Quantcast
Channel: Bharatkalyan97
Viewing all 11035 articles
Browse latest View live

26 million illegal Bangladesh immigrants in India. SoniaG UPA in denial of a massive demographic invasion.

$
0
0
Demographic invasion of India from the North East by Brig Amrit Kapur 

in IDR
 
Six decades of ‘Indian effort’, still Seven Sisters have not been fully integrated with the main landmass. Thousands of crores of money has been pumped into the North East. In fact our Central Govt is indirectly financing the underground governing bodies who de facto continue to rule the roost. The problem has been further accentuated by uncontrolled illegal migration from Bangladesh, the situation in the ‘Gateway to the North East’, the ‘Siliguri Corridor’, where insurgency is brewing and is likely to become a major security concern for our country.
Kamtapuri movement is making steady progress in carving out yet another autonomous state by amalgamating six districts of North Bengal viz, Darjeeling, Jalpaiguri, Cooch Behar Maldah, South Dinajpur and North Dinajpur.
As per 2001 census the population of India is approximately 1.02 billion, almost three-fold increase in population of 1947. The three-fold increase is attributable to, inadequacy and inconsistency of India’s family planning programme, (bureaucracy had to tow the line of their political masters) illiteracy, religious disbeliefs, backwardness of the people, underprivileged condition of women in India, poor health facility and so on. But no one bothered to mention that one of the reasons is presence of over 26 million Bangladeshi illegal migrants in India.
At the time of partition, in East Pakistan (now Bangladesh) the Hindu population was 25.6 percent. It got reduced to 14 percent in 1991 and today it has come down to abysmal 7 percent.
Bangladesh has the highest density of population in the world, the density of its population is 982 persons per/sq km. North Eastern States on the other hand are sparsely populated with average density of little over 215 persons per sq km. Principle of void theory in law of nature has taken its course. In addition not so good economic conditions in Bangladesh have forced people to embrace more lucrative options. This is not only true for this region, Mexican influx into south western United States of America is most recent phenomenon. Large-scale demographic movement continues to take place in the NE, resulting in demographic imbalance in states. In the state of Tripura imbalance has resulted in “demographic inversion”. After the partition, till 1971, there was a massive population influx caused by political, communal and economic reasons, which created serious ethnicity problems in these states. At the time of partition, in East Pakistan (now Bangladesh) the Hindu population was 25.6 percent. It got reduced to 14 percent in 1991 and today it has come down to abysmal 7 percent.
Earlier the minority community were literally forced out of East Pakistan (now Bangladesh), primarily due to religious reasons and now mass exodus is taking place due to ‘economic reasons’ by both the communities. Flow of illegal migrants though in small measure continues post 1971 and the progressive cumulative effect is acquiring alarming dimensions. However, when secular democracy was replaced by autocracy following the murder of Sheikh Mujibur Rehman in 1975, hard-core Islamic Fundamentalists were encouraged to infiltrate into North-eastern states to carry out anti national activities and destabilise the democratic system. The bulk of these migrants initially egressed into states bordering Bangladesh. In addition a large number have infiltrated into almost all parts of India including Delhi, Mumbai, Lucknow and other cities for greener pastures creating economic and law and order problems. Vote bank politics as usual supersedes national interests. Assam, Tripura, North Bengal and Meghalaya face maximum threat to the security in this region due to illegal migration. Gradually, this malaise is spreading to other states like Sikkim, Mizoram, Manipur and Nagaland. Even landlocked Himalayan Kingdom of Bhutan is also sitting on the brink of demographic implosion.
Documents and surveys show enough evidence that migrants from Bangladesh are a deciding factor in 23 to 25 Parliamentary and 117 to 127 Assembly Seats in India.
Besides the illegal migrants, there are settlers from other states who have come to these states in search of job opportunities have further compounded the ethnic strife. This influx of infiltrators and internal migration have outnumbered the sons of the soil and causing socio-economic tensions and frustrations over employment opportunities. They are also considered threat to the language and culture of NE. This coupled with the inconsistent approach of the Union Government to bring the people of these States into the mainstream continues to catalyse the growth of militancy in the region.
Mushrooming madarsas, indoctrination at Pakistan sponsored Inter Services Intelligence (ISI) camps (156 known camps) in Bangladesh and pumping in of counterfeit currency in the region are all indicators that insurgency is once again raising its ugly head and is likely to acquire serious dimensions if not checked, controlled and contained speedily, timely and adequately. ISI is taking full advantage of uncertain situation in Nepal, law of jungle states of northern UP bordering Nepal, Bihar and the North East as also as part of its grand design to shift the focus and centre of gravity to much more vulnerable and sensitive areas as also to relieve the pressure in the western region. This is part of a deliberate nefarious design of the ISI to destabilise most sensitive North East region, seriously threatening secular democratic system in India and threatening “Silliguri corridor”.
Documents and surveys show enough evidence that migrants from Bangladesh are a deciding factor in 23 to 25 Parliamentary and 117 to 127 Assembly Seats in India.
India shares 4096 km of border with Bangladesh and it costs Rs three crores per km to effectively police this border, i.e., on account of manning of border by policing force, construction and maintenance of border roads, border fencing, riverine patrols, watchtowers and so on. Over three scores of battalions of Border Security Force are presently policing the border which is woefully inadequate. For effective domination and policing requirement is well over 100 battalions. The government has been able to fence only 987 km of this border till now. Rs. 2300 crores are being spent every year in guarding this border. (WB-2217 Kms, Assam-262 Kms, Meghalaya-443 Kms, Tripura-856 Kms, Mizoram-318 Kms).

Assam: The Victim of Outsiders Effect

Assam is the mother state of the North-East, any instability in this state is bound to have cascading effect in other six sisters. It has 74 percent of total population of the North East. In 1826, Assam was annexed by the British by virtue of the ‘Treaty of Yandabu’ and made part of Bengal presidency. The British in pursuit of their ‘Divide and Rule’ policy, partitioned Bengal in 1905. Assam lost its separate identity and became part of a Muslim dominated East Bengal. In 1911 partition of Bengal was annulled and Assam again became a separate province.
Emerging trends in the region indicate that Muslim Fundamentalist Organisations (MFOs) are joining hands with the militants and disgruntled elements of the society to raise anti-India tirade or separatist movements.
The British imported tea garden labourers from other provinces, as the Assamese were not willing to work as labourers. They also imported peasants from East Bengal, mostly Muslims, to work on virgin land in Lower Assam to meet the growing demand for food in the wake of the large movement of population. The growth of a large Muslim population in the province helped the Muslim League to gain ascendance in Assam. In the 1940s, the demand for Pakistan as a separate homeland for Muslims gained momentum.
The Muslim League wanted Assam to be included in East Pakistan. In 1946, Assam and West Bengal were grouped together. Although, Congress High Command agreed to the grouping, Shri Gopinath Bordoloi, the leader of Assam Congress was quick to see the danger in grouping Assam with Bengal. He rebelled and demanded rejection of grouping plan, thus Muslim League’s plan to get Assam included in East Pakistan was foiled. Zulfikar Ali Bhutto in his book “Myth of Independence” wrote, “It would be wrong to think that Kashmir is the only dispute that divides India and Pakistan. One at least is nearly as important as the Kashmir dispute, that of Assam and some districts of India adjacent to East Pakistan. To these, Pakistan has very good claims. East Pakistan must include Assam to be financially and economically strong”. Wise words, but unfortunately during his lifetime he had to helplessly watch the formation of Bangladesh.
The unabated influx of illegal migrants from Bangladesh/East Pakistan has been continuing after Independence. In 1970, the population of East Pakistan was 7.5 crores but in 1974 it had come down to 7.14 crores. On the basis of 3.1 percent annual growth, the population should have gone up to 7.7 crores. The shortfall of 60 lakhs people can be explained only by large-scale migration. The statistical data on demography speaks for itself.
Relevance of above data gives further credence to the decadal percentage growth of population of All India, Assam and Bangladesh as under: -
You can see from above that the decadal percentage of growth of population in Assam is more than the growth in Bangladesh, except for the period 1971-1981 due to anti-foreigners agitation in the state when these people fled the state and 1991 -2001 obviously due to illegal migration.
The community-wise growth rate given as under will give you a better picture of communal imbalance being created in Assam by the immigration of Bangladeshis :-
As per the 1991 census, four districts of Assam namely Dhubri, Goalpara, Barpeta and Hailakandi became Muslim majority districts. Two more districts; Nagaon and Karimganj have attained Muslim majority in 1998. These statistics indicate that illegal migrants coming into India after 1971 have been exclusively Muslims. These changes have significantly altered the electoral profile of Assam which is unethically exploited by political parties for their partisan gains compromising the stability of the region.

Demographic Inversion in Tripura

In other states there has been demographic invasion leading to demographic imbalance, whereas Tripura had to witness demographic inversion. The tribal population of Tripura, which was 93 percent in 1947 has been reduced to a minority of 23 percent of its 31.9 million population today. The changing demographic balance, economic pressures and awareness resulted in tribal resentment, which grew with the unabated influx of migrants. It is difficult to assess the quantum of immigration since no such data is available; however, a comparison between population growth and the decadal growth birth rate indicates that maximum influx has taken place into Tripura after 1950 which will be evident from the data given as under:
From 1951, the others’ population is growing in leaps and bounds defying the natural growth rate. At present a Mobile Task Force (MTF) is responsible to identify and deport the illegal immigrants from Tripura. From 1974 till mid 2006 the Task Force has deported approximately 1,78,000 illegal immigrants to Bangladesh. It is just a drop in the ocean.Now let us have a look at distribution of population by religion in the state of Tripura:-
This table highlights following issues: -
  • Hindus. The population has been rising by approx 30% every decade.
  • Muslims. The population has been rising steadily at a rate of 40%.
  • Buddhists. Their population has increased by an average rate of 90% each decade. This group mainly comprises Chakmas and Mogs who have come to Tripura from Chittagong Hill Tracts in search of greener pastures and economic opportunities.
  • Christians. Their growth can be attributed to the adoption of Christianity by the Tribals.
Demographic Shift in North Bengal
The illegal Bangladeshi Muslim migrants have settled almost homogeneously all along the porous Indo – Bangladesh border. The similarity in language and customs has perfectly aided the silent gradual mingling of these foreigners. However, some areas have been more favoured than others. A few of these areas lie in the Siliguri corridor and including districts of Cooch Behar, Jalpaiguri, Darjeeling, North Dinajpur and South Dinajpur.
The massive influx of 22 million illegal migrants from Bangladesh is a national problem with economic, administrative and political implications.
Demography of Dhubri district of Assam, which is beset with ULFA, BODO and Islamic Militancy, comprised 70 percent Muslims, as per 2001 figures. There has been a continuous unchecked import of illegal Muslim Bangladeshi migrants into the district after 1991 and the present population of Muslims is over 80 percent.
Swing in Population Pattern
A comparison of figures of population by religion in the Jalpaiguri district gives a fair idea in proliferation of Muslim population:-
It can be seen that the Hindu population within the span of a decade has gone down from 87.50% in 1981 to 84.81% in 1991 to 82.30 registering a decrease of approx 2% whereas the Muslim population has increased from 8.75% to 10.04% to 12.39 registering a steady increase.
As per home ministry and IB estimates approx 54 lakhs Bangladeshi Muslim immigrants are settled in West Bengal. Apart from Bangladeshi Muslims a large number of Bangladeshi Hindus have also crossed over into West Bengal.
During 1971 War, approximately one crore Bangladeshi nationals entered India as refugees. After liberation of Bangladesh, they are believed to have returned to Bangladesh. However, approx 30 lakh, filtered back into India finding that someone else has occupied their land, houses and belongings.

Urgent Need to Contain the Demographic Invasion

This silent invasion of the NE states has been taking place for several decades and the Govt has failed to stem this demographic onslaught. What started as a purely natural and economic movement has now acquired communal, political and international dimensions with serious security overtones. Although Bangladeshi migrants have come into several states of India; their number is alarming in the states of West Bengal, Assam and Tripura. Also they are slowly but surely creeping into Mizoram as cheap labour force. It is high time Mizoram learns a lesson from other sister states. If not effectively checked, they may swamp the sons of the soil and this may also help the fissiparous forces in facilitating severing the NE landmass from the rest of India. This will lead to disastrous strategic and economic results. Politicians for their own vested interests are under playing this issue of grave importance to national security. Lt Gen (Retd) SK Sinha, PVSM , erstwhile Governor of Assam in his report to the Central Govt suggested some steps, which can be taken in this regard, these are: -
  • Awareness should be promoted about illegal migration. It is not only a threat to the identity of the people of NE but a grave threat to our national security.
  • Border fencing should be completed on a war footing. Observation towers and lights should be provided on the same scale as in Punjab and Jammu and Kashmir i.e., Northern and Western Border.
  • BSF battalions deployed should be given responsibility to hold frontages which they can effectively dominate. The time tested modus operandi being followed in Punjab, BSF battalions should hold a frontage of 25 to 30 kilometres in plains and on eastern borders of Bangladesh it may be 10 to 15 kilometres only. Thus need for additional BSF battalions.
  • Diversion of BSF battalions from the border for other task, when the battle against infiltrators is on, must be avoided.
  • All country boats, plying in the river near the border should be registered and their registration numbers marked on them.
  • Provisioning of multi-purpose photo identity cards should be speeded up to all our nationals. Districts bordering Bangladesh should be accorded higher priority.
  • The National Register of Citizens should be updated and computerised. A separate register of Stateless citizens should also be maintained.
  • As far as possible, we should assist in the process of economic development in Bangladesh. Have joint ventures to increase the stakes of each country.
  • Hindu illegal migrants who have infiltrated after 24 March, 1971 should not be given refugee status. They should be treated as illegal migrants.
  • Survey teams working under Magistrates, be nominated to identify the illegal migrants within a fixed time- frame.
  • IMDT Act. The Illegal Migrants Detection Tribunal (IMDT) Act of 1983 was struck down by the Supreme Court in July 2005 following a public interest litigation by Sarmanand Sonawal, AGP MP from Dibrugarh. The IMDT Act of 1983 was applicable only to Assam. A foreigner in Assam is to be dealt with under this act, while in rest of the country they are dealt with under Foreigners Act – 1946. Since 1983, till 2006 the Assam Govt had been able to identify approximately 12000 illegal migrants and of these it has been able to deport only 1700. No country in the world had two sets of laws like this. Obviously, this discrimination against the state of Assam was to appease the minorities. The govt sought to bypass the Supreme Court judgement by bringing amendments to Foreigners Act (1946) by Foreigners (Tribunals) Amendment Order. For political reasons this too was struck down by the apex court in 2006. The drawbacks of the IMDT act are:-
  • Onus of proof to establish citizenship lies with the state of Assam under IMDT Act, while it lies with the individual in case of other states.
  • Police does not have powers to detain, arrest or search a suspect thus making it convenient for the suspected migrant to melt away. They can abscond during the screening period or 30 days period allowed for appeal before the Appellant Tribunal.
  • Unlike other criminal cases, witnesses appearing before the tribunal are not paid any travel expenses. So witnesses refuse to oblige the Govt.
  • The complainants are required to pay a monetary fee to complain against a suspected illegal migrant.
  • Roughly Rs 750 crores have been spent on implementations with hardly any worthwhile results.

Security: Implications and Concerns

The massive influx of 22 million illegal migrants from Bangladesh is a national problem with economic, administrative and political implications.
Three trends emerge from this movement of migrants:-
  • The fear of the indigenous people of being swamped by immigrants threatening their ethnic identity.
  • The desire of foreign elements to somehow acquire Assam.
  • Efforts of some politicians to take advantage of the situation for their own purpose/shortsighted gains.
The illegal migration of Bangladeshi Muslims has acquired a national security dimension, this is being compounded by growing international Islamic fundamentalism and the desperate efforts of forces hostile to India to destabilise the country. It is not far-fetched to visualise a Kashmir like situation in another 5 years, wherein Bangladesh fully supported by Pakistan may fight a proxy war and cause national security problems. There is also a threat to the land link of the North East with the rest of India i.e. the Gateway to the North East i.e., “Siliguri Corridor”. Assam’s turnover of 4900 crores a year in tea, 7800 crores in oil and other economic assets of the North East can be endangered. Any breach of this link will have disastrous consequences for the entire nation.
Emerging trends in the region indicate that Muslim Fundamentalist Organisations (MFOs) are joining hands with the militants and disgruntled elements of the society to raise anti-India tirade or separatist movements.
 
Earlier published articles-
1. Bodo Muslim Conflict in Assam - historical roots by R Upadhyay - http://www.esamskriti.com/essay-chapters/BODO~MUSLIM-CONFLICT-in-ASSAM~-Historical-Roots-1.aspx
2. After 28 years vital Clause 6 yet to be implemented - http://www.assamtribune.com/scripts/detailsnew.asp?id=mar1413/at05
3. Unchecked infiltration by Shib Shankar Chatterjee in IDR 8/12/2012 http://www.indiandefencereview.com/news/unchecked-infiltration/
4. http://www.assamtribune.com/scripts/detailsnew.asp?id=sep1112/at05 - Centre admits infiltration from Bangla.
5. A PIL by NGO Swajan had pleaded with SC that there was an urgent need to segregate the illegal Bangladeshi migrants in Haryana. 
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Haryana-faces-problem-of-illegal-migrants-also/articleshow/15539603.cms?.
6. Promise Land – Bangladeshis in Kerala – On Monday, the state home ministry sent a report to the Centre to this effect, stating that tens of thousands of Bangladeshis had come to the state, according to a report in a leading Malayalam daily. “We welcome workers from other states in the country, but the illegal infiltration of Bangla-deshis is a cause for concern,” Home Minister Thiruvanchoor Radhakrish-nan was quoted as saying.” http://www.business-standard.com/india/news/promise-land/485009/
7. Cattle smuggling to Bangladesh on the upswing – app 1.5 million cows. http://www.theshillongtimes.com/2012/07/23/cattle-smuggling-to-bangladesh-on-the-upswing/
8. We are in denial, but

Bangladeshis are still flooding India's northeast

 in Rediff.  http://www.rediff.com/news/column/bangladeshis-are-still-flooding-indias-northeast/20140321.htm
The local labour force is streaming out of the region looking for jobs in peninsular India, creating a vacuum that makes it easier for the Bangladeshis to fill in, says R N Ravi.
Contrary to the state government’s lore -- that the unregulated influx of Bangladeshis in Assam is a thing of the past -- a recent field research by the writer shows that it is a live and kicking phenomenon. More and more Bangladeshis are filling the expanding labour and low-end services sectors in Assam and its neighbouring states in the northeast.
Mutation of once visceral existential fears over the unregulated migration of Bangladeshi nationals into an inexorable fatalism has been one of the striking characteristics of contemporary socio-political landscape of Assam.
The issue that has seismic implications for national security, the future of Assam and its neighbours and which had once erupted into the historic Assam agitation (between 1979 and 1985) seems to be mourning at the margin today.
The Congress has consistently rubbished the noise over illegal Bangladeshi migration as a mere bogey raised by its political rivals.
Meanwhile, the census of 2011 has tilted the argument against migration.
Unlike the previous decadal censuses since the beginning of the 20th century that showed unusually high population growth in Assam, attributed to migration from Bangladesh and its earlier reincarnations, the census of 2011 showed a decline to 16.93, below the national average of 17.64.
The Congress government flaunts it to bolster its long-held position denying the Bangladeshi migration and rebuffing those who feel otherwise.
The decline in the decadal growth rate of Assam’s population from a significantly high figure to merely the national average and then to one below the national average in the latest census gives an impression that Bangladeshi migration to the state is a phenomenon of the past.
However, emerging new settlements of Bengali Muslims at the outskirts of cities and towns of Assam and the absence of an effective border control regime make such a conclusion counter-intuitive.
The census data, usually, is considered the most authentic source for insights into demographics and its nuances. However, in the northeast, it has not been entirely above suspicion. Several local communities suspect its integrity.
Absurd data like a considerable four per cent negative population growth in Nagaland in the 2011 census lends weight to their suspicion. In such a scenario, it made sense to look for empirical evidence on the issue to discern the truth.
An empirical research conducted in the eight colonies of settlers that emerged in the last two decades at Lahorijan in Karbianglong district of Assam, adjoining Dimapur in Nagaland, has revealed some startling facts.
Lahorijan is in close proximity to Dimapur town. It is littered with sprawling unauthorised colonies of Muslim settlers. Some of the colonies -- Dudu, Balijan and Shantigaon -- are huge unauthorised settlements, each with nearly 15,000 or more inhabitants. The assessed population of the eight colonies that were subject to the survey was over one lakh.
The study has revealed that the majority of the colony dwellers were displaced families from other parts of Assam who were rendered homeless and landless due to periodic floods and erosion. However, at least 26 per cent among the settlers were found to be illegal migrants from Bangladesh who arrived after 1990 and continued to stream in, at a higher pace, in the last decade.
Although each of the one thousand families in the eight colonies randomly picked up for the survey claimed to have been displaced from other parts of Assam, 26 per cent among them furnished false pre-displacement addresses.
Verification of the revenue records and on the spot detailed inquiries at the given previous addresses revealed their deceit.
Later, when they were confronted with their falsehood and likely Bangladesh origin, they shied away from further scrutiny. The study focused more comprehensively on these families.
Unlike the displaced families from other parts of Assam who invariably shifted the whole family including the children, the aged and the infirm, the migrants from Bangladesh were mostly adults, all in the age group between 20 and 50 years.
The Bangladeshi migrants were overwhelmingly illiterate, though a few among them were semi-literate.
Over 50 per cent of them were daily wage labourers engaged in construction and farm work.
Nearly 25 per cent plied rickshaws and six per cent were involved in masonry. The rest earned their livelihood through a host of activities including hawking, tailoring, plumbing, carpentry, rag-picking, working in restaurants, shops and as housemaids.
One was a teacher in a makeshift school in one of the colonies and another one was a maulvi at a newly set up mosque.
These colonies began emerging in the late 1980s but gathered momentum in 1990s.
Nearly 36 per cent of the Bangladeshi migrants in these colonies came into existence in the late 1980s.
About 26 per cent were formed between 1990 and 2000, indicating a decline in the pace but it picked up in the subsequent decade -- 2000-2010 -- during which approximately 40 per cent of them arrived and settled there.
The study revealed a direct co-relation between the increase in the volume of central funds to the northeast and the pace of illegal Bangladeshi migration. These Bangladeshi migrants, contrary to the orthodox view about them, do not engage in their traditional wetland cultivation. They cater to the needs of labour in the non-agricultural sector.
Steadily increasing flow of funds from the Centre to the northeast since the days of the National Democratic Alliance’s rule -- that adopted the policy of 10 per cent budgetary allocation of all the Union ministries to the region -- has created a skewed economic landscape due to the growth of urbanisation without any industrial base.
The scenario is such that a few are getting richer overnight while the bulk of population remains largely untouched by the growth story.
Construction activities are at an all-time high. Shopping malls, restaurants, personal healthcare institutions, spas and beauty parlours are mushrooming at the urban centres.
In contrast, in rural areas, millions are still rendered homeless and forced to live on the road for months on end due to the rampaging floods. Children are forced to abandon schools, disrupting their academic calendars for several months, during the floods.
Some 20 years of the North-East Industrial Policy -- aimed at boosting industrial growth in the region -- and the inflow of torrents of development funds for the last decade and a half have failed in providing a credible industrial base and dignified job opportunities for the youth in the region.
The local labour force is streaming out of the region and to the rest of India in huge numbers for menial low-paid jobs as private security guards, plantation workers, domestic aids, road construction laborers etc.
A recent study (International Journal of Current Research, Vol 6, January 2014, Jyotikona Chetia) shows how diminishing avenues of traditional livelihood and absence of job opportunities are driving hordes of youth from Dhemaji district in Assam to the rest of India in search of menial jobs.
The study shows that the distraught parents encourage their teenaged sons to escape the local environment -- of uncertain life and absent livelihood -- to remote corners of India even when the wages are pitifully low.
The magnitude of the youth exodus may be gauged from the fact that from Gormua, a village of 700 households in Sissirborgaon block, over 400 young men have left for peninsular India in search of menial jobs. Such bulk exodus of the youth from rural Assam is causing serious socio-cultural distortions.
One of the aftereffects of the youth exodus is a labour vacuum in the state that makes it easier for the Bangladeshis to fill.
The emerging pockets of palpable prosperity and concomitant demand by the neo-rich for luxuries and artifacts of a better life have created enhanced pressure on labour for unskilled or semi-skilled services.
Such demands are acting as pull factors for Bangladeshi immigrants. A robust ethnic support base comes in the way of their detection as they have little difficulty in getting absorbed in the local milieu.
The study revealed that the present format of special developmental assistance to the region -- instead of absorbing the local youths -- is providing employment to a large number of Bangladeshis and is an incentive for further influx.
The continuing unregulated influx of Bangladeshis in the northeast is fraught with insidious geopolitical and security implications for the country.
And for the northeast, especially Assam, it is an existential issue. Confronting it with due seriousness is a long overdue imperative for India’s national security.
Image: A flood victim carries her kitchen utensils on her head while walking through her flooded neighborhood to a relief camp in the village of Bijuli Bari, in Assam. Photograph: Reuters
R N Ravi is a retired special director of the Intelligence Bureau and monitored the China border for over 20 years. He can be reached at ravindra.narayan.ravi@gmail.com

How Modi transformed Kutch after the Bhuj quake of 2001 -- Atish Patel

$
0
0
Courtesy Hurst Publishers
 
Mr. Simpson’s book cover. 
Q&A: How 2001 Quake Aided Modi’s Rise 
Atish Patel, Dec. 27, 2013

At 8:46 a.m. on Jan. 26, 2001, a 7.7-magnitude earthquake shook the state of Gujarat, killing 20,000 people and toppling around 339,000 homes.

Over a decade later, Kutch – the district in the western Indian state hit hardest by the calamity – has transformed into an economic boomtown with flat new roads, an airport and tax-free zones that have attracted hundreds of businesses and created thousands of jobs. The state’s chief minister, Narendra Modi, has touted the region’s development as one of the successes of his government. 
But anthropologist Edward Simpson argues in a new book that not all the changes in Kutch following the earthquake have been for the better, and that in the years following the quake, divisions between Hindus and Muslims in Kutch have widened.
In “The Political Biography of an Earthquake,” published in the U.K. earlier this month, Mr. Simpson also makes the case that the disaster offered Mr. Modi, Gujarat chief minister since late 2001, an opportunity to strengthen his position in the Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party. This year, the BJP, presently in the opposition at the federal level, announced that Mr. Modi was its choice for prime minister ahead of national polls next year.
The Gujarati-speaking 42-year-old author, who teaches at London’s School of Oriental and African Studies, spoke with The Wall Street Journal about the book, which will be available in India next year. Edited excerpts.
The Wall Street Journal: What led you to write this book?
Edward Simpson: I stayed in [the Kutch coastal town of] Mandvi for two years between 1997 and 1999 researching Muslim seafaring traditions. When the earthquake hit Gujarat, I phoned up people living in Bhuj [a town in Kutch flattened by the earthquake] to see how they were, what they were doing and what the conditions were like.
That was what really sparked my interest in doing the research. I wasn’t really interested in disasters until that point. It was the narratives and the suffering of the people I knew that drew me to it.
WSJ: What role did Hindu nationalist groups like the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh [National Volunteers Association] and Vishwa Hindu Parishad [World Hindu Council] play in the aftermath of the quake?
Mr. Simpson: In the aftermath of an earthquake, the nongovernment sector is often organized along religious or political lines, as it is in peacetime and non-disaster time as well. So some religious organizations tended to support their own communities over others.
The VHP and the RSS were already established in Bhuj at the time of the earthquake, so through existing networks they were able to mobilize resources. They were incredibly quick to act and very well prepared and bought to many people the sort of relief and comfort I suppose people needed.
They were very efficient with funeral rites, very efficient with the distribution of food – much more so than the state.
If I have a critical perspective on the actions of these groups, it is on how, during reconstruction, these organizations were allowed to become private partners of [the state].
Villages were being built by these organizations and that’s how they built their support base. They could set rules on who could live [in reconstructed villages] and who couldn’t.
WSJ: Many have called the earthquake a blessing in disguise because it accelerated industrial growth to turn Kutch into an economic boomtown. Do you agree?
Mr. Simpson: It is controversial to think about something that killed so many people as a blessing. But I will also say that I’ve heard people in Kutch describe it as a blessing in disguise, including people who lost loved ones in the disaster.
The rate of change has been such that it’s a very different place and there is far more money in Kutch than there was before.
Many people became much richer because of various compensation schemes and the price of land. In this way, the earthquake had some really quite dramatic effects on the household economy for many people – not for everyone of course. And I think that is the blessing that people are talking of.
For the media, the blessing is the industrialization and infrastructure, but I’m not so convinced that people in Kutch are talking about that. Most of the region in Kutch that has been industrialized was not affected by the earthquake.
Mostly the roads and factories are quite far removed from the lives of many people affected by the earthquake. I think a lot of industrialization would have happened anyway, but the earthquake was a facilitator, something to speed up the process.
WSJ: Did Modi and the BJP bolster their popularity in the region in the wake of the earthquake?
Mr. Simpson: Mr. Modi’s repeated presence in Kutch [as part of reconstruction efforts] has done much to sideline his former rivals in the region.
The BJP has presented the reconstruction of western Gujarat as a rip-roaring and unproblematic success – a vindication of their policies. It is one of my aims in the book to show that there is much more to the story than that and success is itself a political and subjective measure. How success is measured and counted is something that people in Gujarat should be critically and openly discussing.
In Bhuj, watching that town being rebuilt, the ways in which divisions have been forced into new urban design — and not only by deliberate political will, but also by bureaucratic processes, by Muslims wanting to live closer together for reasons of fear, which was quite often the case around 2002 and 2003 –  I think Bhuj now is a more polarized town than it was before the earthquake.
WSJ: In your book you note that Shyamji Krishnavarma, a Kutch-born freedom fighter that Mr. Modi has described as an inspiration, was heavily publicized by the BJP in the years following the earthquake. You describe Mr. Krishnavarma as a troubled man who was almost autocratic. Do you see any similarities between the two men?
Mr. Simpson:  I don’t think there’s much of a similarity, but Krishnavarma has been very useful in creating new kinds of political ideas in Gujarat. Krishnavarma is part of the school curriculum and many of the key buildings in Bhuj are named after him. There has been a concerted effort to promote [a man] who promoted the use of violence to bring about the freedom of India.
Krishnavarma represents a very different kind of Gujarati freedom figure to those who have come to be synonymous with Gujarat in the late 20th century. He is very different toSardar Patel and Mahatma Gandhi. He is much more aggressive.
For the BJP, Krishnavarma is a very convenient rediscovery. It allows them to rewrite the history of who are the heroes of Indian history, and that I think is a very integral part of Mr. Modi’s project in Gujarat.
When posters were put up [of Mr. Krishnavarma] — tens of thousands of them in western India between Mumbai and Kutch around 2003 — the photograph they chose to use had more than a passing resemblance to Mr. Modi.
Atish Patel is a multimedia journalist based in Delhi. You can follow him on Twitter @atishpatel.
Follow India Real Time on Twitter @WSJIndia

Swiss Bank secrecy ends - Report. Restitution of Illicit wealth should begin.

$
0
0

http://www.admin.ch/opc/en/classified-compilation/20100418/201102010000/196.1.pdf Federal Act 

on the Restitution of Assets illicitly obtained by Politically Exposed Persons Restitution of Illicit Assets Act (RIAA) of 1 October 2010 (Status as of 1 February 2011)

Start with return of Rajiv Gandhi account monies (reported by Schweizer Illustriete) to Indian financial system. NaMo government should enact an ordinance nationalising such illicit wealth held abroad the way Indira Gandhi nationalised private banks.

Kalyanaraman


Swiss Bank Secrecy Ends

Swiss Bank
The News Minute| Bangalore, Geneva| May 6, 2014| 10.10 pm IST
The Swiss banking secrecy laws, cherished and envied by one and all ended today as Switzerland signed on to an Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) pledge with 47 other countries with which it will be obliged to exchange a series of information. 
“It is clearly the end of banking secrecy abused for tax purposes,” said OECD tax Director Pascal. Switzerland and Singapore on Tuesday joined the growing ranks of countries agreeing to share tax information automatically between governments. 
An influential Swiss money manager told The News Minute (TNM) under the pledge signed by a total 47 countries, all financial information will be shared between governments, including taxpayers' bank balance, dividends, interest income and sales proceeds used to calculate capital gains tax. While secrecy ends, foreigners with bank accounts in the country will be able to conduct normal and transparent businesses.
"It's clearly the end of bank secrecy abused for tax purposes," OECD tax director Pascal Saint-Amans told journalists at a meeting held by the international think tank in Paris. "It means that governments can really assess the tax owed by people who thought they could hide in other jurisdictions," he added.
The agreement with the OECD will also mean that all countries including India will now be able to automatically receive information about illegal activities in Swiss banks by tax evaders and money launderers.
While most of the signatories had already committed to sharing tax information on an automatic basis, the fact that Switzerland and Singapore have now also signed up is a big step in a fight against tax evasion that governments have intensified since the global financial crisis.
With agencies
Facing mounting pressure to dismantle a cherished culture of banking secrecy, some of Switzerland's 300-plus private banks had already signalled last year their readiness to work with U.S. officials to crack down on wealthy Americans.
Switzerland is still the world's biggest offshore financial centre with $2 trillion (1.17 trillion pounds) in assets. But Singapore is breathing down its neck and a 2013 study showed finance professionals see it soon overtaking the Alpine nation amid a global tax crackdown and tighter regulation.
http://www.thenewsminute.com/stories/Swiss%20Bank%20Secrecy%20Ends#.U2m44IGSySp

Vrddha Garga was the earliest reference to precession of equinoxes?

$
0
0
"Clearly, both the astronomical markers recorded by Rishi Gargya in Atharva Veda kaanda 19 sookta 7 would be correct only near about circa 2400 BCE. This must certainly be incontrovertible proof that Rishi Gargya's Sookta was composed near 2400 BCE, dating Atharvana Veda to at least 2400 BCE." The key question is: what is the date of Vrddha Garga? Abhyankar claims it to be 500 BCE. http://www.new1.dli.ernet.in/data1/upload/insa/INSA_1/20005b5f_19.pdf 

Kalyanaraman
http://www.vedicastronomy.net/stars_bharatheeya.htm


NAMES OF STARS FROM THE PERIOD OF THE VEDAS
Bharateeya Nakshatra system
Though the lunar time between two successive full moons is 29.53059 solar days, the time taken for moon to go round the earth (sidereal month) is 27.32166 days. Moon also has an oscillatory motion crossing the ecliptic. The moon anomalistic motion and nodal motion have periods are 27.55545 and 27.21222 days for a revolution around earth. The reason for time between full moons being higher than sidereal month is because, the moon has to go around the earth by more than a revolution (nearly 390 degrees) to keep with earth which moves forward in its trajectory around sun. The Chandramaana lunar calendar system keeps a natural cyclic count of days using two Moon based properties described below.
First property is that moon functions as an astronomical day count clock in which Moon is the pointer and the stars are numerals in the sky pointed to by moon each day of the lunar month. The astronomers of Vedic period identified this approximate 13 degree movement of the moon between successive days and named the 27/28 stars pointed to by moon on a daily basis over a rotation as 27/28 nakshatra's, corresponding to little less than a lunar month. Thus a Nakshatra shift corresponds to moon traverse over approximately one solar day.
The second property is the size of fractional moon exposure to sun can indicate a day count and is defined as a moon day or thiti. Thirty thiti's are defined in a lunar month, each thiti being smaller than a solar day. Fifteen are identified as Shukla paksha or ascending fortnight and next fifteen are called krishna paksha or descending fortnight.
This system of day count calendar keeping, is traceable to Veda's. Veda's, which are perhaps the oldest original documentation of knowledge any where in the world, still in their original shape and language. A study of theVeda's, Brahmana's, and Aaranyaka's point exclusive use of a lunar pointer as the primary calendar in the Vedicperiods. Pournamsya, a time at which earth, sun, moon are aligned is a time of singularity used for religious purposes and formed the unit of half a month and is used in Rigveda. The Vedas also refer to solar events such as Aayanas, and Vishuwat-Sankramana's as solar singular events. Ayana means Solstices when apparent North-South movement of Sun reverses, usually occurring on June 21 and Dec 22. Vishuwat means equal or the spring and fall equinox’s when daytime is equal to nighttime, usually occurring on March 21 and Sep 21. There are vedic references to solar singularities with corresponding solar/lunar pointed star locations.
The six-season definition is unique to vedic system and is not found in any other recorded culture or system. These seasons are, Vasanta, Geeshma, VarshaSharad, Himavanta and Shishira each season being about two moon cycles. It is in Taittareeya Samhita (Krishna Yajurveda) and in Atharva samhita 19th kaanda /7th Sootrathat an explicit first definition and identification of the twenty- seven(28) Nakshatra’s is available (Refs, 1 and 2). It should be noted that the concept of Zodiac/Raashi is not even hinted in any vedic texts of the old period.
The table below provides a list of the twenty-seven stars from Taittareeya Samhita and Krishna Yajurveda 4thKaanda 4th Prashna of Andhra School. Similar list is referred to in Atharvaveda, 19th kaanda/7th Sookta. It differs from the Yajurveda list in that twenty eight stars are listed. In 19th Kaanda/8th sooktha twenty eight(ashtha vimshaaninakshatras are declared. The nakshatra not explicitly used in Jyotishya and in yajurvedais named Abhijit. The taiaareeya brahmana (third Ashtaka) derived from yajurveda again lists 28 nakshatrasincluding Abhijit. It is referred to in Athrvana veda. The author or Drashtaara of Atharva veda sookta is Gaargya Rishi.
The confusion about 27/28 Nakshatras can be analyzed as follows. The 27.3 days taken by moon for visiting the same star can be rounded to either 27 or 28. Each of these integers represents a nakshatra or a daily star. It is possible that initially 28 nakshatras were proposed and defined to represent every day. This is evident fromGargya’s Nakshtara sooktha. Subsequently many years later when Jyotishya was taking a more formal and mathematical shape, 27 integer identities were perhaps found to be more reasonable and accurate. Hence one of the original 28 nakshatras had to be deleted. This could not be done easily as the vedas are considered to be ‘apourusheya’ and no liberties were allowed. Hence perhaps Abhijit, was declared to be an imaginary nakshatrameant only for phala.(ref 10).
The Table below lists names of Nakshatras, the deity to which Nakshatra is dedicated to, and alternate names.Ashwini and Bharani are listed as last two Nakshatras. Note that the list starts from Krittika and not fromAshwini as is currently used in Jyotishya Shaastra (Ref 3). The time at which Rishi Gargya documented the list of nakshatra's in Atharvana Veda is at least circa 2400 BC, as analyzed in appendix I. The appendix also dates the Jyotishya Shaastra as having been brought in to the present form around circa 400 BC.
NakshatraNo. of starsAlternate nameDedicated to
Krittika6Agni
Rohini5Prajaapati
Mrigasheerisham3Soma
Aardharaa1Rudra
Punarvasu2-4Aditi
Tishya3PushyaBrihaspati
Aaslesha1AshreshaSarpa
Maghaa5Pitru
Poorva Phalguni2PubbaBhaga
Uttara Phalguni2Uttara
Hastaa3Savitru
Chitra1ChittaIndra
Swati1Vaayu
Vishaaka2Indraagni
Anooradha4Mitra
Jyeshta3Indra
Vichruta11MoolaPitru
Aashada2PurvashadaAapah
Aashada(Abhijit)3UttarashadaVishvedeva
Shrona3ShravanaVishnu
Shravishta4DhanishtaVasu
ShathaBhishaja100Indra
Proshtapada2Purvabhadra
Proshtapada2UttarabhadraAhirbadhni
Revathi32Pausha
Ashwini3Ashwini
Bharani3Yama

The lunar calendar was in universal and secular use in ancient Bhaarata. Historical events used lunar calendar for dating all events. It is well known that Gautama Buddha was born, achieved his enlightenment and died on full moon day with the full moon pointing to Vishakha Nakshatra. The twelve months were named after the stars at which full moon occurs and these are ChaitraVaishakha, Jyeshta, Ashaada, Sharavna, Bhadrapda, Ashwija, Kaartika, Margashira, Pushya, Maagha, Phalguna. Typically alternate stars with some skips refer to month names and hence accommodate 27 stars corresponding to nearly 360 degrees motion of Sun in a solar year.The first question that arises is whether a 'Nakshatra' corresponds to one single star entity or a group of stars in the sky. Bharateeya Jyotishya shaastra states that each Nakshatra name corresponds to a group of stars called star mansions or Asterisms. The concept is that Chandra or Moon visits these mansions in his trajectory around earth. It is very possible that at the inception of daily star concept during the early vedic period, a Nakshatra may have been a specific single star. Nakshatra positions may have been rationalized in later days to mansions or groups of stars for purposes of mathematical averaging to be exactly 13.333 degrees apart required in Jyotishya. The table above also shows the number of stars, accepted by Jyotishya shaastra, constituting the specific Nakshatra.

European Influence on the Bharatheeya system:

The European view (originally from Chaldian and Kassarian cultures of Middle East and from Egypt), propagated by Greek philosophers, of the night sky and the star system ran in a different direction in ancient times in that Sun was considered as the pointer to skies. In contrast, the moon is considered to be the primary pointer fromvedic astronomical point of view. Star groups pointed to by the sun were defined as Zodiacs representing clusters of stars forming shapes of animals and figures. Zodiacs were named after animal shapes or Greek mythological figures. The twelve months were named and represented Zodiac groups, which had an animal form through which the Sun passes.
If we compare the names of Bhaarateeya Rashis and Zodiacs and Weekdays, are same but for the language as shown in table below. It is inconceivable that two non-communicating societies can evolve name systems, which are translations of each other in a linguistic sense. Clearly, one of the two parties influenced the other.
RavivarSundaySun
Induvasar or SomavarMondayMoon
Bhomyavasar or MangalvarTuesdayMars
Sowmyavasara orBudhavarWednesdayMercury
Brihaspativasara or GuruvarThursdayJupiter
Bhargava vasara or ShukravarFridayVenus
Sthiravasara or ShanivarSaturdaySaturn

MeshaAries
VrishabhaTaurus
MithunaGemini
KarkatakaCancer
SimhaLeo
KanyaVirgo
TulaLibra
VrishchikaScorpio
DhanuSagitarrius
MakaraCapricorn
KumbhaAquarius
MeenaPisces
The Vedas and other older texts do not refer to weekdays named after Graha's or Planets or to Raashis. TheGrahas referred to in Veda's are Surya, ChandraBrihaspati, Shukra, Budha, shani, Kuja, Rahu, Ketu. They extensively refer to Nakshatra month names and moon pointing at different Nakshatra's for various purposes. Therefore it appears likely that the Bharateeya cosmological system interacted with the European solar calendar and gradually the Jyotishya shaastra was modified to the present form, as we know now. Sun based concepts ofRashi, weekdays were invoked in to Jyotishya. This could have occurred, perhaps through contact with Yavanas (Greek's) as there is considerable evidence of Greek and Bharateeya interaction during period before Chandra Gupta. Appendix provides astronomical time markers which confirm the origins of Jyotishya Shaastra in present form to circa 400 BC. Without acceptance of this interaction, it is difficult to explain why the twelve Zodiacs of the European star system are translations of the Nakshatra-Rashi defined in Jyotishya.
It is worth while looking at the some Bharateeya astronomers of a more recent time of 300-500 AD. They areAryabhataVaraha MihiraBrahma Gupta. These astronomers were aware of the vedic astronomy and made new and unique contributions. Specifically Aryabhata made contributions to Spherical geometry, a part of understanding the earth as a globe. Varaha Mihira's contributions include pesently used Soorya Siddhanta, (He refers to nine types of time keeping and calenders) and the fact that he proposed Prime Meridian through Ujjainin Madhya Pradesh. He knew of Earth's Precession and called it as ayanaamshaBrahma Gupta made contributions to Arcsin in Trigonometry. Aryabhata had estimated the beginning of kaliyuga as 3102 BC. He stated that when he was 26, sixty of the 60-year cycles were completed after start of kaliyugaVarahmihiramade an estimate of 2526 before start of Shaka varsha for Mahabharata's Yudhishtira. Texts from that period likeYavana Jataka, Romaka Siddahnta provide evidence of understanding of European astronomical works.
The Chandramaana Lunar scale has 27 daily and twelve month name definitions. While amalgamating the solar calibrations of zodiacs in to Lunar calibrations of Nakshatra's, the issue of translating 27 Nakshatras in a revolution to 12 Rashis was solved in Jyotishya Shaastra by treating 1/4 of a Nakshatra as a unit making Nine quarters of Nakshatra as one Raashi.
Every society in human history has had its own vision and definition of skies. The precision of Egyptian,(Chaldean/Akkadian) Messapotamian, Mayan, Stonehenge, Chinese culture are known to us, and certainly there must have been many others unknown to documented history. The stars in the skies were identified and named as single stars or groups and their relation to sun movement has been observed (Ref 6,7,8,9).
Chinese have had a long tradition of astronomical observations. They appear to have used, Sun, Moon and Jupiter as pointers which included zodiac division in to 28 segments as early as 1200 BC. The 28 segmental division is somewhat similar to vedic system. The starting position of the 28 zodiacs was in Libra (near Swati orVishakha). That appears to rule out Chinese interaction with Vedic culture.
The concept of animal shaped zodiac representing 10-12 zodiacs per year is attributed to Chaldean and Akkadian cultures of Messapotamia. Egyptian Dendera Palnisphere, presently in France, which has been dated to about 1800 BC shows the twelve zodiacs (Ref 4). The earliest traceable documentation from European sources is by Ptolemy in 130 AD, who lived in Alexandria in current Egypt. He compiled data from many centuries of European knowledge before him and he used Hipparchus's astronomical observations (nearly 300 year older than Ptolemy) for many of his observations. The observation of Earth's Precession is attributed to Ptolemy and Hipparchus, and is a major astronomical observational finding. Ptolemy’s works comes down to modern days via Arab astronomers who called his work `Al magist’. In this Ptolemy, refers to 48 constellations in the skies. He used the Egyptian year and month names, which were well advanced and similar to Julian system. Interaction of middle eastern/European astronomical knowledge with Bharateeya knowledge clearly must have happened, much before Ptolemy when many Greeks were in Bhaarat. Ptolemy's zodiac boundaries are different from present zodiac boundaries of same name. The Arab astronomers used Ptolemy's data base and made a thorough study of the skies after Ptolemy and many individual stars were named by them in post Ptolemy centuries. These names have been widely accepted and used.
During many centuries after Ptolemy's time, number of changes have occurred in constellation definitions and boundaries. In 17th century, Bayer systematically named stars using three parameters, first to give star a serial number in its constellation, and second to assign a Greek alphabet representative of the brightness and third to refer to constellation where star is. Therefore a should always be the brightest star of the constellation followed by b, etc. Flamsteed numbers are another catalog of stars from same era. The presently accepted 88 Zodiac definition was frozen in 1932 by International Astronomical Union and stars are named by Bayer's system. This came about because of the meriad constellation names and boundaries that were being floated at that time.
Since the profound beginnings of modern astronomy by Kepler, Galileo, Newton and their astonishing advances in recent times by Hubble and others, extensive and detailed catalogs of all bodies in skies have been made. Optical and other electromagnetic wavelength telescopes have been used to study all objects in the skies. The modern astronomers have a very precise understanding of major and minor planetary motion, binary stars, Messier objects, Comets, and even man made objects in sky. Modern astronomical science has catalogs all the visible stars. The identification currently extensively used in modern astronomy is the HD number standing for Henry Draper Classifications, and SAO number standing for Smithsonian Astronomical Observatory catalog number. There are star catalogs from Germany, France, and Britain.
Most of the European style analysis of astronomical references in veda's (starting from German and British writers of 19 and early 20th century) have always suggested that the vedic text astronomical observations were generally primitive and any non-primitive elements were some how derived from Messapotamian/Akkadian/Chaldean origins. These analyses trivialize any significant original observations in theVeda's. This bias has been brought out be David Frawley succinctly in his work (ref-8).
Star Brightness/rules used for identifying Vedic star equivalence
Star brightness has been numerically expressed since Hipparchus in 150 BC. The scale presently used to measure brightness of objects is an inverse geometrical scale with brightness of sun at -26. With such a bright object, flooding atmosphere, other objects in sky are only visible to normal human eyes during night when sun is not visible. Full moon has a brightness of -12. Venus at its brightest has a brightness of -3. A change of brightness by 2.56 refers to a change of brightness by factor of two. The brightest star is Sirius, which has a brightness of -1.5. On a clear dark night (without moon), the dullest object that can be seen by healthy human eye is considered to be +6.
The following principles and assumptions can perhaps be used as the basis for establishing identity ofBharateeya Nakshatras in this article.
*Nakshatra named by people at Vedic time, must have been visible to naked eye and hence must be brighter than +5, based on brightness definitions.
*Moon is said to visit the Nakshatra or star mansions. Moon traverse plane is inclined to sun motion plane and hence over a period of time, the moon trajectories form a band. Let us call it as the moon traverse band. It is typically 5 degrees around ecliptic. Hence for any star or group of stars to qualify as a Nakshatra, it must be within the moon traverse band or outside not exceeding a few moon diameters. One Moon diameter is about 0.6 degree as seen from earth.
* The Nakshatras should be about 13.33 degrees apart or to 1/27 of 360.
* It is also necessary that they belong to the Raashi's or twelve Zodiacs. There are 88 officially identified zodiacs in the sky, moon traverse band passes only through 12. It should be noted that the Raashi or zodiac boundaries may vary from past definitions of 2400 years ago when possibly the Zodiac concepts were amalgamated in toJyotishya.
*In Bharat, the traditional Panchangas/almanacs provide chandramana details including the beginning and end of visit of moon to 27 Nakshatras time to within few minutes of accuracy for every day of the year. Such almanacs are used even today for religious purposes. This data has to correlate with our identification in that moon must be near the star.
Implicit in these rules is the assumption that Jyotishya Shaastra experts of circa 400 BC carried forward the knowledge and identity of the Nakshatras correctly from vedic period accurately in correlating nakshatra's toRaashi's at that time. It is this interrelation of Nakshatras and Raashi's that permit us to identify what the vedictime names of stars were. The effect of natural motion of stars is assumed to be insignificant, but accounting for precession or Ayanamsha is necessary.
An astronomical computer software, LOADSTAR PRO GS has been used to identify the traditional Bharateeya Nakshatras and their equivalents based on the rules and assumptions declared above.
LoadStar Pro GS Astronomical Software
This is a powerful modern computer based astronomical program (ref 5). This software provides the view of sky from 10000 BC to 10000 AD at any specific location and time on earth. The accuracy of this software is declared to be as follows.
4000BC-2000BC2000BC-0AD0-1900AD1900AD-2000AD
Sun24 arcsec6 arcsec4 arcsec2 arcsec
Moon0.9 deg0.5deg6 arcmin13arcsec
Stars---2 arcsec
Software can track solar system bodies, stars, Messier Objects, Comets and all natural heavenly bodies given a date and time. This program provides graphic view of the sky for any coordinate system and can correct for earth's Precession, Proper Motion in the Milkiway, optical refraction due to air (altitude and temperature) for any day in Gregorian calendar (16th century AD) or Julian calendar extrapolated back up to 10000 BC. Further, the location of the observer at any latitude, longitude and altitude is accounted for. The software is capable of identifying all Henry Draper objects, Smithsonian Astronomical Objects and others. The various pictures provided in this document are derived from this software. The software has been cross-correlated to Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory's Ephemeris, and Interactive Computer Ephemeris (ICE) of US Naval Observatory for 20th century.
The night sky picture for various Raashis are presented in approximately 30 degrees square of night sky. The Moon traverse band is found by finding moon trajectories over a period of 20 years. This is shown in all the figures as a band of dots. The Sun trajectory is fixed and bisects the moon band as a line.
The Nakshatras were identified by using the material from Bhaarateeya chandramana panchangas (Almanacs) for a given day and looking at the moon pointer to see which Nakshatra was pointed to, over a period of randomly chosen dates covering a hundred year period. Then the rules laid out above were used to choose the best candidate for Nakshatra.
Figure 1 shows the picture of Mesha or Aries group of Stars in the sky. Clearly, the Moon Band does not touch the Mesha Raashi or Aries as presently identified, but is within about 5 degrees of the band. Figure 1 shows fourNakshatras viz., Revati from Meena Raashi, Ashwini, Bharani, and Krittika.
Ashwini Nakshatra is defined in Bharateeya Jyotishya as group of three stars. A study of the figure 1 suggests that the best candidates for this group are as shown in table below based on brightness point of view, location with reference to moon traverse band and distance from previous Nakshatra.
NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Ashwini3751511292913 a Aries+2.01Hamal
7510211636Aries+2.63-
92680115025g1-Aries+3.9-
The month of Ashwija (usually October in the Gregorian System) is named after Ashwini and at the full moon ofAshwija Moon is near Ashwini Nakshatra. If a single star has to be identified as representing Ashwini Nakshatra, Best candidate is 13 a Aries / SAO-75151/HD-12929/Hamal.
The Bharani Nakshatra is defined as a group of three stars. Brightest can be identified as HD17573 and SAO75596. The following table provides candidates which qualify as Bharani Nakshatra from brightness point of view, location with reference to moon traverse band and distance from previous Nakshatra.
NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Bharani3755961757341-Aries+3.61-
755781736139-Aries+4.51-
755321690835-Aries+4.65-
If a single star has to be identified as representing Bharani Nakshatra, best candidate is 41-Aries/SAO-75596/HD-17573.
Krittika Nakshatra is defined as a set of six stars. Bharateeya tradition has it that Kaartikeya, is surrounded by five Apsaras. This set of stars is identified by classical European system as Plaeidis. Brightest amongst them is called Alcyone by Arabs. The following table provides the candidates of stars for Krittika Nakshatra or Lunar mansion from brightness point of view, location with reference to moon traverse band and distance from previousNakshatra.
NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Krittika6761992363025 hAries+2.87Alcyone
762282385027+3.63-
761312330217+3.70-
761552340820+3.88-
762292386228BU+5.09-
761402333819+4.3-
If a single star has to be identified as representing Krittika Nakshatra, best candidate is 25hAries/SAO-76199/HD-23630/ AlCyone.
Krittika is also the name of the Chandramana month Kaartika. On the full moon day of Kaartika, the moon is near Krittika Nakshatra. In the Raashi/Nakshatra translation, both the Ashwini/Bharani belong to Mesha Raashi. The Krittika is considered as 1/4 a part of Mesha (Aries) and 3/4 a part of Vrishbha (Taurus).
Arundhati Nakshatra (though not a part of the 27 day pointing stars) is near the Krittitka. It is said to be the eighth star in the cluster Krittika(Ref-2).
The Ashwini/Bharani Nakshatras stars are separated by 50 minutes of time or about 12.5 degrees (E-W), whileBharani and Krittika are separated by about 55 minutes corresponding to about 13.75 degrees (E-W). Both these gaps are near the ideal 13.33 degrees E-W gap between stars.
Figure 2 shows the night sky covering the Vrishabha Raashi or the Taurus. It shows Nakshatras, Krittika, Rohini, Mrigashiras. Nakshatra Krittika has already been discussed in Mesha Raashi, where a quarter of Krittikais said to occur.
 
Rohini Nakshatra is defined traditionally as a mansion of five stars. In olden days, Europeans called it as Haydes. The following table provides candidates which qualify as Rohini Nakshatra from brightness point of view, location with reference to moon traverse band and distance from previous Nakshatra.
NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Rohini5940272913987 aTau+0.85Al Debaran
939552830777q1Tau+3.85-
938682737154 gTau+3.63-
938972769761 DTau+3.76-
939542830575 eTau+3.53-


Rohini is the brightest of the 27 Stars used for Bharateeya Nakshatra system of names, with a brightness of 0.85. Rohini is identified as birth star of Sri krishna. The distance between Krittika and Rohini is about 12.5 degrees (E-W). If a single star has to be identified as representing Rohini Nakshatra, best candidate is 87aTau/SAO-94027/HD -29139/ Aldebaran.
Mrigashiras is traditionally defined as a mansion of three stars. The following table provides candidates which qualify as Mrigashira Nakshatra from brightness point of view, location with reference to moon traverse band and distance from previous Nakshatra.

NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Mrigashiras37716835479112 bTau+1.65El nath
7733637202123 zTau+2.98-
9462836389119CE+4.38-
Mrigashiras Nakshatra is associated with month of Maargashira where, on full moon day, moon will be nearMrigashira Nakshatra. This approximates to month of December. The Zodiac name Vrishbha suggests a bull with horns, and Mrigashiras is the head of the bull. With some imagination, in figure 2 one can imagine springing bull.Mrigashiras has been named El Nath by Arabs. If a single star has to be identified as representing Mrigashira Nakshatra, best candidate is 112b Tau /SAO-77168 /HD -35497/ Elnath.
The distance between Rohini and Mrigashiras is about 50 minutes corresponding to 12.5 degrees (E-W) not too far from 13.33 requirement. All the Vrishbha stars are within the Moon traverse band.
In the Raashi/Nakshatra translation, 1/4 of Krittika is treated as a part of Mesha and 3/4 of Krittika is treated asVrishbha RaashiRohini is considered to be fully in Vrishbha while 1/2 of Mrigashiras is in Vrishabha and the other 1/2 is in Mithuna.

Figure 3 shows the night sky covering Mithuna Raashi or Gemini Zodiac. The stars in figure 3 are Aardhra andPunarvasu.
Aardhra is traditionally called as a mansion of single Nakshatra. The following able provides candidate, which qualify as Aardhra Nakshatra.

NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Aardhara1959124710524 gGem+193Al Hena
24 g Gem/SAO-95912/HD47105/Arab 'Alhena' is the best candidate for Aardhra. It is 68 minutes or 17 degrees (E-W) away from Mrigashiras. It is 2 diameters out of moon traverse band.
Punarvasu Nakshatra is considered traditionally to be a mansion of four stars. The following table provides candidates which qualify as Punarvasu Nakshatra from brightness point of view, location with reference to moon traverse band and distance from previous Nakshatra.

NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Punarvasu4796666250978 bGem+1.15Pollux
06017966 aGem+1.59Castor
796536234577 kGem+3.56-
793745820760 iGem+3.72-
If a single star has to be identified as Punarvasu, then 78 b Gem/SAO-79666/HD-62509/'Pollux' is the best candidate for Punarvasu. It is a very bright star of +1.15 brightness. It is about one to two-moon diameter outside of moon band. Punarvasu is 60 minutes or 15 degrees (E-W) away from Aardhra.
In Raashi/Nakshatra translation 1/2 of Mrigashiras, Full Aardhra and 3/4 of Punarvasu are considered to be part of Mithuna.
Figure 4 shows the night sky covering the stars in the Karkataka Raashi. The Nakshatras in this Raashi arePushya (or Tishya) and Aaslesha.
Pushya Nakshatra is considered to have three stars traditionally. The following table provides a list of stars, which qualify as Pushya from brightness point of view, location with reference to moon traverse band and distance from previous Nakshatra.
NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Pushya31165696926717 bcnc+3.52Al Tarf
978197125027BP-cnc+5.5-
978817209431 qcnc+5.35-
If a single star has to be identified as Pushya (Tishya), then 17b Cnc/SAO-116569/HD-69267/ is the best candidate. The brightness of this star is 3.52. Pushya is 40 minutes or 11 degrees (E-W) away from Punarvasu. There are no alternate choices of star for Pushya in this RaashiPushya is also nearly 6 to 8 moon diameters away from the moon-traversing band. Pushya is 40 minutes or 10 degrees (E-W) away from Punarvasu. Arab name is Al Tarf.

Aaslesha Nakshatra is considered to have two stars. The following table provides a list of two stars, which can qualify as Aaslesha from a brightness point of view, location with reference to moon traverse band, and distance from previous Nakshatra.
NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Aaslesha2982677675665 acnc+4.23Asselus Australis
9808774442cnc+3.93-
If a single star has to be identified as Aaslesha, then 65 a Cnc/SAO 98267/HD 76756 is the best candidate.Aaslesha is 45 minutes or 11 degrees (E-W) away from Pushya. This star is also called by Latin name Asseleus Australis. Chinese astronomers also had a name for this star translated as Second Minister.
In Raashi/Nakshatra translation 1/4 of Punarvasu, whole of PushyaAaslesha are considered to be part ofKarkataka.
Figure 5 shows Nakshatras of Simha. For the imaginative, a lion with a high tail is visible in figure 5. TheNakshatras shown are, Maghaa, and Pubba/ Poorva Phalguni. There are a number of bright stars in the Raashi.
Maghaa Nakshatra is considered to have two stars. The following table provides a list of two stars, which can qualify as Maghaa from a brightness point of view, location with reference to moon traverse band, and distance from previous Nakshatra.
NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Maghaa5989678790132 aLeo+1.35Regulus
989558773730 hLeo+3.53-
812988948441 g1 Leo+2.61Algieba
812658902536 zLeo+3.42-
980788380814 oLeo+3.52-
If a single star has to be identified as Maagha, then the best candidate is 32 Leo/SAO 98967/HD 87901/Regulus. Its is located 70 minutes or 17 degrees (E-W) away from AasleshaRegulus is an old European name for Maghaa known to Ptolemy.
Poorva Phalguni / Pubba Nakshatra is considered to be a lunar mansion of 2 stars. The following table provides a list of two stars, which can qualify as Poorva Phalguni from a brightness point of view, location with reference to moon traverse band, and distance from previous Nakshatra.
NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Poorva Phalguni2995129763370 qLeo+3.34Chort
817279760368 dLeo+2.56-
If a single star has to be identified as Poorva Phalguni, then SAO 99512/HD 97633 is the best candidate, and it is located at 65 minutes or 16 degrees (E-W)from Maagha. Poorva Phalguni is also called Chort by Arabs.
In Raashi/Nakshatra translation, whole of Maghaa and whole of Poorva Phalguni are considered to be part ofSimha Raashi. 1/4 of the Uttara Phalguni is also considered as Simha Raashi.
Figure 6 shows 35 degrees containing four Nakshatras in Kanya Raashi called Uttara Phalguni, Hastaa, Chitra, and Swati.

Though Uttara is a part of Virgo/Kanya in the zodiac, in Bharateeya measure it is considered as a part of Tula. All the Kanyaa Nakshatras are in the Moon Band and are the brighter stars of the RaashiUttara Phalguni orUttara is onsidered to be a lunar mansion of 2 stars. The following table provides a list of two stars, which can qualify as Uttara Phalguni from a brightness point of view, location with reference to moon traverse band, and distance from previous Nakshatra.

NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Uttara Phalguni29980910264794 bLeo+2.14Denebola
119076102870bVir+3.61Zavijava
Both the stars are at same time distance from Poorva Phalguni. If a single star has to be identified as Uttara Phalguni, then 94 b Leo/SAO 119076 / HD 102870 is the best candidate, despite Denebola being brighter. Reason is that Denebola is about 5 diameters out of Moon traverse band while Zavijava is in the moon traverse band. Uttara Phalguni, is also called Zavijava by Arabs.
Hastaa is considered to be a lunar mansion of 3 stars. The following table provides, a list of three stars which can qualify as Hastaa from a brightness point of view, location with reference to moon traverse band, and distance from previous NakshatraHastaa has also been called Porrima, probably an Arab name.
NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Hastaa3011038029 gVir+3.68/2.68Porrima
11967411338043 dVir+3.38-
10038411322647 eVir+2.83-
If a single star has to be identified as Hastaa, then star 29 g Virgo identified as HD-110380, (It has no SA0 identification) is best candidate for Hastaa Nakshatra. Its brightness has been declared as +2.8 in some references and +3.6 in some. Hastaa is 55 minutes or 14 degrees (E-W) away from Uttara Phalguni Nakshatra. It also carries the Arab name Porrima.
Chitra is considered to be a lunar mansion of single star. The following table provides the stars which qualifies asChitra from a brightness point of view, location with reference to moon traverse band, and distance from previousNakshatra.
NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Chitra115792311692367 aVir+0.98Spica
Chitra is 50 minutes or 13.3 degrees (E-W) away from 'Hastaa'. There can be no doubt about the identity ofChitra. It also stands for the name of the first month in Chandramaana calender. The Bhrateeya Chandramaana Ugadi (new Year day) is on the new moon day of this month, and this day is very near the Spring Equinox day. In Raashi/Nakshatra translation, 1/4 of Uttara-Phalguni is considered as belonging to Karkataka. 3/4 of Uttara-Phalguni, whole of Hastaa and 1/2 of Chitra are considered to belong to Kanyaa Rashi. The other half of Chitra is shown as Tula Raashi.
This star which is very near the ecliptic was scientifically studied by Hipparchus in 150 BC and by Ptolemy in 150 AD, and they noticed the property of earth's precession using observations on Spica.
Figure 7 shows the 30 degrees square of Tula Raashi and shows, Swati, Vishaaka in Tula, and Anooradha, Jyeshta Nakshatras of Vrishchika. Tula or the Libra Zodiac is a very small one. Swati is a difficult Nakshatra to identify, because 10-20 degrees (E-W) away from Chitra there are no bright stars.
The following table provides the stars which qualifies as Swati from a brightness point of view, location with reference to moon traverse band, and distance from previous Nakshatra.
NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Swati113982412485099 iVir+4.08Symra
There are some scholars who have argued that Arcturus is Swati. Arcturus is located in 'Bootes' constellation and is identified as SAO-10094/HD-124893/16-Bootes of brightness +1.24. However, Arcturus is at 19 N degrees where as northern limit of moon traverse (8 S to 18 S) band is -8 degrees. Hence the star
Arcturus is located 27 to 37 degrees away, north from moon traverse band, hence can not be seriously considered, as being pointed to by Moon. This 27 degrees is the distance between two Nakshtra's and too large an error. If we accept moon visits the Arcturus mansion, all our identifications become questionable. The Arcturus mansion located in Bootes constellation is nowhere near Tula (Libra) or Vrishchika. Even 5000 years ago, the location of that constellation was far away from moon traverse band. Hence SAO-139824/HD 124850 /99i Vir, also called Syrma by Arabs is the best candidate for Hastaa. This Nakshatra is 45 minutes or about 12 degrees (E-W) away from Chitra. It is bright enough to have been given a name by Arab astronomers.
Vishaaka is considered to be a lunar mansion of 2 stars. The following table lists likely candidate stars in Tula from a brightness point of view, location with respect to moon traverse band, and distance from previous Nakshatra.
NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Vishaka2158840130841a2 Lib+2.75Zubenelgenubi
14034013574227 bLib+2.61Zubeneschemele
If one star has to be chosen as Vishaaka in Tula Raashi, it is 92a2Libra, identified as SAO 158840 or HD 130481. The brightness is +2.75. It has been called, Zubenelgenubi by Arabs. Vishaaka pair is 45 minutes or 11(E-W) degrees away from Swati. Though Zubeneschemele is a little brighter, it is a little away from moon traverse band. Vishaaka is right in the middle of the moon traverse band. Guatama Buddha was born, received enlightenment, and died on the full moon day of Vishaka when full moon was on this nakshatra.
In the Raashi/Nakshatra translation, whole of 1/2 of Chitra, whole of Swaati and 3/4 of Vishaaka is considered to be in Tula Raashi.

Figure 8 shows the 30 degree square of Vrishchika Raashi in which AnooraadhaJyeshta and Moola Nakshatra choices are to be made. Anooradha is considered to be a mansion of four stars

The following table lists the stars, which qualify as Anooradha Nakshatra from brightness point of view, location with reference to moon traverse band, and distance from previous Nakshatra.
NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Anooradha484014143275dSco+2.3Dschubba
1598621442178b1Sco+2.63-
183987143018pSco+2.9-
184123144470w1 Sco+3.97-

If a single star has to be identified as Anooraadha then the best candidate is 7d-Sco/SAO 184014/HD 143275.Anooraadha is 1 hour 10 minutes or 17 degrees (E-W) away from VishaakaAnooradha is also called Dschubbaby Arabs.
Jyeshta is considered to be a lunar mansion of 3 stars. The following table lists the stars, which qualify asJyeshta Nakshatra from brightness point of view, location with reference to moon traverse band, and distance from previous Nakshatra.
NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Jyeshta318441514847821 aSco+1.08Antares
18433614716520 sSco+2.88-
18448114943823 gSco+2.83-

If a single star has to be identified as Jyeshta, then the best candidate is 21 a Sco/SAO 184415/HD 148478.Jyeshta is 30 minutes or 8 degrees (E-W) away from Anooraadha. The brightness of Jyeshta is a high +1.08.
In the Raashi Nakshatra translation, 1/4 of Vishaaka, whole of Anooraadha and whole of Jyeshta are considered as Vrishchika.
Figure 9 shows 30 degrees square area around Dhanu Raashi. The Nakshatras in this figure are Vichruta/Moola, and Poorvaashada. Both the stars are in the moon traverse band. For the imaginative, a stretched bow can be seen in the Dhanu RaashiVichruta or Moola Nakshatras considered to be a star mansion with eleven stars.
The following table presents candidate stars, which qualify as Moola based on brightness, location with reference to moon traverse band, and distance from previous Nakshatra.
NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Moola1118532015705642 qOPH+3.28-
18529615689740 eSAG+4.4-
18540115779244-SAG+4.17-
18541215791945-SAG+4.29-
16033215512535 eOPH+2.43Sabik
18547015864351-SAG+4.8-
16070015987655 zSAG+3.54-
16047915692853 gSAG+4.33-
185155161592cSAG+4.54-
18519815588636-OPH+5.29-
18532715635039-OPH+6.8-

If one star is to be identified as Moola, then the best candidate for Moola or Vichruta Nakshatra is 42 q OPH from Ophichius zodiac of the European system. It falls in the star band and is 50 minutes or 13 degrees (E-W) away from Jyeshta. Its brightness is +3.28. Arab Sabik is another strong candidate for Moola with +2.43 brightness and is also 13 degrees from Jyeshta.
Moola or Vichruta has been extensively referred to in Atharveda Kaanda 2,Kaanda 3 and kaanda 6 (Ref 2).Vichruta, stands for darkness and Moola carries an adjective Arishta. This word has two meanings, one standing for sweet and second associated with bad associated with death. Astronomically, Moola is in line with Milkiwaygalactic center. Did some astronomical event appear 5000 years ago near the center of Milkiway galaxy, which could explain why Moola is considered as bad? In modern astronomy, there have been conjectures of a black hole at the center of our Milkiway. This area of sky is visually dark because large amount of matter is presumed to exist around the center of the Galaxy. Did vedic period astronomers know of the center of the galaxy or did they see some astronomical event justifying the bad omen associated with Moola?.
Poorvaashaada Nakshatra is considered to be a star mansion of two stars. The following table presents candidate stars, which qualify as Poorvashaada based on brightness, location with reference to moon traverse band, and distance from previous Nakshatra.
NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Poorva Aashaada218744817519134 aSAG+2.06Nunki
18760017668738 zSAG+2.6-
If one star is to be identified as Poorvaashadha, it is 34 aSag, which has an Arab name Nunki. Its brightness is +2.06. There are other stars nearby and one which has a brightness of 1.8. But it is far away from the moon traverse band, and hence is not a good candidate for Poorvaashada. Poorvaasaahda is 80 minutes or 20 (E-W) degrees away from Moola.
Uttarashaada is considered to be a star mansion of two stars. It is shown in figure 10. The following table presents candidate stars, which qualify as Uttarashaada based on brightness, location with reference to moon traverse band, and distance from previous Nakshatra.
NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Uttara Aashaada2163481193495bCap+3.07-
1634271929476a2-Cap+3.56Geidi

If one star is to be identified for Uttaraashada, it is the twin star 5a/6a2 both in Capricorn Zodiac. They are of brightness 4.24 and 3.56.Together the pair appear as one star. The SAO identities are SAO-163422/163427 or HD -192876/192947. There is a large gap between Poorvaashada and Uttaraashaada of nearly 22 degrees (E-W). There are no likely candidate stars for Uttaraashaada in the 22 degrees in the moon traverse band or near by. Arabs call this as Geidi associated with slaughter of sheep.
In Raashi/Nakshatra translation, whole of Moola and whole of Poorvaashaada are treated as Dhanu Raashi, while 1/4 of Uttaraashaada is a part of Makara Raashi.
Figure 10 shows some of the the stars in Makara raashi which are Uttaraashadha and Shravana.
We have already discussed Uttarashadha nakshatra and its identification. The original nakshatra from vedicperiod, Abhijit, would be a star between Uttarashaadha and Shravana.
Shravana Nakshatra is considered to be a star mansion of three stars. The following table presents candidate stars, which qualify as Shravana based on brightness, location with reference to moon traverse band, and distance from previous Nakshatra.
NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Shravana316464420709849 dcap+2.83Deneb Al Geidi
16342720608840 gCap+3.66-
19034120407534 zcap+3.74-

If one star is to be identified as representing Shravana, it is clearly 49d-cap of brightness+2.83 identified as SAO-164644 and HD-207098. It is 30 minutes or 8 degrees (E-W) away from Uttarashada, which is a part of Makara Raashi. Arabs also call Shravana as Deneb Al Geidi.
Since half of Dhanishta is considered to be part of Kumbha raashi Figure 11 shows Dhanishta Nakshatra is considered to be a star mansion of four stars. The following table presents candidate stars which qualify asDhanishta based on brightness, location with reference to moon traverse band, and distance from previousNakshatra.
NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Dhanishta414610721305155zAqr+3.66-
14604421205148gAqr+3.84-
1275021257152p Aqr+4.66-
14618121399862hAqr+4.02-
If one star is to be identified as representing Dhanishta, it is clearly 55z of brightness +3.66 identified as SAO-146107 and HD-213051. From a distance point of view this star is 45 minutes or about 12 degrees (E-W) away from Shravana. The Moon trajectory is within a few diameters of Dhanishta.
In terms of Nakshatra-Raashi translation, 3/4 of Uttaraashaada, whole of shravana and 1/2 of Dhansihta are defined as belonging to Makara Raashi.
Figure 11 Shows the sky with about 30 degrees square of the Makara and Kumbha Raashi, in which Shravana, Dhansihta and Shatabhisha are to be found.
Shatabhishaja Nakshatra is defined to be a star mansion of 100 stars. Shata is undred and bhishaja stands for medical doctor. The significance of later is not apparent. The following table presents one candidate star, which qualifies as Shatabhishaja based on brightness, location with reference to moon traverse band, and distance from previous Nakshatra.
NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Shatabishta10014658521921590 fAqr+4.22-
and 99 others whose identity has not been proposed -
There is great dilemma about star for Shatabhishaja because one hundred stars of brightness <+5 brightness are not visible. Did one hundred bright objects exist in this part of sky 5000 years ago? One bright star near ecliptic is 90f Aqr, and best qualifies as single star identity of Shatabhishaja. The other identities are SAO-146595/SAO-146620, or HD-219449/HD219688. This star pair is 50 minutes or 13 degrees (E-W) away fromDhanishta, which is an ideal location.
Since half of Poorvabahdra is a part of Meena Raashi, figure 12 shows Poorvabhaadra (Proshtapada) Nakshatra,which is defined to be a star mansion of two stars. The following table presents candidate stars, which qualify asPoorvabhaadra based on brightness, location with reference to moon traverse band, and distance from previousNakshatra.
NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Poorva Bhadra212851322461728 wPsc+4.02-
12833622260318 lPsc+4.5-
If a single star is to be found to represent Poorvabhaadra, the best choice is SAO128513/HD224617 /28w Psc. Star Poorvabhaadra really is in Meena Raashi. The brightness is +4.02.
In the Nakshatra/Raashi translation, 1/2 of Dhanishta, whole of Shatabhisha and 3/4 of Poorvaabhaadra are considered as belonging to Kumbha Raashi.
Figure 12 shows the Nakshatras of Meena Raashi, which contains the Nakshatras Poorvabhaadra, Uttarabhaadra, Revati and Ashwini of Mesha Raashi. All the stars in this Meena Raashi are very low in brightness. Modern astronomers always use this area to identify new Sun's minor planets because of less interference from low brightness stars.
Uttarabhaadra is considered to be a Nakshatra with two stars. The following table lists likely candidate stars forUttarabhaadra from a brightness point of view, location with reference to moon traverse band, and distance from previous Nakshatra.
NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Uttara Bhadra2109474465663 dPsc+4.43-
109267618671 ePsc+4.27-
If a single star is to be found to represent Uttara Bhaadra, then the best candidate is 63 dPsc, SAO-189474/HD-4656. It is in the moon band and is located about 12-14 degrees (E-W) away from Poorvabhaadra. But 71e is only 7 degrees away from Revati, while 63 is midway between Poorvabhaadra and Revati. Hence, the best choice is 63. The Poorva and Uttara Bhaadra Nakshatras represent Bhadrapada month, usually September of Gregorian calender.
Revati Nakshatra is considered to be a star mansion with 36 stars. There are a number of stars in figure 12. The following table presents one candidate star which qualifies as Shatabhishaja based on brightness, location with reference to moon traverse band, and distance from previous Nakshatra.
NakshatraNo.SAOHDBayerBrightArab/Other
Revathi3692484927099 hPsc+3.62-
and 35 others whose identity has not been proposed.
If one star has to be identified for Revati, it is 99h Psc, which is the brightest star of Meena Raashi. Its identities are SAO-92484 or HD-9270.The brightness is +3.62. It is 45 minutes or about 12 degrees (E-W) away fromUttarabhaadra.
In the Raashi/Nakshatra translation, 1/4 of Poorvabhaadra, whole of Uttarabhaadra and whole of Revati are parts o the Meena Raashi.
The table below provide a summary of the work on equivalence of Bhaarateeya Nakshatras with other star names used by different cultures and modern day star tables. In this article, effort has been made to identify single star to represent a Nakshatra. However, the Jyotishya definition is that the Nakshatras stand for group of stars. Hence the stars identified below belong to that group and are the brightest of the Nakshatra group.
NakshatraSmithson Astro ObserHenry DraperBayer IdentityBrightOther NamesLight YearsDeg from Spring Equinox
Ashwini751511292913 aAries+2.01Hamal7531
Bharani755961757341 Aries+3.61-42
Krittika761992363025 hTau+2.87Alcyone40057
Rohini940272913987 aTau+0.85Aldebaran7069
Mrigashira7716835497112bTau+1.65Alnath20082
Aardhra959124710524 gGem+1.93Alhena10098
Punarvasu796666250978 bGem+1.15Pollux35115
Pushya1165696926717 bCnc+3.52Al Tarf124
Aashlesha982677444247 dCnc+3.93AsselusAustralis135
Maghaa989678790132 aLeo+1.35Regulus85152
Pubba995129763370 qLeo+3.34Chort168
Uttara119076102870bVir+3.61Zavijava177
Hastaa011038029 gVir+2.8/3.6Porrima33190
Chitra15792311665867 aVir+0.98Spica250203
Swati13982412485099 iVir+4.08Syrma214
Vishaka15884013048192a 2Lib+2.75Zubenelgenubi65224
Anooradha184014143275dSco+2.3Dschubba600240
Jyeshta18441514847821 aSco+1.08Antares400248
Moola18532015705642 qOPH+3.28-260
Poorvashada18744817519134sSGR+2.06Nunki250282
UttaraShada163422192876aCapr+4.24Giedi95303
Shravana16464420709849 dCapr+2.83Deneb Algeidi37325
Dhanishta1461072130515z1Aqr+3.60-335
Shatabhisha14658521921591fAqr+4.22-343
Poorva Bhadra12851322461728 wPsci+4.00-0
Uttara Bhadra109474465663 dPsci+4.43-12.5
Revathi92484927099 hPsci+3.62-22.5

A study of the star latitudes along the ecliptic reveals that while average gap between Nakshtra's is 13.33 degrees the maximum is 22 degrees (E-W) and minimum is 8 degrees (E-W).
In summary, the uniquely Bharateeya star proper name system with their probable equivalents in the modern sense, and the probable time of their naming has been detailed. The time at which these names were given has been identified as at least 2500BC, suggesting that the last of the veda's was probably composed at that time. These should help in negating the stereotype statements that all the vedas were composed about 1000 BC.
Astronomical time marks in Atharva Samhita & Jyotishya shaastra.
When was Atharvana Samhita composed?
Though we consider that the Star system to be basically stationary with reference to Solar system, there is an earth wobble occurring at rate of 26000 years per revolution which makes the star system appear to move slowly with reference to Sun. This has been called Earth's Precession and was first identified nearly 2000 years ago by Ptolemy and Hipparchus.
The position of Chitra (Spica), which is very near the ecliptic, was recorded by Hipparchus (circa 150 BC) on the autumnal Equinox day with reference to Sun. It was studied again by Ptolemy (circa 150 AD) nearly 300 years later on same autumnal Equinox day. Ptolemy found that Chitra appeared to have moved about 3 degrees toward Sun (Ref 4). Ptolemy decided that Sun was moving one degree for 100 years in reference to stars. This observation made nearly 2000 years ago, was probably the first documented recording of Earth's Precession. Today we know that Ptolemy was correct and that Earth's Precession rate is about 1.36 degrees for 100 years.
This 2000-year old observation, confirms the uniformity of Earth's Precession validating the geocentric mathematical models that exist for motion of objects in the sky. It allows us to extrapolate backward and forward in time, positions of objects in sky using computer software like Load Star pro. Thus, any past Sun position records, on Equinox/Solstice days referring Sun position to stars, carries the astronomical time mark of the period (Ref-8).
There are two possible definitions of a year as observed from Earth.
A Sidereal year is time taken for Sun to move from one star, and then come back to same star. This is full 360 degrees movement of Earth around the Sun.
A Solar year is the time taken by Sun in its passage from one equinoctical point back to same point.
One would expect these two years to be same, but Solar year is shorter than Sidereal year by about 19 minutes and 50 seconds and is said to be caused by inertial effects. It is called Earth's Precession.
First let us get a contemporary picture of the location of our solar system in the Milkiway galaxy. This is illustrated in figure below. Our solar system is located at the edge of the Milkiway disk of stars. The Milkiway is estimated to be about 50000 light years in its diameter. It consists of a large number of stars and other matter. The stars visible to our naked eye are generally within a few hundred light years around us. Some giant stars are located nearly 1000 light years are also visible to naked eye. Thus most of the 10000 stars visible to us are very near our solar system.
In the illustration below, the center of Milkiway Galaxy is in the direction of Moola nakshatra. Thus bulk of the Milkiway matter is concentrated, as seen from earth, near stars Jyeshtha, Moola, Poorva/Uttarashadha.
Because of Earth's Precession, the angle of earth's motion to come back exactly to same latitude (Solar year) is only 359.864 degrees around the sun. Solar year is the classical definition of a year, as the 23.5 degrees earth's tilt controls the weather, seasons and the position of Sun in its north-south traverse. A notional 360 degrees Sidereal year is irrelevant to us.
But the 359.864 degrees Solar year is relevant because of repeating weather and seasons and hence Solar year is a natural year. That means every solar year, the Sun position drops back by about 0.0136 degrees with respect to stars. Also, it may be noted that the earth’s spin polar axis also shifts by same angle of 0.0136 degrees per year in a coning motion. Most popular books on Stars illustrate this spinning top like coning motion property of Earth's Precession, but do not illustrate the apparent ecliptic plane motion of stars. The diagram below illustrates the star shift in the ecliptic due to Precession on spring equinox day. The diagram shows the 27 nakshatra's in a circle of diameter of the order of few hundred light years with sun at the center.
The diagram below shows the effect of Earth's Precession on Sun/Star/Earth's position exactly at the time of Spring Equinox. In this diagram, the Sun is always on equator and the day time equals night. Diagram shows Earth's position from 2400 BC to 2000 AD. Every year, the Earth's seasons start occurring 0.0136 degrees (or roughly 0.0136 days) earlier. The diagram also shows twenty-seven Bharateeya nakshatra's in the infinite distance in the ecliptic plane. It should be noted that the Precession does not change the Equator position or the Earth's tilt of 23.5 degrees. It only changes the direction of polar axis.
ThBhaarateeya Veda's have left some astronomical time marks in the texts. Amongst the Veda's, Atharvana Vedais considered to be chronologically the last. Based on the identification of the twenty-seven Baharateeya Nakshatra's, and using the astronomical time markers in Atharvana veda's 19th kaanda/ 7th sooktha. it is possible to to identify when the last of the veda's, Atharvana Veda was composed. The Atharva veda 19th kaanda/7th Sooktha reads,
Atharvana Veda Kaanda 19 / Sooktam 7
Gargya Rishi! Nakshatrani Devata! Trishtup-Bhurik Chandaha!
Chitrani sakam divi rochanani sarisrupani bhuvanejavani
turmisham sumatimichaamaano ahaani geerbhi saparyami nakam!1!
suhavamagne krittika rohini chaastu bhadram mrigashirah Sham aardhrah !
punarvasu soonruta chaaru pushyo Bhaanur aslesha ayanam magha mey !2!
punyam poorva Phalguni chottra hasta schittra shiva swaati sukho mey astu!
raadhe vishaakhe suhav anooradha jyeshta sunakshatramarishta moolam !3!
annam poorva raasataam aashadha oorja devy uttaraa aavahantu!
abhijinma raasataam punyameva shravanah shravishtaah kurvatam supushtim!4!
Aa mey maha chatabhishagam vareeya Aa mey dvaya proshtapadaa susharma!
Aa reyvato chashvayujow bhagam ma Aa mey rayim Bharanya aavahantu!5!
This Sookta dedicated to Nakshatra's was recorded (Drashtaara) by Gargya Rishi. The Sookta describes both astronomical and astrological elements. Twenty eight Nakshatras are identified starting with Krittika and reference is made to Ayanam occurring in Maghaa. A nakshatra Abhijit is shown between Uttarashadha and Shravana. Its use has been discontinued in the Jyotishya with only twenty seven identified currently. The authenticity of the Athrarvanatexts is well accepted, by the very reverence shown towards precise learning. Hundreds of generations ofShrotreeya's have carried veda's down to us in its original language using oral traditions of Krama, Pada, Jatha, andGhana Paatha so that distortions are nonexistent. Two major astronomical time markers are evident and implicit in the Sooktha. They are,
1. Rishi Gargya starts the list of twenty seven nakshatra's starting with Krittika. Choice of Krittika as the first of twenty-seven is very significant. In contrast Jyotishya Shaastra uses Ashwini as the first star. The choice of firstNakshatra must correspond to a logically first day of a solar year, which dictates the weather cycles. Which is the year’s first day? Astronomically speaking, the spring Equinox day in Northern Hemisphere temperate zone is a logical one. It heralds the arrival of the spring, in temperate zone of northern hemisphere of the earth. Vasantha ritu, the spring has always been considered as beginning of a year from Rig-vedic times. Hence, the first observation implicit in Rishi Gargya's sooktha is that on spring Equinox day, Sun was at Krittika Nakshatra. Figure 13 shows Sun location on March 21, 2400 BC from Load Star Pro. The Sun is on equator and is pointing to Krittika nakshatra.
Compare this to Figure 14 which shows Sun 4400 years later, on March 21,2000 at same equator but Sun is onPoorva Bhadrapada. Thus Sun has Precessed by about 57 degrees in 4400 years since Rishi Gargya's Sooktha.
 
2. Rishi Gargya refers to Ayana occurring in Maghaa during his time. Ayana refers to apparent direction of Sun's North-South motion. The day of direction reversal is called an Ayana day (Uttara and Dakshina Ayana). When Rishi Gargya refers to Ayana he is clearly referring to a Solstice day and that Ayana occurred when Sun is at Maghaa.
It could be either Dakshina Ayana(Summer Solstice ) or Uttara Ayana(Winter Solstice). Let us look at Load Star pictures of Sun at Daskhina Ayana (Summer Solstice) 4400 years ago. Figure 15 shows the Sun at +23.5 degrees on June 21, 2400 BC. This is the day of Dakshina Ayana. Sun is clearly at Maghaa Nakshatra.
Rishi Gargya's Ayana could also be Uttara Ayana, (Winter Solstice), but it fails because the first nakshatra would then have to be Hasta or Chitra and the date would be 22000 BC. The Soothra indicates Krittika as the first.
The diagram below shows the picture of Earth's position over past 4500 years on Summer Solstice day when Sun reaches the peak northern position of +23.5 degrees and starts his southern movement (Dakshina Ayana). The Sun position as observed from earth in 2400 BC on this day would be at Maghaa. In circa 400 BC, Sun would be in Pushya. Today, Sun is between Mrigashira and Aardhra.
Hence Rishi Gargya's Atharvana Veda 19 Kaanda and Sooktha 7, clearly has two astronomical time markers and provide a clue as to when it was composed. It is easy dismiss that the starting of Nakshatra list with Krittika as an accident, but recording of star locations which are true for both Equinox and Solstice in same sookta can not be accidental. It suggests a well understood contemporary knowledge of motion of Sun, Moon and Stars in the skies. While such knowledge may have been more thoroughly documented in other texts, only a brief poetic indication of that knowledge appears to have been made in the veda's.
Clearly, both the astronomical markers recorded by Rishi Gargya in Atharva Veda kaanda 19 sookta 7 would be correct only near about circa 2400 BC. This must certainly be incontrovertible proof that Rishi Gargya's Sookta was composed near 2400 BC, dating Atharvana Veda to at least 2400 BC.

When was Jyotishya Shaastra brought to presently used form?

As previously observed, the Earth's Precession makes the Sun move back one degree along the ecliptic in about 76 years with reference to star system. All Sun position references in past with reference to stars on days of Sun singularity, thus carry the astronomical time mark. Bhaarateeya Jyotishya shaastra probably was brought to the presently used form, at a time when old vedic chandramana and all other data was integrated with Raashi or Zodiac based concepts. The time at which this was done can be identified using following.
1. Jyotishya Shaastra starts the lists of Nakshatras with Ashwini, suggesting that Sun was at Ashwini on Spring Equinox day in that period.
2. Jyotishya states that Uttara Ayana starts exactly when sun enters Makara (Capricorn) suggesting that Sun was near Uttaraashadha on Winter Solstice day (Gregorian Dec 21).
Sic'Yasmin Kshane sooryam gachati Makaram; tatah prabhruti shanmasa udagayanam. from Rudra Skanda Bashya(10th century AD) of Khadhira Grihya Sutra (4 century BC).
Use of Load Star Pro and scan of Sun position over past few thousand years yields following results. Figure 16 shows the position of Sun on Spring Equinox day of 400BC (March 21).
The sun is on equator and is clearly at Ashwini Nakshatra. This explains as to why Jyotsihya Shaastra starts thenakshatra list from Ashwini. The figure showing the position of Earth, Sun on Spring Equinox Day in previous section also confirms the fact that Sun would at Ashwini. As already illustrated now sun is at Poorva Bhadrapada. Nakshatralisting today must start from Poorva Bhadrapada.
Figure 17 shows the position of sun on Gregorian December 21(winter Solstice),the start of Uttara Ayana in 400 BC. Clearly the sun is at +23.5 degrees and near Uttara Aashadha near Makara Raashi. This supports the Jyotishyastatement that Uttara Ayana occurred when Sun entered Makara near about 400 BC.
Compare this to figure 18, which shows the position of sun on December 21, 1998. Thus sun is clearly at Dhanu Raashi and not at Makara.
Thus the twin observations of Jyotishya Shaastra, (of the Spring Equinox and Winter Solstice) are valid only near 400 BC and hence that is the period when it probably took the present form. It is clear that Bharateeya astronomers who knew of the astronomical information carried down from vedic culture, looked at Western Zodiac based system and then merged the two to form present Jyotishya Shaastra. Hence Jyotishya uses both the 27 Nakshatra's and 12raashi's.
It should be noted that the Western Zodiac system appears to have been frozen at same time period. It uses Aries as the starting Zodiac in recognition of Spring Equinox occurring at time of entry of Sun to Aries.

Astronomical identity of Saptha Rishi's, Dhruva & Arundhathi

On the night of the marriage, Bhaaratheeya brides are shown a star called 'Arundhathi' in the night sky. Arundhathi is the wife of sage vasishtha. This couple is revered as a loving and ideal couple worthy of emulation, because of their devotion to each other and harmony.
Vasishtha is one of the seven rishis. The seven stars in the northern sky was named 'saptha rishi mandala', and it is more popularly known as 'Ursa major' constellation. It is also called 'Great bear' or 'Big Dipper'. The astronomical identity of these stars is very easy to establish due to explicit definitions given by Varaha Mihira in his Brihat Samhita (circa 550 AD).
There are two sets of definitions as to who the saptha Rishi's are. The vedic tradition is 'Gautama, Vishwamithra, Jamahagni, Bharadwaaja, Kashyapa, Vasishtha and Athri' are the saptha rishis. However, the saptha Muni's according to Varahamihira are' Marichi, Vasishtha, Angirasa, Athri, Pulasthya, Pulaaha, and Kruthu'. V.S.Apte in his famous Sanskrit-English dictionary (circa 1800) also concurs with later definition. Vasishtha and Athri figure in both the lists. However, V.S.Apte refers to Arundhathi being a star in the pleiades group or Krittika of our vedic tradition. Pleiades is far away from Ursa major. Clearly Apte's definition deviates from Varaaha Mihira's identity of Arundhathi.The later is more logical in that Arundhathi must accompany Vasishtha.
Varaaha Mihira explicitly identifies the Ursa Major and provides the proper names of seven dominant stars, and attributes the origin of these names to sage 'Vruddha Garga'. In all probability 'Vriddha garga' is same as 'Gargya Rishi' of Athrvana veda 19 kaanda 6-7 sooktha whose time was approximately 2400 BC. He is referred to in Mahabharatha as the person who named Krishna, and is considered as Achaarya of vedic astronomy.
Varaaha Mihira in his Brihat Samhitha, dedicates 13 kaanda to Saptha Rishis. The first six verses provide following descriptions translated as:
  • We have on Vriddha Garga's authority that in the Northern Sky, the Saptha Rishi's revolve around Dhruva Nayaka like a necklace.
  • From east to west the Saptha Muni's Marichi, Vasishtha, Angirasa, Athri, Pulasthya, Pulaaha,, and Krathu sit. Chaste Arundhathi accompanies sage Vasishtha.
These descriptions provide us with adequate information about the explicit astronomical identity of the nine stars, called as Dhruva, Arundhathi & saptha Rishis's. Figure 19, 20 and 21 illustrate Load Star Pro views of the 'Ursa major', with zoom in to 'Vasishta-Arundhati' pair. This constellation is known in Northern Hemisphere as rotating around the pole star Polaris.
Thus 'Dhruva' clearly is Polaris. The saptha Rishi's are the seven major stars of Ursa major. We can easily identify from figure 19, that 'Marichi' stands for Alkaid, 'Vasishta' stands for Mizar, 'Angirasa' stands for Alioth, 'Athri' stands for Megrez, 'Pulasthya' stands for Phecda, 'Pulaaha' stands for' Merak and 'Krathu' stands for DuBhe. The companion star for Mizar is Alcor. Hence 'Arundhathi' stands for Alcor. In figure 19, Vasishta and Arudhathi (Mizar-Alcor) can not be seen separate.
As we zoom in, illustrated by figures 20 and 21, the separation between Vasishtha and Arundhathi become evident.
The star Arundhathi is difficult to separate from Vasishta for people with poor eyesight. Arundhathi's brightness is 4 and is within 0.2 degrees of Vasishtha whose brightness is 2.2. This makes it difficult to separate them.
NakshatraOther nameBayer IdentityHenry DraperSAOBrightness
MarichiAlkaid85 UMaHD 120315447521.86
VasishthaMizar79 z UMaHD 116656287372.27
AngirasaAlioth77 e UMaHD 112185285531.77
AthriMegrez69 D UMaHD 106591283153.31
PulasthyaPhecda64 g UMaHD 103287281792.44
PulaahaMerak48 b UMaHD 95418278762.37
KrathuDuBhe50 a UMaHD 95689153841.79
ArundhathiAlcor80 UMaHD 1168423084.01
DhruvaPolarisa UMaHD 8890287512.02
The table above provides the modern astronomical identity of the nine stars from vedic period which are not in the ecliptic. Dhruva is not illustrated in any of the figures, as its identity is very well known in the sky.
In Bhaaratheeya culture, anecdotally people who are approaching death can not separate Arundhathi from Vasishtaand hence can not see Arundhathi. The gap between Vasishtha -Arundhathi is said to be widening due to proper motion and it is now a days relatively easier to see them seperately, while few thousand years ago it was more difficult. In other cultures of the world also, historically in ancient times, keenness of eyesight was measured by the ability to distinguish the two stars Vasishtha-Arundhathi (Mizar-Alcor).

Astronomical identity of Vedic star Agasthya

While the 27/28 daily stars Krittika to Bharani are in the ecliptic plane, the Saptha Rishis in the extreme north near the Dhruva/Polaris, only one star in the southern sky has been named during vedic period. It is Agasthya (canopus).Agasthya Rishi crossed vindhya mountains southwards and it is a major event in the vedic chrononlogy. He is held in great reverence in the south and associated with Lopamudhra his wife. Thus it is not surprising that a star in southern extreme is named after Agasthya.
The astronomical identity of Agasthya can be determined based on Varaaha Mihira's work Brihat Samhita(Ref 12). He has dedicated the whole of 12th kaanda (chapter) to Agasthya Rishi. Varaaha Mihira(550 AD) again refers to the authority of Rishi Vriddha Garga (2400 BC ) in identifying Agasthya. This identity is not as explicit as the Saptha Rishi's, but he gives the season in which Agasthya is visible. That means the star was not visible during nearly 4-5 months near summer at Ujjain where Varaaha Mihira was located. Based on this, it is very easy to identify the star as Canopus in constellation Carina as Agasthya. Canopus is 53 degrees south, and in summer when earth tilts 23.5 degrees north, people north of Tropic of Cancer can not see Canopus, because of daylight and being down in horizon. The figure 22 shows the star Agasthya Rishi.
Agasthya is so far south that people in Northern Hemisphere, like New York, Athens etc can never see Agasthya.Agasthya and Constellation Carina are not even shown in popular star charts and books sold in USA. Agasthya is best visible in the winter months near winter solstice for people living south of 25-30 degree latitude as the dark period increases in Northern Hemisphere. People living in Australia, can easily see Agasthya most of the time. The brightness of this star is very high at -0.72. Amongst the 37 stars (including daily stars Krittika to Bharani, Saptha Rishi's, Arundhathi, Dhruva and Agasthya), Agasthya is the brightest of them all. Following table provides the formal astronomical identity of Agasthya.
NakshatraOther nameBayer IdentityHenry DraperSAOBrightness
AgasthyaCanopusa CARHD 45348234480-0.72

References

Yajurveda Samhita - in three volumes (Sanskrit in Kannada script), Ramakrishna Ashrama Publication, Mysore, 1984
Athrva Bhasha Bhashyam (Sanskrit in Nagari script), Kshemakarana Das Trivedi, Dayanand Samsthan., New Delhi, 1912
Bodhayana, Aapasthambha, Ashwalayana, KhadiraGrihya Sootras (Sanskrit in Nagari script), Government Oriental Library Series, Mysore, 1904
Great Books of Western World (English), -Book 16- Ptolemy, Copernicus, Kepler, Edited by R M Hutchins, University of Chicago, 1952
Load Star Pro (English), Wayne Annala, Zephyr Services, Pittsburg, 1994
What Star is that? (English), P L Brown, Viking Press, 1971
History of Astronomy (English translation of Italian text), Giorgio Abetti, Henri Schumann, 1952.
David Frawley (English), Gods, Sages and kings, Passage Press Publication 1988
E C Krupp (English), Echoes of Ancient Skies-The Astronomy of Lost Civilizations, Harper & Row Publishers, 1983
Ramashesha Shastri, Kannada Bhagavatha Mahapuraana,1-12 skandas in 8 volumes(private publication),1912-193
Taittareeya Brahmana (Sanskrit in kannada Lipi), Ramakrishn aashrama Publication 1996, Bangalore

http://www.vedicastronomy.net/stars_references.htm

What is neech rajniti, neech karm ? (24:59) -- Listen to NaMo and answer. Create Congress Mukt Bharat.

Swiss black money probe: over 100 entities under scanner

$
0
0
The Economic Times

Swiss black money probe: Over 100 entities under scanner

It is suspected that some of the entities may have brought back illicit wealth through stock market route, by using complex fund structures of some overseas funds.








NEW DELHI: As India steps up its pressure on Switzerland to get details of suspected tax evaders having bank accounts in the European nation, a discreet probe is underway of eachstock market dealing of over 100 entities linked to these cases to detect possible re-routing ofblack money

The entities under watch include individuals whose names figure in a list of over 700 Swiss bank account holders, as also the bankers and associates related to certain banks whose Switzerland-based branches are under scanner. 

Besides, 10-15 listed Indian companies including a few blue-chip names directly or indirectly linked to these banks and their Indian customers are also under a close tab for any suspected market manipulations, senior officials said. 

It is suspected that some of these entities may have brought back their illicit wealth through the stock market route, by using complex fund structures of certain overseas funds, including those floated by select European banking giants. 

The official said that a few large global banks are under scanner, although it is also possible that the banks themselves might be unaware of the illicit activities being carried out by their executives for the benefit of their clients. 

He further said that these bankers are suspected to have first convinced their clients to move their funds to non-Swiss locations like Singapore, Dubai and London before eventual transmission to India, to avoid the ever-growing glare or regulatory and intelligence agencies on funds and entities linked to Switzerland. 

While jurisdictions like Mauritius and Cyprus earlier used to be preferred as such intermediary locations, these places have themselves come under scanner of Indian agencies and therefore bankers are opting for some new routes. 

Refusing to disclose the name of these individuals, banks or the listed companies under scanner, a senior official said these include some really big names and those figuring in the lists of richest persons and biggest companies, but that disclosure of further details at this moment may jeopardise the probes that are still in the initial stages. 

These probes come at a time when India has strongly objected to Switzerland's denial of information about account details of certain Indians at HSBC's Swiss bank branches, in whose cases "incriminating evidence of tax evasion" have been found here. 
In his third letter to Switzerland in this regard, Finance Minister P Chidambaram said that the interpretation made by Switzerland that it cannot share information as per India's request was not in accordance with international standards.
http://tinyurl.com/qx879rl

Varanasi Modi public meetings goof-up by Election Commission (Video: 21:25) 4 letters to EC

$
0
0
Election Commission of India should bear full responsibility for the goofed-up approval process for a public meeting by Narendra Modi in Varanasi constituency where he is a contestant. Listen to the Press Conference addressed by Arun Jaitley. ECI should not create any apprehension in the minds of Indian citizens that ECI is not acting firmly and fairly in allowing the democratic process which it is mandated to perform as a Constitutional Body. ECI, don't go down in Indian history as a peanut Commission, a biased wonder destroying the traditions of Indian democracy ever since India attained her Independence from British colonial rule in 1947.

Kalyaanaraman
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XNq8nl3cexg Streamed live on May 7, 2014


Embedded image permalink
Embedded image permalink


Thursday , May 8 , 2014 |

Stung BJP on warpath in holy city

Varanasi, May 7: The BJP has lashed out at the Election Commission and threatened to hit the streets of Varanasi tomorrow morning, alleging that Narendra Modi was denied permission to hold three events in the city he is contesting the Lok Sabha election from.
The party tonight wrote a terse letter to the poll panel saying it was withdrawing its applications for permission for a rally at Benia Bagh, a Ganga aarti on the river bank and a meeting with leading citizens at a hotel, signalling it was raring for a fight.
Senior BJP leader Arun Jaitley, who demanded recall of the Varanasi returning officer, will sit on dharna outside the Banaras Hindu University campus with Modi’s aide Amit Shah, party MP Ananth Kumar and other leaders and workers in what is being seen as an attempt to milk the controversy ahead of polling in 18 seats in Uttar Pradesh and six in neighbouring Bihar on May 12.
The protesters are expected to march from the BJP’s election office, located in the heart of Varanasi, to BHU. Modi, who is scheduled to address a rally at Rohainya in rural Varanasi tomorrow, will also drive down from the helipad on the BHU campus to the party’s office, hoping to repeat the huge roadshow he staged before filing his nomination on April 24.
The Election Commission said tonight it was “surprised and disappointed” by the BJP’s decision to hold protests although it had been trying to resolve the matter “in accordance with law and the ground situation”, reports PTI.
Returning officer Pranjal Yadav had asserted at a news conference at night that permission had been granted for the Ganga aarti and the meeting with a group of citizens. “But we cannot allow Modi’s rally at Benia Bagh for security reasons,” Yadav said.
Benia Bagh, a premier meeting venue, is located in a minority-dominated neighbourhood. Sources in the Varanasi administration said there were fears Modi’s rally could foment communal tension. The sources also said the ground fits up to 50,000 people but over a lakh were expected.
After the returning officer was quoted by PTI early in the evening as saying permission had been granted for the two events and for holding the rally at an alternative venue on an application by a BJP leader, Jaitley accused Yadav of “lying through his teeth”. He denied the party had received permission for any event or that it had requested an alternative site for the rally.
But the Election Commission, in a letter to Jaitley, said the district administration had granted permission for the “Ganga poojan” and the “meeting of eminent citizens”, adds PTI. It said it had consulted the Uttar Pradesh chief secretary and the state police chief, who endorsed the district administration’s reservations on security as well as the suitability of Benia Bagh as the rally venue, including its capacity.
“You will appreciate that the commission cannot overlook the security concerns expressed by competent authorities,” the letter said. It also noted that a BJP representative, Vidyasagar Rai, had requested an alternative site on May 6 but that Jaitley had later urged the returning officer not to process the permission.
“Hence the commission is surprised and disappointed that your party has chosen to hold protests,” it said.
Jaitley had earlier sought to blame the panel for the decision to hold the dharna, saying “in case the constitutional remedy of approaching the EC is not available to us, we will have no option but to protest”.
He wrote three letters to the poll panel, accusing the returning officer of being “partisan” and rejecting the BJP’s requests for permission for all three events. He alleged that polling in Varanasi “cannot be free and fair with Mr Pranjal Yadav as the returning officer”. Jaitley said: “The returning officer wants to deny us the opportunity to campaign and by refusal to exercise the jurisdiction vested in you, you have condoned that default.”
Rahul roadshow
Rahul Gandhi will hold a roadshow in Varanasi on May 10, the last day of campaigning.

http://www.telegraphindia.com/1140508/jsp/frontpage/story_18320047.jsp#.U2rR_IGSySo

Congress goondaism on open display in Amethi -- Sandhya Jain

$
0
0

Congress goondaism on open display in Amethi

Sandhya Jain7 May 2014
Sandhya Jain is a political analyst and independent researcher. She is the author of ‘Adi Deo Arya Devata- A Panoramic View of Tribal-Hindu Cultural Interface’ (Rupa & Co., 2004) and ‘Evangelical Intrusions. Tripura: A Case Study’ (Rupa & Co., 2009).
Congress goondaism on open display in Amethi
Unbelievable as it may have seemed till only the other day, Amethi has eclipsed Varanasi in terms of dramatic value in the general election of 2014. In Varanasi, people know they are going to elect the primus inter pares of the new regime; given the unparalleled response to his road show when he went to file his nomination on April 24, no surprises are expected, even if the district administration persists with the mean-minded denial of permission to hold a public rally.
May 7, however, will go down in Indian history as the day that truly brought the curtains down on a decadent and decaying dynasty, and sent its weak but desperate heir on a political trajectory of no return. For someone raised to believe that the people of India (read courtiers, spin doctors and fellow travellers) would one day shove him into the Prime Minister’s office, which he would then graciously accept, Rahul Gandhi clearly finds the prospect of an honest defeat in an electoral contest unpalatable, and unacceptable.
Indeed, this may be true of his larger family as well, which alone explains why Preeti Sahay, secretary or public relations officer of his sister, Priyanka Vadra, was found to be illegally present in booth number 210 and 211 in Thori village of Jagdishpur area of the constituency (pic.twitter.com/oyd9nnezMm). She was clearly tasked with some chore, Priyanka Vadra herself having previously left as per Election Commission guidelines, as she was neither a voter nor a candidate.
As luck would have it, the BJP’s highly combative Smriti Irani discovered Preeti Sahay and got into a verbal match with her on discovering that she did not have the pass for entering the booth. Irani then clicked Sahay’s photograph with her mobile and alerted the media that was following her around  (pic.twitter.com/Uo8uHBbyYm). Sahay meanwhile told ABP reporter Vikas Bhadauria not to film her presence in the booth.
The Election Commission, which has been found terribly wanting in vulnerable States like West Bengal and in sensitive constituencies like Amethi where the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) has been protesting uneven behaviour for the past two days, tried to equate the two parties in the incident. District Electoral Officer Jagat Raj Tripathi said that after the BJP candidate complained, the police took Sahay out of the booth, but added, “Prime facie, we found that both the persons were wrong in their own places. While Preeti Sahay should not have been inside the booth, Smiriti Irani also misbehaved inside the booth”. So, a culprit and a potential victim of malpractice enjoy parity in the eyes of the Electoral Officer!
Congress’s Amethi candidate Rahul Gandhi himself got embroiled in several questionable practices during this high stakes election, which has the potential to nix his political career and ambitions forever. For the first time in the past 10 years, the Gandhi scion spent the night in Amethi and remained present during the polling, thus revealing his anxiety about his fate due to the threat mounted by Smriti Irani and the AAP’s Kumar Vishwas.
As Rahul Gandhi moved from booth to booth inside the constituency, which has also been shown on ABP News, the social media got after him with unexpected ferocity. To begin with, these unpaid election observers protested that a non-voter (Rahul Gandhi) had entered a booth (pic.twitter.com/2a0WpMqHz3), inspected the voting machine (pic.twitter.com/6lD2nfVjLp) and appeared to be monitoring the voting (pic.twitter.com/KjAnvM9MCJ). Worse, he even conducted a meeting with a few workers (pic.twitter.com/udbUI2dy3J) inside the booth, that too, without wearing the requisite badge. Clearly the Gandhis think that normal rules do not apply to them.
Many things were amiss with the Congress vice-president’s behaviour. To begin with, a person who is an SPG protectee cannot move around the constituency with security, much less enter a polling booth if not a voter in the constituency, which Gandhi is not, having cast his vote in Delhi on April 7. The law states, “(21) On the day of the poll, no person who has been assessed to be having a security threat and therefore given official security shall enter the vicinity of a polling station premise (within 100 meters) with his security personnel. Further, on the day of the poll no such person shall move around in a constituency with his security personnel. If the person provided with official security happens to be a voter also, then he or she shall restrict his / her movement – accompanied by security personnel, to voting only”.
Another rule says, “V Polling Booth. Excepting the voters, no one without a valid pass from the Election Commission shall enter the polling booths”. While the AAP candidate Kumar Vishwas and his supporters were less agile in uploading proof of the Congress malfeasance during the election process, they constantly complained of booth capturing, fake voting and intimidation of workers. The AAP alleged that despite complaints from several places about intimidation of workers, the observers and district administration failed to take action on complaints being sent through phone, e-mail and SMSes.
However, advocate Somnath Bharti managed to post a picture of Congress’s abuse of power by hoisting the party buntings and Rahul Gandhi poster in a Government school serving as a booth (pic.twitter.com/Wc1Mxyrjxa).
Twitter was abuzz with complaints of the distribution of money and liquor in the constituency last night, which was allegedly returned by the Amethi residents. If true, this would be worrying news for those doing the distribution. At Gunnaur village in Musafirkhana area, the BJP alleged that some youths carrying over rupees one lakh in cash were distributing the same among voters. Police Superintendent Hira Lal confirmed the detention of two boys but said no cash was recovered from them. According to CNN-IBN, AAP complained against Rahul Gandhi travelling in Amethi with a cavalcade of 15 vehicles on polling day (CNN-IBN News ‏@ibnlive 3h).
The party alleged massive both capturing and violation of the model code of conduct and that no one from the Election Commission was accessible. A similar complaint was made by the BJP candidate late last night as well. Allegations of booth capturing and goondaism were most pronounced from places where the Congress candidate was on a sticky wicket. At Phula village, Rahul Gandhi lost his temper when a villager chanted har har Modi. At one booth in this village, Rahul Gandhi protested at a lotus drawn on a black board. Locals say the situation is bad for the ruling party, hence its desperation.
http://www.niticentral.com/2014/05/07/congress-goondaism-on-open-display-in-amethi-221082.html

Why should the Election Commission of India function as a Pradesh Sonia Congress Committee? -- V. Sundaram, IAS (R)

$
0
0
Why should the Election Commission of India function as a Pradesh Sonia Congress Committee?

V.SUNDARAM IAS®

I derive my inspiration to write this article from the words of Bernard Shaw (1856-1950) who said : ‘’ My way of Joking is to tell the Truth ‘’.  The functioning of the Election Commission of  India today has become a Cruel Joke!

More then 60.239 Lakhs of Genuine Voters have been deliberately left out of the Final Electoral Roll in Maharashtra by the Election Commission of India. This is a criminal offence.  On this is  ground alone F I Rs can be filed against all the Election Commissioners for their total failure to discharge their due responsibilities under the Indian Constitution.

Chief Election Commissioner Sampath was appointed as Election Commissioner on the recommendation of Rajasekhara Reddy (Former Chief Minister of Andhtra Pradesh ) made to Sonia Gandhi. He is a Dedicated Congress Partisan like Navin Chawla who was a Loyalist of the Nehru- Gandhi Family right from the first day of his Entry into the IAS in 1969. Navin Chawla was indicted by the SHAH COMMISSION in 1978.                                      

Navin Chawla can be viewed as Sampath of yesterday and Sampath of today can be viewed as Navin Chawla of yesterday. Either way Sonia Gandhi should not be allowed to succeed in her Nefarious Mission of Rigging the Process  of Lok Sabha Polls 2014. 


I have no doubt that the Election Commission of India has given a firm Commitment to  Sonia Gandhi to rig the 2014 Lok Sabha Polls in a Planned , Methodical, Mischievously  Selective and Selectively Mischievous Manner in order to ensure their runaway success of the Congress Party in at least 100 Lok Sabha   Constituencies. Leaving out 60.239 Lakhs of Genuine Voters from the Official Electoral Roll is an Integral Part of this Grand Process of Rigging the 2014 Lok Sabha Polls.

Dinesh Agrawal has rightly called the malfunctioning of the Election Commission of India as Quixotic and Biased. Here his observations are very relevant: ‘’First they ban Amit Shah for his “revenge” speech. Then they ban Azam Khan for his “Muslims saved Kargil” speech. Both are idiotic cases and didn’t deserve any action. But like the media, the EC too now indulges in “monkey balancing”. Amit Shah’s ban has been reversed but not Azam Khan’s. I’m no fan of Khan but if he wants to say Muslims saved Kargil, what is wrong in it? At best it’s a lie or not the full truth. That should be combated by other politicians not by the EC. Which political speech during an election does not have some sprinkling of lies and distortions? This whole nonsense of “hate speech” is driven a lot by religious issues. There is nothing hateful in what Khan or Shah said. Why are we so scared that Hindus and Muslims are dumb who will fall prey to such speeches? Are the ECs supposed to act as their Mother-in-law?’’

Here is yet another Quotation from Dinesh Agrawal: ‘’There is another moron (who invented the DNA testing system) called Abu Azmi who wants the DNA of those Muslims, who didn’t vote for his party, to scientifically establish if they are Muslims or RSS members. For the record, even RSS has a Muslim-wing. So far, terrorists wanted to hear some verses from Quran or the name of Mohammad’s mother to establish one was a Muslim. Now we have a new method? In case some have forgotten, this same EC covered all theelephants of Mayawati on frivolous claims of other parties that it would influence voters. The EC spent crores on it. Does the EC really believe voters are that dumb? There was even a complaint by
                                                
Congress in MP to hide lotus ponds. This has been getting sillier with time. Then there’s the question of campaigning or flashing symbols on voting day. Which age does the EC live in?’’


The EC recently filed FIRs against Narendra Modi for flashing the Lotus badge while talking to media after voting in Gandhinagar on April 30. The Congress and others complained about it and the EC held a special 3 hour emergency meeting after which they decided to file the FIRs against Modi. This is as stupid as it gets. There’s a 24X7 media beaming sound-bites from various candidates on voting day. There was Nandan Nilekani commenting on BJP and why Congress should win after he voted in Bangalore. In the pic below, others using symbols after voting are doing so deliberately and not accidentally:




My Friend Dr.S.Kalayanaraman is absolutely right when he says that the Election Commission of India should bear full responsibility for the goofed-up approval process for a public meeting by Narendra Modi in Varanasi Constituency where he is a Contestant. In a  Press Conference addressed by Arun Jaitley, he has stated that the  Election Commission of India(ECI) should not create any apprehension in the minds of Indian citizens that the  ECI is not acting firmly and fairly in allowing the democratic process which it is mandated to perform as a Constitutional Body. The ECI should take due care to see that it does not  go down in Indian history as a Peanut Commission, a BIASED BONELESS WONDER, destroying the traditions of Indian democracy ever since India attained her Independence from British colonial rule in 1947.

The Election Commission is functioning as a 24x7 Wholetime Agency of the Sonia Congress Party. They have effectively blocked all the Rallies of Narendra Modi in Varanasi. At the same time they have given Blanket Permission to Buddhu Rahul Gandhi to conduct all his Railes and Meetings in Varanasi. Perhaps Priyanka Gandhi has influenced the ECI to treat Narendra Modi as One belonging to NEECH JATI. So Much For the Open and Shameless Bias of the ECI!! And yet the ECI has in a disgraceful fashion told Arun Jaitley :’’You cannot insinuate Bias to the ECI. We are functioning in a Fair Manner."

TAILPIECE


At the Beginning was ECI

THE ECI was with SONIA CONGRESS

SONIA CONGRESS WAS THE ECI











What The End of Swiss Banking Secrecy Means For India -- Chitra Subramaniam

$
0
0

What The End of Swiss Banking Secrecy Means For India

Chitra
By Chitra Subramaniam May 7, 2014
How does Switzerland, a country of 8 million people develop and lead ten global brands? The same way it manages one third of the world’s assets under management (AUM). Time will tell whether the end of banking secrecy this week will lead to a realigning of assets in other tax-havens. Since we broke the story in India yesterday we have been inundated with calls and messages asking what this means for Indians. Read our report from Tuesday, May 6th here.  
The good news for Indian tax-evaders and money-launderers is that India is not a part of the Paris-based Organisation for Economic Development and Cooperation (OECD) that groups 47 countries with varying economic and political might from around the world. The bad news is that Indian Finance Minister P. Chidambaram’s could be hoist on his own bluff. 
In a recent statement to reporters he said if the Swiss government does not cooperate with India in its tireless and ceaseless pursuit of illegal Indian money in Switzerland, he would shame Bern in front of the G-20. Fact of the matter is many powerful countries in the G-20 – an economic grouping of countries that technically challenges the G-8 - are also members of the OECD. 
What this latest development can mean for India, if the Indian government wants, is the following. When an Indian opens a bank account in the Alpine country, s/he will be required to sign a document which will state that information will be shared between Bern and New Delhi. This will include normal reporting information like bank balance, dividends and interest and sales proceeds used to calculate capital tax gains. This is already the practice between OECD countries and Switzerland and Singapore have now joined the group. 
Estimates of how much money is illegally held by Indians in Swiss banks ranges from US$1.42 billion to US$2.18 billion with the CBI and the finance ministry constantly contradicting each other of either exaggerating or under-quoting. Money goes where money feels safe so while tax-evaders and money-launderers are not waiting to be caught, there will always be a paper and/or electronic trail. 
The other frequently asked question in India is– and The News Minute received a fair share of these in the last 24 hours – how far back will the information go. The short answer is also the straight one – everything depends on New Delhi. As things stand now, if India or any other country asks for information relating to illegal accounts and tax evasion, the Swiss will answer. The Swiss banks can no longer have illegal accounts held by foreigners.
Simply stated, it is not for want of laws that New Delhi has failed. It is want of will – now and for decades. The national Indian pastime of passing the buck is the country’s best kept secret and there many jokes in Switzerland’s banking, financial and political circles about how Indian politicians and businessmen open their eyes wide shut when it comes to l’argent sale or black money. 
Swiss banking secrecy and the fabled numbered and secret accounts date back to 1934 when Jews fleeing Nazi Germany deposited their money and documents to be kept safe in the deep vaults of a country most believed was neutral. Switzerland’s neutrality is an armed neutrality – not just militarily but also armed strategically with information, money and precision. Just like invading tanks cannot overrun the country and its alpine topography, Swiss banking secrecy and its methods have developed and strengthened over several decades as all countries deposited their wealth in a country whose political stability served all interests. 
All that has changed dramatically over the past decade as a result of national but more importantly, international pressure from countries seeking to retrieve their money and assets deposited in Swiss banks by dictators and corrupt politicians, drugs and arms dealers. Push came to shove in 2009 when the United Bank of Switzerland (UBS) paid a fine of US$780 million to the US government, entering into a deferred prosecution agreement on charges of conspiring to defraud the American government by impeding their tax authority, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). Read about the UBS story here- UBS tax evasion controversy
For the record, I add here that during the Bofors investigations, unknown to me, a Ms. Donovan from London was transferring money into my UBS account in Switzerland. I returned the money as soon as it showed up in my monthly statement. UBS did not disclose who Ms. Donovan was. Suffice for the moment to say that along with the UBS, another Swiss banking giant Crédit Suisse was also involved in the Bofors payoffs. I also received a legal notice from a Delhi-based public relations consultant-turned image guru. I will write about that in another post. 
Fearing a similar trans-Atlantic probe, top private banks changed the company structures and holdings to limit liability. The latest Swiss bank to be investigated is Crédit Suisse – slated to plead guilty in a US court shortly – and banking sources say the bank could be fined as much as US$1.4 billion for helping American citizens evade taxes by providing false and fraudulent information. Read- Tunisia, Peru, Nigeria and now America to retrieve illegal money in Swiss banks: India?
Pressure on Switzerland and Swiss banks has also been mounting from Germany and France to share information about tax-evaders and money-launderers. Tax is one of the primary reasons people park their money in Switzerland. “It is clearly the end of banking secrecy abused for tax purposes,” OECD said in a statement. What the United Kingdom (UK), also a member of the OECD, proposes to do with tax evasion and money laundering via British Virgin islands (BVi) and the Caymen Islands is an issue that will be keenly watched by all including Swiss bankers. 
We wrote this spoof last week. That was before the end of Swiss banking secrecy. Read -Swiss Banks and India – The Accidental and Unwilling Press Release
Chitra Subramaniam, The News Minute's Editor-in-chief, is a journalist most known for her reporting on Bofors. She has been a UN correspondent, reported on the Bosnian war, GATT-WTO, Arms Control, among other issues. She was a diplomat at the WHO (leading the policy analysis and communications work for the flagship tobacco control treaty the FCTC), managed a company from Switzerland working with the TATA Group (India), The Wallenberg group (Sweden) and Ferrari (Italy), to name a few. She is a recipient of two of India's highest journalism awards-The B.D. Goenka Award and the Chameli Devi Award.
http://www.thenewsminute.com/stories/What%20The%20End%20of%20Swiss%20Banking%20Secrecy%20Means%20For%20India#.U2pav4GSySq

Why you couldn't find your name on the voter list -- Anupam Saraph. Who is to guard the guard with cheat sheet?

$
0
0

Why you couldn't find your name on the voter list

Last updated on: May 07, 2014 17:05 IST
‘The failure of the ECI to follow the Registration of Electoral Rules and create verified and audited rolls or even verifiable and auditable ones, highlight that the entire electoral roll is merely a compilation of names without any effort or intention for completeness, correctness or fair play.’
‘We are fooling ourselves by electing our representatives based on faulty electoral rolls that do not represent the people of the constituency. Elections based on these rolls are neither free nor fair. Democracy is under siege,’ says Dr Anupam Saraph.
There is no verified and audited copy of the electoral rolls with anyone.
Electoral rolls for a parliamentary constituency include all the rolls of the assembly constituencies within the PC. Each AC roll has about 300 parts, each of which has about 1,500 persons listed. None of these parts is verifiable or auditable.
According to Rule 6 of the Registration of Electors Rules, the electoral rolls should have been alphabetically displayed like in a phone book or arranged by house numbers for easy spotting of missing names and duplicates or suspicious entries.
In practice, the names are randomly distributed across and within parts of the electoral roll. That is precisely why you had trouble finding your name on the printed rolls or identifying the “part” to which your name belonged in order to locate your polling centre and within it the booth where you needed to cast your vote.
More importantly, that is why you can never tell if this is a complete list of voters from your neighbourhood or even a genuine one.
Rule 25 of the Registration of Electors Rules requires an intensive revision of the rolls and requires that rules 4 to 23 be applied in such revision as they would apply in relation to the first preparation of a roll.
When such a revision takes place, the corrected papers have to be kept in the office of the registration officer until the expiration of one year after the next intensive revision of that roll. Every person has the right to inspect the election papers referred to in rule 32 and to get attested copies.
No such papers exist as no intensive revision of the rolls has happened.
In September 2011, the Election Commission of India had asked for the block-level registers (ie, registers containing details of all the electors in the block) be updated through door-to-door visits. No such visit ever happened.
The block-level registers were not available for inspection despite repeated requests to the election offices. If block-level registers are not updated, it implies that addresses and persons on the roll may not exist, or that addresses and persons that exist may not be on the roll.
With complete disregard to the conflict of interest of political parties in the matter, the district election offices outsourced the task of submitting forms for addition (form 6) and deletion (form 7 and 8A) of names to political parties in order to produce an amended copy of the existing roll (also called as summary revision).
This made possible selective addition of those favourable to the party as also the selective removal of those unfavourable to the party easy. It also made possible the addition of dummy voters to allow for fake voting and double voting easy.
To add insult to injury, the district election offices accepted such forms in bulk without scrutiny or verification. It is no surprise, therefore, that all irregularities would creep into electoral rolls.
Electoral rolls prepared with such irregularities fraudulently interfere with the process of an election whereby members of a party can occupy a polling booth, excluding and voting in place of those people who should be able to vote there. This is booth-capturing as described in section 135A of the Representation of the People Act of 1951.
The Election Commission of India also permitted the use of Aadhaar cards as a proof  of identity and proof of address. Aadhaar is a random number assigned to unverified and unaudited data submitted by private parties. It is not a proof of identity or address; not even a proof of existence. It certainly is not a proof of citizenship. Not even the UIDAI certifies it as such.
This means that in one stroke the ECI allowed the registration of residents with different identities, residents of another location, non-existing persons and even non-citizens.
It also opened up the possibility of multiple registrations by the same persons or even registration at locations other than where they belong and with multiple IDs.
To make matters worse, netas or their agents doing bulk submission of form 6 and 7 to add or delete names were also enrolment agents and introducers for Aadhaar.  
This made it possible and easy to create persons with similar identities in different locations to allow for fake or duplicate voting.
It also made it possible and easy for such netas or their agents to submit forms on behalf and without the knowledge of those who did Aadhaar registration with them.
It is possible and easy to doctor the roll to favour the neta by moving people across constituencies, adding or deleting persons.
The task of creating rolls from the data entered by election staffers into the electoral roll management system was outsourced to by the ECI to Aatishay Infotech, a Bhopal-based IT company also working on Aadhaar enrolment.
As there is no verification or audit of the roll, or transparency of the role of Aatishay Infotech in the entire process, it is easily possible that not all persons submitting form 6 may have been included, as also persons may be deleted without submitting form 7 --  or even that not all persons or addresses may actually exist.
Strangely, the ERMS prints selective information and incomplete addresses on the roll and EPIC.
It has been widely reported and observed and is easily verifiable by downloading a PDF copy of any roll, that addresses are incomplete and therefore untraceable.  
This makes persons on the roll or with EPIC untraceable.
It makes it impossible to audit the rolls. It is possible for persons to impersonate another, by claiming error in the information on the roll.
Under the Registration of Electors Rules, rolls and connected papers shall be kept in the office of the election registration officer until the expiration of one year after the next intensive revision (or creating such rolls afresh) of that roll.
No papers are ever available with the ERO as intensive revision is a rare event. It is difficult, at best, to trace how the names got into or out of the roll.
In the absence of any verifiable or auditable rolls, how can one estimate the extent of the damage?
If you calculate the number of people who would be expected to be on the roll given the age structure as published by the Census of India and the population of a constituency as published by the Maharashtra State Election Commission, you would get the table below.








This shows that there are at least 35 pc non-existent voters.
Add to that if 25 pc of the existing electors are deleted, as is apparent from the PDF lists found pm the ECI website, the electoral rolls are off by at least off by a whopping 60 pc.
This has been brought to the attention of the election machinery from 2011.
In fact, activists from Pune took objections to the entire electoral roll as far back as on voters day, January 25, in 2012 with the district election officer in Pune. The district election office has not even undertaken an inquiry as required under Rule 20 of the Registration of Electors Rules. The complaint lodged with the then commissioner of police has also not progressed.
The elections to Parliament have not happened on new, intensively revised rolls. Rather, there have been more additions and deletions through political parties. The roll is therefore expected to have an even larger mismatch in being representative of any constituency.
If the Representation of the People Act cannot cause the people to be represented, what can?
The writing on the wall is clear. We are not the largest democracy as we have claimed ourselves to be, we only appear to be a democracy.
Our netas have lost perspective of what democracy is all about and have come to represent elections and the formation of local bodies, legislative bodies or Parliament as democracy.
Our administration has come to believe that the netas are their bosses, not the people.
We are made to believe that elections are the only way we can participate in the democratic process.
So why worry?
The failure of the ECI to follow the Registration of Electoral Rules and create verified and audited rolls or even verifiable and auditable ones, highlight that the entire electoral roll is merely a compilation of names without any effort or intention for completeness, correctness or fair play.
We are fooling ourselves by electing our representatives based on faulty electoral rolls that do not represent the people of the constituency. Elections based on these rolls are neither free nor fair. Democracy is under siege.
The ECI continues to use unverified and unaudited electoral rolls and fails to have any audit to certify all who voted were eligible or all who were eligible were on the rolls.
The ECI creates the rolls, conducts the election, declares it to be free and fair and also rules on any objections of the process.
The Preamble to the Constitution guarantees us justice. Where can the aam aadmi get justice if the ECI uses Section 329 of the Representation of the People Act to prevent the courts from “interfering”?
Will the courts strike down Section 329 under Article 13 of the Constitution that strikes down laws inconsistent with or in derogation of Fundamental Rights?
Especially since the entire mockery of election process has compromised the people’s right to Freedom of Speech under Article 19 of the Constitution, apart from declaring as unequal all those whose opinion will no longer be counted and thus violating Article 14.
It is clear that the ECI must undertake an intensive revision of the electoral rolls through door-to-door visits by staff that is hired solely for this purpose. With publicly accessible online maps, it should be easy to number each part of the roll and each house on each street for complete transparency.
It is not impossible to mail a two-part bar-coded postcard to the electors at each address once the door-to-door surveys are completed, which they would be required to mail back with their signature to confirm their address.
It is not too much to require the Comptroller and Auditor General to audit the rolls for their compliance with Rule 6 of the Registration of Electors Rules, for completeness, correctness and fairness.
It certainly is not asking for too much to require the conduct of free and fair elections as soon as, and only after, such genuine, verified and audited electoral rolls are available.
Dr Anupam Saraph has researched Indian elections since 2009 and has submitted detailed reports on election reforms to the ministry of law and justice and the Election Commission of India. He is also a member of the Nagrik Chetna Manch that has raised this issue with the Chief Justice of India and the Election Commission of India.
Dr Anupam Saraph

Election Commission apology for missing voters' names in Maharashtra

People stand in queues to cast their votes at a polling station in Mumbai on Thursday
New Delhi The Election Commission has apologised and promised an investigation into the large number of names missing from voters' lists in Maharashtra, where elections were held yesterday in 19 constituencies, including six in Mumbai.
TOP 10 UPDATES ON THE STORY
  1. "We will look into the matter and we apologise for the inconvenience caused to voters," Election Commissioner HS Brahma said today. He is one of three election commissioners.
  2. Hundreds of thousands of names were found missing from the voters' lists on Thursday, when the 19 constituencies in the state voted in the sixth phase of the national election.
  3. In Mumbai, around two lakh voters could not find their name on the list. Mumbai has six Lok Sabha seats.
  4. Among those who said they could note vote because their names were missing were HDFC chairman Deepak Parekh, lawyer Ram Jethmalani and Marathi  actor Atul Kulkarni.
  5. Mumbai recorded a 53% voter turnout on Thursday, a sharp rise from the 2009 elections, but far less than many other parts of the country.
  6. Sources in the Election Commission say these voters can't cast their vote in this election, but the error will be corrected before the Maharashtra assembly election due later this year.
  7. Ananya Sharma tweeted a letter she says she received from the Election Commission. It said, "We could not provide any reason for the rejection of your form. Due to the closing of the voting list, we cannot add your name to the voter list and therefore you cannot vote in the Lok Sabha elections." NDTV cannot verify the authenticity of the letter.
  8. Voters' names were reportedly left out in "a clean-up" drive to remove voters who have not voted in the last few elections, have moved out or have died. A group of citizens in Mumbai has threatened to go to court over the missing names.
  9. But the election commissioner also said that voters were partly responsible too as they could have pointed out that their names were missing on March 9, when the final voters' lists were verified.
  10. Maharashtra sends 48 MPs to the Lok Sabha, the second largest contingent after Uttar Pradesh.
Story First Published: 


RahulG violates, ECI officials violate code of conduct for transparent, free and fair polls. Who guards the guard of democratic suffrage?

$
0
0

Amethi EVM Machines carried without protection on the streets  

The Election Officials are in complete violation of ECI guidelines outlined by ECI. Will ECI conduct transparent, free and fair polls?
See Slide 37 of the ppt prepared by ECI for disseminating the Code of EC Official conduct and Code of Conduct for all others involved in the democratic process.
http://eci.nic.in/ECI_Main/training/EVM-%20As%20on%20January,%202014.ppt See slide 37:



Kalyanaraman


Rahul was in EVM enclosure during voting hours in Amethi

Shailvee Sharda & Shalabh,TNN | May 8, 2014, 01.26 AM IST



Rahul was in EVM enclosure during voting hours in Amethi
Congress leader Rahul Gandhi 
AMETHI: Congress leader Rahul Gandhi was present on polling day in Amethi for the first time in 10 years and he seems to have violated the law by entering the voting compartment, the closeted area where the EVM machine is kept, during polling hours in at least three booths. These are Ashtabhuja Vidyalaya in Sahamau, Prathamik Vidyalaya Koora and Madhyamik Vidyalaya Phoola, all of them in the Tiloi assembly segment, between 9.15am and 10.24am. 

TOI photographer V Sunil captured him peering over the EVM machines at two places during polling hours and emerging from the EVM enclosure at another. A senior Election Commission official told TOI in Delhi that during polling, only three people can access the voting compartment: the voter, presiding officer and polling officer. 

In case a candidate gains access to the polling station, the presiding officer will be held responsible, said the official. The candidate can be acted against only if he enters the polling compartment while a voter is in the process of voting, and the offence here is violation of secrecy of voting, as provided in the Representation of the People Act, 1951.

Rahul Gandhi was seen entering the polling area by others too. The Aam Aadmi Party complained on Wednesday about the violation of election rules by Rahul Gandhi. The party tweeted several pictures of Rahul in polling booths. A picture showing him looking at an EVM was accompanied with a tweet that asked, "Is the candidate allowed to go to the polling machine?"



(These TOI photographs show (left) Rahul Gandhi inspecting an EVM machine at Amethi's Madhyamik Vidyalaya Phoola in Tiloi assembly segment at 10.24am and (right) emerging after inspecting an EVM machine at Ashtabhuja Vidyalaya in Sahamau at 9.20am, both within polling hours)

Rahul reached a polling booth in Bhoaiya Kesariya Gram Sabha in Bhadarpur Block of Amethi at 8.15am with his aide Kaushal Vidyarthi and talked to a voter. At 9.20am he was seen emerging from the enclosed area after inspecting an EVM machine at Ashtabhuja Vidyalaya in Sahamau. At 10.24am he inspected an EVM machine at polling booth number 137-Amethi at the Madhyamik Vidyalaya Phoola in Tiloi assembly segment. 

The EC official in Delhi said that a candidate can enter the polling booth during polling hours and interact with the voters, but cannot canvass for votes during such an interaction. Prior to polling, a mock-poll is held at the polling station. A candidate or his agent can enter the voting compartment at this stage to check if the EVM is functioning properly. 

Clearly, Rahul Gandhi was not present during the mock-poll hours - between 5am and 7am - as he reached the Furstaganj air strip at 7.30am. While the presiding officer would have to explain Rahul's presence at the EVM enclosure during polling hours, the penalty against the candidate for violating the law is not clear. 
(With inputs from Bharti Jain in Delhi) 
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/home/lok-sabha-elections-2014/news/Rahul-was-in-EVM-enclosure-during-voting-hours-in-Amethi/articleshow/34796103.cms

Election Commission is not a neutral umpire -- Tweets. Is EC conducting free, fair polls? Who guards the guard?

$
0
0

Election Commission is not a Neutral Umpire !

1. @narendramodi's serious allegations on Election Comm. Who is your Owner? Who appointed you? Stop taking sides https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xphsq1CWmho 
2. Why was @narendramodi forced to take on Election Comm.? Is EC a Neutral Umpire ? Are they really doing their Duty ? Lets check out ---
YouTube @YouTube

Varanasi charter -- NaMo

$
0
0

CHARTER FOR VARANASI BY SHRI NARENDRA MODI Wednesday, 07 May 2014

Sea tensions along Indian Ocean rim. India should intervene, prevail upon China to reduce tensions

$
0
0

Vietnam, Philippines Incidents Raise Sea Tensions

Vessels Clash Over Chinese Oil Rig; Philippines Detains Fishermen Near Spratly Islands

Updated May 7, 2014 9:48 p.m. ET
Chinese ships confronted the Vietnamese coast guard Wednesday, ratcheting up the struggle over control of disputed waters in the South China Sea. Vietnam Coast Guard/Associated Press
Strains between China and its neighbors burst to the surface in two parts of the South China Sea, taking the high-stakes struggle for control over the waters to new levels of friction.
Off Vietnam, dozens of Chinese military and civilian ships clashed with the Vietnamese coast guard, with Vietnamese officials complaining its vessels were repeatedly rammed. On the same day, Philippine police apprehended Chinese fishing vessels loaded with hundreds of sea turtles in disputed waters.
About 80 Chinese vessels moved into an area near the disputed Paracel Islands, where Hanoi has sought to prevent China from deploying a massive oil rig, said Rear Adm. Ngo Ngoc Thu, vice commander of the Vietnamese coast guard. He said the flotilla included seven military ships and that it was supported by aircraft.
He said the situation, which started brewing over the weekend, was "very tense" and said six Vietnamese officers had been injured in the standoff.
The confrontation—by far the most serious in recent years between the two neighbors—marked a significant escalation in Beijing's willingness to press its natural-resource claims, analysts said.
Vietnamese officials said Chinese vessels rammed into Vietnamese coast guard vessels as relations, surrounding a Chinese oil rig in the region, became fraught. Separately, the Philippines said a Chinese fishing vessel full of sea turtles had been apprehended. The WSJ's Brian Spegele reports.
Theresa Fallon, a senior associate at the European Institute for Asian Studies, a Brussels-based think tank, said China's move represented the regional energy sector's "worst nightmare" and was bound to provoke Vietnam's anger.
"This is a huge rig—it's the size of a couple of football fields," Ms. Fallon said.
A senior administration official said the White House views the latest escalation as part of a pattern of behavior as China continues to try to advance its territorial claims. "We're obviously very concerned about it," the official said. "We have conveyed our concerns to the Chinese."
The standoff is "an unprecedented situation," said Ian Storey, a senior fellow at the Institute of Southeast Asian Studies in Singapore. The sheer number of Chinese vessels that appeared to be involved was a clear indication of China's "resolve to make sure this rig can operate in these waters."
Chinese State Councilor Yang Jiechi described the move as part of a Chinese business's normal operations and asked Vietnam to stop interfering, a Foreign Ministry spokesman said at a daily briefing.
China's Defense Ministry didn't respond to a request to comment.
The U.S., which has a vital interest in maintaining open sea lanes for trade in the South China Sea, has encouraged a multilateral approach to resolve the disputes—though China insists on negotiating with one country at a time.
The State Department said on Wednesday said China's decision to move the oil rig into contested waters was "provocative and unhelpful."
"We are strongly concerned about dangerous conduct and intimidation by vessels in the disputed area," said State Department spokeswoman Jen Psaki.
President Barack Obama toured the region last month, stressing U.S. security cooperation. The latest escalation of tensions in the South China Sea reinforces that the disputes "are not going to be solved with one trip or one speech," said Michael Green, senior vice president for Asia at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington. "And it shows that the Chinese side is not fazed by the negative reaction in the region," Mr. Green said.
China and Vietnam fought a brief but bloody border war in 1979. Today, China's military far outguns Vietnam's, but that doesn't mean Vietnam will quickly back down. "Vietnam has a record of not pulling back from military confrontations," said James Hardy, Asia-Pacific editor at IHS Jane's Defence Weekly.
A Vietnamese naval soldier stands guard on one of the disputed islands in the South China Sea. Reuters
Security scholars said the latest escalation in tensions is the cumulative result of deep-seated mistrust over China's intentions among smaller regional players combined with Beijing's increased assertiveness as well as a lack of mechanisms to prevent and manage crises.
The confrontation also illuminated the role of China's state-owned energy companies in helping advance China's territorial ambitions, despite frequent assertions by executives that they are driven by profit and not politics.
The company controlling the oil rig, China National Offshore Oil Corp., or Cnooc, has previously figured as a controversial actor in the South China Sea, by offering up for foreign cooperation oil blocks in contested waters.
The deep-water rig launched with much fanfare in 2012, at which time the company chairman described it as a "strategic weapon" for China's oil industry. The company didn't respond to requests to comment Wednesday.
Vietnam released footage it said was of a Chinese vessel ramming a Vietnamese Coast Guard ship in the South China Sea as Vietnam tried to prevent the deployment of a Chinese oil rig in disputed waters. Via The Foreign Bureau, WSJ's global news update.
The administration of President Xi Jinping, who took over as China's Communist Party leader in November 2012, has pledged to bolster ties with regional neighbors. At the same time, China has stepped up its assertiveness in territorial disputes, which has undermined regional trust-building.
The Philippines on Wednesday apprehended a Chinese fishing vessel "carrying large numbers of endangered species" near Half Moon Shoal, a sandbar in the disputed Spratly Islands in the South China Sea and a hotbed for illegal sea-turtle poaching. Philippines police senior inspector Dante Padilla said an inspection of the boat yielded around 500 sea turtles, some of them dead.
He said the police had arrested the captain of the Chinese vessel and its 10 crew members.
The Philippines Department of Foreign Affairs said in a statement it seized the Chinese fishing boat "to enforce maritime laws and to uphold Philippine sovereign rights over its [exclusive economic zone]."
Chinese Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Hua Chunying urged the Philippines to release the fishermen and to refrain from taking further provocative actions. Ms. Hua said the Chinese Embassy in Manila had complained to the Philippine government.
The Philippines and China have overlapping maritime claims in several areas in the South China Sea. Amid China's recent aggressive assertions of its claims in the dispute areas, the Philippines had brought its case before an international tribunal to rally international support for its territorial claim.
On his visit to the region last month, President Obama assured the Philippines that American military support is "ironclad," though he left vague whether the U.S. would come to the aid of the Philippines in its island disputes.
The territorial disputes aren't part of the agenda of this weekend's meeting of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations in Myanmar this weekend. The summit is aimed at regional integration and participation in the G-20 summit in November. Tensions flared at an Asean summit in 2012 after Philippine President Benigno Aquino III disputed a statement by Cambodia, then the summit's chairman, about an agreement in the bloc "not to internationalize the South China Sea from now on."
—Colleen McCain Nelson,
Trefor Moss,
and Cris Larano
contributed to this article.
Write to Vu Trong Khanh at trong-khanh.vu@wsj.com and Josephine Cuneta atjosephine cuneta@wsj.com
http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB10001424052702304431104579547241211054588?mg=reno64-wsj&url=http%3A%2F%2Fonline.wsj.com%2Farticle%2FSB10001424052702304431104579547241211054588.html



34 pm JST
May 7, 2014

CHINA

Abe Blames China for Asian Tensions

Prime Minister Shinzo Abe speaks at NATO in Brussels.
 
Agence France-Presse/Getty Images
Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe wants to persuade European leaders that China–not just Russia–is responsible for boosting security concerns to levels not seen since the end of the Cold War.
Mr. Abe spoke late Tuesday, just before new confrontations in the South China Sea were reported.
“In the South China Sea, there has been a series of actions based on unilateral claims, and a sense of urgent vigilance is mounting among regional countries,” Mr. Abe said at the Brussels headquarters of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization.
He drew a parallel between Russia’s invasion of Crimea and China’s muscle-flexing in the East China Sea and South China Sea, while repeatedly referring to new tensions in the post-Cold War era.
“We cannot accept changes to the status quo by force or coercion. This is a global issue that also impacts Asia,” Mr. Abe said.
Earlier this week, Vietnam said it would take “all measures necessary” to protect its interests after a Chinese state oil company began drilling an oil rig in what Hanoi considers its exclusive economic zone. On Wednesday, Vietnamese officials said Chinese vessels rammed into Vietnamese coast guard vessels about 10 miles, or 16 kilometers, from the contested site.
Separately, Philippine police said Wednesday that their maritime group had apprehended a Chinese fishing vessel loaded with hundreds of sea turtles near Half Moon Shoal, a sandbar in the disputed Spratly Islands in the South China Sea, drawing swift condemnation from Beijing.
Japan has its own territorial disputes with China over a group of tiny East China Sea islands administered by Japan.
Mr. Abe has routinely criticized the fast pace of China’s military expansion. In the latest speech, he put it in a European context. He said China’s defense budget has grown to 40 times the level at the end of the Cold War and now is roughly equivalent to the outlays of the U.K., France and Germany combined.
The prime minister said Japan has boosted the number of scrambles by its fighter jets “to the same level as during the height of the Cold War” owing to what he called incursions by Chinese military aircraft into skies near Japan.
To counter China’s military rise, Japan has been beefing up its security ties with nations in Southeast Asia. Mr. Abe used his current 10-day, six-nation tour to do the same with some European nations. In the U.K., he signed a pact to strengthen defense cooperation. With France, Japan agreed to start joint development of military equipment.
“Together, we triumphed in the Cold War…. The security environments surrounding Japan and Europe are once again becoming increasingly severe,” Mr. Abe said.
http://blogs.wsj.com/japanrealtime/2014/05/07/abe-blames-china-for-asian-tensions/


EC democracy blockade in Varanasi. Lies of EC exposed -- Arun Jaitley. Withdraw Airline Permit to AirAsia - Swamy to CEC

$
0
0

                                                                                                            May 8, 2014.

Shri V.S. Sampath,
Chief Election Commissioner,
Nirvachan Sadan, Ashoka Road,
New Delhi.

Dear Sir,

            I write this letter to bring to your notice the decision of the Director General Civil Aviation (DGCA) in the Ministry of Civil Aviation having given the Airlines Operators Permit(AoP) to the Air Asia Joint Venture and Tata Singapore Airlines to start a new airlines.

In this regard I draw your attention to the Election Commission’s answer
to my RTI application No.4/RTI/2014-CC&BE/747, dated 15th April, 2014
where it stated in item 3 that my letter to the Election Commission was forwarded to the Ministry of Civil Aviation for their report/views/comments.

             Subsequently I have notbeen informed whether the Election Commission  replied to the same.   In any case if it is not in agreement with the views expressed in my letter I would assume that the Election Commission would have held a hearing or opined in the matter.

            It is quite clear based on the precedence of the Election Commission’s decision that an AoP leading to to the promised offering the lowest fares is an inducement to voters and therefore it is a clear violation of the Model Code. Moreover,  there is an ongoing court case in which Contempt Petition is also pending against the DGCA and notice has been issued to him to file a Rejoinder.  The matter will be heard by a specially constituted Bench in the Delhi High Court in July.  Hence I see no reason whatsoever in law or by precedence that this proposal which is a new proposal be permitted
to bge cleared by a out-going Government when hardly ten days are left for the new Government to take over.  This will also be a clear violation of Section 13(1)(d)(iii) ofThe Prevention of Corruption Act.

            Hence I urge you to grant injunction against the implementation of the said Airlines Operators Permit and communicate the same to the Ministry of Civil Aviation and take any other further steps as you deem fit in the interest of fairness in the conduct of elections as guaranteed under Article 324 of the Constitution.
                                                            Yours sincerely,


                                                ( SUBRAMANIAN  SWAMY )

THE CAMPAIGN DAIRY – 8-5-2014
Arun Jaitley

Leader of Opposition (Rajya Sabha)

I cannot conceal my disappointment with the Election Commission. Men in constitutional offices need to be bolder. Timid men can dwarf high offices.
The Election Commission scrutinizes us all the time. They are extremely vigilant in tackling the side shows in the elections. They are concerned with what adjectives are used by whom. But when it comes to preventing booth capturing which has reappeared after a decade in elections 2014 they are out of their depth.                                        
By condoning the Returning Officer’s stand on ‘No-Modi rally’ in Varanasi city the Election Commission has used the security card to prevent Narendra Modi’s right to campaign in his constituency. If you can’t ensure security, don’t hold the polls in the country. But if you do hold the polls please provide a level playing field. You cannot deny the candidate the right to campaign. Rahul Gandhi can have a road show in Varanasi but Narendra Modi cannot have a rally. The security card is selectively used.
THE FALSEHOOD OF THE RETURNING OFFICER
  • Of all the permissions given to us by the Returning Officer, two are for the landing of the helicopter. How very fair. One helicopter has been allowed to land twice – once in the rural area and once in the city.
  • I withdrew all applications at 20:10 hours yesterday since it is impossible to organize a function the next day if a “mid night” permission comes. He allowed a prayer permission after 48 hours of struggle and an oral refusal earlier.
  • To meet a 150 eminent citizens at a hotel banquet hall he earlier said that Shri Modi cannot be allowed to drive into the city. Two hours after I withdrew all applications, he announced to the media that he was allowing Shri Modi to meet 150 people. How very liberal. These are all the permissions with regard to the campaigning in the city. Modi’s entire campaign in Varanasi city is restricted to a prayer at the Ganga Ghat and meeting 150 persons in a hotel. Additionally there are two helicopter landings.
  • Can he produce any document that the BJP had agreed to an alternate site which is much smaller? No.
If the Election Commission chooses to believe such a Returning Officer and feels that this is not a denial of opportunity to campaign, my right to Satyragrah begins. The Election Commission now condones the guilt of the Returning Officer.
My advice to the Election Commission is – dont look helpless. Don’t merely rely on the Returning Officer and officials of the Uttar Pradesh Government. They are a nominees of the people who want to prevent Modi. There is more to a campaign than a prayer and meeting 150 people. 
http://www.bjp.org/en/media-resources/press-releases/article-shri-arun-jaitley-on-the-campaign-dairy-8-5-2014

Modi’s Varanasi rally: EC shoots midnight letter to Jaitley, says can’t overlook security concerns in matter

In its letter to Jaitley, the EC expressed surprise and disappointment at BJP's decision to hold protests. Tweet This
http://indianexpress.com/article/india/politics/modis-varanasi-rally-ec-shoots-midnight-letter-to-jaitley-says-cant-overlook-security-concerns-in-matter/

Satyagraha in Varanasi. Shame on you ECI (Video 5:28, 1:32:55) Democratic revolution unfolds in Varanasi.

$
0
0
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jEePo6ugBqo

BJP workers arrive for 'satyagraha' against EC


Published on May 7, 2014
District administration has imposed Section 144 in Varanasi. Roads leading to Lanka Gate area are being blocked by police even as a huge contingent of RAF is on standby at the protest site.

Hundreds of BJP workers have converged outside Lanka Gate of Banaras Hindu University to take part in 'satyagraha' dharna against the Election Commission for denying permission to Narendra Modi to hold a rally in the city on Thursday.

Arun Jaitley, Ananth Kumar, Amit Shah and other senior BJP leaders are also set to arrive at the protest site.

Renewing his attack on the Election Commission, Arun Jaitely accused the poll panel of using the 'security card' to deny Modi the right to campaign his constituency.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SIzF5FscEoI#t=5483

Azamgarh public meeting: Narendra Modi (21:49)

EC wantonly violates right to equality of NaMo -- Ram Kumar Ohri, IPS (R) Satyagraha in Varanasi (Videos)

$
0
0
Backbencher’s Blog May 8, 2014

            Election Commission   Wantonly  Violates     
                       Right  to Equality   of NAMO.

                                                     Ram Kumar Ohri, IPS(Retd) 
                                          ****************   

          It is a pity that no political analyst, no media mandarin, nor the Bhartiya Janta Party, has shown the courage to haul our partisan Election Commission before the Supreme Court for deliberate denial of the Right to Equality  to Shri Narendra Modi, despite his being a Prime Ministerial candidate.  By denying the right to hold a meeting in his own constituency, i.e., Varanasi, the Election Commission and the Returning Officer of Varanasi has violated Shri Modi’s right to equality. How can the Returning  Officer of Varanasi, a stooge of Akhilesh Yadav, and protégé of the CEC, treat different candidates of different political parties in an unequal manner ?

The Right to Equality before law flows from Article 14 of the Constitution and its violation consitutues too serious a matter to be ignored by the Indian public, especially by the self-styled intellectuals masquerading as secular chatterati. 

Additionally the Right to Social Equality and Equal Access to Public Areas has been elaborately stated in Article 15 of the Constitution. In such circumstances, how could the Returning Officer and the CEC deny refuse to give the necessary permission to only one candidate, i.e., Shri Modi, to hold a meeting in his constituency ?

The most sordid  aspect of the unparalalled  political malfeasance is that it has been done by a constitutional authority, namely the Election Commission of India. 

          With my limited knowledge of the constitutional law but long years of experience gathered in service I feel that it is a fit case for being taken to the Supreme Court.  It is a simple commonsense that when Rahul Gandhi, Arvind Kejriwal and some other aspirants for the Varanasi Parliamentary seat were allowed to hold meetings in the temple town of Kashi, the country’s Prime Ministerial candidate has been subjected to discrimination on frivolous grounds.  

          Time has come to challenge the misconduct of the Returning Officer as well as all members of the Election Commission in Supreme Court and seek orders for their removal from their offices, at least till the general elections 2014 are  over. The apex court should ask the central government to appoint another set of  impartial members to man the Election Commission. 

                                        *************** 


Copyright  @ Ram Kumar Ohri

http://bharatkalyan97.blogspot.in/2014/05/satyagraha-in-varanasi-shame-on-you-eci.html




 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jEePo6ugBqo

BJP workers arrive for 'satyagraha' against EC


Published on May 7, 2014
District administration has imposed Section 144 in Varanasi. Roads leading to Lanka Gate area are being blocked by police even as a huge contingent of RAF is on standby at the protest site.

Hundreds of BJP workers have converged outside Lanka Gate of Banaras Hindu University to take part in 'satyagraha' dharna against the Election Commission for denying permission to Narendra Modi to hold a rally in the city on Thursday.

Arun Jaitley, Ananth Kumar, Amit Shah and other senior BJP leaders are also set to arrive at the protest site.

Renewing his attack on the Election Commission, Arun Jaitely accused the poll panel of using the 'security card' to deny Modi the right to campaign his constituency.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SIzF5FscEoI#t=5483


Modi fever rises, administration panics


Smita Barooah8 May 2014
Addictions counsellor,photographer,writer



Modi fever rises, administration panics
Read Part-1 and Part-2 of this series of articles first.
There is tension and uncertainty in Varanasi, and we seething against injustice. The Returning Officer Pranjal Yadav has banned Narendra Modi’s rallies scheduled for 8thMay[1]. In addition, he has disallowed Modi from participating in the evening Ganga aarti, and from meeting a group of 150 prominent citizens. The move is shocking and unprecedented. As party spokesperson Nirmala Sitharaman said, “It must be for the first time in Indian election that a candidate is being denied permission to hold rally in his own constituency.” The BJP is challenging the order and sitting on a dharna to protest against the blatant bias.
Modi fever rises, administration panics
The ruling administration’s discomfort with Modi is understandable. Wherever we go, there is discontent with the current state of affairs. People want change and are running out of patience. As a consequence, there is a great deal of hope riding on Modi. At the very least, there is much curiosity about him.
The common man in the urban areas is more aware than the elite think. Tiwari, who owns a paan shop near Sankatmochan temple, says he likes the fact that Modi speaks about being, “Indian first”. He believes that Modi will work for all communities and once he is in power, even detractors will become his fans. Rameshi, our driver, self-appointed guide and political commentator, shares his views daily, with a mouth full of paan. He explains that while corruption and inflation are important issues, national security is an issue too. If Modi comes to power, he says Pakistan would not dare to brazenly attack our soldiers and China would not take our land.
Modi fever rises, administration panics
The people in the rural areas tend to focus more on regional issues in general. They want development, jobs and electricity. The women in Rohaniya lament that the children, who they have educated after so much toil, are sitting at home without jobs. Their villages do not have electricity for more than 6 to 7 hours daily. Bharti is a teacher who works with the blind. She has a degree in education and was trained in Mumbai, but says there are hardly any opportunities for people like her. Talking to them, has reinforced my view that most of our people desperately want means for improving their lives and avenues of employment. They are not seeking dole.
Modi fever rises, administration panics

Modi fever rises, administration panics
Amidst the stories of gloom, the children in the villages have been our mascots and rays of sunshine. I had always felt that it was unfair to involve children in politics. Yet, here, the children fought to be a part of the process. They jostled to get our hats, banners and flags, which they proudly donned as they enthusiastically led our groups around their villages. Perhaps that is the way it should be. After all, this whole struggle is for a better India and the children are our future, our inheritors.http://www.niticentral.com/2014/05/08/modi-fever-rises-administration-panics-221251.html

I admire most the guts of redoubtable Subramanian Swamy -- RK Raghavan, Former CBI Director

$
0
0

Nowhere to hide for corrupt Babus: Why we must thank the SC

by May 8, 2014
Corruption thrives where there is no fear of the law, and there is sanction and encouragement from above.

This is what has been happening in Bharat for several decades, and no one who can check this rot has had the will or desire to arrest this permissiveness that has made us the laughing stock of the civilized world.

It is perhaps the only country on earth where public servant corruption starts at one's birth and ends only at death. Here is where one has to grease the palm of the public servant for getting a birth certificate as well as a death certificate.
]The Supreme Court judgement has come as a whiff of fresh airThe Supreme Court judgement has come as a whiff of fresh air
If a Revenue Inspector demands money for doing the routine thing (such as issue of a ‘patta' which legalizes an individual's ownership of land acquired him by lawful means) it is because the Revenue Minister expects a monthly payment to be passed on to his mentor in the political hierarchy. The same thing is true of sanction for building a house or an apartment or registering its sale.

What to speak of the police. I have heard of instances of an Inspector demanding a bribe to expedite post mortem of a road accident victim's father, and another asking for money to permit the funeral of a lady who had died at the hospital after being under treatment for burns for several days following a clear accident in her kitchen.

This is the obnoxious state of affairs in a country which we are supposed to love and adore. Only in the name of a vague concept which goes by the name ‘patriotism'. With what face can we ask our children abroad to come back and serve our motherland?

It is against the above backdrop that the Supreme Court's ruling this morning comes as a whiff of fresh air.

The Constitutional Bench headed by our brand new Chief Justice of India, Honourable Mr Lodha, has been both wise and savage in putting an end to more than a decade-long privilege enjoyed by senior civil servants at the Centre, of the rank of and above Joint Secretary, whereby the CBI cannot even do a Preliminary Enquiry (PE) against them.

The Court ruled categorically that this so-called Single Directive (euphemism for fearless corruption) was not tenable, solely on the ground that it discriminates between classes of civil servants.

Within the Union bureaucracy it creates a privileged class. More than this, similarly placed officers in the State governments did not enjoy this kind of immunity. The whole matter was examined during the hearing of a PIL filed by the redoubtable Subramanian Swamy (whose guts I admire most) and the Centre for Public Interest Litigation.

This is a shot in the arm for the crusade against public servant corruption which has been burgeoning by the day instead of diminishing against stern judicial sentences and the growing public protest in the form of the rise of Aam Admi Party and similar movements.

A main argument against the Single Directive is the shelter it gives to senior officers, whereby they are helped to buy time against inquiries into their known acts of corruption. Very often these individuals act as conduits to enable their Ministers to make enormous money, through convenient and dishonest notings on file. There are instances of their receiving money directly from those favoured and passing it on to their Ministers after keeping a cut.

Under the Single Directive, the CBI was required to reduce whatever information it had into writing and request the Ministry concerned to permit it to go ahead with a PE into the matter.

There are two obvious flaws here.

By sending a report to the Ministry, the confidentiality of the enquiry is lost, and there is enough time for the dishonest civil servant to cover up his or her tracks. No such report can obviously remain a secret, because no Secretary would like to let down an official working under him or her, unless the misdemeanor is too grave to be suppressed.

Secondly, and most importantly, how will a corrupt Minister keep off from the vital decision making process in giving the CBI an unfettered hand in dealing with the act of dishonesty? Instances are replete where, in the recent past, at least three Union Ministers in three ‘lucrative' Ministries, had come to adverse notice.
]The ruling will greatly help CBI investigators seeking to end corruptionThe ruling will greatly help CBI investigators seeking to end corruption
The public perception is that one of the two had been unfairly let off due to political pressure, and in the third, untenable grounds are being cited to facilitate a reprieve. In such cases, where there is a dishonest Minister who had lined his pockets, how can you expect him to hand over his loyal deputy to the CBI? This alone is sufficient ground to strike down the infamous directive, and the Apex Court has done the right thing. We must compliment it for the sagacity it has shown here. The oppressed common man will welcome it wholeheartedly.

One oft-heard justification for the rule was that an untrammeled and mindless CBI was likely to play with good reputations. This was a genuine concern. With the departure of the Single Directive, the responsibility of the CBI Director grows in ensuring that no flimsy PE is initiated against an honest civil servant who had been a victim of circumstances and had no courage to speak against a dishonest colleague or a powerful Minister.

It is for the CBI to build an internal mechanism that provides for a clinical examination of all facts before arriving at a decision to launch a PE.

This contemplates a collective decision by a core group within the organization which cannot be approached by those elements in the dock.

I personally feel that a decision cannot be the prerogative of the Director alone. A group decision is always more credible than that of an individual. This will be distasteful to the current top brass of the organization. But this is the only way the rest of the world can become convinced that the CBI is an impartial and honest outfit that fears only the law and no one else.

(The writer is a former CBI Director.)

Comments

  • This is just because the UPA has sensed it's demise !
    Why did SC slept over this issue for so long ?
    RML has been fast to oblige !
      • Avatar
        i am sorry I did not make a specific reference to Ministers. They are also 'public servantś within the ambit of the Prevention of Corruption Act 1988, and no prior permission is required by the CBI either for doing a preliminary enquiry or for registering a Regular Case (RC) . Sanction of the government is required only if investigation leads to a chargesheet in a court of law. R.K.Raghavan
          • Avatar
            This was much needed. But then who will watch the watchdog? A change in mentality through increased awareness campaigns is the need of the hour.
              • Avatar
                what about corrupt politicians?why is that its not applicable for them?
              http://www.firstpost.com/india/nowhere-to-hide-for-corrupt-babus-why-we-must-thank-the-sc-1513841.html
              Viewing all 11035 articles
              Browse latest View live


              <script src="https://jsc.adskeeper.com/r/s/rssing.com.1596347.js" async> </script>