Quantcast
Channel: Bharatkalyan97
Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 11039

Saradha scam: Mamata Didi's many uses of bamboo, proven by language and gesture. Shame on you, Mamata; quit politics, paint bamboo instead of trinamul.

$
0
0

Mamata Banerjee uses slang again, this time at a govt function Posted by: Shubham Ghosh Updated: Thursday, December 4, 2014, 10:40 [IST] Share this on your social network:    FacebookTwitterGoogle+   CommentsMail Jalpaiguri (West Bengal), Dec 4: West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee made the headlines recently for uttering a couple of slangs while addressing her party workers. She was criticised in all medium for the reckless use of words aimed at the Centre and some other 'unknown enemy'. [Mamata Banerjee uses abusive words at Trinamool Congress event] But the mercurial supremo of the Trinamool Conrgess (TMC) was little bothered. On Wednesday, she again let loose a verbal assault and this time, from the platform of a government event. Banerjee said at the inauguration of a sports village in Jalpaiguri, said: "Jara kaaj korche, sarakkhon tader picchone ki kore bamboo dewa jaye, tar chinta kore beracche" (efforts are always on to target those who are doing real work). She even made indecent gestures with her hand while uttering this. The expression "bamboo dewa" is considered a slang but Banerjee has little reservations in using it, even as a chief minister. Banerjee's words left the officials and police officers present on the occasion stunned. Some were seen looking at each other while some others ran for a shelter to express their amusement. The Opposition was quick to grab the opportunity. While a senior BJP leader said using the slang repeatedly shows that it is not a slip of tongue but something with which one is familiar. A Left MP asked whether the chief minister was trying to attract the national media by uttering "bamboo". Banerjee used the Bengali form of the same word (baansh) last time, accompanying it with the same indecent gesture. Oneindia News

http://www.oneindia.com/kolkata/west-bengal-chief-minister-mamata-banerjee-uses-slang-again-1581322.html

Bamboos and backsides: Bhadralok 'horror' at Mamata is classist and sexist

by Sandip Roy  Dec 5, 2014 11:13 IST
On NDTV the other night when asked why the West Bengal was fighting a CBI probe into Saradha tooth and nail when Odisha’s Naveen Patnaik and Assam’s Tarun Gogoiwere not, Trinamool’s Derek O’Brien smiled and said that with all due respect, Naveen Patnaik was Naveen Patnaik and Tarun Gogoi was Tarun Gogoi but Mamata Banerjee was Mamata Banerjee.
Didi just proved him right.
At a meeting in Jalpaiguri, Mamata the Irrepressible wanted to express her annoyance with the CPM for going to Narendra Modi to rake up the Saradha issue. But Mamata Banerjee being Mamata Banerjee she decided to let fly some salty Bengali slang, a far cry from the genteel Rabindrasangeet she has spewing out of her traffic lights.
PTI
PTI
Nijera 34 bochhor khomotai chhilo. Kichhu kortey paareni. Aar jaara korchhey taader bamboo diye berachhe. (They were in power for 34 years and could do nothing. And they are shoving the bamboo (up the rear ends) of those who are doing something.)
Bengali bhadralok are aghast. For years they merely turned its nose up at Mamata because of her unpolished rough and tumble street-tough ways, but they tolerated her in a way they would not have tolerated a man from her class background. Now, to them, it looks like Didi is showing her class. The Telegraph pasted a bamboo curtain on its front page with a banner headline saying BAMBOO REPUBLIC – No word is too crude, no gesticulation too loud. And the copy smirks “Readers who insist on their right to know may turn to Page 8 – only if you must and you are aged above18.”
The bhadralok doth protest too much. Didi’s language was slangy, earthy and in bad taste but hardly X-rated. School students routinely say the algebra examination was a “total baansh”. In the lexicon of insults most of which relate to vile acts being perpetrated on mothers and sisters, bamboo is hardly setting the Hooghly on fire.
Should a politician, especially a chief minister, watch her mouth? Absolutely. No matter if she curses up a blue streak in private, should she maintain a certain decorum in public? 100 percent. But at least Mamata Banerjee was not talking about shoving that bamboo up someone else’s rear.
That makes her a little different from her own MP, Tapas Pal who has gone into cold storage ever since video clips emerged of him telling an election meeting that if anyone insulted the mothers and daughters of Trinamool workers, he would let loose his boys into their homes and they would commit rape.
It also puts her a shade apart from Sadhvi Niranjan Jyoti whose haramzada if taken literally casts aspersions on their parenthood of a huge swathe of the population.
But Mamata’s remark coming on the heels of Niranjan Jyoti’s jibe also reveals not just our discomfiture about street slang in public meetings but our extra discomfiture when it comes from a woman. The coarse-mouthed male politician does not raise as many eyebrows as a woman with a loose tongue. A woman is supposed to be demure and ladylike and a woman in politics is supposed to keep up that facade. Mamata broke that rule. That's her greatest sin. The front-page tut-tutting over her statement is really about her class and her sex.
However on the flip side that does not mean that women in politics can expect to treated with gentlemanly courtesy. Mamata is well aware of that. Her entire career has been dogged by slurs – ugly, personal, sexist barbs. In the 2011 campaign , CPM leader Anil Basu alleged Mamata Banerjee took money from America. But he phrased it in a way he would never have done if she was a man. He referred to a red light district and described Mamata’s Trinamool as a bhatar (client).
Basu had also once said after the Singur protests that Mamata “should have been pulled by her hair and dragged (home) to Kalighat and given a lesson for blocking a national highway.” She’s been called “Kalighater moyna” (the parrot of Kalighat, her neighbourhood). CPM general secretary Anil Biswas had sniffed that Mamata wasjomero aruchi as in even the devil would not want to touch her.
It’s not just Mamata. In the rough and tumble of politics, any woman who dares to be a leader can look forward to a barrage of personal attacks. They might be called Didi or Amma or Behenji but that’s where the courtesy ends.
In 1989 in melee in the Chennai assembly, Jayalalithaa found her pallu pulled and torn by angry DMK leaders whereupon she vowed to only re-enter as the chief minister. BJP’s Shaina NC wondered if Mayawati was a “he or a she”. Mulayam Singh Yadav sneered at Mayawati as a “parkati aurat” (bob-cut woman) after she cut her hair short. When 200 of his party's hoodlums tried to break into the room she was staying in in a state guest house, Mulayam sneered “Is she so beautiful that anyone would want to rape her?” Rahul Gandhi might be called Pappu and Narendra Modiderided as Phenku but those insults are still more about their intellectual faculties and political maturity rather than jibes at their sex, looks and love lives.
Mamata’s bamboo slip might betray her frayed nerves these days. Or it might be her idea of connecting with her audience. It’s not a shining "Friends, Romans and countrymen" moment in political oratory but it’s hardly the nadir of political discourse it’s being made out to be.
Sri Ramakrishna said you can reach God by many paths – the most important thing was to reach the roof whether by stone stairs or a rope or bamboo steps. “You can also climb up by a bamboo pole,” said the sage.
In these days of the Saradha scam, perhaps Didi just had the other Saradha Ma's divine consort Ramakrishna and his wisdom about the many uses of bamboo on her mind.
http://www.firstpost.com/politics/bamboos-and-backsides-bhadralok-horror-at-mamata-is-classist-and-sexist-1833987.html

Mamata Banerjee's 'bamboo' cuss outrages Bengal

Mamata-rally
Use of street lingo is, however, nothing new when it comes to Trinamool.
KOLKATA: Even as Trinamool Congress on Thursday staged a walkout in Parliament to protest against the derogatory remarks by Union minister Sadhvi Niranjan Jyoti, back home in Bengal, the party was mum on its leader's culpability at a public forum where she used rank bad language.

At a public rally in Jalpaiguri on Wednesday, Mamata had used crass words replete with invectives and accompanied by gestures that were downright vulgar. Upset with CPM for approaching PM Narendra Modi on the Saradha probe, Mamata had said, "Nijera 34 bochhor khamatai chhilo. Kichhu korte pareni, aar jara korche tader bamboo diye berachhe. Bamboo jangale hoi, ghar bari toirir kaje lage, jane na bamboo jake tara kore she palate path pai na. Amader chamkale amra garjai..." (They were in power for 34 years, but could do nothing. Instead they are trying to figure out how to shove bamboos up the ... of those who are doing it)"

A day after her crude outburst, artists, writers and academics — a group she had actively courted till not so long ago — were united in saying that she had embarrassed them and the state of Bengal. 

"This was never seen in Bengal," said theatre actor Chandan Sen. "Politicians here had often towered over others. But this chief minister's continued use of road slang isn't only demeaning her, but also each one of us. This has to stop. This isn't politics any more. This isn't Bengal either."

Painter Wasim Kapoor said the chief minister herself was a writer and a poet. Writer Shobhaa De tweeted: "'Bamboo on the backside': I nominate it for Phrase of the Year. Thank you, Mamata Banerjee."

"We have some expectations from our leaders," said academic and author Nabanita Deb Sen. "The time, place and social responsibility of the speaker matters. You have to treat your language with care, otherwise you embarrass people. One is disappointed to hear such language..."



(West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee during a TMC rally in Siliguri.)

Linguist Pabitra Sarkar was more scathing. "For the last three years, there has been a decay in the political language in Bengal. While I shudder to think what my grandchild will make of such comments, I hope that the younger generation will dismiss such street language."

Use of such street lingo is, however, nothing new when it comes to Trinamool. State transport minister Madan Mitra had said while warning a police inspector, "Kaner gorai debo na... (Will box your ears)." Trinamool leader Sonali Guha had also used such slang while she was in the opposition.

Experts wonder whether the use of street lingo — once restricted to raucous gatherings, and strictly banished by the true-blue bhadralok — is an attempt to connect with those who attend the chief minister's rallies. Professor Achinta Biswas of Jadavpur University said: "People clapping and appreciating such comments is the bigger concern to me. It's not only the language; the gestures she made are also vulgar."

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Mamata-Banerjees-bamboo-cuss-outrages-Bengal/articleshow/45379665.cms

Crossing the line: Mamata Banerjee takes the lead in use of foul language

HT Correspondent, Hindustan Times  Kolkata Kolkata, December 08, 2014

A new kind of intimidation tactic has emerged in the political theatre of Bengal, and this time the chief minister herself stands as the accused. Mamata Banerjee has led her party colleagues in hitting a new low of foul language use.
The latest episode happened a day after the CBI arrested Srinjoy Bose, Trinamool Congress MP.
While speaking to party workers on November 22, the CM said, “Ke tumi salla? Naam jane na keu. (Who are you bugger? No one knows your name),” while targeting a BJP leader.
On December 3, Banerjee once again crossed limits of decency in speech: “Nijeyra kortey pareyni, jara korchhey sharakkhon tadeyr pechhoney ki korey bamboo dewa jay tar chinta korey jachhey. (They couldn’t themselves work for the people, they are always trying to figure out how to shove bamboos up the... of those who are doing it).”
“Mamata is feeling threatened, and therefore, resorting to such language and behaviour,” BJP national secretary Siddharth Nath Singh claimed.

In June, TMC MP Tapas Paul had threatened to unleash his boys and rape women supporters of CPI(M). Food minister Jyotipriyo Mullick also asked his supporters to socially boycott CPI(M) workers, and even treat them as one treats venomous snakes.

http://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/kolkata/didi-outshines-others-in-foul-language-use/article1-1294245.aspx

Didi Draws Flak for Repeated Use of Foul Language

Published: 05th December 2014 06:15 AM
KOLKATA: West Bengal Chief Minister and TMC chief Mamata Banerjee’s repeated use of foul language, unprecedented in the state’s political history, has drawn flak not only from the Opposition’ but also from leading citizens. CPM leader Sujan Chakraborty said, “Her actions and use of words don’t befit a CM. It is an insult to Bengali culture. As Bengalis, we are feeling ashamed.”
Shamik Bhattacharya, BJP MLA said, “She is displaying the culture of the TMC and the Bengali culture never approves of such behaviour from a Chief Minister.”
Veteran Congress leader Abdul Mannan remarked, “She should realise that she represents the people of Bengal. Use of such foul language is an insult to the people of West Bengal and our culture.”
Commenting on Mamata’s frequent digs at the media and abuse of it, former Chief Justice of HC, Bhagabati Prasad Banerjee said, “These actions and language prove that some people are yet to learn from the outcome faced by former (late) Prime Minister Indira Gandhi who imposed Emergency to gag the media. The media’s job is to criticise and highlight the failures of the government. That is Democracy.”
During her speech at an official public meeting in North Bengal on Wednesday, Mamata had said, “Peace prevails in the hills, as well as in Junglemahal now. But they can’t tolerate it. They couldn’t achieve it and that’s why they are always planning to give bamboo from the back. Just because you own a channel, you cannot just say anything you like. Limits are being crossed.”
“Bamboos are grown in jungles and used to make houses. They don’t know while giving bamboo to others, when bamboo will chase them, where they will seek shelter,” she had said, while gesturing with her right hand.
Reacting to the BJP’s state in-charge Siddharth Nath Singh’s slogan “Bhaag Mamata Bhaag”, during party president Amit Shah’s rally on November 30, she had remarked in Bengali, “Some are saying flee from Bengal. How dare! There is a saying that if you fly too high, you will be wiped out by a storm”.
During a TMC workers’ meeting on November 22, she had called Shah and Singh “shaala” and then immediately withdrew the word, but remarked, “No one has ever heard their names in Bengal.”
She used her right hand to gesture vulgarly  and said, “Since I went to Delhi Tumpai had to bambooed and arrested? I will go to Delhi repeatedly, a hundred times”.
TMC Rajya Sabha MP Srinjoy Basu alias Tumpai was arrested by the CBI for his alleged involvement in the Saradha scam.


http://www.newindianexpress.com/nation/Didi-Draws-Flak-for-Repeated-Use-of-Foul-Language/2014/12/05/article2556201.ece

Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 11039

Trending Articles



<script src="https://jsc.adskeeper.com/r/s/rssing.com.1596347.js" async> </script>