Including the interest earned on the deposit, the amount now is estimated to be over 30 million pounds or Rs 3 billion. 

India had raised objection to the transfer saying the Nizam was not an independent ruler and prevailed upon the bank to freeze the account. Since then the matter is hanging fire. The UK House of Lords had later ruled that the account can only be unfrozen with the agreement between three parties - India, Pakistan and Nizam’s heirs. However, the amount deposited in the Royal Bank of Scotland has no will or trust deed.

The cultural advisor to the Nizam’s Trust, Muhammad Safiullah had estimated in 2008 that the Nizam’s heirs may get 20% of the money, while the Indian government will get a major share. The last Nizam of Hyderabad had 18 daughters and 16 sons; two sons and three daughters are still alive; there are 104 grandchildren. 

The Nizam had refused to accede to India after Independence and wanted Hyderabad to remain an independent princely state, or join Pakistan. But in September 1948, Hyderabad had to join the Indian Union after an operation by Indian armed forces. The Nizam, who known as the richest man of his times, also financed Pakistan’s first national Budget.

In 2008, the UPA government, through a Cabinet decision, decided to pursue an out-of-court settlement after the Nizam’s descendants met the then Prime Minister Dr Manmohan Singh and then Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee. The latter also went to Islamabad in 2008 and offered to settle the issue. But the India-Pakistan dialogue process got derailed after the 26/11 terror attack in Mumbai. Again, after revival, the dialogue process was again derailed after the Pakistani High Commissioner in India met Kashmiri Hurriyat leaders just before foreign secretary level talks were slated to be resumed in Islamabad. Thus the matter still remains unresolved.

The BJP and Prime Minister Narendra Modi should move to bring back the wealth stashed away by the Nizam in the Royal Bank of Scotland.

The Prime Minister made an effort by setting up a Special Investigation Team (SIT) to trace black money, as desired by the Supreme Court. He raised the issue of black money at the BRICS meeting at the margins of G20 in Brisbane and as well as in G20 Summit. The G20 Leaders’ Communiqué noted some transparency in tackling the menace of black money like dealing with base erosion and profit shifting (BEPS) of multinational companies by deciding that “profits should be taxed where economic activities deriving the profits are performed and where value is created.” The leaders committed to finalising the work in 2015, including transparency of taxpayer-specific rulings found to constitute harmful tax practices. They welcomed the progress being made on taxation of patent boxes.

The G20 leaders also decided to begin a global common reporting standard for automatic exchange of tax information (AEOI) on reciprocal basis by 2017 or end-2018, subject to completing necessary legislative procedures.

The government has received some initial information of about 800 account holders with HSBC and is working on it to come to some conclusions. With an eye on the future the government is planning to modify the Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements and other such agreements inked with several countries so as to make disclosures more transparent. It is also thinking of inking new agreements where disclosures would be transparent. But all these are matters of future concern. 

What is needed immediately is to take up the issue of known quantum of wealth stashed away in the Royal Bank of Scotland by the erstwhile Nizam’s finance minister. The amount is substantial at 30 million pounds or Rs 3 billion. The government’s coffer stands to gain substantially as this is the wealth of erstwhile Hyderabad state which rightly belongs to the Indian government after the merger of the princely state. Like Nizam’s state immovable property has become the property of the government after merger, so also the erstwhile princely state’s coffer should be the wealth of the government. India should take up this issue with the UK government to defreeze the account.  
User CommentsPost a Comment
Respected Sir/Madam,

This news about the erstwhile rulers of Hyderabad Deccan stashing away Government wealth in England is not known to many, some six decades after if happened. Legitimately, it belongs to the GOI and the States of AP, Telengana, Maharashtra and Karnataka that are now in possession of the erstwhile territories that constituted the State of Hyderabad under the Nizam.

Whatever non-existing Sovereign locus-standi the Nizam may have had or usurped in sponsoring the first budget of Pakistan ceased to exist after the deposition of his government and the defeat of the Razakars by the GOI.

When the position of GOI is so crystal-clear, one is at a loss to understand how Pakistan came into picture vis-a-vis these funds and why Pranab Mukerji and Manmohan Singh attempted to settle it out of court with Pakistan and on what basis.

This adds another dimension to what transpired at the time of the Partition between Jawaharlal Nehru on our side and M.A.Jinna and L. A. Khan on theirs.

Did J. Nehru offer to share the wealth of the Nizam of Hyderabad and possibly that of the Nawab of Junagadh with Pakistan upon their accession to the State of India? Was it ever made public either via a Gazette Notification or to the Constituent Assembly or to the Constituted Parliaments later? Was a reciprocal offer sought from Pakistan to India when the Princes on the other side ceded to Pakistan? If not, why was it not insisted upon by J.Nehru?

A thorough investigation is needed to go into the circumstances and the manner in which Manmohan Singh and Pranab Mukerjee approached this matter, circumventing the Parliament and the Executive and possibly the Judiciary. Something is clearly fishy here.

If similar deposits were discovered in Portugal originating from Goa or in France originating from Puduchery, would the GOI be forced to share these too with Pakistan ‘out of court’ Manmohan-Pranab style? Are there any limits to appeasing Pakistan by the congress party? Where do their loyalties lie?

Now one understands the difficulties the GOI under Mr. N. Modi is facing in addressing the overseas-wealth and other knotty issues such as Sir Creek, and Kashmir.

With congressmen and congresswomen of doubtful loyalty firmly entrenched everywhere in the polity, in the law-enforcement, in the Judiciary, and in the Executive it is an uphill task indeed to unravel the unaccounted wealth of India.

Subramaniam Narasimhan
December 17, 2014
Subramanaim Narasimhan
http://www.vijayvaani.com/ArticleDisplay.aspx?aid=3427
Viewing all 11232 articles
Browse latest View live


<script src="https://jsc.adskeeper.com/r/s/rssing.com.1596347.js" async> </script>